Deli
Joe's Butcher Shop - Sandwiches & Catering
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
House BLT
House cured candied bacon, sweet butter lettuce, heirloom local tomatoes, sliced avocado, garlic aioli, served on toasted Sourdough$11.99
Aji Amarillo Flank Steak
House marinated flank steak, cilantro aioli, pickled red onion, cotija cheese, shredded romaine, served on a warm Challah Roll$15.99
Evan's IPA Braised Beef
12 hour IPA braised beef, havarti fondue, sweet caramelized onion, spicy arugula, red winegastrique, served on a Stirato Roll *Evan's favorite, $1 is contributed to the Merciful H.E.L.P. Center$14.99
Sandwiches
Cold Sandwiches
Turkey Pesto
Brined roasted turkey breast, tomato conserva, basil pesto, fresh mozzarella, shredded romaine, parm crisp, served on a Stirato Roll$12.99
The French Orchard
Tulip Tree Trillium brie, local butter, bourbon fig jam, Granny Smith apple, served on a French Batard$13.99
The Italian Next Door
Spicy capicola, genoa salami, cotto ham, provolone, heirloom tomato, shredded romaine, and oregano vinaigrette, served on a Stirato Roll$13.99
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chicken salad, avocado, local cucumber, butter lettuce, served on a Challah Bun$11.99
Roast Beef and Cheddar
House made roast beef, scallion/horseradish cream, aged white cheddar, romaine, served on a Stirato Roll$13.99House BLT
House cured candied bacon, sweet butter lettuce, heirloom local tomatoes, sliced avocado, garlic aioli, served on toasted Sourdough$11.99
The #9
We've created a special sandwich with our favorite pro basketball player! Blackened Turkey breast, house made honey dijon dressing, herbed goat cheese topped with fried shallots, served on Amelia's Dinner roll$11.99
Hot Sandwiches
Hot Capicola
Capicola, havarti cheese, caramelized onion, sliced jalapeno, pressed and served on Sourdough bread$11.99Evan's IPA Braised Beef
12 hour IPA braised beef, havarti fondue, sweet caramelized onion, spicy arugula, red winegastrique, served on a Stirato Roll *Evan's favorite, $1 is contributed to the Merciful H.E.L.P. Center$14.99
Debris Po' Boy
Blackened IPA braised beef, pickled red onion, garlic aioli, house remoulade, romaine lettuce, fresh tomato, served on a French Batard$12.99
Chef's Bahn Mi
Citrus braised caramelized pork belly, house pickled vegetables, handpicked cilantro, fresh jalapeno, house made chili aioli, served on a French Batard$14.99
Mission Chicken Torta
House pulled chicken, roasted salsa verde, avocado, aged cotija, shredded iceberg, served on a warm Challah Roll$11.99
El Cubanito
10-hour house braised mojo pork, cotto ham, creamy swiss, house dill pickles, garlic mustard butter, served pressed on French Batard$12.99Aji Amarillo Flank Steak
House marinated flank steak, cilantro aioli, pickled red onion, cotija cheese, shredded romaine, served on a warm Challah Roll$15.99
Hot Italian Beef
Thin sliced roasted beef in our house au-jus, giardiniera, melty provolone cheese, served on a Soft Roll$12.99
Sicilian Meatball
Family recipe meatballs, house made sunday “gravy”, melted provolone, served on a toasted Soft Roll$12.99
Turkey Tarantino
Brined turkey, sundried tomato pesto, lemon artichoke ricotta, bacon, arugula, served on a Stirato Roll$12.99
Rich Boy Scallop Sandwich
Blackened scallops, house made remoulade, tomato, shredded romaine, served on a toasted French Batard$16.99
Grown-Up Grilled Cheese
Melty havarti, provolone, and white cheddar, candied bacon, and tomato served on Sourdough$9.99
Main St. Meatloaf Sandwich
Delicious homemade meatloaf, red onion, natural swiss cheese, and homemade tomato jam. Mom is jealous!$10.99
