Skip to Main content
  • Carmenta's Italian Brooklyn 50 Starr Street

    • Home
    • /
    • Brooklyn
    • /
    • Carmenta's Italian Brooklyn 50 Starr Street
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image
    Italian

    Carmenta's Italian Brooklyn 50 Starr Street

    50 Starr Street

    Brooklyn, NY 11221


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Website

    Directions

    Salads Online
    Sandwiches Online
    Pasta Online
    Specials Online
    Sides Online
    Dessert Online
    chips Online
    NA Beverages Online
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • Italian Combo Hero

      Berkshire pork mortadella, spicy Molinari coppa, houisemnade mozzeralla, red onions, olive oil, red wine vinegar, on a sesame seeded hero. (dairy, allium allergy)
      $19.50
    • Turkey & Salsa Verde Sandwich

      North country smoked turkey breast, salsa verde, mayo, red onions, fried shallots, sesame seeded bread. ( alliums)
      $19.75
    • Creste de Gallo , English Peas, Nduja.

      Creste de gallo pasta, English peas, Nduja (a spreadable spicy Italian sausage)spreadable Italian sausage and melts into the sauce, mint, herbs, fiore sardo (smoky sheep’s milk cheese)
      $21.00

    Salads Online

    • Caesar Salad

      Baby romaine, anchovy vinagrette, sesame croutons and Pecorino Cheese.(egg and dairy free dressing) Allergy alert: Anchovies & Dairy
      $15.26
    • Roasted Beets & Lemon Creme Fraiche

      Contains nuts. Roasted beets dressed with apple cider vinegar, extra virgin olive oil, lemon creme fraiche, pickled onions, charred green onion oil and hazelnuts. (dairy, nut, allium allergy)
      $13.08

    Sandwiches Online

    • Turkey & Salsa Verde Sandwich

      North country smoked turkey breast, salsa verde, mayo, red onions, fried shallots, sesame seeded bread. ( alliums)
      $19.75
    • Spicy Eggplant Parm

      Fired eggplant, Homemade mozz, calabrian chili, tomato sauce, Pecorino DOP, sesame seed bread (dairy , alliums allergy)
      $17.44
    • Italian Combo Hero

      Berkshire pork mortadella, spicy Molinari coppa, houisemnade mozzeralla, red onions, olive oil, red wine vinegar, on a sesame seeded hero. (dairy, allium allergy)
      $19.50
    • Meatball Parm

      All natural beef and pork meatballs, San Marzano tomato sauce, house-made Mozzarella, and Parmesan, on a sesame seed hero. (dairy and allium allergy)
      $17.44
    • Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

      All natural free-bird chicken. Chicken cutlet, homemade Mozzarella, basil, pecorino and tomato sauce. sesame seeded bread. ( allium and dairy allergy)
      $19.50
    • Dom G

      Liuzzi ricotta cheese, house roasted peppers, fried eggplant, red onion, mint, tomato vinaigrette. seeded sesame hero. (dairy and allium allergy)
      $17.44
    • Carmenta's Ortiz Tuna Sandwich

      Ortiz tuna (from Spain) olive tapenade, house dried tomatoes, fennel pollen, red onion, lettuce, orange/fennel vinaigrette. seeded sesame hero. (seafood, allium allergy)
      $19.62
    • Jose Special

      House-made meatballs, fried eggplant, home-made Mozz, salsa verde, Pecorino DOP. (dairy allergy), sesame seed. (sesame seed allergy in the meatballs) (dairy , alliums allergy)
      $19.62
    • Prosciutto cotto & Gruyère

      Imported Italian boiled ham, imported Gruyère, labne and preserved ramps dressing, pickled mustard seeds on a seeded hero. (dairy, allium allergy)
      $18.53
    • Spicy Meatball Parms

      meatball parm with cherry peppers and Calabrian chilies .
      $20.17

    Pasta Online

    • Rigatoni / Vodka

      Rigatoni, vodka, cream, guanciale, tomatoes, chilies ( cannot be modified without pork )(dairy, allium allergy) *we make our sauce base with all ingredients in order to achieve a balanced sauce.
      $19.62
    • Penne / Chicken Sausage

      Penne pasta shape, house made roasted chicken sausage (warm spices, apples, cider, onions , garlic) white wine, charred cherry tomatoes, Parmesan cheese, fresh basil, butter, white wine. (dairy, allium, spices allergy)
      $19.62
    • Lumache with Fennel Sausage Ragu

      Pork fennel sausage, San Marzano tomatoes, garlic, oregano, pecorino, white wine. Finished with pecorino cheese, fresh oregano. (dairy, allium allergy)
      $19.62
    • Mafalde / Tomato

      San Marzano tomato, garlic and basil infused olive oil, pecorino cheese
      $18.53
    • Radiatore / Tuscan Kale pesto

      Tuscan kale pesto, basil, grana padano, garlic, extra virgin olive oil, marinated broccoli rabe, side of garlicky breadcrumbs, ( soy , dairy, allium allergy)
      $18.53
    • Spaghetti Fradiavolo

      San marzano tomato sauce, calabrian chili, garlic and basil oil, pecorino cheese (dairy, allium allergy)
      $18.53
    • Spaghetti / Tomato

      San Marzano tomatoes, basil and garlic infused olive oil, pecorino cheese (dairy, allium allergy)
      $18.53
    • Penne w/ Meat Sauce

