Skip to Main content
  • My Sister's Fault

    • Home
    • /
    • Milford
    • /
    • My Sister's Fault
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image

    My Sister's Fault

    Desserts Shop
    Closed
    CallDirectionsGift Cards
    ‌
    ‌
    Platters - Sides ~ Kids Meals
    Empanadas/Turnovers
    Breakfast until 1pm
    SAVORY SANDWICHES 4PM
    Sweets ~ Desserts
    Drinks ~ Beverages
    Sauces ~ Dipping’s
    Desserts Special Orders (4 days required)
    FAMILY DINNERS (3 DAYS REQUIRED)

    Featured Items

    • Three Empanadas & Rice Platter

      Rice served with your favorite pick of three empanadas!!! Rice In the picture may not represent todays rice (it changes daily) please read before ordering!
      $14.75
    • Half & Half Platter Fried Wingettes (4) & 4oz Pork Shoulder Served with Rice Platter

      4 wingettes and 4oz of slowly cooked pork shoulder, served with your choice of rice. You can add up to 3 sides at an additional charge!
      $18.00
    • NEW! Garlic & Cheese Bread Toast (3)

      Amazing. House-made Pan Sobao ✔️House-made Garlic Mojo ✔️Garlic & Cheese Toasts — 🧄🤤Side of marinara
      $6.00

    Platters - Sides ~ Kids Meals

    POPULAR PLATTERS

    Our rice and menu changes daily. Online Pictures may not represent the actual platter. Please read todays Rice description before ordering. If ordering for a different day. Please keep in mind the rice of the day may be different.
    • SIDE OF RICE

      Pick from today's rice options. Beans are sold separately
      $3.50+
    • Three Empanadas & Rice Platter

      Rice served with your favorite pick of three empanadas!!! Rice In the picture may not represent todays rice (it changes daily) please read before ordering!
      $14.75
    • Rice Platter & Pernil (Shredded Pork Shoulder)

      Slowly cooked shredded pork, served with your choice of rice. You can add up to 3 sides at an additional charge!
      $16.00
    • Eggs, Plantains & Avocado Served with Rice of the Day Platter

      2 FRIED EGGS (please leave in the comments how will you like your eggs cooked) served with your choice of rice, 3 sweet plantains and avocado.
      $13.25+
    • Fried Wingettes (6) served with Rice Platter

      6 wingettes seasoned the Caribbean way, (not breaded) juicy and delicious,served with your choice of rice. You can add up to 3 sides at an additional charge!
      $18.00
    • Half & Half Platter Fried Wingettes (4) & 4oz Pork Shoulder Served with Rice Platter

      4 wingettes and 4oz of slowly cooked pork shoulder, served with your choice of rice. You can add up to 3 sides at an additional charge!
      $18.00
    • Japanese BBQ Chicken served with RICE

      Our amazing Japanese BBQ Chicken served with Rice and your choice of 2 SIDES!
      OUT OF STOCK
      $17.50
    • Chicken Lasagna Platter (Angies Style)

      Angies style consist of, lasagna pasta, Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella and Cream Cheese. Served Bread Lettuce & Tomato
      OUT OF STOCK
      $16.00
    • Goulash Platter with Rice & Side

      Angies style goulash made with 100% ground beef, elbow pasta, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, parmesan and cream cheese! Freaking amazing! Platter is served with your choice of Tostones, Sweet Plantain, Bread and your choice of rice!!!!
      OUT OF STOCK
      $17.00
    • Boneless Ribs served with RICE (Char Siu)

      Platter includes your choice of rice served with BBQ Boneless Ribs Chino Latino Style, Available today Friday only while supply lasts.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $17.50
    • Grilled Chicken Breast served with RICE Platter

      Thinly sliced chicken breast served with grilled onions and white garlic sauce!
      OUT OF STOCK
      $17.00

    Sides & Apps

    • SIDE OF RICE

      Pick from today's rice options. Beans are sold separately
      $3.50+
    • Pink Stewed Beans (NO RICE)

      Angies style pink stewed beans contain ham. DOES NOT INCLUDE RICE
      $4.00+
    • CHICKEN WINGS (Side)

