
Sushi
BUTTERFISH 15 Franklin Place
15 Franklin Place
Rutherford, NJ 07070
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items

The One
A curated journey celebrating the finest seasonal sushi. Start with warm, lightly salted edamame and sashimi of the day—Yellowtail with fresh shaved jalapeño and yuzu tokkibi. Follow with eight pieces of expertly crafted nigiri: Yellowtail, Salmon, Akami, Fluke, Suzuki, Albacore, Otoro, and Hokkaido Scallop. Conclude with eight pieces of maki: 4-piece Chūtoro Maki and 4-piece Blue Claw Crab Maki. A harmonious balance of flavors, textures, and artistry, offering an unforgettable sushi experience.$69.00THE PREMIUM
$99.00
Truffle Sashimi
Akami and Hamachi layered with pieces of white truffle in a yuzu ponzu base & garnished with microgreens.$32.00
Food
Starters

Large Edamame
Steamed to perfection with a touch of sea salt.$11.00
Cucumber Salad
Our Cucumber Chili Crunch Salad is a favorite amongst everyone! Crisp, Bright & Refreshing, Our Chili Crunch is made In House by Chef, NOT out of a jar!$15.00
FOUR BLUE POINTS CON LECHE AMARILLO
Four beautiful Blue Point Oysters sourced locally from Maine (Cold Water). Served on the half shell in a delicious little pool of Leche Amarilla Del Tigre. Several layers of flavor in the leche amarilla, primarily citrus forward with unique aromatics, slightly sweet from the raw oyster. A super awesome bite!$32.00
Japanese Yellowtail Ceviche
The best ceviche known to man. Melt in your mouth young yellowtail that's been marinated in a Leche Del Tigre made from scratch by chef. Super citrus forward and aromatic. a Butterfish Favorite for sure!$24.00
MISO BLACK COD
A decadent quarter-pound of black cod, meticulously marinated in premium sake for two full days to infuse deep umami and subtle sweetness. Broiled to perfection, it is served in a stunning white miso reduction, creating a silky, caramelized glaze that highlights the fish’s buttery texture and delicate flavor.$42.00
Salmon Burrata
Fresh salmon topped with burrata in a yuzu vinaigrette made in house by chef drizzled with aromatic olive oil & truffle honey, finished with flakey sea salt.$26.00
Tuna Wasabi
Lean bluefin tuna sashimi (Akami) is topped with fresh grated wasabi root done on a shark skin pad by Chef. He folds in a little yuzu and scallion then pipes that on top for a super awesome bite! Our bluefin tunas are flown in six days a week from Japan and broken down daily in house by Chef.$34.00
Toro Wasabi
Otoro sashimi topped with fresh grated wasabi root done on a shark skin pad by Chef. He folds in a little yuzu and scallion then pipes that on top for a super awesome bite! Our bluefin tunas are flown in six days a week from Japan and broken down daily in house by Chef.$42.00
Salmon Belly Crudo in Yuzu Miso Reduction
Velvety slices of salmon belly, exquisitely marinated and served in a luminous yuzu miso reduction. Crowned with delicate tempura pearls and a bespoke house-made togarashi, this dish delivers a symphony of rich umami, vibrant citrus aromatics, and contrasting textures. An indulgent, unforgettable bite of refined decadence.$26.00
Truffle Sashimi
Akami and Hamachi layered with pieces of white truffle in a yuzu ponzu base & garnished with microgreens.$32.00
White Truffle Scallop Carpaccio
Hokkaido scallops flown in six days a week from Japan are shucked to order and drizzled with yuzu, yuzu kosho, olive oil and topped with white truffles & finished with a sprinkle of sea salt.$36.00
Butterfish Omakase
THE ONE
$69.00Edamame and Sashimi
1X YELLOWTAIL 1X SALMON 1X FLUKE 1X SUZUKI
Toro Handroll SET
1X TUNA 1X ALBACORE 1X TORO 1X SCALLOP
Bluecrab Handroll SET
THE SIGNATURE
$79.00Edamame and Sashimi
1X SALMON 1X YELLOWTAIL 1X SCALLOP 1X SUZUKI 1X SAGOSHI
Toro Handroll SET
1X TUNA 1X TORO 1X UNAGI SOLO 1X FLUKE 1X ALBACORE
Crab Handroll SET
THE PREMIUM
$99.00Edamame - Sashimi - Salmon Burrata
1X TUNA 1X ALBACORE 1X TORO 1X KANPACHI 1X SUZUKI 1X OYSTER ON HALF SHELL
Toro Handroll SET
1X YELLOWTAIL 1X SALMON TRUFFLE 1X UNI 1X SCALLOP 1X UNAGI FOIE GRAS 1X JAPANESE A5 WAGYU
Crab Handroll SET
Chef Tasting Omakase
$150.00Cucumber, Tuna Tataki, Sashimi of The Day
1X MADAI 1X KINMEDAI 1X TORO 1X TUNA 1X BOTAN EBI 1X SEARED TORO
Toro Grab Handroll
