Skip to Main content
  • Anderson's Frozen Custard West Amherst

    • Home
    • /
    • Amherst
    • /
    • Anderson's Frozen Custard (Niagara Falls Blvd.)
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image
    American

    Anderson's Frozen Custard (Niagara Falls Blvd.)

    2369 Niagara Falls Boulevard

    Amherst, NY 14228


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Food
    Kid's Meal
    Beverages
    Dessert
    Frozen Pints
    Cakes, Pies, & Big Wheels
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • All Natural Roast Beef Sandwich

      Anderson's famous beef on weck. All natural roast beef traditionally on kimmelweck roll, most commonly dressed with horseradish. Made to your liking.
      $10.48+
    • Curly Fries

      $3.59+
    • Milkshake

      $4.60+

    Food

    Roast Beef & Turkey Sandwiches

    • All Natural Roast Beef Sandwich

      Anderson's famous beef on weck. All natural roast beef traditionally on kimmelweck roll, most commonly dressed with horseradish. Made to your liking.
      $10.48+
    • Adobo All Natural Roast Beef Sandwich

      Anderson's classic all natural roast beef sandwich topped with red onion, adobo bbq sauce, and guacamole
      $12.46+
    • BBQ Beef Sandwich

      All natural roast beef slow-cooked in Anderson's original tangy barbecue sauce.
      $8.78
    • All Natural Turkey Sandwich

      All natural turkey with no additives. Served hot or cold. Prepared to your liking.
      $9.01+

    Burgers & Dogs

    • All Natural Angus Beef Hamburger

      No preservatives, additives or hormones. Includes your choice of condiments. Cheese not included.
      $9.01+
    • Adobo All Natural Angus Burger

      All natural angus beef burger topped with topped with red onion, adobo bbq sauce, and guacamole
      $10.99+
    • Sahlen's Hot Dog

      Flame grilled locally popular Sahlen's hot dog on a hotdog bun. Includes your choice of condiments and toppings.
      $4.05

    Chicken & Fish Sandwiches

    • Buffalo Chicken Tender Sandwich

      Our crisp, all natural chicken tenders tossed in Buffalo wing sauce, with lettuce and blue cheese
      $9.01
    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich

      4oz chicken breast grilled to perfection, on a toasted roll with your choice of toppings.
      $9.01
    • Wild Caught Alaskan Pollock Sandwich

      Breaded wild caught pollock, fried to perfection. Served standard with lettuce, tomato, and a side of tartar sauce.
      $9.01

    Chicken Tender Baskets

    • Small Chicken Tender Basket w/ Fries

      Served plain or Buffalo style, with your choice of dipping sauce. Contains wheat.
      $9.89
    • Large Chicken Tender Basket w/ Fries

      Served plain or Buffalo style, with your choice of dipping sauce. Contains wheat.
      $16.00

    Veggie Sandwiches

    • Vegan Veggie Burger

      Vegan Veggie Burger. Includes your choice of condiments and toppings.
      $8.09
    • Vegan Veggie Sandwich

      Lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, cucumber, and guacamole, on a kaiser roll.
      $5.98

    Full Salads

    • Spring Salad

      Spring mix with mandarin oranges, red onion, feta cheese, and pecans
      $10.11
    • Greek Salad

      Spring mix with fresh tomatoes, red onion, cucumber banana peppers and feta cheese, typically served with a side of Greek dressing!
      $7.45

    Fries & Sides

    • Curly Fries

      $3.59+
    • Cajun Fries

      $4.18+
    • Onion Rings

      $4.18+
    • Baked Potato

      OUT OF STOCK
      $3.31
    • Adobo Loaded Fries

      Large order of golden curly cue fries loaded up with guacamole, sour cream, adobo BBQ sauce, and red onion
      $8.99
    • Homestyle Mac n' Cheese

      $6.94+
    • Side Salad

      $4.32
    • Steamed Broccoli

      $4.32
    • Potato Salad

      $3.08

    Extra Sides

    • SIDE of Melted Cheddar Sauce

      $1.33
    • SIDE of Beef Gravy

      $1.33
    • SIDE of Guacamole

      $1.98

    Dippers & Dressing

    • SIDE of Ranch

      $1.01
    • SIDE of Blue Cheese

      $1.01
    • SIDE of Honey Mustard

      $1.01
    • SIDE of Buffalo Dipping Sauce

      $1.01
    • SIDE of BBQ Sauce

      $0.55
    • SIDE of Tartar Sauce

      $0.55
    • SIDE of Balsamic Vinaigrette

      $1.01
    • SIDE of Raspberry Vinaigrette

      $1.01
    • SIDE of Greek Dressing

      $1.01
    • SIDE of Hot Honey

      $1.33
    • SIDE of Adobo BBQ Sauce

      $1.01

    Kid's Meal

    • Kid's Meal

      $11.49

    Beverages

    Fountain & Bottled Beverages

    • Fountain Drink

      $3.17+
    • Bottled Water

      $2.99

    Frozen Beverages

    • Milkshake

      $4.60+
    • Malted Shake

      $5.42+
    • Strawberry Sensation

      $4.60+
    • Vegan Shake

      $7.36+

    Dessert

    Classic Dessert Dishes

    • Signature Frozen Custard

      $4.00+
    • Handmade Hard Ice Cream

    • Lemon Ice

      $2.02+
    • Lemon Chiffon Twist

      $4.00+
    • Plant-Based Frozen Dessert

    Sundaes

    • Reese's Pieces Sundae

      Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with hot fudge, peanut butter, and Reese’s Pieces®
      $5.84+
    • Turtle Sundae

      Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with hot fudge, hot caramel, and pecans.
      $5.84+
    • Mexican Sundae

      Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with rich chocolate syrup and Spanish peanuts.
      $5.84+
    • Create Your Own Sundae

      $4.51+
    • Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae

      Sweet treat of the month! Signature vanilla frozen custard smothered with strawberry topping and topped with cheesecake pieces!
      $5.84+
    • Dirt Sundae

      Our signature vanilla frozen custard topped with chocolate syrup and crushed OREO® cookie dirt, crawling with sour gummy worms!
      OUT OF STOCK
      $6.30+
    • Banana Split

      Vanilla & Chocolate Signature Frozen Custard in between two banana halves. Chocolate syrup, strawberry, and marshmallow toppings. Topped with handmade whipped cream & chopped nuts
      $9.24
    • Brownie Overboard

      Rich fudge brownie with vanilla & chocolate frozen custard, topped with hot fudge, handmade whipped cream & chopped nuts
      $9.24
    • Choco-Peanut Butter Passion

      Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Cookie, Whipped Cream & Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cups
      $9.24
    • Strawberry Glacier Sundae

      $4.60+

    Arctic Swirls

    • Arctic Swirl

      $6.99+
    • Strawberry Cheesecake Arctic Swirl

      Sweet Treat of the Month! Signature strawberry frozen custard blended with strawberries and cheesecake pieces!
      $7.82+

    Frozen Pints

    Pre-Packed Pints

    • Black Cherry Ice Cream (Pint)

      $8.50
    • Bubblegum Ice Cream (Pint)

      $8.50
    • Cake Batter Ice Cream (Pint)

      $8.50
    • Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream (Pint)

      $8.50
    • Coffee Toffee Crunch Frozen Yogurt (Pint)

      $8.50
    • Cookie Dough Ice Cream (Pint)

      $8.50
    • Graham Cracker Crunch Ice Cream (Pint)

      $8.50
    • Maple Walnut Ice Cream (Pint)

      $8.50
    • Mint Chunk Ice Cream (Pint)

      $8.50
    • Watson's Sponge Candy Ice Cream (Pint)

      $8.50

    Custom Hand-Packed Pints

    • Signature Frozen Custard (Pint)

      $6.70
    • Lemon Ice (Pint)

      $5.80
    • Plant-Based Frozen Dessert (Pint)

      $10.20

    Cakes, Pies, & Big Wheels

    Traditional Round Cakes

    • Round Cake - Balloons

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with colorful celebratory frosting balloons. Colors may vary. Serves 8-10.
      $26.49
    • Round Cake - Chocolate

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with confetti sprinkles. Colors may vary. Serves 8-10.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $26.49
    • Round Cake - Confetti

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with confetti sprinkles. Colors may vary. Serves 8-10.
      $26.49
    • Round Cake - Pink Roses

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with pink frosting roses. Serves 8-10.
      $26.49
    • Round Cake - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with natural colored rainbow sprinkles. Serves 8-10.
      $26.49
    • Round Cake - Spring Seasonal

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with spring-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 8-10.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $26.49
    • Round Cake - Summer Fun

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with summer-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 8-10.
      $26.49
    • Round Cake - Father's Day

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with Father's Day-themed toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 8-10.
      $26.49

    Traditional Sheet Cakes

    • Sheet Cake - Balloons

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with colorful celebratory frosting balloons. Colors may vary. Serves 16-20.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $40.99
    • Sheet Cake - Mini Cones

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with mini cones and confetti sprinkles. Colors may vary. Serves 16-20.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $40.99
    • Sheet Cake - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with natural colored rainbow sprinkles. Serves 16-20.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $40.99
    • Sheet Cake - Spring Seasonal

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with spring-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 16-20.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $40.99
    • Sheet Cake - Summer Fun

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with summer-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 16-20.
      $40.99
    • Sheet Cake - Father's Day

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with Father's Day-themed toppings. Specific decorations may vary. Serves 16-20.
      $40.99

    Specialty Cakes

    • Cookie Dough Fudge Cake

      Chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream with a center layer of cookie dough pieces and rich chocolate fudge. Topped with frosting and more of our delicious cookie dough pieces and fudge. Serves 8-10.
      $32.99
    • Rainbow Fudge M&M Cake