      Our wings are prepared in the traditional Puerto Rican pollo frito style. They are marinated and non-breaded, so they’re meant to be juicy and flavorful not heavily crispy. Because the chicken is marinated, it goes into the fryer with moisture. The crispier we fry it, the more moisture is lost, which means the chicken becomes drier inside. If you’re looking for a breaded, extra-crispy wing, our wings may not be what you’re expecting. Mix of flat & drums.
      $6.00+
    • Pork/ Pernil (SIDE)

      Our Caribbean flavored slowly cooked Pork shoulder served the size of your choice.
      $5.00+
    • New! Mini Chicken Cordon Blues

      Deep Fried Mini Chicken Cordon Blue filled with Ham & Cheese and your choice of side sauce. (BBQ recommended)
      $5.00+
    • NEW! Garlic & Cheese Bread Toast (3)

      Amazing. House-made Pan Sobao ✔️House-made Garlic Mojo ✔️Garlic & Cheese Toasts — 🧄🤤Side of marinara
      $6.00
    • Tostones (Green Plantains)

      Double fried and smashed green plantains served with one side of mayo ketchup and a side of garlic.
      $4.00+
    • Sweet Plantains (maduros)

      Ripe sweet plantains
      $3.25+
    • Dominican Fried Cheese

      Dominican Fried Cheese served with a side of Guava Jelly
      $7.00
    • Yuca Balls filled with Cheese

      Yuca Balls (cassava balls) filled with cheese served with a side of guava jelly
      $5.00+
    • AVOCADO (SIDE)

      Fresh Avocado
      OUT OF STOCK
      $2.00+
    • Pan Sobao (2 Loafs of Bread)

      Our made in house Puerto Rican soft & sweet bread.
      $4.50
    • Plantain Chips Bag (Goya) (G/F)

      Large Bag of Goya Plantain Chips
      $3.99
    • Chicharrones/ Pork Rings Bag (Goya)

      Large Bag of Goya Pork Rings
      $3.99
    • Goulash 'Angie's Style'

      THIS IS THE SIDE ORDER ONLY. Enjoy $2 off when order it Cold. It was freshly prepared and packed this morning, so all you have to do is heat it up whenever you’re ready to enjoy it! Made with 100% ground beef, tomato sauce, mozzarella, Parmesan, and our secret ingredient… cream cheese! 💛 Pro tip: Add a side of our Garlic Cheese Bread for the perfect meal!
      OUT OF STOCK
    • Side of Boneless Ribs (Char Siu)

      8oz of boneless ribs does not include rice. Please Order rice separately!
      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.00
    • Side of Pork Chunks (Carne Frita)

      10oz side of Pork Chunks includes onion and a side sauce
      OUT OF STOCK
      $9.00
    • Side of Japanese BBQ Chicken

      8oz of Angies Style Japanese BBQ Chicken Thighs - AMAZING
      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.00+
    • Deep Fried Cheesecake (Nutella & Biscoff)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.00

    Kids Meal

    • (Kids) 5 Mini Cordon Blue, 6oz Rice, 1 Empanada

      5 Mini Cordon Blue Choice of rice Choice of Empanada Choice of Sauce
      $10.00
    • (kids) 6oz Shredded Pork - 6 oz Rice - 1 Empanada

      Side of rice, 1 side of pork, 1 empanada of your choice
      $10.00
    • (Kids) 3 Wingettes - 6oz Rice - 1 Empanada

      Side of rice, 3 wingettes, 1 empanada of your choice
      $10.00
    • (kids) Mini Melt HAM & AMERICAN , 6oz RICE - 1 Empanada

      Side of rice, one empanada & one mini ham & cheese melt.
      $8.00
    • (kids) Mini NUTELLA Sandwich, 6oz RICE - 1 Empanada

      Side of rice, one empanada and a mini nutella sandwich.
      $8.00
    • (kids) Mini Melt TURKEY & SWISS, 6oz RICE - 1 Empanada

      Side of rice, served with empanada of your choice and a mini turkey & swiss melt P
      $8.00
    • (kids) Mini Melt ONLY AMERICAN Cheese, 6oz RICE - 1 Empanada

      Side of rice, served with empanada of your choice and a mini grilled cheese!PLEASE KEEP IN MIND THAT our rice changes daily picture may not represent todays rice!
      $8.00

