Skip to Main content
  • Magpies Softserve Highland Park

    • Home
    • /
    • Los Angeles
    • /
    • Magpies Softserve Highland Park
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image

    Magpies Softserve Highland Park

    Ice Cream Shop
    Closed12PM - 10:45PM
    CallDirectionsGift Cards
    ‌
    ‌
    Softserve
    Slices of Softserve Pie
    Whole Softserve Pies
    Softserve Pints (16 ounces)
    Extras
    To Go Tote
    To Go Toppings (8 ounces)
    Merchandise

    Softserve

    • Choose 2 Flavors (Regular 9 ounces)

      Chose any two flavors!
      $7.50
    • Corn Almond (Vegan)

      "Tastes like the remaining milk after eating Frosted Flakes" - Allergens: Nuts, Gluten - Almond Milk Base
      $6.50+
    • Sweet Cream

      "Tastes like real sweetened whipped cream" - Dairy Base
      $6.50+
    • Malted Milk Chocolate

      "Tastes like the best chocolate malt shake ever!" - Allergens: Gluten - Dairy Base
      $6.50+
    • Roasted Strawberry (Vegan)

      To deepen the flavor and enhance their natural sweetness, we slow roast strawberries down to a concentrated puree, then fold it into our Softserve base” - Oat Milk Base
      $6.50+
    • Midnight Chocolate (Vegan)

      “Deep, rich chocolate flavor without the bitterness associated with dark chocolate” - Oat Milk Base
      OUT OF STOCK
      $6.50+
    • Mint (Vegan)

      “Cool and refreshing.. Imagine the best mint chip ice cream you’ve tasted, minus the chocolate chips” - Oat Milk Base
      $6.50+
    • Candy Apple (Vegan)

      “Tart Granny Smith with caramelized sugar cooked hard and glassy red, like the ones sold on a stick at the fair” - Oat Milk Base
      $6.50+
    • Oatmeal Cookie (Vegan)

      “The rich nutty flavors of oats, paired with hints of molasses, cinnamon, and vanilla, create a timeless classic that even grandma will be eager to get the recipe for!” - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $6.50+
    • Banana Milkshake (Dairy)

      “Ripe banana, honeyed sweetness, light floral notes and vanilla” - Allergens: Dairy - Milk Base
      $6.50+
    • Butter Pecan (Dairy)

      “Brown butter blended with the caramel like flavor of the toasted pecans makes this a Magpies favorite!” - Allergens: Dairy, Nuts - Dairy Base
      $6.50+
    • Swirl of Corn Almond & Midnight Chocolate (Vegan)

      "Tastes like the remaining milk after eating Frosted Flakes" + “Deep, rich chocolate flavor without the bitterness associated with dark chocolate” - Allergens: Nuts, Gluten - Almond Milk Base + Oat Milk Base
      OUT OF STOCK
      $6.50+
    • Swirl of Sweet Cream & Malted Milk Chocolate

      "Tastes like real sweetened whipped cream" + "Tastes like the best chocolate malt shake ever!" - Allergens: Gluten - Dairy Base
      $6.50+
    • Swirl of Mint & Oatmeal Cookie (Vegan)

      “Cool and refreshing.. Imagine the best mint chip ice cream you’ve tasted, minus the chocolate chips”+ “The rich nutty flavors of oats, paired with hints of molasses, cinnamon, and vanilla, create a timeless classic that even grandma will be eager to get the recipe for!” - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $6.50+
    • Swirl of Butter Pecan & Banana Milkshake (Dairy)

      “Brown butter blended with the caramel like flavor of the toasted pecans makes this a Magpies favorite!” + “Ripe banana, honeyed sweetness, light floral notes and vanilla” - Allergens: Dairy, Nuts - Dairy Milk Base
      $6.50+
    • Swirl of Roasted Strawberry & Candy Apple (Vegan)

      “To deepen the flavor and enhance their natural sweetness, we slow roast strawberries down to a concentrated puree, then fold it into our Softserve base” + “Tart Granny Smith with caramelized sugar cooked hard and glassy red, like the ones sold on a stick at the fair” - Oat Milk Base
      $6.50+

    Slices of Softserve Pie

    • Slice of Original Fried Softserve Pie (Vegan, Nuts)

      Corn Almond Softserve layered with fudge, honeycomb, topped with whipped cream & fried candied corn flakes in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Gluten, Nuts - Almond Milk Base
      $10.95
    • Slice of Cookies & Cream Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Vanilla Bean Softserve layered with fudge & oreo cookies, topped with oreo whipped cream & chocolate crumble in a chocolate graham crust - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $10.95
    • Slice of Banana Foster Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Brown Sugar Banana Softserve layered with banana jam & candied pecans, topped with rum whipped cream & graham crumble in a graham cracker crust - Allergies : Nuts, Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $10.95
    • Slice of Ube Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Ube Softserve layered with maple coconut chips & ube cake, topped with ube caramel whipped cream & ube crumble in a chocolate graham crust - Allergens: Gluten - Coconut Milk Base
      $10.95
    • Slice of Coffee Toffee Softserve Pie (Dairy)