1X YELLOWTAIL 1X SALMON TRUFFLE 1X UNI 1X SCALLOP 1X UNAGI FOIE GRAS 1X JAPANESE A5 WAGYU
SURF AND TURF GRAB HANDROLL
Nigiri

2pc Albacore
This albacore is NOT what mom used to put on your sandwich. Our Albacore is FRESH and flown in daily. It melts in your mouth like butter, simple yet such an awesome bite.$12.00
2pc Bluefin Tuna
Our super lean bluefin is flown in six days a week from Japan. Chef breaks down his whole tuna and serves this bluefin nigiri topped with some of his house made chili crunch. A Butterfish favorite!$12.00
2pc Botan Ebi w/ Yuzu Caviar
Sweet, tender botan ebi atop perfectly seasoned sushi rice, crowned with a delicate touch of yuzu caviar. A harmonious bite of ocean sweetness and bright, citrusy elegance.$18.00
2PC Fluke
Delicate, buttery fluke layered over seasoned sushi rice and accented with fragrant Oba leaf. A light, herbaceous bite that highlights subtle ocean flavors with a refreshing finish.$14.00
2pc Hamachi
Buttery, melt-in-your-mouth yellowtail served atop seasoned sushi rice with a dot of yuzu koshu on top. Silky, rich, and elegantly balanced, showcasing the delicate flavor of the ocean.$12.00
2pc Hokkaido Scallop
Our Scallops are flown in from Hokkaido, Japan six days a week! Topped with a dot of Yuzu Koshu, these scallops are sweet, delicate, massive and meaty, our scallops are some of the best you will ever have. Two pieces to an order.$14.00
2pc Hokkaido Uni
Our uni is flown in from Hokkaido, Japan six days a week! Super rich, tons of umami, incredibly delicate and fat forward, our uni is some of the best you will ever have. Two pieces to an order.$24.00OUT OF STOCK
2pc Japanese A5 Wagyu
Our Japanese A5 Wagyu is flown in from Japan multiple times each week. Beautifully marbled and totally melt in your mouth. Our A5 Wagyu Nigiri comes with two pieces to an order and seared with chef's torched.$25.00
2PC Kanpachi
Tender, buttery Kanpachi atop seasoned sushi rice, finished with thinly shaved fresh jalapeño for a bright, subtle kick. A harmonious balance of clean ocean flavor and gentle heat.$14.00
2pc Kinmedai
Delicate, subtly sweet golden eye snapper atop seasoned sushi rice. Silky and tender, offering a refined, clean ocean flavor with a melt-in-your-mouth texture. Lite sear from chef's torch.$16.00
2pc Madai
Elegant, mild-flavored sea bream served atop seasoned sushi rice. Light, tender, and subtly sweet, showcasing the delicate nuances of pristine ocean freshness.$16.00
2PC Sagoshi
Juvenile Japanese mackerel served atop seasoned sushi rice, offering a clean, buttery texture with a delicate, savory flavor. A refined, ocean-fresh bite with subtle richness.$14.00
2pc Salmon
Silky, buttery salmon sourced daily from Norway, served atop perfectly seasoned sushi rice. Fresh, vibrant, and melt-in-your-mouth, highlighting the pristine quality of the ocean’s finest catch.$10.00
2pc Seared Salmon Belly
Two pieces of our seared salmon belly. Our salmon is flown in from Norway six days a week.$12.00
2pc Seared Toro
Two pieces of Otoro, the more premium cut of the bluefin tuna belly that's been hit with Chef's torch to pull forward some of that fatty goodness. This also adds a delicate crust to the exterior of the toro.$20.00
2 pc Shima Aji
Shima Aji, also known as Stripped Jack, is a fish prized for its delicate, buttery flavor and firm, crisp texture. It's often described as having a subtle sweetness and a refined, clean taste. Two pieces to an order.$20.00
2PC Suzuki
Delicately sliced sea bass draped over perfectly seasoned sushi rice, finished with a bright sprinkle of fresh lemon zest for a subtle citrus lift.$14.00
2pc Toro
Luxuriously marbled fatty tuna atop hand-formed sushi rice, crowned with freshly grated wasabi root for a vivid, aromatic kick that enhances the delicate richness of the fish.$18.00
2pc Unagi
Our unagi is the BEST! Fresh water eel seared with Chef's torch and served on two beautifully seasoned pillows of rice for a super awesome bite!$12.00
2pc Unagi Foie Gras
Our unagi is the BEST! Fresh water eel seared with Chef's torch and topped with Foie Gras from a very elevated bite. A Butterfish favorite for sure! Two pieces to an order.$18.00
2pc Yellowtail
Two pieces of our Yellowtail Snapper nigiri. A light, delicate protein filled with wonderful flavor.$12.00
