I ordered a large 20” supreme pizza and added extra toppings of beef and extra cheese, which were $3 each, in addition to the $28 base price. My order was takeout so we didn’t eat the pizza until we got home. I’ve been to NY Pizza Company once before and having lived many years back in my youth in NYC as well as central and southern NJ, I can honestly say this pizza is about as deliciously authentic as it gets and all the ingredients are definitely of a very high quality. Only issue I had was, as I stated, I ordered additional toppings of beef and extra cheese. I could definitely taste the beef but seems like (and I could be wrong about this) they forgot to add the extra cheese. It was New Year’s Eve so they may have been very busy and I’m sure it was just an innocent mistake. If I had ordered to eat in-store, I would have let my server know and it would have been a quick and easy fix. But since I ordered it to-go and live several miles away it would’ve been a hassle to return to the restaurant to fix the issue, so we ate (and still very much enjoyed) the pizza as is. All in all, amazingly great quality food as well as an authentic-as-it-gets NY style pizza. This is my second time going to NY Pizza Company and, despite the possible oversight in my order, I would definitely go back as well as recommend it to others I know. Overall, keep doing what you all are doing!
Ordered 20" Supreme Pizza.
