American Southern
Carey Hilliards Garden City
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
On Special
On Special
Tail-On White Shrimp Combo
Large tail-on white shrimp, fried golden brown! Georgia white shrimp when available.$23.69
4 Pc. COMBO Finger
Fresh chicken breast tenders, marinated and hand-breaded served with honey-mustard sauce.$12.99
Pineapple Upside Down Cake
Served warm with a sweet glaze on top.$6.19
Carey Combo
This new dinner combines our most popular chicken and seafood! (3) Fried Chicken Fingers paired with Original Fried Shrimp, (2) sides, hushpuppies, and a drink.$21.99
To-Go Drinks
Drinks (other than teas)
Appetizers
Appetizers (other than wings)
Small Onion RIng
$5.19
Large Onion Ring
Made to order and definitely worth the wait. Sweet, Southern onions hand-breaded, double-dipped and delicately fried…simply the South's finest!$6.19
Cup Brunswick Stew
$4.19
Bowl Brunswick Stew
$6.19
Cup Crab Stew
$7.79
Bowl Crab Stew
$10.29
Fried Pickles
NEW! Our favorite hand-battered crinkle-cut pickles! Perfect when dipped in Carey Sauce.$6.19
Boom Boom Shrimp
A bowl full of lettuce covered with plenty of our delicious fried shrimp, then it's drizzled with our creamy, spicy "Boom Boom Sauce"$11.39
Cheese Sticks
Five mozzarella cheese sticks dipped in breading and fried 'til crisp, served with marinara sauce.$6.19
Grilled Tail On White Shrimp APP
A LIGHTER CHOICE MEAL FOR CUTTING CALORIES AND STAYING HEALTY! Large Grilled Tail-On White Shrimp served with our own zesty cocktail sauce!$10.29
Rib Appetizer
A teaser portion of our meaty St. Louis-style ribs served with toast, onion, and pickle.$10.29Shrimp Salad App
$6.69
6pc Smoked-Fried Wing Appetizer
Hickory-smoked, then fried Jumbo wings with a mild and smoky flavor.$9.29
12pc Smoked-Fried Wing Appetizer
Hickory-smoked, then fried Jumbo wings with a mild and smoky flavor.$18.59
CUP Classic Beef Chili
$5.99
BOWL Classic Beef Chili
$11.99
CUP Broccoli Cheese Soup
$4.99
BOWL Broccoli Cheese Soup
$8.99
Salads
Barbecue Pork House Salad
Our House Salad topped with our hickory-smoked lean and tender Barbecue Pork$11.39
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce sprinkled with shredded Parmesan cheese, house-made croutons and served with Caesar dressing.$6.19
Fajita Chicken & Grilled Shrimp Salad
Our House Salad topped with Chopped Fajita Chicken and Grilled Shrimp.$16.49
Fajita Chicken Salad
Our House or Caesar Salad topped with Chopped Fajita Chicken$11.39
Finger Salad
Our House Salad topped with Fried Chicken$11.39
Fried Shrimp Salad
Our House Salad topped with hand-breaded Fried Shrimp.$11.39
Grilled Chicken Breast Salad
Our House Salad topped with a Grilled Chicken Breast with Swiss cheese and bacon.$11.39
Grilled Salmon Salad
Delicious 8oz. grilled salmon filet$17.50
Grilled Shrimp Salad
Salad topped with Grilled Tail-On White Shrimp.$11.39
House Salad
A mixed bed of romaine and iceberg lettuce with shredded cheddar and Monterey Jack cheese. Colored with chopped red tomatoes, cool cucumbers, and house-made croutons!$6.19
Shrimp Salad Plate
A generous serving of our famous baby shrimp salad. As an appetizer or a plate$11.89
Side Caesar
A small appetizer portion Caesar salad.$4.19
Tossed Salad
A small appetizer portion tossed salad.$4.19
Fresh Seafood