      Coffee Toffee Softserve layered with fudge & almond toffee, topped with coffee whipped cream, caramel, fudge drizzle & chocolate crumble in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Gluten, Dairy, Nuts - Milk Base
      $10.95
    • Slice of Gluten Free Chocolate Covered Strawberries Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Roasted Strawberry Chocolate Chip Softserve layered with fudge & Devil's food cake, topped with whipped cream & strawberry sauce in a chocolate graham crust - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Slice of Drumstick Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Brown Sugar Vanilla Softserve layered with caramel, fudge & waffle peanut bark, topped with whipped cream & toasted peanuts in a graham cracker crust - Allergies: Gluten, Nuts (Peanuts) - Oat Milk Base
      $10.95
    • Slice of Chocolate Halloween Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Dark Chocolate Truffle Softserve layered with fudge & Devil's food cake, topped with whipped cream, fudge & cookie crumble in a chocolate graham crust - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $10.95
    • Slice of Chili Mango Lime Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Chili Mango & Lime Softserve layered with mango lime sauce & sugar cookies, topped with whipped cream, mango sauce, tajin & cookie crumble in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $9.95
    • Slice of Nutter Butter Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Peanut Butter Softserve layered with graham crumble, topped with whipped cream, peanuts & Nutter Butter cookies in a graham cracker crust - Allergies: Nuts, Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $10.95
    • Slice of Chocolate Chip Cookie Softserve Pie (Dairy)

      Chocolate Chip Softserve layered with fudge, chocolate chip cookies, topped with whipped cream, chocolate shavings & graham crumble in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Dairy, Gluten,Eggs, Soy - Milk Base
      $10.95

    Whole Softserve Pies

    Serves 8-10 guests
    • Whole Original Fried Softserve Pie (Vegan, Nuts)

      Corn Almond Softserve layered with fudge, honeycomb, topped with whipped cream and fried candied corn flakes in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Gluten, Nuts - Almond Milk Base
      $49.95
    • Whole Cookies & Cream Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Vanilla Bean Softserve layered with fudge & oreo cookies, topped with oreo whipped cream & chocolate crumble in a chocolate graham crust - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $49.95
    • Whole Banana Foster Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Brown Sugar Banana Softserve layered with banana jam & candied pecans, topped with rum whipped cream & graham crumble in a graham cracker crust - Allergies : Nuts, Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $49.95
    • Whole Ube Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Ube Softserve layered with maple coconut chips & ube cake, topped with caramel ube whipped cream, & ube crumble in a chocolate graham crust - Allergens: Gluten - Coconut Milk Base
      $49.95
    • Whole Coffee Toffee Softserve Pie (Dairy)

      Coffee Toffee Softserve layered with fudge & almond toffee, topped with coffee whipped cream, caramel, fudge drizzle & chocolate crumble in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Gluten, Dairy, Nuts - Milk Base
      $49.95
    • Whole Gluten Free Chocolate Covered Strawberries Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Roasted Strawberry Chocolate Chip Softserve layered with fudge & Devil's food cake, topped with whipped cream & strawberry sauce in a chocolate graham crust - Oat Milk Base
      $54.95
    • Whole Drumstick Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Brown Sugar Vanilla Softserve layered with caramel, fudge & waffle peanut bark, topped with whipped cream & toasted peanuts in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Gluten, Nuts (Peanuts) - Oat Milk Base
      $49.95
    • Whole Chocolate Halloween Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Dark Chocolate Truffle Softserve layered with fudge & Devil's food cake, topped with whipped cream, fudge & cookie crumble in a chocolate graham crust - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $49.95
    • Whole Nutter Butter Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Peanut Butter Softserve layered with graham crumble, topped with whipped cream, peanuts & Nutter Butter cookies in a graham cracker crust - Allergies: Nuts, Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $49.95
    • Whole Chili Mango Lime Softserve Pie (Vegan)

      Chili Mango & Lime Softserve layered with mango lime sauce & sugar cookies, topped with whipped cream, mango sauce, tajin & cookie crumble in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $49.95
    • Whole Chocolate Chip Cookie Softserve Pie (Dairy)

      Chocolate Chip Softserve layered with fudge, chocolate chip cookies, topped with whipped cream, chocolate shavings & graham crumble in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Dairy, Gluten,Eggs, Soy - Milk Base
      $49.95

    Softserve Pints (16 ounces)

    • Banana Bread Pint (Vegan)

      - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Banana Milkshake Pint

      “Ripe banana, honeyed sweetness, light floral notes and vanilla” - Allergens: Dairy
      $11.95
    • Black Sesame Pint (Vegan)

      “Has a bold and nutty flavor, similar to a light peanut butter taste” -Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Brownie Batter Pint (Vegan)

      “Remember that moment when Mom set down the mixing bowl after pouring the brownie batter into the pan? Now, you can indulge in all that rich, chocolatey goodness without battling your siblings for the coveted spoon-licking privilege!” - Allergens: Gluten, Soy - Oat Milk Base
      OUT OF STOCK
      $11.95
    • Butter Pecan Pint

