
American
Horsefeathers
94 North Broadway
Tarrytown, NY 10591
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
LUNCH/DINNER
Appetizers
BBQ Ribs 1/2 Rack
$19.00Chicken Littles
$13.00Coconut Shrimp
$15.00FF / SPF Mix
$9.00Fried Combo
wings, rings, fried mushrooms, zucchini sticks & fried mozzarella.$25.00Fried Mushrooms
with a side of horseradish sauce.$12.00Fried Plumpy Calamari
$20.00Garlic Bread
plain, with mozzarella or with tomato, basil & parmesan.$7.00
House Cut Steak Fries
$8.00
Jalapeno Poppers
$12.00Maryland Blue Crab Cake
with a side of tartar sauce & lemon.$13.00
Mini Cheeseburgers
$12.00Mini Hamburger
$12.00
Mozzarella Sticks
$12.00
Nachos
Plain, Supreme, Chili or Both$11.00
Onion Rings
beer battered & house made.$13.00
Potato Skins
We do potato skins differently around here. Fresh potatoes are shaved, fried until crunchy at the edges, then buried under melted cheddar and thick-cut bacon. Served with sour cream for dipping.$12.00
Shrimp Cocktail
Much bigger than jumbo.$21.00Spinach Dip
with toasted bread, dollop of sour cream.$12.00Stonington Scallops
Served with a side of tartar and pesto.$16.00Sweet Potato Fries
$9.00
Wings
$16.00Zucchini Sticks
$13.00
Soups
Burgers
Plain Burger
$16.95
Cheese It!
American, swiss, soft cheddar, horseradish cheddar, blue cheese, mozzarella or muenster.$17.95
Pig Out
Cheese and bacon$19.25
Patti Melt
Burger inside of a grilled cheese.$18.50Cheeseburger Club
White toast, bacon, lettuce & tomato.$19.50
Old English
Cheddar and bacon on a toasted English Muffin.$19.50
California
American cheese, avocado, lettuce & tomato.$19.50Get Hot
Plain burger with 4oz of chili on the side$18.50
#1
Mushrooms, onions, cheddar 'n hot sauce.$18.95
Sautéed Fresh Mushroom & Onion
$18.95Johnnie
Roasted garlic and soft cheddar$18.50Knickerbocker
Carmelized onions "rolled in", horseradish cheddar$18.95
Howie
Blackend, avacado, tomato, dijon honey mustard$18.50Chicken/ Bun
$17.50
Salads

Tossed Salad
Mixed Greens, tomato, cucumber, red onion, radish, olives & croutons.$9.25Ceasar
with roasted croutons$13.50Apple Salad
Apple, arugula, cranberry, walnut, reggiano cheese with raspberry vinegarette$14.50Grilled Veggies
Red & green peppers, squash, zucchini, eggplant, arugula, gorgonzola cheese with balsamic vinegarette.$16.95
Pan Seared Broccoli Salad
Pan seared broccoli, mixed greens, gorgonzola, tomato, onion & calamata olives.$18.50
Arugula
Roasted red peppers, bocconcini, olives, tomato, onion & artichoke. Served with a side of garlic toast.$18.50
Spinach Bowl
Spinach, mushrooms, swiss, tomato, bacon, egg & croutons. Served with warm honey mustard dressing.$17.50Gorgonzola
romaine lettuce, gorgonzola, tomato, olives & red roasted peppers.$16.50Cobb Salad
Chicken, cheddar cheese, bacon, tomato, egg, croutons, with blue cheese dressing.$19.50Chilled Baked Salmon
Chilled backed salmon, mixed greens, fresh garlic string beans, red roasted peppers & gorgonzola cheese.$22.95
Tuscan Tuna In Olive Oil
Tuscan tuna, tomato, egg, radishes, calamatas, capers, onion, mixed greens. Served with olive oil herb dressing.$18.50
Wedges
Philly Cheese Steak
Peppers, onions, American cheese, grilled roast beef.$17.50Grilled Chicken & Veg Wedge
Grilled Chicken, red & green peppers, squash, zucchini, eggplant & shaved reggiano parmesan cheese on a toasted wedge.$16.95
Broadway Dip
Roast beef, sautéed onions, melted Swiss, au jus.$16.95French Dip
Roast beef on wedge bread served cold, with warm au jus.$15.50John Paulding
Turkey, horseradish cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion & cranberry mayo.$16.50Arthur Avenue Wedge
Arthur Avenue Italian sausage parmigiana, peppers & onions.$16.50
Cuban
Fresh Pork, ham, swiss cheese, pickle, mayo & mustard on a pressed garlic wedge.$17.50
Chicken Cutlet
Fried chicken cutlet, melted Muenster cheese & red roasted peppers on a garlic wedge.$17.50
Pub Club
Turkey, roast beef, bacon, lettuce tomato, mayo on wedge bread.$16.95Sliced Steak Wedge
Sliced steak trimmed lean, American cheese & sautéed onions.$21.95Rocky Balboa
thinly sliced roast beef with melted Swiss cheese on a garlic wedge.$17.50Chicken Parm Wedge
