Skip to Main content
  • Big Johns Pizzeria

    • Home
    • /
    • Key West
    • /
    • Big Johns Pizzeria
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    Big Johns Pizzeria

    1103 Key Plaza

    Key West, FL 33040


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Website

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Food Menu
    Pasta
    New York Style Pizza
    Calzones, Strombolis, Rolls
    Non-Alcoholic Beverages Menu
    Beer & Wine
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • 12" Medium

      $13.95
    • Antipasto Salad

      Rolled ham, provolone, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella, served with house vinaigrette over garden salad
      $15.95
    • Tiramisu

      $5.50

    Food Menu

    Appetizers

    • Garlic Knots - 6 piece

      $5.59
    • Garlic Knots - 12 piece

      $9.30
    • Cheesy Bread

      Side of toast baked with mozzarella cheese & parmesan
      $4.25
    • French Fries

      $4.96
    • Side Chicken Salad

      $4.00
    • Mozzarella Stick

      $12.00
    • Caprese Appetizer

      $12.00
    • Chicken Fingers

      5 piece crispy chicken tenders
      $12.00
    • Buffalo Wings

      10 piece authentic buffalo, New York-style chicken wings tossed in sauce of choice
      $13.95
    • Buffalo Fingers

      $12.00
    • Fried Shrimp Basket

      Fried shrimp with side of french fries
      $14.96
    • Fried Shrimp

      $10.95
    • Side Meatballs + Sauce

      $10.95
    • Side Sausage + Sauce

      $10.95
    • Side Chicken Parmesan

      $12.00
    • Side Meatball Parmesan

      $12.00
    • Side Shrimp Parmesan

      $12.00
    • Side Eggplant Parmesan

      $12.00

    Soup of the Day

    12oz Cup
    • Lobster Bisque

      $5.50
    • Potato Bacon

      $5.50

    Fresh Salads

    • Small Garden Salad

      $5.00
    • Large Garden Salad

      $9.50
    • Small Caesar Salad

      $5.00
    • Large Caesar Salad

      $9.50
    • Chicken Caesar Salad

      Crisp romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, tomatoes croutons, and parmesan cheese with side of creamy Caesar dressing.
      $14.95
    • Shrimp Caesar Salad

      Crisp romaine, sautéed garlic shrimp, tomatoes, croutons, parmesan cheese with side of creamy Caesar dressing.
      $14.95
    • Antipasto Salad

      Rolled ham, provolone, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella, served with house vinaigrette over garden salad
      $15.95
    • Caprese Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, fresh basil, sliced fresh mozzarella, lightly drizzled with balsamic glaze
      $14.95
    • Greek Salad

      Romaine, fresh veggies, Kalamata olives, topped with Greek feta cheese, served with house vinaigrette
      $14.95
    • Spinach & Gorgonzola Cheese Salad

      Spinach, fresh veggies, roasted red pepper, crumbled bleu cheese and bacon bits
      $14.95
    • Buffalo Chicken Salad

      Crispy fried chicken tenders tossed in our buffalo sauce, served over fresh garden salad
      $14.95
    • Chicken Salad

      Homemade chicken salad made with diced chicken breast, fresh veggies served over fresh garden salad
      $14.95
    • Proscuitto Caprese Salad

      a layer of fresh arugula, then a layer of prosciutto, then tomatoes and fresh mozzarella drizzle with olive oil
      $15.95

    Sandwiches - Cold

    • Italian Grinder

      Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, onion, tomato & house vinaigrette
      $12.75
    • Crispy Chicken Fillet

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, provolone, and light mayo
      $12.75
    • Chicken Salad Sub

      Diced chicken breast tossed with mayo, lettuce, onion & tomato
      $12.75
    • Prosciutto & Mozzarella Sandwich

      Prosciutto, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella on arugula, drizzled with olive oil
      $12.75

    Sandwiches - Hot

    • Hot Ham & Cheese Sandwich

      Sliced ham & melted provolone cheese
      $12.75
    • Philly Steak & Cheese Sandwich

      Melted mozzarella & grilled steak
      $12.75
    • Sausage & Peppers Sandwich

      Italian sausage, green pepper, marinara & melted mozzarella cheese
      $12.75
    • Philly Chicken & Cheese Sandwich

      Melted mozzarella & grilled chicken
      $12.75
    • Tuscan Pesto Chicken Sandwich

      Breaded chicken tenders with creamy pesto sauce, roasted red peppers, onions, spinach & side of creamy house vinaigrette
      $12.75
    • Shrimp Po' Boy

      Fried shrimp, sweet Thai chili sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion on toasted hogie
      $12.75
    • Meatball Parmesan Sandwich

      Marinara and melted mozzarella cheese
      $12.75
    • Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

      Marinara and melted mozzarella cheese
      $12.75
    • Eggplant Parmesan Sandwich

      Marinara and melted mozzarella cheese
      $12.75
    • Shrimp Parmesan Sandwich

