Skip to Main content

  • GoodFellas Pizzeria

    • Home
    • /
    • Niagara Falls
    • /
    • GoodFellas Pizzeria
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image

    GoodFellas Pizzeria

    American
    Open now11:15AM - 10:30PM
    CallDirectionsWebsite
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • 1/2 Tray Pizza and 20 Wings

      Classic cheese pizza and one free topping plus 20 wings. Add additional toppings for extra.
      $38.98

    • 3 Fingers W/ Fries

      3 chicken fingers with the sauce of your choice. Served with french fries and blue cheese.
      $10.98

    • Fish Fry

      Fried haddock fish, French fries, mac salad, coleslaw, bread, and tartar sauce
      $14.98

    Food

    House Specials

    • 1/2 Tray Pizza and 20 Wings

      Classic cheese pizza and one free topping plus 20 wings. Add additional toppings for extra.
      $38.98

    • Full Tray Pizza and 30 Wings

      Classic cheese pizza and one free topping plus 30 wings. Add additional toppings for extra.
      $65.98

    • Full Tray Pizza and 50 Wings

      Classic cheese pizza and one free topping plus 50 wings. Add additional toppings for extra.
      $77.98

    Pizzas

    • Tray Pizza

      Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
      $29.98

    • 1/2 Tray Pizza

      Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
      $15.98

    • Large Pie

      Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
      $18.98

    • Medium Pie

      Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
      $15.98

    • Slice - Pepperoni

      One square slice from our fresh pepperoni and cheese pizza, warmed in the oven.
      $2.50

    • Slice - Cheese

      One square slice from our fresh cheese pizza, warmed in the oven.
      $2.00

    • Personal Pie

      Personal pie pizza cut into 4 pieces. One free topping is included.
      $9.98

    Specialty Pizzas

    • Medium White Pizza

      $18.98

    • Large White Pizza

      $21.98

    • Half Tray White Pizza

      $17.98

    • Full tray White Pizza

      $27.98

    • Medium Chicken Finger Pizza

      $18.98

    • Large Chicken Finger Pizza

      Your choice of tomato, blue cheese, ranch or white base; topped with chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce.
      $21.98

    • Half Tray - Chicken Finger Pizza

      Your choice of tomato, blue cheese, ranch or white base; topped with chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce.
      $20.98

    • Full Tray - Chicken Finger Pizza

      Your choice of tomato, blue cheese, ranch or white base; topped with chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce.
      $30.98

    • Medium Steak Pizza

      $18.98

    • Large Steak Pizza

      $21.98

    • Half Tray Steak Pizza

      $20.98

    • Full Tray Steak Pizza

      $30.98

    • Gluten Free Pie

      $12.98

    • Cauliflower Crust

      $11.98

    • Half Tray BBQ Chicken

      $18.98

    • Full Tray BBQ Chicken

      $33.98

    Wings/Fingers

    • 10 Boneless Wings

      Includes one 2 oz. cup of blue cheese.
      $11.98

    • 10 Chicken Wings

      Includes one 2 oz. cup of blue cheese.
      $14.98

    • 20 Chicken Wings

      Includes two 2 oz. cups of blue cheese.
      $26.98

    • 30 Chicken Wings

      Includes three (3) 2 oz. cups of blue cheese.
      $40.98

    • 50 Chicken Wings

      Includes 4 (four) 2 oz. cups of blue cheese.
      $65.98

    • 4 Chicken Fingers

      Includes one 2 oz. cup of blue cheese.
      $11.98

    • 8 Chicken Fingers

      Includes two 2 oz. cups of blue cheese
      $23.98

    • 12 Chicken Fingers

      Includes three (3) 2 oz. cups of blue cheese.
      $33.98

    • Extra Blue Cheese

      $1.50

    Old Fashioned Pizzas

    • Full Tray - Old Fashioned Pizza

      A full tray made with a Pizza sauce base and topped with Parmesan cheese and sprinkled with oregano.
      $26.98

    • Half Tray - Old Fashioned Pizza

      1/2 tray made with a Pizza sauce base and topped with Parmesan cheese and sprinkled with oregano.
      $14.98

    • Large - Old Fashioned Pizza

      Large pie made with a pizza sauce base and topped with Parmesan cheese and sprinkled with oregano.
      $18.98

    • Medium - Old Fashioned Pizza

      Medium pie pizza with a Pizza sauce base topped with Parmesan cheese and sprinkled with oregano.
      $15.98

    Finger Foods

    • Pizza Logs (5)

