Holiday Sides

Gayle's Mom Stuffing Mix
Dry Mix. We provide the seasoned bread crumbs. You will need to provide the celery, onion, butter, chicken stock and herbs or whatever strikes your fancy. Recipe included.$9.50
Homemade Gravy, pint
$11.95
Homemade Gravy, quart
$23.90
Cranberry Sauce, half pint
$7.25
Cranberry Sauce, pint
$14.50
Mini Mushroom Turnovers
Flaky pastry with a savory mushroom filling. Delicious warm or at room temperature.$24.95
Stuffed Cheese Puffs
Bite-size herbed puffs, stuffed with our savory cheese spread.$24.95
Deviled Eggs 6 pack
Traditional deviled eggs. A favorite Gayle's appetizer.$11.50
Roasted Garlic Artichoke Dip
$8.25
Fern's Tangy Cheese Spread
$8.25
Roasted Red Pepper Cashew Spread
$8.25
Savory Cheese Spread
$8.25
Crostini, bag
Serve with spread, use as croutons or eat them right out of the bag! 8 oz.$9.75
Dinner Rolls & Fresh Bread
Dinner Rolls
Fresh Bread

Francese Baguette
Moist, chewy Italian bread made in the French style. A substantial crust with a very open crumb.$6.25
Rio Sourdough Baguette
$6.25
Carpo's Seeded Francese Baguette
$6.50
Joe's Bread, round
Dark, caramelized crust with a chewy, moist crumb. Made with our sourdough starter, wheat flour, and sea salt.$10.50Joe's Bread, round, half loaf
Dark, caramelized crust with a chewy, moist crumb. Made with our sourdough starter, wheat flour, and sea salt. Available sliced or not sliced.$5.25
Capitola Sourdough Round
$7.95
Capitola Sourdough Sandwich
$8.50
Olive Sourdough
$8.95
Jewish Rye
$9.50
Old World Raisin Walnut Bread
Organic Old World Raisin Walnut Bread - formally know as Raisin Nut Rye - new name - same great bread!$9.50
Muesli Sandwich Loaf
Filled with pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, sliced almonds and sesame seeds with just a hint of honey$7.95
English Toaster
$6.50
Challah Twist
$6.95
Challah Sandwich
$6.95
Francese Bun, 4 pack
$7.50
Handmade Pies

Pumpkin Pie
Baked in our flaky all butter crust.$25.95
Apple Crumb Pie
Hand peeled apples are baked until just soft with a touch of cream & cinnamon with a streusel crumb top.$38.95
Pecan Pie
Pecan halves in a rich brown sugar custard.$38.95
Marionberry Pie
Tangy marionberries baked in an our all butter crust with a sugared lattice top.$38.95
Chocolate Cream Pie
With a chocolate shortbread crust, topped with whipped cream and chocolate curls.$48.00
Key Lime Pie
Creamy, sweet-tart key lime filling in a graham cracker crust and topped with whipped cream. Serves 8-12. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$48.00Whipped Cream, pint
$7.50Frozen Pie Shell
Our all-butter frozen pie shell, ready for you to fill and bake.$10.95
Danish & Croissants
Breakfast & Brunch

Orange Marmalade Loaf
Moist orange soaked tea cake.$8.95
Three Ginger Ginger Bread
Moist & spicy with fresh, candied and ground ginger.$20.95
Harvest Pumpkin Muffin
$5.35
Croissant
$4.95
Chocolatine
$5.95
Pain de Amande
Classic almond croissant. Dusted with powdered sugar.$6.15
Cinnamon Sugar Downtowner
$4.95
Garlic Cheese Twist
$5.75
Ham & Cheese Croissant
$6.95
Apple Cheese Danish
$5.60
Old Fashioned Cinnamon Roll
$6.65
Bear Claw
$6.50
Pecan Schnecken
$6.50
Marionberry Turnover
$5.75
Old World Raisin Walnut Roll
Sweet without sugar$2.95Chive Biscuit
$2.95
Teal's Granola
With oats, oat bran, dried cranberries, sunflower seeds, almonds, pecans, hazelnuts, brown sugar, maple syrup, honey & cinnamon. 11 oz bag$16.75
Thanksgiving Cakes