      $12.75

    Desserts

    • Homemade Tres Leches

      Fluffy light cake soaked in a sweet milk mixture and topped with fresh whipped cream and cinnamon
      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.50
    • Cannoli

      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.50
    • Tiramisu

      $5.50
    • Cheesecake

      $5.50
    • Limoncello Cake

      Bright citrus taste derived from fresh lemons topped with white chocolate.
      $5.50
    • Rice Krispie / Waffle - Marshmallow, Brown Butter & Sea Salt

      $4.25
    • Peruvian Chocolate Brownie

      Featuring a rich, slightly fruity chocolate flavor and dense, fudgy texture, these bold chocolatey brownies are chock full of sustainably-sourced chocolate, pure cane sugar and cage free eggs
      $4.75
    • Rice Pudding

      Rice pudding is a traditional dessert that combines rice with milk and sugar, cooked until thick and creamy. Topped with cinnamon, served cold.
      $5.50
    • 12" Nutella Pizza

      Drizzled with chocolate hazelnut Nutella + strawberries topped with powdered sugar
      $16.50
    • 16" Nutella Pizza

      $20.50

    KIDS

    • Kids Chicken Fingers

      Kids basket of chicken fingers and french fries
      $10.00
    • Kids Spaghetti Marinara

      $9.00
    • Kids Spaghetti Butter

      $8.00
    • Kids Spaghetti + Meatball

      $10.00

    Extra Sauce

    • Side Marinara

      $0.75
    • Side Garlic Oil

      $0.50
    • Extra Ranch

      $0.50
    • Extra Blue Cheese

      $0.50
    • Extra HOUSE

      $0.50
    • Extra Caesar

      $0.50
    • Extra Italian

      $0.50
    • Side HOT Sauce

      $0.50
    • Side MILD Sauce

      $0.50
    • Side BBQ Sauce

      $0.50
    • Side Alfredo Sauce

      $5.00
    • Side Pesto Sauce

      $5.00
    • Side Creamy Tomato Basil Sauce

      $5.00
    • Side Meatsauce

      $5.00
    • Homemade House Dressing - 16 Oz

      $10.00

    Pasta

    Italian Pasta Dinners

    • Marinara Dinner

      $13.95
    • Ham with Cheese Dinner

      $19.96
    • Meat Sauce Dinner

      $16.95
    • Homemade Meatballs Dinner

      $16.95
    • Italian Sausage Dinner

      $16.95
    • Shrimp Scampi Dinner

      Shrimp sauteed in garlic butter, lemon juice, served over pasta
      $22.96
    • Pasta Primavera Dinner

      Pasta with mushrooms, onion, broccoli, spinach, tomato & fresh garlic. Served in marinara sauce OR garlic and oil sauce
      $19.96
    • Creamy Basil Tomato Dinner

      Fresh basil, sliced tomato sauteed in creamy pink sauce
      $16.96
    • Creamy Pesto Dinner

      Creamy green basil sauce, garlic served over pasta
      $16.96
    • 5 Cheese Ravioli Dinner

      Ravioli pasta stuffed with 5 cheese over creamy white sauce
      $16.96

    Baked Pasta Dinner

    • Homemade Meat Lasagna Dinner

      Fresh pasta layered with ricotta, ground beef, mozzarella & marinara
      $19.96
    • Baked Ziti Dinner

      Creamy ricotta, marinara & mozzarella on top
      $19.96
    • Eggplant Rollatini Dinner

      Sliced breaded eggplant rolled with ricotta, marinara & mozzarella, served over pasta
      $19.96
    • Chicken Parmesan Dinner

      Lightly breaded chicken breast, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese, served over pasta
      $19.96
    • Eggplant Parmesan Dinner

      Thin-sliced, breaded eggplant with marinara & mozzarella, served over pasta
      $19.96
    • Stuffed Shells Dinner

      Pasta shells stuffed with ricotta cheese, topped with marinara & mozzarella
      $19.96

    Creamy Alfredo Dinners

    • Classic Fettuccine Alfredo

      $16.96
    • Veggie Fettuccine Alfredo

      $18.96
    • Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo

      $19.96
    • Shrimp Fettuccine Alfredo

      $22.96

    New York Style Pizza

    Pizza By The SLICE

    • Specialty Slice

      $5.00
    • Build Your Own Slice

      $4.00

    New York Styled Pizza

    • 12" Medium

      $13.95
    • 16" X-Large

      $17.95

    Specialty Pizza

    • Buffalo Chicken

      Diced chicken, buffalo sauce, mozzarella & ranch drizzle on top
      $20.47+
    • Hawaiian

      Pineapple tidbits, diced ham & mozzarella cheese
      $20.47+
    • Margherita

      Fresh buffalo mozzarella, basil, extra virgin olive oil & pizza sauce
      $20.47+
    • The Chickle Pizza

      Chicken, Pickles, Bacon, Pickled Onions
      OUT OF STOCK
      $20.49+
    • White Pie