Pulled Pork
$11.99
Kids Menu
Salads
Grand Palace Salad
Assorted mixed spring lettuce, sliced thai marinated chicken breast, sautéed snow peas and grape tomatoes, shaved brussels sprouts, and orange supremes, crowned with our house made orange sesame dressing$12.99
Basque Steak Salad
Freshly shredded romaine lettuce, sliced marinated flank steak, roasted red pepper, pickled red onion, marcona almonds, shaved parmesan cheese, house made poblano cream dressing$14.99OUT OF STOCK
Side House Salad
Spring mixed lettuce, tomatoes, fresh cucumber, shredded carrots, herbed croutons, with balsamic dressing$7.99
Chips
Broad Ripple Chips ORIGINAL
A local classic. Hand crafted in small batches.$1.99
Broad Ripple Chips SWEET/SPICY
Hand crafted locally, a touch of sugar and bit of spicy heat!$1.99
Joe Chips Bacon/Cheddar
Bacon and cheddar flavor kettle chips, class up your sandwich with that baked spud taste$1.99OUT OF STOCK
Joe Chips BBQ
BBQ Kettle Chips seasoned with a BBQ back rib seasoning won in a poker game$1.99
Joe Chips Jalepeno
Jalapeno flavor in a crispy kettle chip. Add a little heat to your sandwich$1.99
Joe Chips Plain
Kettle Chips with sea salt, cooked in small batches. Super crunchy$1.99
Joe Chips Salt & Vinegar
Kettle Chips seasoned with a blend of sea salt and vinegar for that perfect pucker$1.99
Sides each
Broccoli Salad- 6oz
6oz, Broccoli, bacon, cran raisins, red onion, carrot, and orange dressing$4.50
Potato Salad- 6oz
6oz, Home made with red potatoes, mayo, mustard, and sweet pickle relish, the classic$3.00
Pasta Salad- 6oz
6oz, Tri-color fussili with italian herb dressing, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, olives and more$3.50
Shaved Brussels Sprouts Salad- 6oz
6oz, Fine shaved brussels sprouts with bacon and brown sugar$4.25
Lemon Pepper Coleslaw- 6oz
6oz, Fresh shaved cabbage and carrots with our homemade lemon pepper dressing$3.25
Macaroni Salad- 6oz
6oz, Fresh made Elbow Macaroni with Green Pepper, Red Pepper, Mayonaise, Celery, Onion, Dijon Mustard, and Sour Cream. Just like Mom used to make!$3.00
Street Corn- 6oz
6oz, Corn, Red and Green Peppers, Jalapeno, Red Onion, Mayo, Lime, Cilantro, Paprika and Cotija Cheese!$4.25
Desserts
Salted "Carmel" Brownie
Home baked dark chocolate brownie cut generously then coated in our house made salted caramel cream$4.99Smores Mousse
Scratch made chocolate mousse with a graham cracker crust and marshwellow center.$6.99
Oatmeal Moon Pie Cookie
2 homemade oatmeal cookies sandwiched around our own creamy whipped center$4.99
Chocolate Chip Chip Cookie
Two scratch-made chocolate chip cookies with ruffles potato chips to add a nice salty texture to the sweetness.$4.99
Fruit and Yogurt Parfait
Using our oatmeal cookies as a base for these delicious parfaits, made with vanilla yogurt with sliced strawberries and whole blueberries.$8.99
Drinks
Bottled Water
16.9oz, 500ml, bottled water$1.25
Coca-Cola
Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love 12oz can$1.69
Diet Coke
Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink 12oz can$1.69
Sprite
Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free 12oz can$1.69
Gatorade Red
20 oz$1.99
A' Siciliana Limonata - Lemon Italian Soda - 11.15oz
$2.49
A' Siciliana Aranciata - Italian Blood Orange Soda - 11.15oz
$2.49
Catering (24-48 Hour Advance Notice)
Gourmet Box Lunches (10 Box Min.)
Let us provide your lunch!
You get a gourmet sandwich with a side and dessert of your choice, all boxed up and ready to be picked up or dropped off. Add drinks for an additional charge.
Minimum of 10 boxes, any order under 10 boxes will be rejected.