      Grass-fed beef cooked with onions, garlic, oregano, San marzano tomatoes, finished with basil and pecorino. (dairy and allium allergy)
      $19.62
    • Mafalde / Beef Bolognese

      Mafalde ( long ribbon noodles), braised beef cheeks with red wine, sofritto, tomatoes. finished with pecorino. ( dairy, allium allergy). this is not a traditional bolognese. please read the description.
      $24.00

    Specials Online

    • Chicken Cutlet And Arugula

      Fried chicken cutlet, Liuzzi ricotta cheese, house roasted peppers, "arugula pesto", fresh lemon on sesame seeded hero, ( soy, dairy, allium allergy)
      $18.53
    • Fried Kennebeck Potatoes

      Fried Kennebeck potatoes tossed with chili oil and served with side of herb garlic mayo ( nuts, soy, allium allergy)
      $10.50
    • Ricotta Cavatelli & Braised Wild Mushrooms

      Ricotta Cavatelli, Braised wild mushrooms, onions, herbs, bianco sardo, garlic panko, summer truffle butter (dairy and allium allergy)
      $21.80
    • Creste de Gallo , English Peas, Nduja.

      Creste de gallo pasta, English peas, Nduja (a spreadable spicy Italian sausage)spreadable Italian sausage and melts into the sauce, mint, herbs, fiore sardo (smoky sheep’s milk cheese)
      $21.00

    Sides Online

    • Marinated broccoli rabe (cold)

      Garlic, chili, lemon, olive oil, crunchy garlic, ( soy, allium allergy)
      $14.17
    • Marinated Artichokes

      Artichokes marinated with orange zest, chili, garlic, herbs
      $11.99
    • Castelvetrano Olives

      Castelvetrano olives are mild, buttery, and sweet green olives from Sicily, marinated in olive oil, coriander (la Boite coriander), orange zest, fennel pollen
      $10.00
    • Marinated gigante beans

      Chili, citrus, ramps, herbs, garlic
      $8.72
    • Calabrian Chiles

      Calabrian chilli spread
      $3.82
    • Marinara Sauce

      San marzano tomatoes, fresh garlic, basil, Sicilian sea salt. Excellent for dipping garlic bread or just enjoy extra on anything.
      $4.36
    • Rice balls and tomato sauce

      Risotto rice, Parmesan, Mozzarella, Calabrian Chili, Tomato Sauce, (3 pc) (allium, dairy allergy)
      $13.08
    • Homemade Meatballs (side)

      All natural beef and pork meatballs cooked in San Marzano Tomato sauce, pecorino, basil . ( Dairy, allium, sesame seed allergy)
      $14.17
    • Garlic Bread w/ Basil Butter and Parmesan

      Wuthrich Butter, genovese basil, garlic confit, fresh garlic and Parmesan. Dairy and allium allergy, on sesame seed bread
      $5.45
    • Fried Chicken Cutlet (Side)

      All natural chicken breaded and fried, tomato sauce, parmesan, basil. (allium, dairy allergy)
      $15.26
    • Pee-Wee Potato Salad

      shahazi spice, mayo, cider vinegar, pickled mustard seeds
      $7.63

    Dessert Online

    • Tiramisu (house made)

      Whipped marscarpone,YOGURT with sabayon (cooked egg yolks), anise (anise liquor), strong espresso, imported lady finger cookies dipped in espresso and anise. The yogurt gives this a balanced flavor!!! Please read this description before adding to your cart!!!
      $11.99
    • Banana Bread w/ Chocolate

      house made banana bread with chocolate feves, served with spiced whipped cream and dehydrated chocolate .
      $8.75

    chips Online

    • Torres chips

      Choose one Truffle/ jamon/ Mediterranean herbs
      $5.00
    • North country kettle chips

      $3.00
    • dirty chips

      maui onions and funky fusion flavors. Please select one of the two before you check out
      $3.00
    • cape cod

      $2.73
    • Zapps Jalapeño

      $3.82
    • Torres Mediterranean Herbs

      Imported potato chips with Mediterranean herbs flavor
      $5.00
    • Torres Truffle Chips

      Impoted Truffle flavored kettle chips
      $5.00
    • Torres Cured Cheese

      Imported Torres cured cheese chips
      $5.00

    NA Beverages Online

    • Coke (12oz)

      $3.27
    • Diet Coke (12oz)

      $2.73
    • Dr. Pepper

      $2.73
    • Club Soda

      Canada Dry sodium free 12 oz
      $2.73
    • Ginger Ale

      $2.73
    • IBC Root Beer

      $3.82
    • Bruce Cost (Blood Orange + Meyer Lemon)

      $4.36
    • Bruce cost ginger ale

      $4.36
    • Yerba Mate (white label)

      Sparkling soda
      $4.36
    • BLOOD ORANGE San Pelligrino 12 oz cans

      Please specify flavors before checking out *Orange *Blood Orange* or *Grapefruit
      $3.82
    • Lemon Ice Tea

      San Benedetto, product of Italy
      $4.36
    • Peach Ice Tea

      San Benedetto, product of Italy
      $4.36
    • Mexican coke or Saratoga sparkling

      $6.00

    All hours
    Sunday12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Wednesday12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Thursday12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Friday12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Saturday12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    50 Starr Street, Brooklyn, NY 11221

    Directions