Pumpkin Cheesecake
In a ginger cookie crust with vanilla whipped cream & decorated with white chocolate autumn leaves. One size only. Serves 8-12.$48.00
5 Inch Shimmering Pumpkin Princess
Chocolate cake, raspberry jam, pastry cream & chocolate whipped cream with a pumpkin shaped marzipan shell & a dusting of gold. 5 inch cake serves 4-6.$36.00
7 Inch Shimmering Pumpkin Princess
Chocolate cake, raspberry jam, pastry cream & chocolate whipped cream with a pumpkin shaped marzipan shell & a dusting of gold. 7 inch cake serves 8-12.$62.00
9 Inch Shimmering Pumpkin Princess
Chocolate cake, raspberry jam, pastry cream & chocolate whipped cream with a pumpkin shaped marzipan shell & a dusting of gold. 9 inch cake serves 12-16.$82.00
5 Inch Pecan Praline Cake
Vanilla sponge cake, housemade caramel, caramel whipped cream & candied pecans, iced with caramel buttercream. 5 inch cake serves 4-6. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$36.00
7 Inch Pecan Praline Cake
Vanilla sponge cake, housemade caramel, caramel whipped cream & candied pecans, iced with caramel buttercream. 7 inch cake serves 8-12. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$62.00
9 Inch Pecan Praline Cake
Vanilla sponge cake, housemade caramel, caramel whipped cream & candied pecans, iced with caramel buttercream. 9 inch cake serves 16-20. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$82.00
5 Inch Salted Caramel Cake
Our Salted Caramel Cake features devil’s food cake with a housemade salted caramel filling. The outside is finished with a dark chocolate icing and topped with flaked sea salt. 5 inch cake serves 4-6. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$36.00
7 Inch Salted Caramel Cake
Our Salted Caramel Cake features devil’s food cake with a housemade salted caramel filling. The outside is finished with a dark chocolate icing and topped with flaked sea salt. 7 inch cake serves 8-12. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$62.00
9 Inch Salted Caramel Cake
Our Salted Caramel Cake features devil’s food cake with a housemade salted caramel filling. The outside is finished with a dark chocolate icing and topped with flaked sea salt. 9 inch cake serves 16-20. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$82.00
5 Inch German Chocolate Cake
Devil's food cake with traditional coconut/caramel/pecan filling and chocolate buttercream. 5 inch cake serves 4-6. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$36.00
7 Inch German Chocolate Cake
Devil's food cake with traditional coconut/caramel/pecan filling and chocolate buttercream. 7 inch cake serves 8-12. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$62.00
9 Inch German Chocolate Cake
Devil's food cake with traditional coconut/caramel/pecan filling and chocolate buttercream. 9 inch cake serves 16-20. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$82.00
5 Inch Black & White Cake
Wheat-free chocolate cake featuring chocolate ganache and vanilla whipped cream inside. The outside is finished with vanilla whipped cream and a chocolate ganache pour. 5 inch cake serves 4-6. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$36.00
7 Inch Black & White Cake
Wheat-free chocolate cake featuring chocolate ganache and vanilla whipped cream inside. The outside is finished with vanilla whipped cream and a chocolate ganache pour. 7 inch cake serves 8-12. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$62.00
9 Inch Black & White Cake
Wheat-free chocolate cake featuring chocolate ganache and vanilla whipped cream inside. The outside is finished with vanilla whipped cream and a chocolate ganache pour. 9 inch cake serves 16-20. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$82.00
5 Inch Chocolate Mousse
Chocolate cake, mousse, whipped cream and glaze, with ground hazelnuts on the sides. 5 inch cake serves 4-6. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$36.00
7 Inch Chocolate Mousse
Chocolate cake, mousse, whipped cream and glaze, with ground hazelnuts on the sides. 7 inch cake serves 8-12. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$62.00
9 Inch Chocolate Mousse
Chocolate cake, mousse, whipped cream and glaze, with ground hazelnuts on the sides. 9 inch cake serves 16-20. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$82.00
5 Inch Burnt Almond Cake
Vanilla sponge cake, almond pastry cream inside, almond Bavarian cream and candied almonds outside. 5 inch cake serves 4-6. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$36.00
7 Inch Burnt Almond Cake
Vanilla sponge cake, almond pastry cream inside, almond Bavarian cream and candied almonds outside. 7 inch cake serves 8-12. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$62.00
9 Inch Burnt Almond Cake
Vanilla sponge cake, almond pastry cream inside, almond Bavarian cream and candied almonds outside. 9 inch cake serves 16-20. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$82.00
5 Inch Carrot Cake
Our Carrot Cake is a classic and features cream cheese icing inside and outside. With hand painted carrots. 5 inch cake serves 4-6. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$36.00
7 Inch Carrot Cake
Our Carrot Cake is a classic and features cream cheese icing inside and outside. With hand painted carrots. 7 inch cake serves 8-12. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$62.00
9 Inch Carrot Cake
Our Carrot Cake is a classic and features cream cheese icing inside and outside. With hand-painted carrots. 9 inch cake serves 16-20. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$82.00
5 Inch Princess Cake
Vanilla sponge cake, pasty cream, raspberry jam & vanilla whipped cream inside with a marzipan shell in your choice of green, pink or lavender and a fresh rose. 5 inch cake serves 4-6. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$36.00
7 Inch Princess Cake
Vanilla sponge cake, pasty cream, raspberry jam & vanilla whipped cream inside with a marzipan shell in your choice of green, pink or lavender and a fresh rose. 7 inch cake serves 8-12. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$62.00
9 Inch Princess Cake
Vanilla sponge cake, pasty cream, raspberry jam & vanilla whipped cream inside with a marzipan shell in your choice of green, pink or lavender and a fresh rose. 9 inch cake serves 16-20. To add a personalized inscription to your cake, please email orders@gaylesbakery.com be sure to include your name, order number and date the order is for.$82.00
Pastries & Cookies
Thanksgiving Pastries