Seafood Combo Pick 2
Seafood Combo of Any 2 Combine our fried shrimp, tilapia, flounder, catfish, deviled crab, oysters, or scallops to create your favorite "duo from the deep"$24.79
Seafood Combo Pick 3
A trio of all your favorite seafood delicacies! Choose three from: fried shrimp, tilapia, flounder, catfish, deviled crab, oysters, or scallops.$26.79
Captain's Platter
Indulge in our famous Captain's platter, it's the BIG one! An incredible, irresistible combination of White Grilled and fried shrimp, scallops, oysters, tilapia, and deviled crab.$28.89
Original Shrimp
Shrimp, freshly hand-breaded every day and carefully fried to a perfection. AN ORIGINAL.$19.99
Flounder
Lightly coated and fried with our famous seasoned breading. It's the real thing.$21.69
Scallops
Everyone enjoys the delicate taste of our lightly breaded and golden-fried scallops. Simply delicious!$24.79
Deviled Crab
Delicately seasoned crabmeat baked in two natural shells. AN ORIGINAL$17.50
Catfish
The pride of the South. Mild, sweet catfish rolled in our seasoned cracker meal and golden-fried.$16.49
Oysters
We bread 'em up and fry' em golden brown, just waitin' for your enjoyment.$21.69
Grilled Salmon
Fresh 8oz. grilled, boneless fillet. The flavor is out of this world!$19.59
Redfish
Choose grilled or blackened for this seasoned 8-oz boneless fillet.$19.59
Tail-On White Shrimp
Large tail-on white shrimp, fried golden brown! Georgia white shrimp when available.$21.69
Shrimp & Flounder
Served with Original fried shrimp, fried flounder, and your choice of 2 sides.$24.79
Sandwiches & Burgers
Original Club
An ORIGINAL! Extra lean sliced ham, crisp bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on toast.$9.29
Deluxe Club
NEW! A half pound of hot thinly shaved ham and oven roasted deli turkey with crisp bacon, Swiss and American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on toast.$12.39
Pork Club
Our famous barbecue pork with bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. Great when dipped in our barbecue sauce!$10.29
Turkey Club
LIGHTER CHOICE MEAL FOR CUTTING CALORIES AND STAYING HEALTHY! Fresh sliced turkey with bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.$10.29
BLT Sandwich
A classic! Grilled bacon, fresh lettuce, tomato and mayo on toast$6.19
Char-Grilled Chicken Sandwich
LIGHTER CHOICE MEAL FOR CUTTING CALORIES AND STAYING HEALTHY! Tender, boneless breast of char-grilled chicken with crisp bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.$10.29
Grilled Salmon Sandwich
Fresh 8oz. grilled, boneless fillet served on warm bun with lettuce, tomato, bacon, and tartar sauce.$16.49
Southern Fried Chicken Sandwich
A boneless, skinless fillet with an exciting, delicious seasoning. Served with lettuce, tomato, and mayo.$10.29
Bacon Cheeseburger
A tasty cheeseburger with crisp bacon strips, fresh lettuce, sliced tomato and mayo. Try it with barbecue sauce for that Western touch.$11.39
Cheeseburger
Our juicy hamburger topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo$10.29
Hamburger
Served thick and juicy with lettuce, tomato, and mayo$9.79
Fried Fish Sandwich
Served on a bun with tartar sauce$11.89
Shrimp Salad Sandwich
Chilled, tender baby shrimp salad served with lettuce and mayo on toast$10.29
Smash Burger (new!)
