Skip to Main content
  • Hefner's Custard Cedarburg

    • Home
    • /
    • Cedarburg
    • /
    • Hefner's Custard
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image

    Hefner's Custard

    Ice Cream Shop
    Open now11AM - 8:45PM
    CallDirectionsGift Cards
    ‌
    ‌
    GRILL
    DRINKS
    CUSTARD
    SPECIALS

    Featured Items

    • Jumbo Cheeseburger

      Single hamburger with American cheese and your choice of toppings.
      $7.19
    • Fries

      $3.69
    • Onion Rings

      $4.19

    GRILL

    Sandwiches

    • Jumbo Hamburger

      Single hamburger with your choice of toppings.
      $6.49
    • Jumbo Cheeseburger

      Single hamburger with American cheese and your choice of toppings.
      $7.19
    • Double Hamburger

      Double hamburger with your choice of toppings.
      $9.19
    • Double Cheeseburger

      Double hamburger with American cheese and your choice of toppings.
      $10.19
    • Mushroom Swiss Burger

      Cheeseburger with Swiss cheese and fried mushrooms.
      $8.29
    • Double Mushroom Swiss Burger

      Double cheeseburger with Swiss cheese and fried mushrooms.
      $11.39
    • CEDAR-BURGER

      Cheeseburger topped with Cedar Creek Winery’s pinot grigio Swiss spread, American cheese, bacon and fried onions.
      $9.39
    • Huge Hefner

      Double cheeseburger with extra bun slice, American cheese, lettuce, pickles, raw onions and 1000 island dressing.
      $11.69
    • Fish Sandwich

      Breaded cod fillet sandwich with your choice of toppings.
      $6.69
    • JAWS

      Two breaded cod fillets sandwiched between a hamburger bun and topped with American cheese, lettuce, raw onion and tartar sauce
      $10.49
    • Grilled Cheese

      $3.99
    • Chicken Fingers

      Panko crusted chicken tenderloins with your choice of dipping sauce.
      $7.29
    • Grilled Chicken

      ***NEW Hormel® Fire Braised Chicken Breast Fillet*** Chicken breast fillet fire-seared before being slow-cooked in their own juices. Served with your choice of toppings.
      $7.29
    • Breaded Chicken

      Juicy chicken breast fillet breaded in flour seasoned with salt, pepper, buttermilk and a hint of savory spices.
      $7.29

    Sides

    • Fries

      $3.69
    • Onion Rings

      $4.19
    • Cheese Curds

      $5.49
    • Fry/Ring Mix

      $4.19
    • Tater Tots

      $3.69
    • Cheese Fries

      cheese served on the side
      $4.59
    • Mozzarella Sticks

      served with marinara
      $6.19
    • Breaded Mushrooms

      $5.69
    • Fry/Tot Mix

      $3.89
    • Mini Fried Tacos

      served with sour cream & salsa
      $4.69
    • Tater Tots

      $3.69

    Kids Meals

    • KIDS CORN DOGS

      1 Entrée, 1 Side & 1 Drink
      $6.59
    • KIDS FINGERS

      1 Entrée, 1 Side & 1 Drink
      $6.59
    • KIDS GRILLED CHEESE

      1 Entrée, 1 Side & 1 Drink
      $6.59

    DRINKS

    Sodas

    • Medium Soda

      $2.89
    • Large Soda

      $3.39

    Bottled Drinks

    • Bottled Water

      $0.99
    • AriZona Arnold Palmer

      Half Iced Tea & Half Lemonade
      $2.49
    • Cool Blue Gatorade

      $1.99
    • Fruit Punch Gatorade

      $1.99
    • Lemon-Lime Gatorade

      $1.99

    Kids Drinks

    • Kids Milk

      $1.89
    • Kids Chocolate Milk

      $2.19
    • 100% Juice Box

      $1.49
    • Kids Soda

      $2.09

    Floats/Custard Soda

    • Float

      $4.99
    • Chocolate Custard Soda

      Old fashioned custard soda made with vanilla custard, carbonation and chocolate syrup
      $4.79

    Slush/Custard Smoothie

    • Small Slush

      $2.29
    • Medium Slush

      $2.59
    • Large Slush

      $2.89
    • Small Custard Smoothie

      Blend of vanilla custard, sweet slushie and your flavor choice.
      $3.09
    • Medium Custard Smoothie

      Blend of vanilla custard, sweet slushie and your flavor choice.
      $3.49
    • Large Custard Smoothie

