Skip to Main content
  • Nicky's on the Bay

    • Home
    • /
    • Bay Shore
    • /
    • Nicky's on the Bay
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image

    Nicky's on the Bay

    American
    Closed
    CallDirectionsGift Cards
    Starters
    Salad / Soup
    Entrée
    Sides
    Kids

    Starters

    • Popover

      Rosemary & white cheddar, whipped honey butter
      $5.00
    • Baked Clams

      Seasoned bread crumb, lemon
      $14.00
    • Calamari

      Classic with lemon and marinara
      $19.00
    • Crab Cake

      4 oz. of lump crab meat, Mississippi remoulade
      $30.00
    • Fried Mozzarella

      Oreganata-breaded, bruschetta, balsamic glaze
      $14.00
    • Mussels

      C H O I C E O F : White wine garlic & butter or fra diavolo
      $22.00
    • Shrimp Cocktail

      House made cocktail sauce, lemon
      $23.00
    • Whipped Ricotta

      Charred pita bread, calabrian pepper, roasted chickpeas, honey drizzle
      $19.00
    • Wings

      C H O I C E O F : Buffalo • BBQ • Naked Served with blue cheese
      $18.00
    • Grilled Octopus

      Adobo-marinated octopus, chimichurri drizzle, mixed green salad, smashed Yukon potatoes
      $30.00
    • Rock Shrimp Tempura

      Tempura battered shrimp, sweet chili aioli, toasted sesame seeds, chopped cilantro
      $26.00
    • Crispy Brussel Sprouts

      Applewood smoked bacon, dried cranberries, old bay seasoning, hot honey
      $19.00
    • Burrata Beet Salad

      Roasted golden beets, arugula, caramelized figs, crushed pistachio, white balsamic glaze
      $22.00

    Salad / Soup

    • Caesar Salad

      Crisp romaine hearts, herbed croutons, shaved parmesan, caesar dressing
      $16.00
    • Lobster Bisque

      Fresh lobster, crostini, herbs
      $15.00
    • New England Clam Chowder

      Bacon, thyme, cream, local chopped clams, natural broth
      $15.00
    • Apple Harvest Salad

      Mesclun, granny smith apples, poached pears, goat cheese, cherry tomatoes, candied walnuts, white balsamic vinaigrette
      $18.00
    • Butternut Squash Soup

      $15.00

    Entrée

    • 2 Lb Lobster

      Maine lobster steamed or broiled. Served with arugula salad, lemon, melted butter
      $92.00
    • Braised Short Rib

      Garlic mashed potatoes, red wine demi, broccoli rabe, crispy onions
      $38.00
    • Burger

      Prime burger, toasted brioche, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, American cheese, signature steak sauce aoli, fries
      $27.00
    • Everything Crusted Tuna

      Blue Fin Tuna, crunchy garlic oil, seaweed salad, pineapple fried rice
      $50.00
    • Halibut

      Pan-seared in lemon butter sauce, risotto, spinach
      $45.00
    • Linguini Clam Sauce

      White wine clam sauce, herbs, butter, garlic, grated parmesan
      $37.00
    • Lobster Roll

      H O T : Butter-poached lobster, garlic, lemon aioli, and dill C O L D : Lobster salad, celery, shallot, lemon aioli Both on a toasted garlic and herb buttered roll, served with crispy chips
      $46.00
    • NY Strip

      Double R Ranch 20oz Prime with roasted garlic Yukon potatoes, house made steak sauce, Brussel sprouts
      $81.00
    • Shrimp Scampi

      Garlic butter, herbs, lemon, served over linguine
      $40.00
    • Skirt Steak

      Double R Ranch 12oz Prime with garlic mashed potatoes, asparagus, housemade steak sauce
      $60.00
    • 1/2 Roasted Chicken

      Garlic mashed potatoes, oyster mushrooms, mushroom au jus
      $42.00
    • Pork Chop

      Apple fennel arugula salad, apple-cider vinaigrette, shaved parm
      $49.00
    • Crispy Duck Confit

      Sweet potato puree, caramelized onions, pomegranate gastrique
      $46.00
    • Blackened Swordfish

      Tri-color couscous, mushrooms chips, citrus beurre blanc
      $48.00

    Sides

    • Asparagus

      $12.00
    • Fries

      $12.00
    • Mac & Cheese

      $12.00
    • Mashed Potatoes

      $12.00
    • Sauteed Spinach

      $12.00

    Kids

    • Kids Chicken Fingers

      $12.00
    • Kids Cheese Burger

      $12.00
    • Kids Pasta

      $12.00
    • Kids Mac & Cheese

      $12.00
    • Kids Mozzarella Sticks

      $12.00
    • Kids Grilled Chicken

      $12.00
    • Kids Grilled Cheese

      $12.00

    All hours
    SundayClosed
    Monday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Tuesday4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Wednesday4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Thursday4:00 pm - 8:45 pm
    Friday12:00 pm - 9:30 pm
    SaturdayClosed
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play