Two Grilled Patties,served with grilled onions , American Cheese, Carey Sauce, & & House pickles on a grilled bun$11.39
Shaved Ham Club
Original club with shaved ham.$10.29
Grilled Cheese
$6.19
Double Bacon Cheeseburger
A tasty cheeseburger with crisp bacon strips, fresh lettuce, sliced tomato and mayo. Try it with barbecue sauce for that Western touch.$14.49
Double Cheeseburger
Our juicy hamburger topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo$13.39
Double Hamburger
Served thick and juicy with lettuce, tomato, and mayo$12.89
Chicken & Steak
4 Count Chicken Fingers
Fresh chicken breast tenders, marinated and hand-breaded served with honey-mustard sauce.$11.39
6 Count Chicken Fingers
Fresh chicken breast tenders, marinated and hand-breaded served with honey-mustard sauce.$13.39
Fried Chicken
Freshly cooked from scratch. Please allow 30-35 minutes. Fried until golden brown on the outside, moist and tender on the inside.$12.39
Small Smoked Fried Chicken
Hickory-Smoked, then fried, this chicken is great!$8.29
Large Smoked Fried Chicken
Hickory-Smoked, then fried, this chicken is great!$12.39
Smoked Fried Wing Dinner
6 Jumbo Wings with a mild and smoky flavor served as a dinner with 2 sides$12.39Baked Chicken
$12.39
25pc Chicken Fingers trays
Great for parties! Fried until golden brown on the outside, moist and tender on the inside.$51.25
50pc Chicken Fingers trays
Great for parties! Fried until golden brown on the outside, moist and tender on the inside.$102.50
Individual finger
$2.05
Hamburger Steak
12 ounces of tender ground beef grilled to order. Comes with 2 sides! An ORIGINAL.$13.39
Rib Eye Steak
Abundantly flavorful 12-oz. steak. Grilled to perfection for that great rib eye taste. Includes a tossed salad.$23.69
W/M Chicken Pc
$2.05
D/M Chicken Pc
$2.05
Mix Chix Pc
$2.05
Barbecue
Barbecue Sandwich
Our trademark barbecue sauce brings out the great flavor in this hot sandwich, served on toast. Includes a choice of one side or Brunswick stew.$8.29
SM Barbecue Plate
The hickory-smoked tender barbecue pork that started it all! Served with our secret recipe Brunswick stew, choice of one side, toast, pickle, and onion.$8.29
LG Barbecue Plate
The hickory-smoked tender barbecue pork that started it all! Served with our secret recipe Brunswick stew, choice of one side, toast, pickle, and onion.$10.79
Half-Rack St. Louis-Style BBQ Ribs
A full rack of slow cooked ribs over hickory wood with our legendary barbecue sauce. Served with choice of two sides, and toast$17.50Full-Rack St. Louis-Style BBQ Ribs
A full rack of slow cooked ribs over hickory wood with our legendary barbecue sauce. Served with choice of two sides, and toast$22.69
Half-Pound Pulled Pork
Barbecue hickory-smoked for 16 hours served with toast.$8.29
Pound of Pulled Pork
Barbecue hickory-smoked for 16 hours served with toast.$12.39
Boston Butt T0-GO ONLY, FULLY COOKED TO HEAT AT HOME
Fully cooked, to heat at home. Seasoned lightly with garlic, salt, and pepper, then hickory-smoked. Served with sauce.$30.90
Double Meat Plate
Another classic! This Double Meat Plate is our Original Barbecue Plate served with an Xtra helping of pork!$12.39
Single Side Entrees
SM Tail On White Shrimp
Large tail-on white shrimp, fried golden brown! Georgia white shrimp when available.$12.39
SM. Shrimp
Shrimp, freshly hand-breaded every day and carefully fried to a perfection$11.89SM. Scallops
Everyone enjoys the delicate taste of our lightly breaded and golden-fried scallops.$14.49SM. Catfish
The pride of the South. Mild, sweet catfish rolled in our seasoned cracker meal and golden-fried$10.29
SM. Deviled Crab
Delicately seasoned crabmeat baked in a natural shell$10.79SM. Flounder
Lightly coated and fried with our famous seasoned breading. It's the real thing$12.39
SM. Oysters
We bread 'em up and fry' em golden brown, just waitin' for your enjoyment.$12.39
SM. Hamburger Steak
6 ounces of tender ground beef grilled to order.$8.29
3 PC Finger
Three chicken fingers with your choice of one side.$8.29
SM. Baked Chicken
$8.29
SM. Fried Chicken
Freshly cooked from scratch. Please allow 30-35 minutes.$8.29
SM. Smoked Fried Chicken
$8.29
Kids
Kids Meals
Kids Meals are served with a kid's drink and fries. 10 and under - no substitutions, please.