    Empanadas/Turnovers

    Empanadas

    Angie's Style Empanadas (turnover) is our top seller!
    • New! Pumpkin Cheesecake Empanada

      Pumpkin Cheesecake Empanada is back for the season!!!
      $3.00
    • 6 PACK - EMPANADA DEAL (Six)

      PICK YOUR COMBINATION OF CHOICE!
      $16.00+
    • 12 PACK - EMPANADA DEAL (Dozen)

      PICK YOUR COMBINATION OF CHOICE!
      $34.00+
    • Three Empanadas & Rice Platter

      Rice served with your favorite pick of three empanadas!!! Rice In the picture may not represent todays rice (it changes daily) please read before ordering!
      $14.75
    • Mixed Box of Empanadas

      Includes 1 beef, 1 beef chalupa, 1 chicken chalupa, 1 chicken, 1 cheesedog. NOT EXCHANGABLE
      $16.00
    • BEEF EMPANADA

      Savory Ground Beef (91/8) with a hint of potato. Please order hot sauces if needed under the "sauces" section. We recommend Mami's Sauce with it!
      $3.50
    • BEEF CHALUPA EMPANADA

      Our version of a chalupa is on a empanada filled with beef, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and cheddar cheese...
      $4.00
    • Beef W/ Slice of American

      The empanada is fried first and does not contain cheese inside. After frying, it is split open and a slice of American cheese is added
      $3.75
    • Chicken & Cheese Empanada

      Shredded Chicken Breast with mozzarella & cream cheese and a hint of potato. Please order side of hot sauce under hot sauce section. We recommend chicken empanadas with BBQ Sauce or the sweet chilli.
      $3.50
    • CHICKEN CHALUPA EMPANADA

      Chicken and cheese empanada filled with lettuce, tomato, sour cream and cheddar cheese.
      $4.00
    • Nutella Empanada

      Nutella empanada dusted with powder sugar. Perfect to share or to satisfy that sweet tooth at the end of your meal.
      $3.00
    • Guava & Cream Cheese Empanada

      Made with a flaky buttery dough filled with Philadelphia Cream Cheese and Guava paste
      $3.50
    • Cheesedog Empanada

      Made with 100% BEEF HOT DOG and American cheese deep fried to perfection is our version if pig in a blanket!
      $3.50
    • Pionono Empanada

      Ground Beef, Sweet Plantain & Cream Cheese. The empanada that best describe the sisters with the sweet & savory flavor!
      $4.95
    • Veggie & Cheese Empanada

      Caramelized Onions, Mushrooms & Spinach with a homemade Parmesan and Mozarella cheese Sauce
      $4.95
    • $2 SALE! Pork & Cheese Empanada

      Shredded Baked Pork, Mozarella & Parmesan Cheese
      OUT OF STOCK
      $2.00

    Sauces & Dipping's (o)

    • NEW! Pure Garlic Mojo (2oz)

      $0.50
    • MAMIS VINEGAR

      Our made in house vinegar based hot juice! Perfect for your empanadas or even marinades.
      $0.30+
    • SWEET CHILLI

      $0.50+
    • RED & GREEN HOT SAUCE

      $0.50+
    • MAYO KETCHUP

      $0.50
    • SOUR CREAM

      $0.50+
    • RANCH SAUCE

      $0.50
    • CHEDDAR CHEESE SAUCE

      $0.50+
    • GUAVA JELLY

      $0.50
    • BBQ SAUCE

      $0.50+
    • JAPANESE BBQ

      $0.50
    • MUSTARD

    • Mamis Vinegar (32 oz) Made in House

      Our mom's recipe of spicy yet gentle vinegar base hot liquid goodness now available by the bottle, perfect to marinate or simple put on your empanadas.
      $10.00

    Breakfast until 1pm

    • Mallorca BREAKFAST Sandwich

      Mallorca is a made in house sweet bun classic Puerto Rican recipe! Available for limited time, get it while supply lasts!
      $6.99+
    • Only Egg & Cheese Sandwich #1

      2 fried eggs and your choice of cheese
      $4.99+
    • BACON, EGG & CHEESE #2

      2 Fried Eggs, bacon, your choice of cheese served in bread, wrap or platter
      $6.99+
    • HAM, EGG & CHEESE #3

      2 Fried Eggs, Ham, your choice of cheese served in bread, wrap or platter
      $6.99+
    • Kielbasa, Egg & Cheese #6

      2 eggs, beef kielbasa and your choice of cheese.
      $6.99+
    • Turkey, Egg & Cheese #12

