Skip to main contentToast Local logo

Reviews of New York Pizza Pub

4.5

Rated 4.5 out of 5

39 ratings

  • Timothy G.
    5 out of 5 starsNov 4, 2025

    Ordered Buffalo Chicken Pizza (Pizza Of The Month) and Create Your Own LG.

  • CJ M.
    5 out of 5 starsOct 21, 2025

    Ordered Create Your Own Calzone, Baked Italian Meatballs, and Zarlengo’s Gelato Cup.

  • Dude A.
    5 out of 5 starsOct 13, 2025

    Ordered Gnarly Surfer Dude LG, Supreme LG, and Create Your Own LG.

  • Joseph K.
    4 out of 5 starsOct 10, 2025

    Delicious pizza as always. Quite disappointed the $5 off coupon that prompted us to visit did not apply to our pizza. The person working didn’t know how to apply it to the order, went to the back to ask the manager about it and returned, stating it was only for one topping pizzas..One would think that spending more would qualify for the coupon. Having worked in food service for several years, I would have handled the situation differently had a guest brought in a paper coupon for $5. Nonetheless I still gave a tip.

    Ordered Create Your Own LG.

  • Dude A.
    5 out of 5 starsOct 9, 2025

    Ordered Gnarly Surfer Dude LG and Create Your Own LG.

  • David G.
    5 out of 5 starsAug 22, 2025

    Ordered Cheese Pizza SM.