Skip to Main content
  • Brewster’s New Buffalo

    • Home
    • /
    • New Buffalo
    • /
    • Brewster’s New Buffalo
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image

    Brewster’s New Buffalo

    Italian
    Open now9AM - 8:45PM
    CallDirectionsGift Cards
    ‌
    ‌
    NA BEVERAGES
    BREAKFAST
    EXTRAS
    DESSERTS

    NA BEVERAGES

    OTHER BEV

    • Acqua Panna Still Water

      $4.00
    • Arnold Palmer

      $4.00
    • Fever Tree

      $8.00
    • Flavored Pelligrino

      blood orange or limonata
      $5.00
    • Fresh Squeezed OJ

      $6.00
    • Ginger Beer

      $4.00
    • gingergrass cbd

      $8.00
    • Iced Tea

      $4.00
    • Italian Soda

      $5.00
    • Juices

      orange, cranberry, or apple
      $4.00
    • Kids Bev

      $4.00
    • Large AquaPanna

      $7.00
    • Large Milk

      $4.00
    • Lavender Lemonade

      $6.00
    • Lemonade

      $4.00
    • Raspberry Lemonade

      $6.00
    • San Pellegrino

      italian natural mineral water 16oz
      $5.00
    • Small Milk

      $3.00
    • Soda

      coke, diet coke, sprite, root beer, lemonade, ginger ale, soda water, tonic water, iced tea
      $4.00
    • Strawberry Lemonade

      $6.00
    • Tonic

      $3.00
    • Topo Chico

      Topo Chico has always been known for the legend surrounding its origins. Whether you believe in the legend or not, you'll still be able to enjoy the crisp, no-calorie taste of Topo Chico.
      $5.00

    BREAKFAST

    BREAKFAST ENTREES

    • Avocado Toast

      spiced avocado mousse, spinach and tomato bruschetta topped with two over-easy eggs on thick cut sourdough drizzled with balsamic reduction
      $15.00
    • Berry Pancakes

      stack of 3 pancakes with our homemade berry sauce
      $14.00
    • Biscuits and Gravy

      biscuits and sausage gravy finished with scallions
      $10.00+
    • Breakfast BLT

      smoked bacon, lettuce, roma tomato and garlic aioli with two over-easy eggs on sun-dried tomato focaccia, served with potatoes
      $16.00
    • Hippie Hash

      onion, roasted garlic, roasted red pepper, mushroom, spinach, potato and fresh herb with roasted garlic oil and a side of toast
      $13.00
    • Mary's Mess

      "the mess" with a brewster's bloody mary
      $22.00
    • Mascarpone - Stuffed French Toast

      brioche dipped in custard, layered with mascarpone topped with our homemade berry sauce and powdered sugar
      $17.00
    • Pancakes

      stack of 3 served w/ pure maple syrup
      $12.00
    • Regular French Toast

      $12.00
    • The Mess

      our house specialty scramble w/ cheddar cheese + bacon + onion + roasted red peppers + potatoes + eggs + roasted garlic + sausage w/ a biscuit no substitutions*
      $17.00
    • The Old Standby

      two eggs to order, potato, choice of bacon or sausage patty and a biscuit
      $12.00

    A LA CARTE

    • Bacon

      two strips
      $4.00
    • (2 ) Eggs

      two cooked to order
      $4.00
    • Sausage

      two links
      $3.00
    • Biscuit

      served w/ dara's homemade jam
      $2.00
    • SD of Hippie Hash

      onion, roasted garlic, roasted red pepper, mushroom, spinach, potato and fresh herb with roasted garlic oil and a side of toast
      $8.00
    • SD potatoes

      diced and seasoned
      $4.00
    • Side of gravy

      $3.00
    • Single Pancake

      served with pure maple syrup
      $4.00
    • Toast w Jam

      $2.00
    • Fruit bowl

      $5.00
    • cinnamon roll

      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.00

    KIDS BREAKFAST

    • Kids Berry Pancakes

      served with our homemade berry sauce
      $7.00
    • Kids Egg Breakfast

      two eggs scrambled with cheddar cheese and a biscuit
      $5.00
    • Kids Pancakes

      served with maple syrup
      $5.00
    • Kids French Toast

      served with maple syrup
      $7.00

    EXTRAS

    • 1 MEATBALL

      $3.00
    • 1/2 PINT DRESSING

      $4.00
    • 4 Shrimp

      $11.00
    • Add Chicken Breast

      $6.00
    • ADULT SIZED MIXED VEG

      $8.00
    • HOUSE BREAD LOAF

      $11.00
    • MARINARA 1/2 pint

      $4.00
    • MARINARA PINT

      $8.00
    • MARINARA QUART

      $16.00
    • PESTO 1/2 pint

      $16.00
    • PESTO PINT

      $32.00
    • PINT DRESSING

      $8.00
    • QUART DRESSING

      $16.00
    • Side Alfredo

      $1.00
    • Side 4 Dinner Meatballs

      $12.00
    • Side 2 Meatballs

      $6.00
    • Side Marinara

      $1.00
    • Side Pesto

      $1.00
    • Side Pizza Sauce

      $0.50
    • Soup Quart

      $15.00
    • SOURDOUGH DOUGH BALLS

      raw dough ball
      $5.00
    • TRADITIONAL DOUGH BALLS

      raw dough ball
      $3.00
    • Salmon Filet 6 oz

      $13.00
    • Side House Dressing

      $0.75
    • Avocado

      $2.00
    • Side of Beef Tips

      $10.00
    • crispy chicken

      $7.00

    DESSERTS

    • a la mode

      $3.00
    • Cookies

      $3.00
    • Hummingbird cake

      $12.00
    • Lemon Tres Leches

      $10.00
    • PB Pie

      $11.00
    • Sticky Toffee

      $10.00
    • Tiramisu

      $10.00

    All hours
    Sunday9:00 am - 11:15 am, 11:45 am - 3:45 pm, 4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Monday9:00 am - 11:15 am, 12:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Tuesday9:00 am - 11:15 am, 11:45 am - 3:45 pm, 4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Wednesday9:00 am - 11:15 am, 11:45 am - 3:45 pm, 4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Thursday9:00 am - 11:15 am, 11:45 am - 3:45 pm, 4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Friday9:00 am - 11:15 am, 11:45 am - 3:45 pm, 4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Saturday9:00 am - 11:15 am, 11:45 am - 3:45 pm, 4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    Serving delicious food in downtown New Buffalo ♥️ offering breakfast, lunch and dinner 7 days a week!

    Location

    11 West Merchant Street, New Buffalo, MI 49117

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play