Cocoa & Cream Collective

Build your perfect start to the day— choose your bread, cheese, meat and egg for a satisfying breakfast sandwich.

A savory, cheese-filled breakfast bread with an egg added to the top.

Lightly spiced and baked to golden perfection, our gluten-friendly apple donuts are made from scratch with fresh apples, warm cinnamon, and a touch of brown sugar.

Classic flaky, buttery croissants made fresh in house.

Traditional-style bagels with a crisp exterior and chewy, flavorful interior — baked fresh daily.

House-made, buttery pastry filled with our rotating selection of fruit compotes and cream cheese fillings.

Tender, buttery scones made in-house and baked fresh daily.

Moist, fragrant, and baked from scratch sweet loaves.

A thoughtfully curated breakfast for 6-8 people, featuring Cocoa & Cream’s fresh-made morning favorites, including a mix of our cinnamon rolls, apple cider donuts, croissants, Danishes or bagels. Ideal for meetings, celebrations, or an easy morning for a group.

A thoughtfully curated breakfast for 10-12 people, featuring Cocoa & Cream’s fresh-made morning favorites, including a mix of our cinnamon rolls, apple cider donuts, croissants, Danishes or bagels. Ideal for meetings, celebrations, or an easy morning for a group.

Freshly baked, thoughtfully made, and perfectly sized for young guests. Includes your choice of a muffin, Danish, or bagel, served with an applesauce pouch and your choice of milk or juice for a balanced breakfast they'll love.

A hearty breakfast made just for growing appetites. Includes a Morning Collective Sandwich made with two real eggs, cracked and cooked fresh in our kitchen, your choice of all-natural bread, bagel, or croissant, your favorite cheese, and breakfast meat, plus an applesauce pouch and your choice of milk or juice.

Enjoy a handcrafted breakfast featuring a 16 oz. cup of our medium roast Baker's Reserve brewed coffee and your choice of a freshly baked bagel with cream cheese, flaky croissant, buttery Danish, or our beloved signature cinnamon roll.

Enjoy a handcrafted breakfast featuring a 20 oz. latte made according to your preferences and your choice of a freshly baked bagel with cream cheese, flaky croissant, buttery Danish, or our beloved signature cinnamon roll.

Enjoy a handcrafted breakfast featuring a 16 oz. iced latte made according to your preferences and your choice of a freshly baked bagel with cream cheese, flaky croissant, buttery Danish, or our beloved signature cinnamon roll.

Fuel your morning with a 16 oz. cup of our Baker's Reserve brewed coffee paired with our signature Morning Collective Sandwich. Made to order with two real eggs, cracked and cooked fresh in our kitchen, your choice of all-natural bread, bagel, or croissant, your favorite cheese, and breakfast meat for a satisfying start to the day.

Fuel your morning with a 20 oz. latte made to your preferences and paired with our signature Morning Collective Sandwich. Made to order with two real eggs, cracked and cooked fresh in our kitchen, your choice of all-natural bread, bagel, or croissant, your favorite cheese, and breakfast meat for a satisfying start to the day.

Fuel your morning with a 16 oz. iced latte made to your preferences and paired with our signature Morning Collective Sandwich. Made to order with two real eggs, cracked and cooked fresh in our kitchen, your choice of all-natural bread, bagel, or croissant, your favorite cheese, and breakfast meat for a satisfying start to the day.

Build your perfect sandwich — your way. Includes your artisan bread, meat, cheese, and toppings.

Choose your favorite bread and cheeses, then we grill it golden and gooey with a touch of house butter.

Choose your bread and one of our jams Grape, Strawberry, Raspberry, or Peach. Peanut butter spread just right, and yes — the crusts come off!

Sliced turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and Gouda layered on your choice of our all natural breads.

Cocoa & Cream’s Mid-Day Collective Sandwich served with a bag of chips and one of our fresh-baked signature cookies — a perfectly curated lunch for busy afternoons, office meetings, or lunch on the go.

Everything you expect from sourdough — golden crust, tender interior. Perfect for sharing or serving at your table.

Still everything you expect from fantastic sourdough but made with whole wheat flour.

Crusty outside, soft inside — perfect for sandwiches or as a side to soup or salad.