      Chocolate ice cream with a center layer of our rich chocolate fudge and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our vanilla ice cream, more fudge, and real M&Ms. Serves 8-10.
      $32.99
    • Cookies & Cream Dream Cake

      OREO ice cream with a center layer of real OREO cookie pieces, frosting, our smooth rich fudge and more OREO cookies. Serves 8-10.
      $32.99
    • Candy Bar Snickers Cake

      Vanilla and milk chocolate ice cream with a center layer of Snickers pieces and caramel, all topped with our chocolate icing, more snickers, caramel, and fudge. Serves 8-10.
      $32.99

    Fudge Ganache Cakes

    • Mint Fudge Ganache Cake

      Chocolate Mint ice cream with a center layer of our rich chocolate fudge and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our mint chunk ice cream, all covered with our special chocolate ganache sauce. Serves 12-15.
      $39.99
    • Peanut Butter Fudge Ganache Cake

      Peanut Butter ice cream with a center layer of our delicious peanut butter sauce and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our chocolate ice cream, all covered with our special chocolate ganache sauce. Serves 12-15.
      $39.99

    Cake Slices

    • Cake Slice - OREO

      OREO ice cream with a center layer of real OREO cookie pieces, frosting, our smooth rich fudge and more OREO cookies.
      $5.49
    • Cake Slice - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles

      Layers of our handmade chocolate and vanilla ice cream, separated by a layer of cookie crumble. Decorated with natural colored rainbow sprinkles.
      $5.49
    • Cake Slice - Peanut Butter Fudge Ganache

      Peanut Butter ice cream with a center layer of our delicious peanut butter sauce and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our chocolate ice cream, all covered with our special chocolate ganache sauce.
      $6.69

    Whole Ice Cream Pies

    Serves 8.
    • Turtle Pie

      Chocolate pie crust layered with chocolate and vanilla ice cream and a center layer of caramel. Topped with a decorative fudge border and a center of caramel and pecans. Serves 8.
      $19.99
    • Peanut Butter Fudge Pie

      Graham cracker pie crust layered with peanut butter ice cream. Topped with a decorative fudge border and peanut butter. Serves 8.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $19.99
    • Mint Fudge OREO Pie

      Mint chunk ice cream in a chocolate pie shell, adorned with buttercream frosting, whole OREO cookies and decadent fudge sauce
      $19.99

    Pie Slices

    • Pie Slice - Turtle

      Cookie crunch topped with vanilla ice cream, a fudge border, caramel and pecans.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.99

    Big Wheel 6-Packs

    • 6-Pack - Vanilla (Plain)

      Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream.
      $12.99
    • 6-Pack - Vanilla w/ Assorted Toppings

      Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with various candies and toppings. Specific decorations may vary.
      $12.99
    • 6-Pack - Chocolate (Plain)

      Chocolate wafers filled with chocolate ice cream.
      $12.99
    • 6-Pack - Chocolate w/ Assorted Toppings

      Chocolate wafers filled with chocolate ice cream and decorated with various toppings. Specific toppings may vary.
      $12.99
    • 6-Pack - Vanilla/Chocolate (Plain)

      Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla and chocolate ice cream.
      $12.99
    • 6-Pack - Twist (Plain)

      Chocolate wafers filled with twist ice cream.
      $12.99
    • 6-Pack - Vanilla/Chocolate/Twist (Plain)

      Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla, chocolate, and twist ice cream.
      $12.99
    • 6-Pack - Spring Seasonal

      Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with spring-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary.
      $12.99
    • 6-Pack - Summer Fun

      Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream and decorated with summer-themed sprinkles and toppings. Specific decorations may vary.
      $12.99
    • 6-Pack - Black Raspberry (Plain)

      Chocolate wafers filled with black raspberry ice cream.
      $12.99
    • 6-Pack - Black Raspberry w/ Assorted Toppings

      Chocolate wafers filled with black raspberry ice cream and decorated with various toppings. Specific toppings may vary.
      $12.99

    Individual Big Wheels

    • Jumbo Chocolate Chip Big Wheel

      Jumbo chocolate chip cookies filled with vanilla ice cream.
      $9.99
    • Big Wheel - Vanilla (Plain)

      Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream.
      $2.99
    • Big Wheel - Natural Color Rainbow Sprinkles

      Chocolate wafers filled with vanilla ice cream, decorated with natural colored sprinkles.
      $2.99

    All hours
    Sunday11:00 am - 9:30 pm
    Monday11:00 am - 9:30 pm
    Tuesday11:00 am - 9:30 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 9:30 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 9:30 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 9:30 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 9:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    Family-owned and serving Western New York for 80 years and counting, offering classics like All Natural Roast Beef on Weck, Signature Frozen Custard, Handmade Hard Ice Cream, Kids Meals, Party Food Catering, a "Weck on Wheels" Food Truck, and much more! The Anderson’s family along with the management and team invite you to stop by and taste the tradition!

    Location

    2369 Niagara Falls Boulevard, Amherst, NY 14228

    Directions