
American
Bay House Oyster Bar & Restaurant
8 Sassafras Pier
Erie, PA 16507
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Oyster Bar
Starters
Lobster Seafood Dip
Spicy, creamy lobster & crab dip served with toasted flatbreads$19.00Oysters Rockefeller
Oysters topped with spinach, parmesan, bacon, panko bread crumb & lemon brûlée$24.00Pork Belly Burnt Ends
Slow rendered pork belly, bourbon bbq, crispy tobacco onions, house pickles with raspberry-chipotle glaze$18.00Southwest-Style Crab Cakes
A jumbo lump crab cake on top of street corn spinach dip with queso fresco, red chimichurri, tricolored tortilla strips and a lime wedge$18.00Street Corn Spinach Dip
Roasted corn and spinach in a spiced pepper cheese sauce with queso fresco and lime; served with tri-color tortilla chips$14.00Tempura Fried Oysters
Lightly battered and fried with a bok choy slaw tossed in blood orange rice wine vinaigrette with siracha aioli$21.00Tuna Poke Nachos
Ginger teriyaki glaze, avocado, pickled red onion, sliced jalapeño, red & green aiolis, queso fresco over fried wonton chips$24.00
Flatbreads & Mains
Blackened Salmon
Pan seared norwegian aukra salmon blackened with a coconut mango sauce; garnished with asparagus, lemon brûlée, citrus zest & toasted coconut$38.00Caprese Fettucine
Roasted tomatoes, spinach and mozzarella balls tossed with bruschetta alfredo with grilled chicken, parmesan cheese, balsamic glaze, and grilled focaccia$29.00Smothered Chicken
Grilled chicken topped with smokey onions, mushroom medley, and a creamy ranch sauce; served with garlic mashed potatoes$24.00Top Sirloin Medallions Lunch
Argentine grilled Angus Reserve Cut [ 10 oz. ] with your choice of side & buttered green beans. Side Options // Hand-Cut Fries, Fresh Fruit or Home Fries Accompaniments // Garlic Herb Butter + 3 / Steak Sauce + 3 / Grilled Wild Mushrooms + 4 / Smoked Onions + 4 / (2) Eggs Any Style$45.00Truffle Mac & Cheese
Housemade smoked cheddar beer cheese, cavatappi pasta, with toasted white truffle crunch & fresh chive$21.00Buffalo Chicken Bacon Ranch Flatbread
Chopped buffalo fried chicken tenderloins, vodka sauce, smoked cheddar & mozzarella cheese with ranch dressing finish$16.00Margherita Flatbread
House marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil pesto & marinated tomato$16.00Three Cheese Flatbread
House marinara sauce, four cheese blend including smoked cheddar, mozzarella & shaved parmesan$15.00
Sandwiches & More
Served with your choice of side // Hand-Cut Fries or Fresh Fruit [ *Gluten-Friendly Bread is Available + 4 ]
Bay House Club Sandwich
Ham, turkey, hydro lettuce, tomatoes, bacon, swiss and American cheese on three layers of white bread with mayo$20.00Beer-Battered Haddock Sandwich
Beer battered fresh haddock on a toasted brioche bun with dill caper tartar, hydro lettuce, tomatoes, and pickles on the side$20.00Bourbon Cheddar Chicken Sandwich
Natural grilled chicken breast, applewood bacon, smoked cheddar, maple bourbon mayo, butter lettuce, house pickles & tomato on a brioche roll$21.00Chicken Bruschetta
Grilled chicken breast, melted mozzarella, balsamic glaze, bib lettuce, wrapped in warm naan bread$19.00Classic Burger
Angus Reserve burger, American cheese, butter lettuce, house pickles & tomato on a brioche roll; served with Bay House steak sauce.$17.00Shrimp & Lobster Roll
Shrimp & lobster, dijonnaise & fresh dill on a toasted nantucket roll$21.00Wagyu Brisket Burger
Chuck, brisket, and short rib blend burger with Dubliner Irish cheddar, hydro lettuce, tobacco onions, and honey dijon aioli$28.00Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
$21.00
Soups & Salads
Bay House Chowder
Clams, shrimp, mussels, potatoes & corn with fresh parsley & oyster crackers$10.00Tomatillo Soup
Housemade with three varieties of peppers in a zesty tomatillo broth topped with sour cream and tortilla strips$9.00Bay House Salad
Mixed greens, cucumber, tomato, smoked cheddar & croutons$10.00Caesar Salad
Romaine, croutons & shaved parmesan tossed in caesar dressing$9.00Grilled Peaches Burrata
Basil pesto burrata, grilled peaches, shaved prosciutto, balsamic glaze, pomegranate, toasted pistachio, greens & truffle honey$16.00Mediterranean Salad
Spring greens, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, tomatoes, cucumber, pickled onions and feta cheese tossed in a housemade preserved lemon vinaigrette$14.00
Brunch
Choice Omelet
Made to order with your selections [ Your choice of 4 Selections ] ; served with your choice of side: Home Fries | Hand-Cut Fries | Fresh Fruit [ Everything Option + 3 ]$17.00Avocado Toast
Multi-grain bread, avocado, bruschetta, goat cheese, choice of two eggs any style; served with your choice of side: Home Fries | Hand-Cut Fries | Fresh Fruit [ + Smoked Salmon + 12 ]$17.00Breakfast Bowl
Seasoned home fries with bacon and sausage topped with a Mozzarella and smoked cheddar cheese blend; hollandaise sauce and chives$17.00Breakfast Flatbread
Stonefire flatbread with white sauce, scrambled egg, white cheddar, mozzarella, breakfast sausage, bacon, hollandaise sauce & chives [ Gluten-Friendly Crust is Available + 4 ]$18.00By Bay Burger
Angus Reserve burger, breakfast sausage, honey ham, smoked bacon, fried egg, american cheese & maple mayo on a brioche bun; served with your choice of side: Home Fries | Hand-Cut Fries | Fresh Fruit$23.00Chicken & Waffles
Nashville hot, homestyle hand-breaded fried chicken tenderloins, pearl sugar waffles, bourbon maple syrup, fresh berry compote & powdered sugar$22.00Creme Brûlée French Toast
Brioche bread dipped in sweet vanilla-orange custard, griddled golden brown in butter, salted caramel brûlée, fresh berry compote, finished with powdered sugar & maple syrup$16.00Southwest Bowl
Seasoned home fries topped with southwest corn & black bean salsa, cilantro, queso fresco, chipotle ranch, choice of two eggs any style & cajun spice$18.00Smoked Brisket Egg Benedict
$20.00Side Avocado
$4.00Side Bacon, Smoked
$4.00Side French Toast
$5.00Side Fresh Fruit
$5.00Side Hand-Cut Fries
$4.00Side Home Fries
$4.00Side Smoked Salmon
$12.00Side Sausage, Patties
$4.00Side Two Eggs
$4.00Side Two Waffles
$6.00Side Tenders
$5.00Side Green Chimi Aioli
$1.00Side Red Chimi Aioli
$1.00Side Multi-Grain
$3.00Side Brioche
$3.00Side Gluten-Friendly Toast
$4.00
Kids
Desserts
Bay House Brownie
Housemade double chocolate fudge brownie with dark chocolate morsels, peanut butter frosting, salted caramel drizzle, sweet cream & graham cracker dust$9.00Housemade Carrot Cake
Sweet spice cake with toasted nuts & shredded carrots topped with cream cheese frosting; finished with fresh whipped cream & salted caramel glaze$9.00
All hours
| Sunday | 10:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Saturday | Closed |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
8 Sassafras Pier, Erie, PA 16507