Mini Pumpkin Cheesecake
An individual version of our seasonal cheesecake. With a ginger cookie crust and vanilla whipped cream.$7.50
Caramel Apple Eclair
Traditional pate au choux shell filled with housemade caramel, pastry cream and apple pie filling, with caramel and toasted pecans on top.$7.25
Chocolate Éclair
pate a choux filled with pastry cream and topped with ganache.$7.25
Raspberry Napoleon
Puff pastry with raspberry jam and our Bavarian cream.$7.50
Florentine
Wheat-free. Honey, almond & chocolate with candied orange peel.$4.75
Thanksgiving Cookies

Maple Leaf Cookie
Maple Leaf Shortbread Cookie. Perfect for Fall. Available through Monday 11/24.$2.75
Cranberry White Chocolate Oatie
$3.25
Ginger Cookie
A spicy & sweet chewy ginger cookie rolled in granulated sugar.$2.65
Eggnog Snickerdoodle Cookie
Snickerdoodle cookie with a hint of nutmeg & rum.$2.95
German Chocolate Cookie
Yummy cookie with chocolate chunks, coconut and pecans.$3.15
Chocolate Coma Cookie
Wheat-free. Intensely chocolatey.$2.95
Toll House Cookie
An all-time favorite.$2.65
Butterstar
Our popular butter cookie with festive sprinkles.$2.65
Thanksgiving Cookies by the dozen

Cranberry White Chocolate Oatie, dozen
$35.50
Ginger Cookie, dozen
A dozen spicy & sweet chewy ginger cookies rolled in granulated sugar.$28.95
Eggnog Snickerdoodle, dozen
A dozen Snickerdoodle cookies with a hint of nutmeg & rum.$32.50
German Chocolate Cookie, dozen
Chocolate chunks, coconut and pecans in a yummy cookie.$33.95
Chocolate Coma Cookie, dozen
Wheat-free. Intensely chocolatey.$32.50
Toll House Cookie, dozen
A dozen traditional Toll House cookies - Everybody's favorite.$28.95
Butterstar, dozen
A dozen of our popular butter cookie with festive sprinkles.$28.95
Goodies & Gifts

German Stollen
Rich, buttery German yeast bread. Dense with raisins, almonds and candied orange peel. Keeps well wrapped for up to one month. Try toasting a slice with a little butter.$29.95
Chocolate Apricot Fruitcake
Sophisticated and unusual. Walnuts, chocolate, dried apricots, golden raisins, candied orange peel and spices.$17.95
Biscotti Bag, 12 piece
For dipping in coffee or sweet dessert wine. Gayle and Joe learned this recipe at a café-bakery in New York, from a former priest who made them promise to never share the recipe with anyone.$19.95
Teal's Granola
With oats, oat bran, dried cranberries, sunflower seeds, almonds, pecans, hazelnuts, brown sugar, maple syrup, honey & cinnamon. 11 oz bag$16.75
Crostini, bag
Serve with spread, use as croutons or eat them right out of the bag! 8 oz.$9.75
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | Closed |
Restaurant info
Open Daily from 6:30am-7:30pm Special hours on select holidays.
Location
504 Bay Avenue, Capitola, CA 95010



