Skip to main contentToast Local logo

Reviews of Coterie Pizza - 1850 South Randolph Street

4.9

Rated 4.9 out of 5

80 ratings

  • GREG e.
    5 out of 5 starsJun 7

    Ordered Hot Honey and Cheese Bread.

  • Kami B.
    5 out of 5 starsJun 7

    Ordered Margherita, 12" pizza, Cheese Pizza, and Beer Cheese.

  • Abigale S.
    5 out of 5 starsJun 6

    Ordered Cheese Bread, 3oz Marinara, and Spinach Artichoke.

  • Lesley M.
    5 out of 5 starsJun 5

    Ordered Sausage Sandwich and Beer Cheese.

  • Steve and Linda S.
    5 out of 5 starsJun 5

    First visit, but won’t be our last! While the atmosphere is a bit utilitarian, the pizza was amazing! The homemade dough, leading to a crispy perfect crust; the fresh tasting, vibrant, tomato-y sauce with just a hint of basil; and the various delicious toppings ALL pleasantly surprised us! SO GOOD! Coterie rivals some of the best pizza we’ve ever had!

    Ordered 12" pizza, Margherita, Cheese Pizza, and Pepsi.

  • Steve E.
    5 out of 5 starsMay 29

    Ordered Mushroom Medley, Chicken Bruschetta, Veggie Sandwich, Cheese Bread, Yuengling Traditional, and Pepsi.

  • Dawn N.
    5 out of 5 starsMay 20

    Ordered 12" pizza.

  • Dennis W.
    5 out of 5 starsMay 14

    Ordered Chicken Bacon, Ham and Cheese Sandwich, and Cheese Bread.

  • Allison E.
    5 out of 5 starsMay 13

    Ordered Chicken Bacon, Beer Cheese, 12" Dough Ball, 6oz Beer Cheese, and 3oz Hot Honey.

  • Rennae J.
    5 out of 5 starsMay 10

    Always amazing!

    Ordered Ham and Cheese Sandwich, Chicken Bruschetta, Mushroom Medley, Chicken Bacon, and 6oz Beer Cheese.