      Sliced Turkey Breast, eggs and cheese served with your choice of bread or low carb
      $6.99+
    • Ham & Cheese Melt #15

      Simple! American Cheese and Ham grilled in a sobao bread sandwich. Please leave a comment if prefer low carb.
      $5.95
    • Ava's Grilled Cheese #16

      4 slices of American served in Pan Sobao, melted (please leave a comment if prefer low carb bread)
      $4.99
    • Nutella SANDWICH

      Nutella Grilled in Pan Sobao (Bread) dusted with Powder Sugar
      $6.95
    • Salami, Egg & Dominican Cheese Sandwich #9

      2 eggs, dominican cheese, domincan salami and mayo ketchup sauce
      $11.25+
    • Dominican Mamma Platter #8

      Pork, Salami, Dominican Cheese, eggs, sweet plantain and avocado.
      $10.00+
    • Mini Bacon, Egg & American Sandwich

      Made with pan sobao, includes 1 egg & American cheese. Leave a comment if preferred no cheese. No extra modifications permitted under this menu. Menu is as is!
      $3.50
    • Mini Ham, Egg & American Sandwich

      Made with pan sobao, includes 1 egg & American cheese. Leave a comment if preferred no cheese. No extra modifications permitted under this menu. Menu is as is!
      $3.50
    • Mini Turkey , Egg & Swiss Sandwich

      Made with pan sobao, includes 1 egg & American cheese. Leave a comment if preferred no cheese. No extra modifications permitted under this menu item, comes as is!
      $4.00
    • Eggs, Plantains & Avocado Served with Rice of the Day Platter

      2 FRIED EGGS (please leave in the comments how will you like your eggs cooked) served with your choice of rice, 3 sweet plantains and avocado.
      $13.25+
    • Criollo Sandwich #5

      2 fried eggs, Ham, American, Mayo, Lettuce, Tomato and Ketchup served in your choice of
      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.99+

    SAVORY SANDWICHES 4PM

    Savory Sandwiches until 4pm

    • NEW! Garlic & Cheese Bread Toast (3)

      Amazing. House-made Pan Sobao ✔️House-made Garlic Mojo ✔️Garlic & Cheese Toasts — 🧄🤤Side of marinara
      $6.00
    • Sandwich de Pernil (Pork Shoulder) #24

      Our Slowly Cooked Pork served with Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Ketchup and Swiss.
      $8.00+
    • Cubano Controversial #18

      Our version of a Cubano sandwich and why is controversial? Because we served it in our sweet & soft made in house sobao bread, slowly cooked pork, Ham, Swiss, Sweet Pickles and Mustard.
      $8.00+
    • Sister's Cubano #19

      Slowly Cooked Pork, Ham, Swiss, Lettuce, Tomato, Sweet Pickles, Mustard, Mayo, Ketchup and potato sticks served in a sandwich.
      $8.00+
    • Tripleta Classica #20

      Chopped Pastrami, Ham & Pork, lettuce, American cheese, cheddar sauce, mayonnaise , ketchup and potato sticks in a 6 inch Sandwich made with our sweet & soft bread.
      $8.00+
    • Pastrami Lover's #21

      Chopped Pastrami served with Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo and Swiss.
      $8.00+
    • Turkey & Bacon #22

      Turkey, Bacon, Swiss, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo.
      $8.00+
    • Phillip Pastrami #23

      Chopped Pastrami, Green Peppers, Onions, Muensters Cheese, Mayo and Jalapenos
      $8.00+
    • Ham & Cheese Melt #15

      Simple! American Cheese and Ham grilled in a sobao bread sandwich. Please leave a comment if prefer low carb.
      $5.95
    • Dominican Mamma Platter #8

      Pork, Salami, Dominican Cheese, eggs, sweet plantain and avocado.
      $10.00+
    • Mozzarella Crusted Quesadilla Low Carb (Amazing)

      Made with Low Carb Tortilla (4g net), Mozzarella Cheese & Shredded Pork with a side of lettuce, tomato, jalapenos and sour cream. You can customize it your way !!!
      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.00
    • BBQ Pulled Pork #25