      Blend of vanilla custard, sweet slushie and your flavor choice.
      $3.89

    Milk

    • Small Milk

      $1.89
    • Large Milk

      $2.19
    • Small Chocolate Milk

      $2.19
    • Large Chocolate Milk

      $2.49

    CUSTARD

    Cones/Dishes

    • Baby Cone

      $3.09
    • Baby Dish

      $3.09
    • 1 Scoop Cone

      $3.59
    • 1 Scoop Dish

      $3.59
    • 2 Scoop Cone

      $4.59
    • 2 Scoop Dish

      $4.59
    • 3 Scoop Cone

      $5.49
    • 3 Scoop Dish

      $5.49
    • Waffle Cone

      served with 2 scoops of custard
      $5.29

    Dole® Soft Serve

    • Pineapple Dole® Soft Serve

      Dole® soft serve, served in a dish it is dairy-free, gluten-free, lactose-free and vegetarian.

    Shakes/Malts

    • Regular Shake

      16oz
      $5.39
    • Regular Malt

      16oz
      $5.39
    • Large Shake

      24oz
      $6.39
    • Large Malt

      24oz
      $6.39

    Whiteouts

    • WHITEOUT

      Heaping scoops of vanilla, chocolate or flavor the day custard mixed with your choice of two toppings from our curated list.
      $6.99

    Sundaes

    • Regular Sundae

      1 large scoop of custard with your choice of topping.
      $5.29
    • Large Sundae

      3 scoops of custard with your choice of topping.
      $6.29

    Specialty Sundaes

    • Doggie Delight

      1 scoop of vanilla custard topped with dog biscuits for your pooch!
      $2.99
    • Regular Turtle Sundae

      2 scoops of vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, caramel and pecans.
      $5.99
    • Large Turtle Sundae

      3 scoops of vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, caramel and pecans
      $7.49
    • Banana Split

      3 scoops of vanilla custard cradled by bananas and topped with chocolate syrup, raspberries, strawberries and crushed nuts.
      $7.49
    • Cashew Creation

      3 scoops of vanilla custard topped with marshmallow, butterscotch and cashews.
      $7.49
    • Hefner's Delight

      3 scoops of vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, marshmallow, butterscotch and pecans.
      $7.49
    • Caramel Brownie

      3 scoops of vanilla custard topped with brownie pieces and caramel.
      $6.99

    Packed Custard

    • Pint

      $5.99
    • Quarts

      $10.99
    • 1/2 Gallon

      $17.49

    SPECIALS

    Burger of the Month

    • Morgan's Miami Burger

      Cheeseburger topped with slices of ham & Swiss cheese then topped with roasted garlic mayo, pickles and a pressed and buttered bun.
      $9.49

    Sundae of the Month

    • Dusty Elvis Sundae

      Our creamy vanilla custard topped with peanut butter sauce, hot fudge, bananas and a dusting of malt powder.
      $6.49
    • *LIMITED TIME* Funnel Cake Fries

      Fried funnel cake fries with vanilla custard and cinnamon sugar dusting.
      $5.49

    Monday (Served Monday Only)

    • Gyro

      Blend of lamb and beef gyro meat topped with tzatziki sauce, raw onions and tomatoes on a pita.
      $9.49

    Tuesday Burger Special 11AM-2PM

    • Jumbo Hamburger

      Single hamburger with your choice of toppings.
      $6.49
    • Jumbo Cheeseburger

      Single hamburger with American cheese and your choice of toppings.
      $7.19

    Wednesday (Served Wednesday Only)

    • Sourdough Melt

      Cheeseburger topped with American cheese, Swiss cheese and fried onions on grilled sourdough bread.
      $7.39

    Thursday (Served Thusday Only)

    • September: Pepper Jack Mac and Cheese Bites

      Crispy garlic battered macaroni with a creamy pepper jack cheese sauce.
      $5.99

    Friday (Served Friday Only)

    • Cod Fish Fry

      3-piece battered cod fish fry served with french fries, coleslaw, rye bread, tartar sauce and lemon.
      $15.99
    • Breaded Perch Fish Fry

      4-piece breaded perch fish fry served with french fries, coleslaw, tartar, rye bread and lemon.
      $16.99

    30th Anniversary Specials!

    • Small T-Shirt

      $25.00

    All hours
    Sunday11:00 am - 7:45 pm
    Monday11:00 am - 7:45 pm
    Tuesday11:00 am - 7:45 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 7:45 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 7:45 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 8:45 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 8:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    N71W5184 Columbia Rd, Cedarburg, WI 53012

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play