      Ricotta, fresh garlic, sliced plum tomatoes & mozzarella
      $20.47+
    • All the Way

      Pepperoni, ham, sausage, onion, green peppers, mushrooms, fresh garlic & mozzarella
      $20.47+
    • Veggie Pizza

      Light & healthy: spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, fresh garlic & mozzarella
      $20.47+
    • Meat Lovers

      Pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, genoa salami & mozzarella
      $20.47+
    • Godfather

      Fresh mozzarella, basil, garlic, plum tomatoes
      $20.47+
    • Greek Pizza

      Feta cheese, kalamata olives, onions, spinach, roasted red peppers, garlic & mozzarella
      $20.47+
    • Prosciutto & Fig

      Thinly sliced prosciutto ham, mozzarella, baby arugula with an organic fig sauce base
      $20.47+
    • Shrimp Scampi Pizza

      Delicious shrimp, garlic, extra virgin olive oil, oregano with mozzarella cheese + a dash of lemon
      $20.47+
    • Chicken Alfredo Pizza

      Breaded chicken breast with creamy alfredo and mozzarella
      $20.47+
    • Chicken Parmesan

      Sliced chicken breast, fresh garlic, mozzarella & parmesan
      $20.47+
    • Golden BBQ Chicken

      Chicken, red onions, basil, golden BBQ sauce & mozzarella
      $20.47+
    • Pesto Chicken Bacon

      $20.47+
    • Steak and Cheese Pizza

      Choice of green peppers, onion and/or mushrooms
      $20.47+
    • Spinach White Pie

      $20.47+
    • Niki's Pie

      Our classic Margherita pizza topped with prosciutto and arugula
      $20.47+
    • Half & Half

      $20.47+

    Awesome Stuffed John Pizza

    • 12" Original Awesome Stuff John Pizza

      Pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, genoa salami, mozzarella cheese covered with a layer of dough, baked to golden brown, topped with olive oil + Parmesan cheese
      $24.19
    • 16" Original Awesome Stuff John Pizza

      Pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, genoa salami, mozzarella cheese covered with a layer of dough, baked to golden brown, topped with olive oil + Parmesan cheese
      $28.91

    Calzones, Strombolis, Rolls

    Strombolis

    • Meat Stromboli

      Meat lovers delight. Layers of ham, Italian sausage, pepperoni, genoa salami & mozzarella cheese
      $19.54
    • Veggie Stromboli

      Veggie lovers delight. Fresh mushrooms, onions, spinach, broccoli, tomato, fresh garlic and mozzarella
      $19.54

    Jumbo Calzones

    A real Italian delight mozzarella, parmesan & ricotta. All wrapped in thin pizza dough and baked to a golden brown. Served with marinara sauce.
    • Build Your Own Calzone

      A real Italian delight, mozzarella, Parmesan, and ricotta cheese. All wrapped in a thin pizza dough and baked to a golden brown. Served with marinara sauce
      $14.95
    • Meat Calzone

      Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Genoa Salami, Ham, Mozzarella & Ricotta. Served with side of Marinara.
      $19.54
    • All The Way Calzone

      Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Ham, Onion, Green Pepper, Mushroom, Garlic, Mozzarella & Ricotta. Served with side of Marinara.
      $19.54

    Italian Rolls

    • Chicken Bacon Roll

      $15.95
    • Buffalo Chicken Roll

      $15.95
    • Pepperoni Roll

      $15.95
    • Sausage Green Pepper Roll

      $15.95

    Non-Alcoholic Beverages Menu

    Non-Alcoholic Beverages

    • Canned Products

      $2.50
    • Bottled Products

    • Bottled Water

      $2.00
    • Bottled Tea

      $3.50
    • Jarritos

      $2.95
    • Sicilian Blood Orange Soda

      OUT OF STOCK
      $3.50
    • Sicilian Lemon Soda

      $3.50
    • Apple Juice

      $2.50
    • Powerade

      $3.50
    • San Pellegrino

      $3.50
    • COFFEE


    Beer & Wine

    Bottled Beer

    • Michelob Ultra

      $5.00
    • Yuengling

      $5.00
    • Stella

      $5.38
    • Corona

      $5.38
    • Modelo

      $5.38
    • Heineken

      $5.38
    • Peroni

      $5.38

    Wine by Bottle

    • (NEW) Orange Wine

      Solis Lumen Solis Lumen - Orange 2024 amber color, citrus aromas on the nose
      $20.00
    • Pinot Grigio

      Chloe Pinot Grigio 2024 (750 ml)
      $20.00
    • Rosé

      $20.00
    • Sauvignon Blanc

      Chloe Sauvignon Blanc White Wine New Zealand, 750 ml Bottle
      $20.00
    • Pinot Noir

      $20.00
    • Cabernet Sauvignon

      $20.00
    • Prosecco (Single Serve)

      $8.99
    If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

    All hours
    Sunday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Wednesday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Thursday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Friday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Saturday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    Where The Locals Eat

    Location

    1103 Key Plaza, Key West, FL 33040

    Directions