Old Chicago Pizza
Pizza
Closed
Food
Deep Dish Pizza
All deep dishes have the delicious made-in-house crust that we are famous for. The dough is made in house, from the same recipe that we have been using for over 40 years.
Our deep-dish pizza features a crust that goes up the side of the pan and holds cheese and toppings together. Our large deep dish yields 8 slices, our medium 6 slices and the small 4 slices.
Small Deep Dish
4 slices of our famous crust filled with our special blend of cheese, our traditional red sauce, and your choice of toppings. 9"$22.40
Medium Deep Dish
6 slices of our famous crust filled with our special blend of cheese, our traditional red sauce, and your choice of toppings. 12"$29.50
Large Deep Dish
8 slices of our famous crust filled with our special blend of cheeses, our traditional red sauce, and your choice of toppings. Weighs almost five pounds before toppings! 14"$38.00
Mini Deep Dish
The equivalent of one slice in one mini pizza. Maximum of three toppings.$8.00
Thin/Extra Thin Crust Pizza
All thin crust pizza is made from the same recipe as the deep dish. The crust is a more traditional flat style, with sauce, cheese, and your choice of other toppings. Our large yields 8 slices, our medium 6 slices and the small 4 slices.
Small Thin Crust
4 slices of our famous crust rolled out to a more traditional flat style, our traditional red sauce, our cheese blend, and your choice of toppings. 9"$19.40
Medium Thin Crust
6 slices of our famous crust rolled out to a more traditional flat style, our traditional red sauce, our cheese blend, and your choice of toppings. 12"$26.50
Large Thin Crust
8 slices of our famous crust rolled out to a more traditional flat style, our traditional red sauce, our cheese blend, and your choice of toppings. 14"$33.00
Mini Thin Crust
The equivalent of 1 slice of our famous crust rolled out to a more traditional flat style, our traditional red sauce, our cheese blend, and your choice of toppings.$8.00-
OUT OF STOCK
Small Extra Thin Crust
4 slices. An even thinner layer of our famous secret crust recipe with your choice of sauce, cheese, and toppings. 9"$19.40
Medium Extra Thin Crust
6 slices. An even thinner layer of our famous secret crust recipe with your choice of sauce, cheese, and toppings. 12"$26.50
Large Extra Thin Crust
8 slices. An even thinner layer of our famous secret crust recipe with your choice of sauce, cheese, and toppings. 14"$32.50
Mini Extra Thin Crust
A single serving with an even thinner layer of our famous secret crust recipe with your choice of sauce, cheese, and toppings. Maximum of 3 Toppings.$8.00
Small Gluten Free Thin Crust
We now offer a certified Gluten Free and Vegan crust as a dietary choice. We cannot however address the individual concerns of those at risk. Prepared in our non-gluten free kitchen with our traditional red sauce, our cheese blend, and your choice of toppings. 4 Slices. 9"$24.40
Double Crust Pizza
Something very special! Your choice of two toppings mixed with our famous cheese blend in our traditional dough with another layer of crust on top, sauce, and another layer of cheese. Garlic may also be added.
(Approx 30 minute cooking time)
Small Double Crust
4 Slices of two layers of our traditional crust with our cheese blend and two ingredients topped by sauce and more cheese. 9"$28.00
Medium Double Crust
6 Slices of two layers of our traditional crust with our cheese blend and two ingredients topped by sauce and more cheese. 12"$35.00
Large Double Crust
8 Slices of two layers of our traditional crust with our cheese blend and two ingredients topped by sauce and more cheese. 14"$45.00
Salad
Small Dinner Salad
Romaine topped with red onion and fresh tomato. SINGLE SERVING.$7.00
Small Lisa Iskin Salad
You may never meet the originator of this fabulous salad but she does pop in every once in a while to sample her namesake creation. Romaine lettuce topped with red onion, green bell pepper, sliced mushrooms, chopped olive, a generous helping of mozzarella cheese, and tomato. SINGLE SERVING.$8.00
Small Italian Salad
Romaine lettuce topped with diced tomato and onion, bell pepper, salami, and whole olives. SINGLE SERVING.$7.75
Small Caesar Salad
Romaine Lettuce, Shredded Parmesan, and toasted croutons served with our luscious Caesar Dressing on the side. SINGLE SERVING.$7.75
Large Dinner Salad
Romaine lettuce topped with red onion, bell pepper, tomato and whole olives. SERVES 2-3.$12.00
Large Lisa Iskin Salad