      Our Sweet and Tangy BBQ Pulled Pork is served with Sweet Pickles in our soft & sweet pan sobao.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $9.00+
    • New! Skirt Steak Sandwich

      Thinly sliced skirt steak … includes Swiss & American cheese , Lettuce, Tomato, Grilled Onions, Mayo, Ketchup & Potato Sticks. Served in our made in house Pan sobao or your choice of low carbs. If planning on eating later please leave a comment to put potatoes stick on the side that way they don’t get soggy!
      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.00+

    Sweets ~ Desserts

    Sweets & Dessert

    • 10 Slices BYO Cake (build your own cake)

      10 randomly choose slices of cake for you! PERFECT FOR CELEBRATIONS AND SHARING. You may list flavors of your preference if available we will added for you, if not available we will replace it. Eat at room temp! (Image is just an example, colors and flavors varies every week)
      $60.00
    • Macarons for $3.75!

      Macaron By Brookes Macarons Gluten Friendly if includes the initials (gf) Otherwise it contains Gluten!!!!
      $3.75+
    • Cheesecake Plain- GF

      Puerto Rican Style - Crustless Cheesecake. Gluten Free Contains Sugar.
      $4.00
    • Guava Puff Pastry/ Pastelillo de Guayaba

      Puffpastry filled with guava sauce
      $2.50
    • Quesito - Puff Pastry & Cream Cheese

      Puff Pastry filled with Cream Cheese a classic Puerto Rican delicatesse perfect to pair with a MSF Iced Coffee
      $4.00
    • Dubai Brownie Chocolate Bar

      Brownie topped with Pistachio Kadigyf (thinly chopped phyllo dough) dipped in chocolate. Eat at room temp!
      $6.75
    • Tres Leches Original (5oz)

      5oz cup of our vanilla cake soaked in 3 milk cakes with a homemade whipped cream and a hint of cinnamon. Sold individually
      $3.50
    • Creme Brulèe D' Amaretto

      Our creme brulee flavors changes every week, we torch the brulee to order!
      $5.00
    • Limoncello Raspberry Cake

      $6.00

    Sugar Free & Gluten Friendly Desserts

    All of our sugar free & gluten friendly products are made with almond flour, coconut flour, dairy & some form of nuts.
    • GF SF Churro Cheesecake Donut

      Please eat at room temperature (may contain coconut or almond flour) made with Swerve instead of sugar. Contains dairy and eggs.
      $4.50
    • GF/ SF Peanut Butter & Chocolate Donut

      $3.50
    • GF SF Tiramisu Cake

      Please eat at room temperature (may contain coconut or almond flour) made with Swerve instead of sugar. Contains dairy and eggs.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.00
    • GF SF Tres Leches topped with Berries

      Please eat at room temperature (may contain coconut or almond flour) made with Swerve instead of sugar. Contains dairy and eggs.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.00
    • GF SF Pretzelless Salad

      DOES NOT HAVE PRETZELS!!! Made with Crushed Pecans instead of pretzels is our #1 most popular GF & SF dessert! made with swerved sugar replacement and contains cream cheese.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $4.00
    • GF SF Pumpkin & Cream Cheese Muffin

      OUT OF STOCK
      $4.50

    Whole Cakes Available for Pick Up Today or Tomorrow

    • 9" Vanilla Flan (Large round pan)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $20.00

    Drinks ~ Beverages

    DRINKS

    • ICED- MY SISTERS FAULT COFFEE

      Made with Whole Milk We ADD Condensed Milk and a hint of cinnamon.
      $4.50
    • GUAVA LEMONADE NATALIES ORGANIC

      $4.00
    • ORANGE JUICE NATALIES ORGANIC

      $4.00
    • JUICE-PASSION FRUIT GOYA

      $5.50
    • MALTA GOYA

      $3.50
    • COCA COLA (COKE)

      Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
      $2.00
    • ZERO COKE (CAN)

      $2.00
    • DIET COKE (CAN)

      Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink
      OUT OF STOCK
      $2.00
    • PEPSI (CAN)

      $2.00
    • TROPICOLA (CAN)

      $2.00
    • SPRITE (CAN)

      Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free
      $2.00
    • MOUNTAINS DEW (can)

