Gotham Bagels Lake Geneva

Loose bagels do not come sliced.

Choose 13 bagels. We suggest three 8oz containers of cream cheese per dozen.

Choose 6 bagels

House whipped cream cheese

Northern Atlantic cold-smoked salmon. Comes with arugula, heirloom tomato, red onion, capers.

8oz size container

8oz size container

8oz size container

8oz size container Roasted Poblano and Caramelized Onion

6 Latkes

Veggies for 1/2 Doz Bagels. Comes with Arugula, heirloom tomato, red onion, capers.

1/2 LB Comes with pickles and arugula

1/2 LB Comes with pickles and arugula

Quart of broth with 3 matzo balls. COMES COLD.

House-made classic New York Black and White Cookie

With cinnamon and flaky sea salt

Build your own: choose 3 bagel and cream cheese combos and we make 3 of each. 9 bagels with cream cheese, wrapped and sliced in half (18 halves). Serves 9.

A platter of 9 classic Gotham sandwiches, wrapped and sliced in half. Choice of 3 types of sandwich per platter. Additional charges may apply for premium sandwiches.

Includes a NY Dozen® (13 bagels, a baker's dozen) to build your own, plus 1 lb Atlantic cold-smoked salmon, two 8oz spreads, arugula, heirloom tomato, cucumber, pickles, red onion, and capers. *Please preorder or allow additional prep time.*

Includes a NY Dozen® (13 bagels, a baker's dozen) to build your own, plus two 8oz tuna fish salads, two 8oz smoked whitefish salads, two 8oz spreads, arugula, heirloom tomato, cucumber, Gotham's Famous Pickles, red onion, and capers. *Please preorder or allow additional prep time.*

Includes a NY Dozen® (13 bagels, a baker's dozen) to build your own, plus 2 lbs house-cured pastrami, two 8oz spreads, Gotham's Famous Pickles, mustard, arugula, heirloom tomato, and giardiniera.

Includes a NY Dozen® (13 bagels, a baker's dozen) to build your own, plus 1 lb smoked natural turkey breast, 1 lb sliced fontina, two 8oz spreads, arugula, heirloom tomato, cucumber, pickles, red onion, and capers. *Please preorder or allow additional prep time.*

Two dozen latkes, snake bite hot sauce, sour cream, and homemade apple sauce. *Please preorder or allow for additional prep time for this item*

Scrambled eggs for catering orders, serves 12

Bacon for catering, serves 12

13 New York bagels plus three 8oz containers of cream cheese, bundled for less than buying separately. Choose 13 bagels and 3 cream cheeses. Ask us to slice or single chop.

Fried egg, aged cheddar, & thick cut bacon. Choice of bagel. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.

Fried egg, aged cheddar, & spicy Italian sausage. Choice of bagel. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.

Premium Atlantic cold-smoked salmon, cream cheese, heirloom tomato, red onion, arugula, & capers. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.

Smoked natural turkey breast, fontina cheese, arugula, heirloom tomato, & mayo. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.

Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.

Arugula, heirloom tomato, & red onion. Choice of bagel. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle

Smoked whitefish salad, arugula, cucumber, heirloom tomato, & red onion. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.

Vegan scallion cream cheese, poblano salad, heirloom tomato, arugula, & avocado. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle

Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle

Fried egg, aged cheddar, Nashville fried chicken, thick cut bacon, & spicy aioli. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.

Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle

Piled-high hot pastrami with NY Strong mustard and deli coleslaw

Fried egg, thick cut bacon, aged cheddar, potato latke, & spicy ketchup. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.

Cheddar, avocado, bacon, arugula, heirloom tomato & mayo. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle

Our new seasonal special with creamy spinach artichoke spread, smoked natural turkey breast, heirloom tomato, pickled red onions, and arugula. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.

5 frozen sliced day-old bagels.

Brined to perfection

Smoked carrot hot sauce

Made from fresh skin-on Michigan potatoes

Sweet, Spicy, Savory, Gotham's finest curated seasoning for lovers of flavor.

8oz container

Iced or Hot made with Bassline espresso blend from Passion House Coffee Roasters and warm, aromatic pumpkin pie spices

Iced or Hot made with Bassline espresso blend from Passion House Coffee Roasters, dark chocolate syrup, toasted marshmallow cream, and graham cracker crumbs

Night Moves Blend by Passion House. Sweet and smooth with notes of dark chocolate, candied stone fruits, and sweet caramel.

Iced or Hot made with Bassline espresso blend from Passion House Coffee Roasters. This blend is anchored with rich and creamy chocolate base notes, highlighted with a vibrant blast of citrus acidity up front, and stone fruits, dark cocoa, and molasses balancing it all out.

Classic cold brew from Passion House Coffee Roasters

Made with Bassline espresso blend from Passion House Coffee Roasters. This blend is anchored with rich and creamy chocolate base notes, highlighted with a vibrant blast of citrus acidity up front, and stone fruits, dark cocoa, and molasses balancing it all out.

Made with Bassline espresso blend from Passion House Coffee Roasters. This blend is anchored with rich and creamy chocolate base notes, highlighted with a vibrant blast of citrus acidity up front, and stone fruits, dark cocoa, and molasses balancing it all out.

Made with Bassline espresso blend from Passion House Coffee Roasters. This blend is anchored with rich and creamy chocolate base notes, highlighted with a vibrant blast of citrus acidity up front, and stone fruits, dark cocoa, and molasses balancing it all out.

Your choice of milk with Bassline espresso blend from Passion House Coffee Roasters

Your choice of milk with Bassline espresso blend from Passion House Coffee Roasters

Classic cold brew from Passion House Coffee Roasters topped with our rich lightly sweetened cold cream

Floral lavender and rich honey combined with your choice of milk and Bassline espresso blend from Passion House Coffee Roasters

Unsweetened hand whisked matcha with your choice of milk!

Unsweetened Hand whisked iced matcha with your choice of milk topped with our rich lightly sweetened cold cream

Chai tea with your choice of milk!

Organic Rishi tea blends.

Black unsweetened tea brewed in-house.

Natalie's 100% Orange Juice

Featuring Dr. Brown's sodas. 12oz cans & 6 packs

Natural Alpine Spring Crystal Geyser.

House-made with fresh squeezed lemon juice and pure cane sugar

Equal parts house-brewed unsweetened black tea and homemade lemonade

Box of Passion House Regular Brewed coffee to serve 10 people. Cups, cream, and sugar packets available on request.

Comfy black tee with bagel bat logo

Cozy black sweatshirt with bagel bat logo

One-size black beanie with bagel bat logo