Featured Items
Angry Bear 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Sausage Pinch, Jalapeño, Red Sauce on top, Finished with Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle$24.00Maui Magic 12″
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Ham, Green Pepper, Pineapple Add Jalapeño, or Hot Giardiniera to make it erupt!$16.00Benelli’s Italian Lemonade 32oz
Made with real lemon juice and pure cane sugar, infused with fresh basil$4.00
Appetizers
Garlic Parm Benelli Bites
Bread Bites - Garlic Butter, Italian Herbs, Parm Cheese, Side of Red Sauce for dipping$4.00Cinnamon Benelli Bites
Bread Bites - Cinnamon, Butter$4.00Garlic Cheese Bread
Garlic Butter, Garlic Salt, Italian Herbs, Signature Cheese Blend$5.00Pizza Bread
Red Sauce, Signature Cheese Blend$5.00Tomato Bread
Red Sauce, Signature Cheese Blend, Roma Tomato$5.00Garlic Bread
Garlic Butter, Garlic Salt, Italian Herbs$4.00Apple Pie Pizza 12″
Apple Pie Filling, Finished with Ghirardelli Caramel Sauce Drizzle$10.00Apple Pie Pizza 16″
Apple Pie Filling, Finished with Ghirardelli Caramel Sauce Drizzle$16.00
Detroit Style
Build Your Own 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Red Sauce on top Topped & finished any way you’d like!$14.00Build Your Own 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Red Sauce on top Topped & finished any way you’d like!$18.00Brickyard Cheese 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Red Sauce on top$14.00Brickyard Cheese 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Red Sauce on top$18.00Angry Bear 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Sausage Pinch, Jalapeño, Red Sauce on top, Finished with Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle$15.00Angry Bear 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Sausage Pinch, Jalapeño, Red Sauce on top, Finished with Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle$24.00B.A. BBQ 8x10
Choice of Italian Beef, Sliced Chicken, or Smoked Pulled Pork Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Onion, Green Pepper, Finished with BBQ Drizzle$16.00B.A. BBQ 10x14
Choice of Italian Beef, Sliced Chicken, or Smoked Pulled Pork Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Onion, Green Pepper, Finished with BBQ Drizzle$25.00Brickhouse B.L.T. 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Bacon, Roma Tomato, Finished with Romaine Lettuce & MayoOUT OF STOCK$16.00Brickhouse B.L.T. 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Bacon, Roma Tomato, Finished with Romaine Lettuce & MayoOUT OF STOCK$25.00Detroit O.G. 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Pepperoni Cup & Char, Sausage Pinch, Red Sauce on top, Finished with Shaved Parm, Ricotta, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle$16.00Detroit O.G. 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Pepperoni Cup & Char, Sausage Pinch, Red Sauce on top, Finished with Shaved Parm, Ricotta, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle$25.00Harvest Time 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Roma Tomato, Red Sauce on top$16.00Harvest Time 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Roma Tomato, Red Sauce on top$25.00Maxxed Out 8x10
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Red Sauce on top$16.00Maxxed Out 10x14
Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Red Sauce on top$25.00Over & Under 8x10
Only Recommended for Pepperoni Lovers! Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Double Pepperoni Classic, Double Pepperoni Cup & Char, Red Sauce on top$16.00Over & Under 10x14
Only Recommended for Pepperoni Lovers! Wisconsin Brick Cheese, Double Pepperoni Classic, Double Pepperoni Cup & Char, Red Sauce on top$25.00
Hand Tossed Style
Build Your Own 12"
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend - Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster Topped & finished any way you’d like!$14.00Build Your Own 16"
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend - Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster Topped & finished any way you’d like!$18.00Cheese Pizza 12″
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend - Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster$14.00Cheese Pizza 16″
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend - Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster$18.00B.A. BBQ 12″
Choice of Italian Beef, Sliced Chicken, or Smoked Pulled Pork BBQ Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Onion, Green Pepper$17.00B.A. BBQ 16″
Choice of Italian Beef, Sliced Chicken, or Smoked Pulled Pork BBQ Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Onion, Green Pepper$25.00B.L.T. 12″
Signature Cheese Blend, Bacon, Roma Tomato, Finished with Romaine Lettuce & MayoOUT OF STOCK$16.00B.L.T. 16″
Signature Cheese Blend, Bacon, Roma Tomato, Finished with Romaine Lettuce & MayoOUT OF STOCK$24.00Cheesy Does It 12″
Red Sauce Base, Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster, Fresh Mozzarella, Parm, Romano, Finished with Shaved Parm, Ricotta$15.00Cheesy Does It 16″
Red Sauce Base, Mozzarella, Provolone, Münster, Fresh Mozzarella, Parm, Romano, Finished with Shaved Parm, Ricotta$22.00Chicago Combo 12″
Red Sauce Base, Italian Beef, Sausage Pinch, Hot Giardiniera, Signature Cheese Blend$17.00Chicago Combo 16″
Red Sauce Base, Italian Beef, Sausage Pinch, Hot Giardiniera, Signature Cheese Blend$25.00Chicken Bacon Ranch 12"
Ranch Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Sliced Chicken, Bacon$16.00Chicken Bacon Ranch 16"