Classic Handrolls
Our Omakases & Chef Tasting Experience

The One
A curated journey celebrating the finest seasonal sushi. Start with warm, lightly salted edamame and sashimi of the day—Yellowtail with fresh shaved jalapeño and yuzu tokkibi. Follow with eight pieces of expertly crafted nigiri: Yellowtail, Salmon, Akami, Fluke, Suzuki, Albacore, Otoro, and Hokkaido Scallop. Conclude with eight pieces of maki: 4-piece Chūtoro Maki and 4-piece Blue Claw Crab Maki. A harmonious balance of flavors, textures, and artistry, offering an unforgettable sushi experience.$69.00
The Signature
A refined culinary journey showcasing the pinnacle of sushi artistry. Begin with warm, lightly salted edamame and sashimi of the day—velvety Yellowtail accented with shaved jalapeño and yuzu tobiko. Delight in ten pieces of exquisitely crafted nigiri: Yellowtail, Salmon, Akami, Fluke, Suzuki, Albacore, Otoro, Hokkaido Scallop, Unagi, and Sagoshi. Conclude with eight pieces of delicate maki: 4-piece Chūtoro Maki and 4-piece Blue Claw Crab Maki. Every bite balances sublime flavors, textures, and umami, offering a truly unforgettable omakase experience.$79.00
The Premium
An extraordinary sushi journey crafted for the discerning palate. Begin with three exquisite appetizers: warm, lightly salted edamame, sashimi of the day—Yellowtail with shaved jalapeño and yuzu tokkibi—and our signature Salmon Burrata. Savor twelve pieces of sublime nigiri: Akami, Albacore, Otoro, Kanpachi, Suzuki, Blue Point Oyster on the half shell, Hamachi, Seared Salmon Belly with white truffle, Hokkaido Uni, Hokkaido Scallop, Unagi & Foie Gras, and Japanese A5 Wagyu. Conclude with eight pieces of elegant maki: 4-piece Chūtoro Maki and 4-piece Blue Claw Crab Maki. Each bite delivers unparalleled umami, texture, and artistry—a truly unforgettable omakase experience.$99.00
The Chef Tasting
Experience the pinnacle of elevated dining curated by Two Michelin Star Chef Jeffry Undiarto, the visionary behind n/naka in Los Angeles. Begin by choosing one of four exquisite starters: Salmon Burrata, White Truffle Scallop Carpaccio, Yellowtail Ceviche, or Truffle Sashimi. The journey continues with Cucumber Chili Crunch Salad, Bluefin Tuna Tataki, and the Sashimi of The Day. Savor 12 masterfully crafted nigiri, including Madai, Akami, Botan Ebi, Hokkaido Scallop, Hokkaido Uni, Unagi & Foie Gras, Kinmedai, Otoro, and Japanese A5 Wagyu—followed by eight pieces of exquisite maki: 4-piece Chūtoro Maki and 4-piece Blue Claw Crab Maki. Every ingredient is flown in from Japan six days a week, delivering unmatched freshness, artistry, and an unforgettable tasting experience.$150.00
Classic & Signature Cut Rolls

Avocado Handroll Cut (4 PIECE MAKI)
A simple Four Piece Avocado Cut Roll with nori on the outside. Four pieces per order.$10.00
Inari Cut Roll (4 PIECE MAKI)
Sweet, marinated tofu pockets filled with seasoned sushi rice and gently rolled for a delicate, bite-sized treat. Soft, savory, and subtly sweet—perfect as a light starter or vegetarian favorite.$10.00
Spicy Cucumber Cut Roll (4 PIECE MAKI)
Crisp cucumber wrapped in sushi rice and nori, tossed with a zesty spicy sauce for a refreshing yet fiery bite. Light, crunchy, and perfectly balanced.$10.00
Kampyo Handroll Cut (4 PIECE MAKI)
A delicious Four Piece Kampyo Cut Roll with nori on the outside. Kampyo is like a Japanese pumpkin. Four pieces per order.$10.00
Spicy Tuna Handroll Cut (4 PIECE MAKI)
Our Four Piece Spicy Tuna Cut Rolls are AWESOME! Chef uses super lean blue fin tuna we fly in from Japan 6 days a week to make his spicy tuna. topped with toasted sesame seeds.$13.00
Salmon Handroll Cut (4 PIECE MAKI)
A simple Four Piece Salmon Cut Roll with nori on the outside. Our salmon is flown in 6 days a week from Norway.$13.00Chutoro Scallion Handroll Cut (4 PIECE MAKI)
The chutoro is the more fatty cut of the blue fin tuna belly. Chef takes the Chutoro and breaks that down very finely and likes to finish roll off with a little house made ponzu, scallions and fresh grated wasabi root done on a shark skin pad by chef. A super awesome bite and four pieces to an order. Try with Caviar on top as well! We serve American Sturgeon every evening.$20.00
Hokkaido Scallop & Yuzu Koshu Handroll Cut (4 PIECE MAKI)
