Skip to main contentToast Local logo

Reviews of OLD ACCOUNT - 1844

4.7

Rated 4.7 out of 5

11 ratings

  • Gina G.
    5 out of 5 starsMar 31

    Ordered Fresh Lake Perch, AYCE Beer Battered Cod, fish and chips, Yuengling DRFT, $5 Old Fashioned, and $Extra Sour Cream.

  • Melissa K.
    5 out of 5 starsMar 15

    Ordered Sugar Cookie Latte and Gingerbread White Mocha.

  • Jennifer S.
    5 out of 5 starsMar 14

    Our meal was excellent. The lasagna, breaded walleye, and tortellini were all great. Definitely going back.

    Ordered Classic Lasagna, Tortellini Alla Panna, Walleye Dinner, Stellatini, and Meatball.

  • Lydia S.
    5 out of 5 starsFeb 26

    Ordered Colonel E H Taylor DBL, Deep Eddy Grapefruit, and Stella Artois DRFT.

  • Colleen V.
    4 out of 5 starsFeb 2

    The bread was as hard as a rock. My guess is it was heated up in a microwave. Otherwise, everything was great.

    Ordered 8 oz Flat Iron Steak, 10 oz Boneless Pork Ribeye, New York Sour, Soup Du Jour, and $5 Old Fashion.

  • David M.
    5 out of 5 starsJan 10

    Our server Miriam - outstanding

    Ordered 10 oz Boneless Pork Ribeye, Canadian Walleye, Door County Cheese Curds, Traditional Old Fashion, and Diet Coke.

  • Gina G.
    5 out of 5 starsOct 17, 2025

    Ordered Wild Caught Salmon Fillet, Fresh Lake Perch, Coconut Shrimp, $5 Old Fashioned, and $4 Spotted Cow DFT.