With a mild flavor and cloud-like softness make it a staple that’s comforting, versatile, and delicious down to the very last slice.

A rustic Italian-style bread with a light, airy texture and a beautifully golden crust. Baked with olive oil and topped with savory seasonings, each bite is soft, flavorful, and perfectly satisfying.

Smooth, rich, and baked in-house — a Cocoa & Cream specialty.

Creamy perfection that serves 10-12. Some recipes require an upcharge due to ingredient costs.

A generous slice of house-baked pie made with flaky, buttery crusts filled with seasonal flavors and timeless classics.

Bite-sized happiness — ours are scratch-made cake and frosting before being hand-dipped in premium chocolate.

Fudgy brownies topped with creative layers.

Rich. Chocolatey. Fudgy. Everything a brownie should be — just gluten-friendly.

Two soft oatmeal cookies with a sweet, creamy filling sandwiched between them. A nostalgic favorite has officially joined our gluten-friendly case!

A nostalgic favorite, made from scratch with creamy peanut butter, rich cocoa, and gluten-free oats. Soft, chewy, and perfectly balanced — a little taste of comfort crafted with care.

Two of our signature cookies, filled with buttercream frosting.

Parisian-style almond cookies in assorted flavors that are always gluten friendly.

A timeless classic, handcrafted from scratch. Our buckeyes are made with a rich, creamy peanut butter center, dipped in smooth chocolate for the perfect balance of sweet and indulgent. A Midwestern favorite, made the Cocoa & Cream way.

Crafted with care and made for indulgence, our edible cookie dough is prepared from scratch using heat-treated flour and no raw eggs — just pure, buttery goodness and high-quality ingredients. Perfect for snacking, gifting, or topping your favorite dessert.

In honor of the Silver Award in Muncie's Quest for the Best Bakery category, we're offering a Silver Collection - a sampler of our most popular items. Each box includes a cinnamon roll, artisan brownie, chocolate chip cookie, and baked apple donut.

Our proprietary blend of an exceptional medium roast brewed coffee.

Our proprietary blend of exceptional cold brewed coffee.

Exceptional quality loose leaf tea, brewed in order at the optimal water temperature, using the blend of your choice.

Exceptional quality tea blends, brewed to perfection before being poured over ice. This is brewed unsweetened.

9 oz of pure local honey in a giftable jar. Perfect for home use or as a gift.

4 oz of pure local honey in a giftable jar. Perfect for home use or as a gift.

Our small batch jams are crafted the way they should be — slowly, thoughtfully, and with real fruit at the center. Made using simple ingredients, each jar captures bright, natural flavors designed to complement fresh bread, pastries, and everyday moments worth savoring.

Brew our signature Baker's Reserve Coffee at home.

Brew our signature Baker's Reserve Coffee at home. Our 4 oz bag is the perfect size to add to a gift of our baked good or other treats.

Our premium loose-leaf tea blends are packaged in an attractive tin for you to enjoy at home or gift.

If you are new to brewing loose-leaf tea, this infuser will enable you to make the perfect cup at home.

An irresistable classic of chocolate, peanut butter, and powdered sugar.

Your fur baby deserves a treat too! Made with human-grade, natural ingredients, your dog will enjoy a treat from Cocoa & Cream as much as you do!

Made with eggs and high-quality flour using a 4th generation family recipe before being air-dried for superior texture and flavor.

Lightly spiced and baked to golden perfection, our gluten-friendly apple donuts are made from scratch with fresh apples, warm cinnamon, and a touch of brown sugar.

Moist, fragrant, and baked from scratch sweet loaves.

A nostalgic favorite, made from scratch with creamy peanut butter, rich cocoa, and gluten-free oats. Soft, chewy, and perfectly balanced — a little taste of comfort crafted with care.

Rich. Chocolatey. Fudgy. Everything a brownie should be — just gluten-friendly.

Two soft oatmeal cookies with a sweet, creamy filling sandwiched between them. A nostalgic favorite has officially joined our gluten-friendly case!

A timeless classic, handcrafted from scratch. Our buckeyes are made with a rich, creamy peanut butter center, dipped in smooth chocolate for the perfect balance of sweet and indulgent. A Midwestern favorite, made the Cocoa & Cream way.