American
Mayer’s Tavern
894 3rd Ave
Cape May, NJ 08204
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
Cheeseburger
Mayer's famous burger with white cheddar cheese. A half pound of local and humanely raised ground beef on a brioche bun with lettuce, dijon mayo, and house pickled onions. Comes with housemade french fries.$20.00Fried Scallops
A half pound of lightly fried local sea scallops. Served with citrus slaw and housemade french fries. Includes choice of one sauce. Comes with housemade french fries. Please note this item CANNOT be made gluten-free.$30.00Chicken
Yogurt-marinated humanely raised chicken breast roasted and served with polenta and braised collard greens.$28.00
Appetizers
Crab fritter
Maryland lump crab and scallion fritters served with homemade jalapeno-cilantro sauce. 5 per order.$22.00Fried Calamari
Local calamari fried salt & pepper style w/ jalapenos and scallion.$16.00Baked oysters
Local oysters, freshly shucked and broiled with pimento cheese. 6 per order.$21.00Green salad
Simple green salad w/ shallot-mustard vin, radish, garden herbs.$13.00Kale Salad
Tuscan kale caesar salad w/ savory granola and garlic breadcrumbs. Contains nuts.$15.00Bluefish Spread
Smoked bluefish whipped into a creamy spread. Served w/ onion jam and grilled bread.$12.00Papas bravas
Crispy smashed potatoes w/ pepper jelly and chili mayo.$11.00Crispy chicken
Crispy chicken thighs with seasonal garnish.$16.00
Mains
Fried Scallops
A half pound of lightly fried local sea scallops. Served with citrus slaw and housemade french fries. Includes choice of one sauce. Comes with housemade french fries. Please note this item CANNOT be made gluten-free.$30.00Cheeseburger
Mayer's famous burger with white cheddar cheese. A half pound of local and humanely raised ground beef on a brioche bun with lettuce, dijon mayo, and house pickled onions. Comes with housemade french fries.$20.00Burger
Mayer's famous burger. NO CHEESE. A half pound of humanely raised ground beef on a brioche bun with lettuce, dijon mayo, and house pickled onions. Comes with housemade french fries.$20.00Chicken
Yogurt-marinated humanely raised chicken breast roasted and served with polenta and braised collard greens.$28.00Mussels white large
PEI mussels in a rotating seasonal broth. Large order, approximately 24 mussels, varies depending on size. Served with wedge of toasted baguette.$21.00Mussels white small
PEI mussels in a rotating seasonal broth. Small order, approximately 12 mussels, varies depending on size. Served with wedge of toasted baguette.$15.00Mussels red large
PEI mussels in a rotating seasonal broth. Large order, approximately 24 mussels, varies depending on size. Served with wedge of toasted baguette.$21.00Mussels red small
PEI mussels in a rotating seasonal broth. Small order, approximately 12 mussels, varies depending on size. Served with wedge of toasted baguette.$15.00Steak frites
Sickler Circle View steak frites, onions, steak sauce, rotating cut. Market price.$45.00OUT OF STOCK
Sauces
Remoulade
Classic seafood accompaniment. Made in house with homemade mayo, ketchup, whole grain mustard, celery, scallion. 2oz$0.75Cocktail
Homemade with ketchup, horseradish, worcestershire, lemon. 2oz$0.75Aji verde
Made in house with jalapenos, cilantro, aji verde chiles, cotija cheese, lime juice, and more. Contains dairy & egg. 2oz$0.75Dijon mayo
Housemade dijon mayo. 2oz$0.75Regular mayo
Housemade plain mayo. 2oz$0.75Melted butter
2oz$0.75Horseradish
Classic spicy condiment. 2oz
Sides
Citrus Slaw
Side serving of our cabbage & citrus slaw.$8.00Fries
Side serving of our housemade fries.$8.00Mac & Cheese
Housemade baked mac and cheese with corkscrew pasta, bechamel sauce, cheddar and gruyere.$12.00Spinach
Side serving of fresh spinach lightly sauteed with garlic, olive oil, lemon.$8.00Side Bread
Side of grilled house bread.$5.00
Kids
All hours
| Sunday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Cape May's best spot for local seafood, burgers, cocktails, and more!
Location