      $2.00
    • BRISK TEA (CAN)

      $2.00
    • BOTTLE WATER (Agua)

      $2.00
    • PERRIER SPARK WATER

      OUT OF STOCK
      $3.00
    • GINGER ALE (CAN)

      $2.00
    • TROPI COCO (Coconut)

      $2.00
    • PINEAPPLE JUICE (GOYA)

      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.50
    • *MINI* VIRGIN COQUITO

      Classic Puerto Rican drink made with coconut cream, coconut milk, cinnamon and cloves. This is the mini size
      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.00
    • *LARGE* VIRGIN COQUITO 36oz

      Classic Puerto Rican drink made with coconut cream, coconut milk, cinnamon and cloves.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $20.00

    Sauces ~ Dipping’s

    Sauces & Dipping's

    • NEW! Pure Garlic Mojo (2oz)

      $0.50
    • MAMIS VINEGAR

      Our made in house vinegar based hot juice! Perfect for your empanadas or even marinades.
      $0.30+
    • SWEET CHILLI

      $0.50+
    • RED & GREEN HOT SAUCE

      $0.50+
    • MAYO KETCHUP

      $0.50
    • SOUR CREAM

      $0.50+
    • CHEDDAR CHEESE SAUCE

      $0.50+
    • GUAVA JELLY

      $0.50
    • BBQ SAUCE

      $0.50+
    • RANCH SAUCE

      $0.50
    • JAPANESE BBQ

      $0.50
    • MUSTARD

    • Mamis Vinegar (32 oz) Made in House

      Our mom's recipe of spicy yet gentle vinegar base hot liquid goodness now available by the bottle, perfect to marinate or simple put on your empanadas.
      $10.00

    Desserts Special Orders (4 days required)

    4 Days (Notice) Whole Cakes & Desserts

    THIS MENU REQUIRES A MINIMUN OF 4 DAYS NOTICED
    • 10 Slices BYO Cake (build your own cake)

      10 randomly choose slices of cake for you! PERFECT FOR CELEBRATIONS AND SHARING. You may list flavors of your preference if available we will added for you, if not available we will replace it. Eat at room temp! (Image is just an example, colors and flavors varies every week)
      $60.00
    • Whole Cake 9'' Top Sellers

      Cakes are non-customizable. We do not write on cakes. We do offer a free Happy Birthday Sign if requested.
      $60.00
    • 24 count Mini Quesitos & Mini Pastelillos (12 of each)

      Quesitos - Cream Cheese Puff Pastry. Pastelillos - Guava Puff Pastry. Both in bite sizes. *1 week notice required to order this item*
      $35.00
    • 7'' Rum Cake (Large)

      Simple, Yet Delicious! Bundt Cake Style with Walnuts and lots of RUM!!!!
      $17.00
    • 9” Passion Fruit Cheesecake Topped with Berries Gluten Friendly & Sugar Friendly

      Made with a GF crust and tangy passion fruit filling topped with berries.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $30.00
    • 9” PRETZELESS SALAD Gluten Friendly & Sugar Free

      Made with Crushed pecans instead of pretzels this Gluten friendly and sugar free dessert is our most popular dessert!
      $30.00
    • 9” Tembleque / Coconut Custard (Vegan)

      Our only Vegan, Dairy Free & Gluten Free dessert. Puerto Rican style coconut custard. Get it while is available this holiday season! Contains (cloves & cinnamon)
      OUT OF STOCK
      $20.00
    • Cheesecake Tray Bite Size 20 count

      Variety of flavor cheesecakes in a bite size! 20 count *1 week notice required to order this item*
      $55.00
    • Dessert Party Tray 24 Count

      A variety of bite size desserts. Perfect for gatherings. 24 count(variety is randomly choose) this is the simple version. For a more elegant version is an extra charge of $25
      $60.00
    • DOZEN MINI Guava Puff Pastry

      Our guava filled puff pastry but the mini version.
      $12.00
    • DOZEN MINI QUESITOS

      Our cream cheese filled puff pastry but mini versions of it!
      $24.00
    • Tres Leches 9'' Pick your flavor

      Our Tres Leches is SUPER MOIST! and is not sliceable. We recommend customers to taste our tres leches (by the cup) before ordering a whole one, It is delicious but different!!!!
      $20.00
    • Vanilla Flan 9''