Ranch Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Sliced Chicken, Bacon$24.00Chicken Benelli 12"
Basil Pesto Base, Ricotta, Signature Cheese Blend, Sliced Chicken, Artichoke Hearts, Fresh Mushroom$17.00Chicken Benelli 16"
Basil Pesto Base, Ricotta, Signature Cheese Blend, Sliced Chicken, Artichoke Hearts, Fresh Mushroom$24.00Fontanella Hunt Club 12″
Extra Virgin Olive Oil Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Hard Salami, Sausage Pinch, Finished with Baby Arugula, Balsamic Glaze DrizzleOUT OF STOCK$16.00Fontanella Hunt Club 16″
Extra Virgin Olive Oil Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Hard Salami, Sausage Pinch, Finished with Baby Arugula, Balsamic Glaze DrizzleOUT OF STOCK$24.00Maui Magic 12″
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Ham, Green Pepper, Pineapple Add Jalapeño, or Hot Giardiniera to make it erupt!$16.00Maui Magic 16″
Red Sauce Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Ham, Green Pepper, Pineapple Add Jalapeño, or Hot Giardiniera to make it erupt!$24.00Maxxed Out 12″
Red Sauce Base, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$16.00Maxxed Out 16″
Red Sauce Base, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$24.00Meat Me @ Benelli's 12″
Red Sauce Base, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Bacon, Ham, Signature Cheese Blend$16.00Meat Me @ Benelli's 16″
Red Sauce Base, Sausage Ground, Pepperoni Classic, Bacon, Ham, Signature Cheese Blend$24.00Mr Fun Guy 12″
Garlic Butter Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Button Mushrooms, Baby Bella Mushrooms, Cremini Mushrooms, Special Herbs$16.00Mr Fun Guy 16″
Garlic Butter Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Button Mushrooms, Baby Bella Mushrooms, Cremini Mushrooms, Special Herbs$24.00Roasted Rita 12″
Basil Pesto Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Fire Roasted Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella$16.00Roasted Rita 16″
Basil Pesto Base, Signature Cheese Blend, Fire Roasted Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella$24.00Sampson 12″
Tavern Horseradish Cheddar Base, Italian Beef, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$17.00Sampson 16″
Tavern Horseradish Cheddar Base, Italian Beef, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$25.00
Oven Baked Sandwiches
B.A. BBQ Sandwich
Choice of Italian Beef, Sliced Chicken, or Smoked Pulled Pork BBQ Sauce, Onion, Green Pepper, Signature Cheese Blend$11.00Chicago Combo Sandwich
Red Sauce, Italian Beef, Sausage Pinch, Hot Giardiniera, Signature Cheese Blend$11.00Chicken Benelli Sandwich
Basil Pesto, Ricotta, Sliced Chicken, Artichoke Hearts, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$11.00Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Red Sauce, Ham, Signature Cheese Blend$9.00Harvest Time Sandwich
Red Sauce, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom Roma Tomato, Signature Cheese Blend$9.00Italian Beef & Cheese Sandwich
1/4 Pound Italian Beef, Signature Cheese Blend Double the beef for $2 extra!$10.00Sampson Sandwich
Tavern Horseradish Cheddar, Italian Beef, Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Mushroom, Signature Cheese Blend$11.00Stromboli Sandwich
Red Sauce, Ground Sausage, Onion, Green Pepper, Signature Cheese Blend$10.00
Beverage
Benelli’s Italian Lemonade 32oz
Made with real lemon juice and pure cane sugar, infused with fresh basil$4.00Saratoga Sparkling Spring Water 28oz
28oz Saratoga Sparkling Spring Water Blue Glass Bottle$4.00Coke 20oz
20oz Coke Bottle$3.00Diet Coke 20oz
20oz Diet Coke Bottle$3.00Sprite 20oz
20oz Sprite Bottle$3.00San Pellegrino 16.9oz
16.9oz San Pellegrino Bottle$3.00
Cookies
Double Chocolate Chunk Cookie
Made with Butter, Semi-Sweet and Milk Chocolate Chunks, Chocolate Cookie Batter$1.506 Pack Double Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Made with Butter, Semi-Sweet and Milk Chocolate Chunks, Chocolate Cookie Batter$6.00Dozen Double Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Made with Butter, Semi-Sweet and Milk Chocolate Chunks, Chocolate Cookie Batter$10.00Lemon White Chocolate Cookie
Made with Lemon, Butter, Creamy Chunks of White Chocolate$1.506 Pack Lemon White Chocolate Cookies
Made with Lemon, Butter, Creamy Chunks of White Chocolate$6.00Dozen Lemon White Chocolate Cookies
Made with Lemon, Butter, Creamy Chunks of White Chocolate$10.00Oatmeal Raisin Walnut Cookie
Made with Hearty Oats, Plump Raisins, Tender Walnuts$1.506 Pack Oatmeal Raisin Walnut Cookies
Made with Hearty Oats, Plump Raisins, Tender Walnuts$6.00Dozen Oatmeal Raisin Walnut Cookies
Made with Hearty Oats, Plump Raisins, Tender Walnuts$10.00Peanut Butter Cup Cookie
Made with Creamy Peanut Butter, Mini Peanut Butter Cups, Honey-Roasted Peanuts, Bits of Dark Chocolate$1.506 Pack Peanut Butter Cup Cookies
Made with Creamy Peanut Butter, Mini Peanut Butter Cups, Honey-Roasted Peanuts, Bits of Dark ChocolateOUT OF STOCK$6.00Dozen Peanut Butter Cup Cookies
Made with Creamy Peanut Butter, Mini Peanut Butter Cups, Honey-Roasted Peanuts, Bits of Dark ChocolateOUT OF STOCK$10.00
All hours
| Sunday | 3:00 pm - 8:00 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 3:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 3:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 3:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 3:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Saturday | 3:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Pizzeria
Location
15 Roosevelt Rd, Valparaiso, IN 46383