      Golden, crispy pizza dough rolled and stuffed with savory pizza sauce, melted mozzarella cheese, and pepperoni. Fried to perfection and served with a side of warm marinara sauce for dipping.
      $9.98

    • Jalapeño Poppers (8)

      Jalapeño peppers stuffed with melted cheese, coated in a breading, and fried. Served with a side of ranch
      $7.98

    • Mozzarella Sticks (5)

      Golden, crispy breaded mozzarella sticks fried to perfection with a warm, gooey cheese center. Served with a side of marinara sauce for dipping.
      $8.98

    • Fried Ravioli (12)

      Cheese-filled ravioli coated in a crispy, seasoned breading and fried until golden brown. Served with a side of marinara sauce for dipping.
      $8.98

    • Garlic Bread with Cheese

      Freshly baked bread, brushed with buttery garlic seasoning and topped with melted mozzarella cheese.
      $6.98

    • Small Fry

      $4.98

    • Large Fry

      $5.98

    • Small Poutine

      $6.98

    • Large Poutine

      $7.98

    • Onion Rings

      Thick-cut onion rings in a golden batter and fried.
      $5.98

    • 3 Fingers W/ Fries

      3 chicken fingers with the sauce of your choice. Served with french fries and blue cheese.
      $10.98

    • Small Fry w/ Mozz Cheese

      Small order of fries with melted mozzarella cheese
      $5.98

    • Lg Fry w/ Mozz Cheese

      Large order of fries with melted mozzarella cheese
      $6.98

    Subs

    • Small - Steak and Cheese Sub

      Our most popular sub! Steak and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $10.98

    • Large - Steak and Cheese Sub

      Our most popular sub! Steak and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $12.98

    • Small - Chicken Finger Sub

      Chicken fingers, made with your choice of sauce, on a sub roll. Cheese, veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $10.98

    • Large - Chicken Finger Sub

      Chicken fingers, made with your choice of sauce, on a sub roll. Cheese, veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $12.98

    • Small - Sausage and Cheese Sub

      Sausage and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $10.98

    • Large - Sausage and Cheese Sub

      Sausage and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $12.98

    • Small - Ham and Cheese Sub

      Ham and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $10.98

    • Large - Ham and Cheese Sub

      Ham and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $12.98

    • Small - Assorted with Cheese Sub

      Ham, salami, capocolla and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $10.98

    • Large - Assorted with Cheese Sub

      Ham, salami, capocolla and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $12.98

    • Small - Turkey and Cheese Sub

      Turkey and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $10.98

    • Large - Turkey and Cheese Sub

      Turkey and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $12.98

    • Small - Salami and Cheese Sub

      Salami and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $10.98

    • Large - Salami and Cheese Sub

      Salami and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $12.98

    • Small - Capocollo and Cheese Sub

      Capocollo and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $10.98

    • Large - Capocollo and Cheese Sub

      Capocollo and cheese on a sub roll. Veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $12.98

    • Small - Pizza Sub

      Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese and pepperoni on a sub roll.
      $10.98

    • Large - Pizza Sub

      Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese and pepperoni on a sub roll.
      $12.98

    • Small - BLT Sub

      Bacon, lettuce and tomato on a sub roll. Cheese, veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $10.98

    • Large - BLT Sub

      Bacon, lettuce and tomato on a sub roll. Cheese, veggies, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $12.98

    • Small - Cheeseburger Sub

      $10.98

    • Large - Cheeseburger Sub

      $12.98

    Specialty Subs

    • Small - Stinger Sub

      Our classic steak sub but make it better! Chicken fingers, made with your choice of sauce, and steak. Cheese, vegetables, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $11.98

    • Large - Stinger Sub

      Our classic steak sub but make it better! Chicken fingers, made with your choice of sauce, and steak. Cheese, vegetables, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $13.98

    • Small - Royal Sub

      Sausage and capocolla on a sub roll. Cheese, vegetables, dressing/oil and additional toppings can be added.
      $11.98

    • Large - Royal Sub

      Sausage and capocolla on a sub roll. Cheese, vegetables, and additional toppings can be added.
      $13.98

    • Small - Chicken Parmigiana Sub

      Breaded chicken topped with marinara sauce and melted cheese on a sub roll.
      $11.98

    • Large - Chicken Parmigiana Sub

      Breaded chicken topped with marinara sauce and melted cheese on a sub roll.
      $13.98