Extras/A La Cart
Extras
Cheddar Bake
Cheddar Bake (twice baked potato) Twice baked, stuffed potato loaded with cheddar cheese, sour cream and our special seasonings.$3.09
SM French Fries
$2.59LG French Fries
$3.59
SM Sweet Potato Fries
$3.09LG Sweet Potato Fries
$4.19
SM Hushpuppies
$2.09
LG Hushpuppies
$3.09
Mac & Cheese
$2.59
Baked Potato
$2.59
Potato Salad
$2.09
Cole Slaw
$2.09
Green Beans
$2.09
Side of Toast
$0.95
Side of Pasta Salad
$2.59
Extra Sauce/Dressing
Side Bacon
$2.09
Cup of cheese
Side Lettuce & Tomato
$1.99
Andes Mint
$0.10
Bun
$0.89
Butter Mint - Carey Hilliard’s brand
$0.10
Peppermint York Pattie
$0.15
Indiv. Smoked Fried Chicken
Indiv. Smkd Fried Chicken$4.10
Cup of Pickles
Desserts
Classic Cheesecake
Rich New York style cheesecake with a graham cracker crust$5.69
Brownie Sundae
Warm chocolate brownie topped with vanilla ice cream and chocolate sauce$4.69
Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Pie with Graham Cracker Crust This classic key lime pie is tart, but with a sweet filling, and a graham cracker crust that is amazing.$5.99
Scoop Ice Cream
Fennell special$1.55
Ice Cream Sandwich
A classic Ice-Cream Sandwich. Comes packaged, for a quick bite!$1.99
Catering Pick Up
1 Pound Pulled Pork
$12.39
25 Pc. Hot Wing
Hot Wings with a zing! Served with hot sauce.$36.25
50 Pc. Hot Wing
Hot Wings with a zing! Served with hot sauce.$72.50
BOTTLE Barbecue Sauce
Barbecue Sauce Select from a bottle, pint, or gallon.$4.99
PINT Barbecue Sauce
Barbecue Sauce Select from a bottle, pint, or gallon.$5.99Gallon Barbecue Sauce
Barbecue Sauce Select from a bottle, pint, or gallon.$34.99Brunswick Stew Pint
$6.19Brunswick Stew 1/2 Half Gallon
$23.9925pc Chicken Fingers trays
Great for parties! Fried until golden brown on the outside, moist and tender on the inside.$51.2550pc Chicken Fingers trays
Great for parties! Fried until golden brown on the outside, moist and tender on the inside.$102.50
SM Cole Slaw
$2.09
PINT Cole Slaw
$6.19
Gallon Of Tea
Voted Best Tea in Savannah!$6.49
SM Green Beans
$2.09
PINT Green Beans
$6.19
SM Mac & Cheese
$2.59
PINT Mac & Cheese
$7.75
SM Pasta Salad
$2.59
PINT Pasta Salad
$7.75Pint of Cocktail
$6.19Pint of Shrimp Salad
$16.49Pint of Tartar
$6.19SM Potato Salad
$2.09PINT Potato Salad
$6.19
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 11:45 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 11:45 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 11:45 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 11:45 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 11:45 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 11:45 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 11:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Specializing in: seafood, chicken fingers, and hot wings. Casual dining and family pricing… Take-out, online ordering, dine-in, delivery, or drive-up. The only 1960’s-style Curbside Service restaurant, AND Savannah’s oldest family-owned restaurant. The company is looking to expand over the next decade. Known best for fried shrimp, fresh-brewed iced tea, hush puppies, and famous barbecue sauce. Casual dining with lots of options for quick service.
Location