$17.50
Sandwiches

BBQ Ribs on a Bun
$21.95BLT
$15.95
Chicken Salad Club
Grilled, then pulled chicken with tarragon mayo on 12 grain toast. Bacon, lettuce and tomato.$18.50Chicken Salad Melt
Tarragon mayo, swiss cheese served open faced on an english muffin.$16.25Chicken Salad Sandwich
$16.95Classic Club
$16.50Corn Beef Sandwhich
$15.95
Count of Monte Cristo
French toast with Swiss, turkey & ham.$16.50Deep Fried Flounder
Deep fried flounder, American cheese, house-made tartar sauce.$21.50Egg Salad Sandwich
$15.95Englebert Pumperdink
Turkey, ham, bacon, Swiss cheese, tomato & onion on pumpernickel bread.$17.50
Gobbler
Turkey on 12 grain bread, cranberry, apple-raisin cornbread stuffing.$17.95
Grilled Cheese & Tomato with Tuna or Bacon
$15.95
Grilled Tuna on Rye
with roasted peppers and relish$16.95Maryland Blue Crab Cake
$21.95Nathan's Famous Double Dogs
Choice of plain, with chili, sauerkraut, relish or "the works". Served with a side of fries.$16.95
Paddy O'Grill
$17.95
Reuben
Corned beef trimmed lean, sauerkraut & russian dressing on grilled rye bread. Open or Closed.$17.95Roastbeef Sandwich
$15.50Swordfish
Grilled swordfish on a bun, plain or with caribe spices.$22.95Tuna Melt
Served open on an English muffin, melted Swiss.$16.25Tuna Salad
$16.25
Turkey Avocado
Turkey, swiss, tomato, bacon, Swiss & mayo on pumpernickel bread.$17.95
Turkey Reuben
Turkey, horseradish cheddar, Russian dressing on grilled rye.$16.95Turkey Sandwich
$16.50
Ala Carte
Meat & Poultry
Shell Steak
2" thick, trimmed lean with mushrooms, onions, served plain or marinated in teriyaki.$35.95
Roast Turkey Dinner
Roast turkey, apple-raisin cornbread stuffing, mashed potatoes & cranberry sauce. Served with a house salad.$27.95
Organic 1/2 Chicken
Herb roasted served with mashed potatoes.$29.95Barbecued Baby Back Ribs
Slow roasted. Served with a house salad.$36.95Filet Mignon
$44.95OUT OF STOCKGracie's Real Good Chicken
$27.95
Shepherd's Pie
$27.95Teriyaki Tidbits
$27.95Grilled Chix Dinner
$24.95
Seafood
Pasta
Served with a house salad.
Shrimp & Broccoli
Shrimp, broccoli, wild mushrooms & garlic cream with penne pasta.$28.95Stonington Scallops
Stonington Scallops, tomato, basil, garlic & e.v.o.o. with penne pasta.$28.95Pepperoni Heaven
Pepperoni, bacon, onion, peas & cream sauce with farfalle pasta.$26.95
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
Fried chicken cutlet, marinara, mozzarella cheese. Served with penne pasta.$27.95Basil Pesto Chicken
Chicken, basil, pesto, tomato, farfalle.$27.95
Grilled Shrimp
Grilled shrimp, tomatoes, arugula, garlic & e.v.o.o. with penne pasta.$29.95Chicken & Artichokes
Chicken, artichokes, mushrooms, garlic & e.v.o.o. served with penne pasta.$27.95Country Bolognese
Meat sauce, peppers & onions. With rigatoni pasta.$26.95Arthur Avenue. Sausage Pasta
Arthur avenue sausage, peppers & onions in a light red sauce. Served with rigatoni pasta.$26.95Chicken, Peas, Mushrooms
Chicken, peas & mushrooms in a pink cream sauce with penne pasta.$27.95Stonington Scallops in Cream Sauce
Stonington scallops, bacon & onion in a cream sauce with rigatoni pasta.$28.95Chicken 'n Broccoli
$27.95Wild Mushroom
$25.95Pasta Marinara
$18.95Shrimp Parm
$28.95
KID'S MENU
Kid's Meals
Kids Hamburger
with fries$12.00Kids Cheeseburger
with fries$13.00Kids Hot Dog
with fries$11.00Kids Fried Flounder
with steamed broccoli$14.00Kids Grilled Cheese
with fries$10.00Kids Pasta
with butter or marinara$10.00Kids Grilled Chicken
with mashed potatoes$10.00Kids Chicken Fingers
$12.00Kids Steak Fries
$5.00Kids SPF
$5.00
DESSERT
Apple Pie
$11.00
Black Beauty
Vanilla ice cream sundae, brownie center, chocolate syrup & whipped cream.$11.00Bread Pudding
Ala mode, whipped cream$11.00Baileys Bread Pudding
$13.00Rice Pudding
$8.00
Strawberry Shortcake
Grandma Rogers recipe- homemade biscuit, strawberries, vanilla ice cream & whipped cream$11.00
The Beast
A huge homemade brownie ala mode with hot chocolate syrup.$11.00
Oreo Sundae
$11.00Magic Mountain
$11.00Brownie
$7.00Cobbler
$11.00Ice Cream
$7.00Chocolate And Vanilla Sundae