      “Brown butter blended with the caramel-like flavor of the toasted pecans makes this a Magpies favorite!” - Allergens: Dairy, Nuts - Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Candy Apple Pint (Vegan)

      “Tart Granny Smith with caramelized sugar cooked hard and glassy red, like the ones sold on a stick at the fair” - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Cappuccino Pint (Vegan)

      “Espresso, milk and Softserve, three great things that belong together” - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Chocolate Milkshake Pint (Vegan)

      “The malt provides a hint of nostalgia, reminiscent of a classic malted milkshake, while the chocolate adds a satisfying depth of cocoa flavor” - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      OUT OF STOCK
      $11.95
    • Cinnamon Latte Pint (Vegan)

      “Cinnamon, the highlight of this flavor, offers a warm and spiced sweetness perfect for this season” - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Corn Almond Pint (Vegan)

      "Tastes like the remaining milk after eating Frosted Flakes" - Allergens: Nuts (Almonds), Gluten - Almond Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Fudgesicle Pint (Vegan)

      “Remember asking your parents for money and then running after the ice cream truck, hoping you’re not too late to get your hands on a chocolate fudgesicle? Well, no need to worry, Magpies has you covered!” - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Goat Cheese & Fig Pint

      “Tangy goat cheese balanced by the deep sweetness of ripe figs” - Allergens: Dairy - Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Lady Grey Pint (Vegan)

      "Floral black tea, similar to Earl Grey with citrus/orange notes" - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Lemon Bar Pint (Vegan)

      “Bright and tangy with a buttery shortbread base” - Allergens: Gluten -Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Malted Milk Chocolate Pint

      “Our ‘House’ Chocolate, tastes like a malted milkshake” - Allergens: Gluten - Dairy Base
      $11.95
    • Maple Bourbon Pint (Vegan)

      “Delicious blend of maple syrup and Kentucky bourbon, which adds notes of oak, brown sugar and caramel” - Allergies : Alcohol - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Midnight Chocolate Pint (Vegan)

      “Deep, rich chocolate flavor without the bitterness associated with dark chocolate” - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Milk & Honey Pint

      "Tastes like milk sweetened with honey, similar to a boba shop, but better!" - Allergens: Dairy - Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Mint Pint (Vegan)

      “Cool and refreshing.. Imagine the best mint chip ice cream you’ve tasted, minus the chocolate chips” - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Oatmeal Cookie Pint (Vegan)

      “The rich nutty flavors of oats, paired with hints of molasses, cinnamon, and vanilla, create a timeless classic that even grandma will be eager to get the recipe for!” - Allergens: Gluten -Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Peanut Butter Pint (Vegan)

      “Peanut Butter lovers unite! We fold creamy peanut butter into our Softserve mix, creating a deep, roasted nutty flavor” - Allergens: Nuts, Soy - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Roasted Strawberry Pint (Vegan)

      “To intensify the flavor and bring out the natural sweetness, we slow roast strawberries down to a puree and then fold it into our Softserve base” - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Sweet Basil Pint (Vegan)

      “We mix our Softserve base with fresh basil, resulting in a bright summer flavor of sweet anise and licorice, chased by a clean peppery finish” - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Sweet Cornbread Pint (Vegan)

      “Nostalgic with just the right amount of savory, like warm cornbread pulled from the oven, only colder” - Allergies: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
      $11.95
    • Sweet Cream Pint

      “Tastes like real whipped cream sweetened with sugar” - Dairy Base
      $11.95
    • Vanilla Pint

      “Not all vanilla softserve is created equal. We use the best vanilla extract and paste, which produces a Softserve that stands unrivaled in flavor” - Allergens: Dairy - Milk Base
      $11.95
    • White Chocolate Mocha Pint

      - Allergens: Dairy - Dairy Milk Base
      $11.95

    Extras

    • Ice Block

      $1.00

    To Go Tote

    • Magpies Insulated Tote with Ice Pack (Fits a maximum of 2 whole pies)

      $7.00

    To Go Toppings (8 ounces)

    • To Go Toppings (8 ounces)

    Merchandise

    • Magpies T-Shirt

      Be one of the first to rock our new Magpies T-Shirts! But wait, there's more! Not only have we kept it local by using Los Angeles Apparel shirts, but until December 31, 2024, visit any of our shops wearing Magpies gear and receive 20% off your Softserve Cup or Cone with Toppings!
      $34.95
    • Magpies Mug

      $19.95

    All hours
    Sunday12:00 pm - 9:45 pm
    Monday12:00 pm - 9:45 pm
    Tuesday12:00 pm - 9:45 pm
    Wednesday12:00 pm - 9:45 pm
    Thursday12:00 pm - 9:45 pm
    Friday12:00 pm - 10:45 pm
    Saturday12:00 pm - 10:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    Magpies Softserve in Highland Park is a chef crafted shop serving signature Softserve and Softserve Pies made in-house with real ingredients. A Los Angeles favorite known for inventive flavors and fresh takes on nostalgic classics, Magpies is where the community gathers to share something sweet.

    Location

    5049 York Blvd., Los Angeles, CA 90042

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play