You may never meet the originator of this fabulous salad but she does pop in every once in a while to sample her namesake creation. Romaine lettuce topped with red onion, green bell pepper, sliced mushrooms, chopped olive, a generous helping of mozzarella cheese, and tomato. FEEDS 2-3 PEOPLE.$15.75
Large Italian Salad
Romaine lettuce topped with diced tomato and onion, bell pepper, salami, and whole olives. Serves 2-3.$14.00
Large Caesar Salad
Romaine Lettuce, Shredded Parmesan, and toasted croutons served with our luscious Caesar Dressing on the side. SERVES 2-3.$14.00
Blue Cheese Iceberg Wedge
1/3 of a head of Iceberg lettuce topped with chopped tomato and onion, and a generous sprinkling of blue cheese crumbles. Served with blue cheese dressing. Iceberg Wedge not available in small size. SERVES 1-2$13.00
Side of Ranch
3.25 oz$1.00
Side of Dressing
3.25 oz$1.00
Side of Dressing (Large)
16 oz Pint$6.00
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread
Hold onto your hat, our garlic bread is crisp and savory with a Parmesan and Romano blend and ample butter. 6 slices$8.00
Pesto Garlic Bread
Our famous garlic bread with vibrant basil pesto, butter, and garlic. 6 Slices Nut Free.$8.75
Tomato Pesto Garlic Bread
Our famous garlic bread with a blended sauce made from sundried tomato and herbs. 6 slices Nut free$8.75-
OUT OF STOCK
1/2 Garlic Bread
Hold onto your hat, our garlic bread is crisp and savory with a Parmesan and Romano blend and ample butter. 3 slices$5.00
1/2 Pesto Garlic Bread
Our famous garlic bread with vibrant basil pesto, butter, and garlic. 3 Slices Nut Free.$5.50
1/2 Tomato Pesto Garlic Bread
Our famous garlic bread with a blended sauce made from sundried tomato and herbs. 3 slices Nut free$5.50
Side of Dressing
3.25 oz$1.00
Side of Dressing (Large)
16 oz Pint$6.00
Side of Pesto Sauce
3.25 oz$3.00
Side of Sundried Tomato Pesto Sauce
3.25 oz$3.00
Side of Pizza Sauce
3.25 oz$1.00
Sides
Side of Ranch
3.25 oz$1.00
Side of Dressing
3.25 oz$1.00Side of Dressing (Large)
16 oz Pint$6.00Side of Pizza Sauce
3.25 oz$1.00Side of Sundried Tomato Pesto Sauce
3.25 oz$3.00Side of Pesto Sauce
3.25 oz$3.00
Side Cheese
$1.00
Side Blue Cheese Crumbles
$2.50
Side Croutons
$1.00
Side Jalapenos
$1.00
Side of Vegetables
Dessert
Cookie Choc Chip
A hearty cookie from a recipe created by a member of our staff. Almost a meal in itself.$3.50
Cookie Mocha Chip
A powerful cookie that is made with insane amounts of chocolate and espresso. This cookie packs a punch.$3.50
Cookie Oatmeal Chip
Another hearty cookie, chocolate chips and oatmeal, good for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.$3.50
Cookie Snickerdoodle
A buttery creamy cookie from a recipe also created by a member of our staff.$3.50
Cheesecake NY
Individual New York Style Cheesecake made locally in Petaluma by J.M. Rosen.$8.50
Cheesecake Chocolate
Individual chocolate cheesecake made locally in Petaluma by J.M. Rosen.OUT OF STOCK$8.50
Torte Chocolate Gluten Free
A rich and decadent chocolate torte, made gluten-free without flour.$8.50
Drinks
24 oz. Cola and Grenadine garnished with a cherry.
Pepsi
24 oz Fountain Drink$3.50
Diet Pepsi
24 oz Fountain Drink$3.50
Starry
24 oz Fountain Drink. Caffeine Free.$3.50
Root Beer
24 oz Fountain Drink. Caffeine Free.$3.50
Dr. Pepper
24 oz Fountain Drink.$3.50
Ginger Ale
24 oz Fountain Drink. Caffeine Free. Real Cane Sugar.$3.50
Shirley Temple
24 oz. Garnished with a cherry.$4.50
Roy Rogers
24 oz. Cola & Grenadine. Garnished with a cherry.$4.50
Soda Water
24 oz Fountain Drink. Caffeine Free.$2.00
Pellegrino
16.9 oz Imported sparkling water$4.00
Iced Tea
24 oz, Unsweetened, brewed in house, garnished with a lemon.$3.50
Milk
16 oz, Clover, Whole Milk$3.50
Calypso Lemonade
16oz Bottle$4.00
Calypso Strawberry Lemonade
16oz Bottle$4.00
Langers Apple Juice
15.2 oz$4.00
Langers Orange Juice
15.2 oz$4.00
Just 1/2 Iced Tea 1/2 Lemonade
16oz. Just sweet enough.$4.00
All hours
| Sunday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:30 am - 8:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Since 1978, Old Chicago Pizza has been delighting guests with authentic Chicago-Style Deep Dish pizza from our charming second-floor spot in the Historic Lanmart Building, right in the heart of downtown Petaluma. Our menu doesn't stop at deep dish; we also serve Double Crust, Thin Crust, Extra Thin Crust, and Gluten Free Thin Crust pizzas to satisfy every craving.
Location
41 Petaluma Boulevard North, Petaluma, CA 94952