Toast Local logo

Italian restaurants in Reynoldsburg

Italian restaurants near Reynoldsburg, OH. Order delivery or pickup, book a table, and browse menus and hours for every spot in one place.

Pizzeria New York - Reynoldsburg 7950 E Broad St
Pizzeria New York - Reynoldsburg 7950 E Broad St
Rated 4.9 out of 5 by 24 guestsItalianReynoldsburg2.4 milesPrice range $1-15
Milano's Italian Restaurant 6916 E Broad St
Milano's Italian Restaurant 6916 E Broad St
ItalianReynoldsburg2.0 milesPrice range $15-30