French Orchard Box Lunch (vegetarian)
Tulip Tree Trillium Brie cheese, fig jam, sliced granny smith apples on a toasted French batard$18.99
BLT Box Lunch
House cured candied bacon, sweet butter lettuce, heirloom local tomatoes, sliced avocado, and our housemade garlic aioli. Served on toasted sourdough.$18.99
Italian Next Door Box Lunch
Spicy capicola, genoa, salami, prosciutto cotto, provolone, heirloom tomato, shredded romaine, and oregano vinaigrette. Served on a stirato roll.$18.99
Roast Beef & Cheddar Box Lunch
In house seasoned and cooked roast beef, horseradish cream sauce, aged white cheddar, and shredded romaine lettuce. Served on a stirato roll.$18.99
Chicken Salad Sandwich Box Lunch
Joe's famous chicken salad, sliced avocado, sliced cucumber, and butter lettuce. Served on a challah roll.$18.99
Turkey Pesto Box Lunch
Brine roasted turkey breast, roasted tomato conserva, scratch-made basil pesto, sliced fresh mozzarella, shredded romaine lettuce, and a parmesan crisp. Served on a stirato roll.$18.99
Turkey Tarantino Box Lunch
Brine roasted turkey breast, scratch-made sundried tomato pesto and lemon artichoke ricotta spread, bacon, and arugula. Served on a toasted stirato roll.$18.99
Debris Po' Boy Box Lunch
Blackened IPA braised beef, house made garlic aioli, scratch-made remoulade, shredded romaine lettuce, diced heirloom tomatoes. Served on a toasted French batard.$18.99
Mission Chicken Torta Box Lunch
House pulled chicken marinated in our house made tinga sauce, oven roasted salsa verde, aged cotija cheese, shredded romaine lettuce. Served on a toasted challah bun.$18.99
Aji Amarillo Flank Steak Box Lunch
Marinated flank steak, cilantro and herb aioli, pickled red onion, aged cotija cheese, and shredded romaine lettuce. Served on a toasted challah bun.$18.99
Evan's IPA Braised Beef Box Lunch
12 hour IPA braised beef, melty havarti cheese, caramelized onions, arugula, and our scratch-made red wine gastrique. Served on a toasted stirato roll.$18.99
El Cubanito Box Lunch
10 hour in-house braised mojo pork, prosciutto cotto, swiss cheese, house brined dill pickles, and our garlic mustard butter. Panini pressed on French batard.$18.99
Hot Capocollo Box Lunch
Sliced capocollo, havarti cheese, caramelized onions, and sliced jalapeño. Panini pressed on sourdough.$18.99
Grand Palace Salad Box Lunch
Mixed green lettuce, sautéed snow peas and grape tomatoes, shaved brussel sprouts, orange supremes, and topped with our house thai marinated chicken breast, served with a side of scratch-made orange sesame dressing.$18.99
Basque Steak Salad Box Lunch
Chopped romaine lettuce, sliced roasted red peppers, house made pickled red onions, marcona almonds, grated parmesan cheese, topped with sliced flank steak, and served with a side of our scratch-made creamy poblano dressing.$18.99
Veggie Trays
Broccoli Florets, Celery, Baby Carrots, Grape Tomatoes, and our famous Very Veggie Dip!
Shrimp Trays
Our U15 cooked California White Jumbo Shrimp on a bed of lettuce and served with Joe's Kickin’ Cocktail Sauce!
Lasagna Buffet (48 Hour Notice -- Priced Per Person)
Minimum 14 persons/ 48 hour notice. Order by the # of persons served. Orders not meeting this criteria will be rejected.
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 3:30 pm |
| Monday | 10:30 am - 4:15 pm |
| Tuesday | 10:30 am - 4:15 pm |
| Wednesday | 10:30 am - 4:15 pm |
| Thursday | 10:30 am - 4:15 pm |
| Friday | 10:30 am - 4:15 pm |
| Saturday | 10:30 am - 4:15 pm |
Restaurant info
Joe’s Butcher Shop and Fish Market was founded by my wife, Kathy, and I, in 2006. We proudly offer metro Indianapolis’ finest selection of farm-fresh beef, veal, lamb, pork, homemade sausages, and chicken, as well as the area’s freshest and highest quality seafood. Our scratch made sandwiches are amazing and available for dining in, takeout, and delivery via Toast Delivery Services / DoorDash. - Joe
Location