.png)
American
Better Than Sex - Key West Key West
926 Simonton St
Key West, FL 33040
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items

Double Stuffed
Oreo Bread Pudding. Sweet White Chocolate. Vanilla Bean Love Custard. Cheesecake Ice Cream.$13.00
Man Flowers
Tall. Dark. Handsome. Proud and erect chocolate stout cake. Tart dark chocolate frosting. Chocolate stout ganache. Irish cream ice cream. Salted caramel.$14.00
Between My Red Velvet Sheets Cheesecake
Slide in gently, slowly welcoming the supple embrace this cheesecake is about to give you. An enhanced version of the original, the flavors of a red velvet cake whisper coyly throughout. This girthy cheesecake gets laid intently onto a bed of seductively soft dark chocolate cookie crust, only to be given an unexpected thrust when letting go of your inhibitions. The erect silky chocolate frosting and tease of strawberry will tickle your tongue and prepare you for oral stimulation.$14.00
Desserts

Berry Bondage
You must agree to this sensual experience as the first swallow may leave you feeling helpless. The paraphernalia used in this scene involves tenderly submissive Crepes that temporarily transfer control to repeated layers of Fresh Raspberries and Silky Tart White Chocolate Ganache. Occasionally spanked with a tease of Raspberry Liquor allows for more accessible pleasure. Feeling tempted to restrain from taking another nibble? Oh no, you're about to be Whipped with an Amaretto infused Topping and Berries bonded with a squirt of Strawberry Sauce. CAUTION: A bound person should never be left unattended and should be constantly monitored.$15.00
Blueberry Birthday
Buttered up Cinnamon-Sugar toast. Belgian White Chocolate. Spiked Blueberry Compote and Brie Cheesy kind of Mate. Strawberry Champagne Soup.$14.00OUT OF STOCK
Caress My Carrot
Embrace your inner snuggle-bunny and nuzzle up to this smooth carrot cake. Dried cranberries, pineapple, and pecans deep within. Fondled with vanilla- bean cream cheese frosting and a dribble of honey. (Made with a Gluten Free Flour, However we are not a gluten free facility and all items are made on shared equipment)$14.00
Missionary Crisp
Red Delicious 'skin-on' apples. Buttery cake-like layer "On Top". Salted Graham Cracker. Vanilla Bean Balls. Caramel.$13.00OUT OF STOCK
Double Stuffed
Oreo Bread Pudding. Sweet White Chocolate. Vanilla Bean Love Custard. Cheesecake Ice Cream.$13.00
Fever TG
Smooth. Soft. Supple. A warm airy Chocolate Cake full of body that’s oozing a subtle Chocolate Pudding underneath. Rubbing up against cool white Vanilla Bean Balls.$13.00OUT OF STOCK
Key Lime From Behind
This ethereally light and creamy tiramisu sneaks up from behind with perks of zesty lime that make you want to pucker ever so slightly. Sheets of creamy mousse, sultry sponge cake and a squeeze of key lime curd create this master piece of ……! (Key Lime Tiramisu …. what were you thinking :) Crisp lime meringue cookies nestled alongside are preferred for a quick pick me up, bursting with a key lime coulis that gushes when you bite just right. Finished with a salty graham crumb that is perfect to slide right back in to where you started, for that mmm, yes right there moment.$14.00
Man Flowers
Tall. Dark. Handsome. Proud and erect chocolate stout cake. Tart dark chocolate frosting. Chocolate stout ganache. Irish cream ice cream. Salted caramel.$14.00
Morning After
Danish Brie Cheese. Dark Belgian Chocolate. Wake up with Cinnamon Sugar. Strawberry Champagne Soup.$13.00
Cookie Nookie Pie
Intense Sweetie Pie. Chocolate Chip and Walnut Cookie filling wrapped in a Flakey Pie Crust. Vanilla Bean Ball. Caramel and Semi-Sweet Chocolate.$13.00OUT OF STOCK
Peanut Butter Perversion
Deviantly Corrupt Peanut Butter Silk Pie. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Crust. Salted Peanut Chocolate Bark. Adult Jelly.$14.00
Perfect Partner
Two Chilly Vanilla Bean Balls Squirted with Callebaut White Chocolate.$8.00OUT OF STOCK
Popcorn Pimp Cheesecake
Rich. Smooth. Airy.... Just how we like our men. Vanilla Bean Cheesecake. Sugar Cookie Dough Crust. Salted Popcorn Chocolate Bark. Caramel Saucy.$14.00OUT OF STOCK
Between My Red Velvet Sheets Cheesecake
Slide in gently, slowly welcoming the supple embrace this cheesecake is about to give you. An enhanced version of the original, the flavors of a red velvet cake whisper coyly throughout. This girthy cheesecake gets laid intently onto a bed of seductively soft dark chocolate cookie crust, only to be given an unexpected thrust when letting go of your inhibitions. The erect silky chocolate frosting and tease of strawberry will tickle your tongue and prepare you for oral stimulation.$14.00
Cuddle Cake
Chef Liz has created the ultimate comfort cake that makes everyone want to cuddle. She’s baked a biscoff cookie butter sponge cake, paired it with her biscoff cookie buttercream AND made a cookie butter caramel. It is accompanied by a house made coffee milk. You can add a little to your cake as you get cozier with every nibble.$15.00OUT OF STOCK
All American Girl
Pure and innocent this is the one you’ll want to take home to momma. Light, airy, and refreshing this Madagascar Vanilla Bean Cheesecake is nestled on top of a bed of oh so sweet sugar cookie dough. Then, topped with fluffy clouds of vanilla and almond infused whipped cream, fresh strawberries, blueberries, and freeze-dried raspberries that pop with flavor. Worthy of her companionship we’ve paired this beauty with our spiked Blueberry Compote offering a beautifully textured body with a sparkle in her eye.$14.69OUT OF STOCK
All hours
| Sunday | 6:00 pm - 10:45 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 6:00 pm - 10:45 pm |
| Thursday | 6:00 pm - 10:45 pm |
| Friday | 6:00 pm - 10:45 pm |
| Saturday | 6:00 pm - 10:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Full service intimate dessert restaurant in a speakeasy like setting
Location
926 Simonton St, Key West, FL 33040