    • Small - Meatball Sub

      Meatballs topped with marinara sauce and melted cheese.
      $11.98

    • Large - Meatball Sub

      Meatballs topped with melted cheese and marinara sauce on a sub roll.
      $13.98

    Burritos

    • Steak Burrito

      $10.98

    • Chicken Burrito

      $9.98

    • Stinger Burrito

      $12.98

    Salads

    • Dinner Salad

      $5.25

    • Chef Salad

      $9.98

    • Julienne Salad

      $12.98

    • Grilled Chicken Salad

      $13.98

    • Chicken Finger Salad

      $13.98

    • Antipasto

      $13.98

    • Chicken Taco Bowl Salad

      $13.50

    • Steak Taco Bowl Salad

      $14.98

    Dinners

    • Pasta Dinner with Meatballs

      Your choice of spaghetti or penne pasta, pasta sauce and meatballs. Served with bread and butter.
      $12.98

    • Fish Fry

      Fried haddock fish, French fries, mac salad, coleslaw, bread, and tartar sauce
      $14.98

    Sandwiches & Burgers

    • 1/2 lb Hamburger w/ Fries

      $12.98

    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich w/ Fries

      $12.98

    Dottie's Chicken Soup (Oct-May)

    • Pint of Soup

      $5.98

    • Quart of Soup

      $11.98

    Extra/Sides

    • Side - Blue Cheese

      2 oz. cup
      $1.50

    • Side - Sauce

      $1.50

    • Side - Gravy

      $1.75

    • Side - Sour Cream

      $1.00

    • Side - Salsa

      $1.25

    • Side - Honey Garlic

      $1.50

    • Side - Ranch

      $1.50

    • Side - BBQ Sauce

      $1.50

    • Side - Hot Sauce

      $1.50

    • Side - Medium Sauce

      $1.50

    • Side - Ketchup

      $0.75

    Desserts

    • Fried Dough Bites (12)

      Warm, golden fried dough bites topped with powdered sugar and cinnamon.
      $7.98

    Drinks

    • Coca-Cola Cherry, 2 Liters

      Delicious combination of Coca-Cola and cherry flavor
      $3.75

    • Coca-Cola, 2 Liters

      Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
      $3.75

    • Diet Coke, 2 Liters

      Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink
      $3.75

    • Canada Dry Ginger Ale, 2 Liters

      $3.75

    • Sprite, 2 Liters

      Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free
      $3.75

    • Barq's Root Beer, 2 Liters

      $3.75

    • Crystal Beach Loganberry, 2 Liters

      $3.75

    • Fanta Orange, 2 Liters

      Liberate your every day with fizzy and refreshing fruit-flavored Fanta soda pop
      $3.75

    • Gold Peak Sweet Tea, 20oz

      Gold Peak is real brewed tea made from tea leaves picked for peak taste. Gold Peak Real Brewed Tea has a variety of flavors that pair marvelously with any family occasion, from backyard get-togethers, to holiday traditions, to weekend getaways. Real Brewed. Real Tea. Real Good.
      $2.98

    • Gold Peak Unsweetened Tea

      $2.98

    • Minute Maid Lemonade, 20oz

      There’s always goodness to be found at the end of a Minute Maid rainbow.
      $2.89

    • Fanta Orange, 20oz

      Liberate your every day with fizzy and refreshing fruit-flavored Fanta soda pop
      $2.89

    • Dasani Water, 20oz

      Enhanced with minerals for a crisp, clean and fresh taste
      $2.50

    • Minute Maid Fruit Punch, 20oz

      There’s always goodness to be found at the end of a Minute Maid rainbow.
      $2.89

    • Barq's Root Beer, 20oz

      $2.89

    • Coca-Cola, 20oz

      Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
      $2.89

    • Diet Coke, 20oz

      Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink
      $2.89

    • Canada Dry Ginger Ale, 20oz

      $2.89

    • Sprite, 20oz

      Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free
      $2.89

    • Coca-Cola Zero Sugar, 20oz

      Enjoy the great taste of Coca-Cola with zero sugar, zero calories
      $2.89

    • Coca-Cola Cherry, 20oz

      $2.89
    If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.
    All hours
    Sunday11:15 am - 10:30 pm
    Monday11:15 am - 10:30 pm
    Tuesday11:15 am - 10:30 pm
    Wednesday11:15 am - 10:30 pm
    Thursday11:15 am - 10:30 pm
    Friday11:15 am - 10:30 pm
    Saturday11:15 am - 10:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    Dine in, takeout, delivery!

    Location

    745 West Market Street, Niagara Falls, NY 14301

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play