Our scallops are flown in 6 days a week from Hokkaido, Japan. Chef pairs these massive and super sweet scallops with fresh yuzu and yuzu koshu for a perfectly balanced bite. Sweet from the scallop. Floral and citrus forward from the yuzu. This one's a total home run!$13.00Yellowtail Handroll Cut (4 PIECE MAKI)
A simple Four Piece Yellowtail Cut Roll with nori on the outside. Four pieces per order.$13.00Blue Claw Crab Handroll Cut (4 PIECE MAKI)
A simple Four Piece Blue Claw Crab Cut Roll with nori on the outside and topped with house made furikake. Four pieces per order. Try it with adding avocado!$13.00Unagi Foie Gras Cut Roll (4 PIECE MAKI)
Rich, caramelized freshwater eel paired with seared foie gras, rolled with seasoned sushi rice and nori. A luxurious blend of smoky sweetness and buttery decadence in every bite.$18.00Chutoro & Caviar Cut Roll (4 PIECE MAKI)
Silky, melt-in-your-mouth chūtoro paired with delicate American sturgeon caviar, rolled with seasoned sushi rice and nori. A refined bite that highlights pure, balanced ocean richness.$24.00Seared Salmon Belly and White Truffle Handroll Cut (4 PIECE MAKI)
Taking the salmon cut roll to the next level! This roll utilizes the salmon belly and it gets a beautiful sear from Chef's torch. After, it gets topped with fresh pieces of white truffles for the ultimate bite. Super aromatic with tons of umami. Nori on the outside and four pieces per order. Our salmon is flown in 6 days a week from Norway.$20.00Surf & Turf Cut Roll with Uni (4 PIECE MAKI)
A decadent trio of flavors featuring sweet, cooked blue claw crab, buttery Japanese A5 wagyu, and ultra-creamy Hokkaido uni. Rolled with seasoned sushi rice and nori, this special bite delivers an unforgettable balance of ocean richness and melt-in-your-mouth indulgence.$40.00OUT OF STOCKJapanese A5 Wagyu & Foie Gras Cut Roll (4 PIECE MAKI)
Luxuriously seared Japanese A5 wagyu paired with buttery foie gras, wrapped with seasoned sushi rice and nori. An indulgent harmony of melt-in-your-mouth textures and deep, savory richness in every bite.$34.00Japanese A5 Wagyu & Hokkaido Uni Cut Roll (4 PIECE MAKI)
Melt-in-your-mouth Japanese A5 wagyu paired with ultra-creamy Hokkaido uni, rolled with seasoned sushi rice and nori. A luxurious surf-and-turf expression offering deep umami, rich sweetness, and an exquisitely silky finish.$30.00OUT OF STOCKBotan Ebi, Japanese A5 Wagyu & Caviar Cut Roll (4 PIECE MAKI)
A decadent trio featuring sweet, succulent botan ebi, melt-in-your-mouth Japanese A5 wagyu, and a crown of premium American sturgeon caviar. Rolled with seasoned sushi rice and nori, each piece delivers an exquisite balance of ocean sweetness, rich umami, and elegant brininess.$40.00Botan Ebi & Cucumber Cut Roll (4 PIECE MAKI)
Sweet, tender botan ebi paired with crisp cucumber, wrapped in seasoned sushi rice and nori. Light, refreshing, and delicately sweet. An elegant, simple classic!$20.00Hokkaido Uni & Chutoro Cut Roll With Caviar (4 PIECE MAKI)
Creamy, ocean-sweet Hokkaido uni paired with buttery, melt-in-your-mouth chūtoro, rolled with seasoned sushi rice and nori. A decadent, umami-rich bite that balances the silky richness of the sea with delicate tuna flavor.$34.00OUT OF STOCKHokkaido Scallop & Hokkaido Uni Cut Roll (4 PIECE MAKI)
Sweet, tender Hokkaido scallops paired with ultra-creamy Hokkaido uni, wrapped in seasoned sushi rice and nori. A luxurious, ocean-inspired bite showcasing delicate sweetness and rich, silky textures.$24.00OUT OF STOCK
To Go Beverage

Coca-Cola, Can
Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love$3.00
Diet Coke, Can
Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink$3.00
Sprite, Can
Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free$3.00
Large Fiji Water Bottle
$8.00
Large San Pellegrino Sparkling Water
$8.00
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.
All hours
| Sunday | 5:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 5:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 5:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 5:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 5:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Saturday | 5:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location