      9'' aluminum pan. Flip it over and let the caramel shine!
      $20.00

    FAMILY DINNERS (3 DAYS REQUIRED)

    Larger Food Orders (48 hour required)

    • Family Dinner Pork, Rice and Pan Sobao (serves 8-10)

      Slowly Cooked Pork Shoulder 5 pounds (inlcudes fat) Arroz con Gandules (Pigeon Peas Rice) 5 pounds. 1 Pound of Bread. Serves 8-10 guests
      $95.00
    • 12 PACK - EMPANADA DEAL (Dozen)

      PICK YOUR COMBINATION OF CHOICE!
      $34.00+
    • 6 PACK - EMPANADA DEAL (Six)

      PICK YOUR COMBINATION OF CHOICE!
      $16.00+
    • SIDE OF RICE

      Pick from today's rice options. Beans are sold separately
      $3.50+
    • Pork/ Pernil (SIDE)

      Our Caribbean flavored slowly cooked Pork shoulder served the size of your choice.
      $5.00+
    • Pan Sobao (2 Loafs of Bread)

      Our made in house Puerto Rican soft & sweet bread.
      $4.50
    • Angie's Style Beef Goulash & Pound of Bread

      1/2 Sheet Pan made with 100% Ground Beef, Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Parmesan and our secret ingredient Cream Cheese! Includes 1 Pound of Bread Serves 8-10 guests (1 week noticed required)
      $75.00
    • Whole Angie's Style Lasagna & Pound of Bread

      *1 WEEK NOTICED REQUIRED** 1/2 Sheet Lasagna Pan made with BEEF or CHICKEN, Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Parmesan and our secret ingredient Cream Cheese! Includes 1 Pound of Bread Serves 8-10 guests *1 week notice required to order this item*
      $75.00
    • Whole Angie's Style Chicken Lasagna & Pound of Bread (Copy)

      *1 WEEK NOTICED REQUIRED** 1/2 Sheet Lasagna Pan made with Chicken Breast, Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Parmesan and our secret ingredient Cream Cheese! Includes 1 Pound of Bread Serves 8-10 guests *1 week notice required to order this item*
      $75.00
    • CHICKEN WINGS (Side)

      Our wings are prepared in the traditional Puerto Rican pollo frito style. They are marinated and non-breaded, so they’re meant to be juicy and flavorful not heavily crispy. Because the chicken is marinated, it goes into the fryer with moisture. The crispier we fry it, the more moisture is lost, which means the chicken becomes drier inside. If you’re looking for a breaded, extra-crispy wing, our wings may not be what you’re expecting. Mix of flat & drums.
      $6.00+
    • Yuca Balls filled with Cheese

      Yuca Balls (cassava balls) filled with cheese served with a side of guava jelly
      $5.00+
    • Sweet Plantains (maduros)

      Ripe sweet plantains
      $3.25+
    • New! Mini Chicken Cordon Blues

      Deep Fried Mini Chicken Cordon Blue filled with Ham & Cheese and your choice of side sauce. (BBQ recommended)
      $5.00+
    • 5 POUNDS BBQ Pulled Pork & 2 Pounds of Bread

      5 Pounds of our sweet and Tangy BBQ Pulled Pork. Includes a side of sweet pickles and 2 pounds of pan sobao Serves 8-10 guests *Please be aware this menu requires minimum a 3 day notice*
      OUT OF STOCK
      $65.00

    COQUITO (Holiday Drink)

    • Coquito Virgin (24 hour notice)

      Our Homemade Coquito does not include alcohol but we leave room for you to add your favorite rum. Make sure to shake well and serve better cold for better enjoyment.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $20.00

    All hours
    SundayClosed
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday9:45 am - 6:00 pm
    Wednesday9:45 am - 6:00 pm
    Thursday9:45 am - 6:00 pm
    Friday9:45 am - 6:00 pm
    Saturday9:15 am - 6:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    My Sisters Fault was founded in 2017 by two Caribbean sister's (Rous, Baker & Angie, Cook) Our menu consists of Sweets, Savory, Rice, Empanadas, Pork and our made in house Puerto Rican bread "Pan Sobao"

    Location

    10 Southwest Front Street, Milford, DE 19963

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play