$11.00
BRUNCH
Omlettes / Eggs
Arthur Avenue Omelette
$17.95
Belgian Waffles
$13.00
Breakfast Burrito
$17.95Broccoli Tomato Onion
$16.95
Brunch Quesadilla
scrambled eggs, spinach, bacon & cheddar$16.95Cornbeef Hash
$7.95Cornbeef Hash With 2 Eggs On Top And Toast
$15.95Crab Benedict
poached eggs, maryland blue crab cakes, hollandaise sauce$21.95
Dutch Country Omelette
ham, bacon, peppers, onions, potato, cheddar$17.95Eggs Benedict
poached eggs, english muffin, Canadian bacon, hollandaise$16.95Eggs Rockefeller
two poached eggs, spinach, cheddar dollop, hollandaise atop an open faced English muffin$16.95French Toast with Bacon
$14.95Grilled Shrimp & Arugula
$22.95Grilled Veggies & Swiss
red & green peppers, zucchini, eggplant, squash, swiss & reggiano cheese$16.95Ham & Egg Club Sandwich
$16.95
Irish Omelette
corned beef hash & cheddar cheese$17.50Mexican Omelette
house-made chili, cheddar, guacamole & sour cream$16.95Nova Salmon Omelette
tomato, red onion, capers & cream cheese$21.50Omelette w/ Meat
$16.95Sleepy Hollow Skins
scrambled eggs inside of scooped out potato skins with broccoli, cheddar cheese & bacon$15.95Sliced Steak Wedge & Eggs
$20.05Spinach & Bacon
mushrooms & cheddar$16.95Steak & Eggs
$22.95Sweet Pot Hash Side
$6.95Tomato Avocado Mushroom
$16.95Tomato Basil Pesto
$16.55Two Eggs / Toast
$14.95Wild Mushroom Omelette
with muenster cheese$16.95French Toast with Ham Steak
$15.95Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich
$13.95
DRINKS
N/A Beverages

Coca-Cola
Coca-Cola's crisp, refreshing taste has stood the test of time since 1886. These carefully crafted soft drinks are meant to be enjoyed anytime, anywhere. Pop open a Coca-Cola soda for a taste experience like no other. The familiar fizz and caffeine create an instant magic moment. Refreshing the world for over 130 years, Coca-Cola brings people together and spreads optimism wherever it goes. Find your magic and make life delicious with an ice-cold Coca-Cola.$3.75
Coca-Cola Zero Sugar
There's nothing quite like the crisp, refreshing taste of an ice-cold Coca-Cola Zero Sugar. With zero sugar and zero calories, you can enjoy the same great Coca-Cola taste anytime, anywhere. This zero-sugar cola's secret formula creates a no-sugar taste experience like no other. The familiar fizz and caffeine refresh with every sip. Make the sweetest moments better (without the sugar), with Coca-Cola Zero Sugar.$3.75
Diet Coke
Enjoy a break with Diet Coke, the perfect no-sugar, no-calorie companion. With its bold taste and distinctive blend of flavors, Diet Coke is an everyday hero when it comes to refreshing your day. Every sip of Diet Coke delivers the same great taste that's delighted fans for over 40 years. When you want a sugar-free soda that doesn't sacrifice on taste, reach for a Diet Coke.$3.75
Fanta Orange
The multi-sensory, fruity flavors of Fanta provide a bubbly, exuberant and playful consumption experience.$3.75
Sprite
Sprite's cool and crisp lemon-lime flavor will keep you invigorated and inspired. You know why? Because Sprite keeps it real just like you when pursuing your passions. No caffeine. Just you, an iconic flavor, and whatever you can think of next.$3.75Ginger ale
$3.75Club Soda
$3.75Juice & Club
$4.50Cranberry Juice
$4.50Orange Juice
$4.50Lemonade
$3.75Iced Tea
$3.75Shirley Temple
$3.75Apple Juice
$4.50Pineapple Juice
$4.50Arnold Palmer
$3.75Root Beer
$3.75Root Beer Float
$6.00Large Lurisia
$8.00Orange Soda Float
$6.00Cold Cider
$3.75Dr Pepper
$3.75Milkshake
$7.00Chocolate Milk
$5.00Iced Coffee
$3.95Iced Capp
$6.50Cafe Mocha
$6.00Cappuccino
$6.00Coffee
$3.50Decaf Coffee
$3.50Decaf Espresso
$4.00Double Espresso
$6.50Espresso
$4.00Herbal Tea
$4.50Hot Chocolate
$5.00Hot Tea
$3.50Latte
$6.00Mochaccino
$6.00
All hours
| Sunday | 11:30 am - 8:45 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30 am - 8:45 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:30 am - 8:45 pm |
| Thursday | 11:30 am - 8:45 pm |
| Friday | 11:30 am - 9:15 pm |
| Saturday | 11:30 am - 9:15 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location




