Skip to main contentToast Local logo

Reviews of Mangiamo Italiano Elevato

4.8

Rated 4.8 out of 5

87 ratings

  • Ryan R.
    5 out of 5 starsNov 30, 2025

    Ordered C.C. Sirloin 10oz, Campanelle al Pesto, Mansion Espresso Martini, Burrata Garlic Bread, Casamigos Blanco, Tuxedo Cake, Titos, and Side Options.

  • Genevieve E.
    5 out of 5 starsNov 14, 2025

    Ordered Kurobuta Pork, Scottish Salmon, Chicken Piccata, Lasagna Bolognese, Burrata Garlic Bread, Calamari, Grey Goose, Baseball Meatball, N/A Aperol Spritz, 6oz Nero D'Avla Mary Taylor, 6oz Freixinet Pinot Grigo, and Tea Lipton Brisk.

  • Rob W.
    5 out of 5 starsNov 8, 2025

    Ordered Strawberry Basil Smash and The Playboy.

  • Mark B.
    5 out of 5 starsNov 7, 2025
    Photo from Mark B.'s review

    Amazing meal, service, and atmosphere. Can’t ask for more!

    Ordered Lasagna Bolognese, Exotic Salad, Funghi Risotto, Beef Cheek, Orange Pumpkin Tart, Orange Pumpkin Tart, Bulleit Rye, 6oz Craggy Range Sauv Blanc, 6 oz Barons Rothschild Blanc, and 6oz Diora Pinot Noir.

  • Dennis B.
    5 out of 5 starsOct 10, 2025

    Ordered Scottish Salmon, Pebble Creek Mushroom Ravioli, Wedge Salad, 6oz Oberon, Tirimisu, 6oz 3 Finger Jack Cabernet, and Affogato.

  • Samantha T.
    5 out of 5 starsOct 7, 2025

    Ordered Scottish Salmon, Chicken Piccata, Crab Cakes, 1873 Old Fashioned, Grandioso, Bulleit, Desert Rose, and Arancia.

  • Steve F.
    4 out of 5 starsOct 5, 2025

    Mo’s lounge (speakeasy). Fun place to wait before our reservation. Drinks were good, but expensive.

    Ordered The Tenenbaum, The Saltburn, and The Playboy.

  • Steve F.
    5 out of 5 starsOct 5, 2025

    Had a wonderful time celebrating our 30th wedding anniversary

    Ordered Tenderloin 6oz, Wild Caught Scallops, Side Options, and Blantons.

  • Mia A.
    5 out of 5 starsOct 3, 2025
    Photo from Mia A.'s review

    Ordered Tenderloin 6oz, Lasagna Bolognese, Knife & Fork Caesar, Burt Embers, Sinatra, Savoy, 1873 Old Fashioned, Mansion Espresso Martini, Burrata Garlic Bread, 6oz Remole Rosso, and Side Options.

  • Kevin N.
    5 out of 5 starsSep 24, 2025
    Photo from Kevin N.'s review

    Housed in the historic Augustus Paddock mansion, Mangiamo Italiano Elevato delivers a dining experience that blends old-world romance with contemporary polish. Velvet drapery, crystal glassware, and the glow of fireplaces set an atmosphere designed for celebrations and evenings when dining is meant to linger. Service was exemplary. Jerry, our server, struck the ideal balance of warmth and professionalism, pairing genuine attentiveness with an impressive knowledge of both menu and cocktails. His guidance shaped the evening as much as the setting. Starters offered a strong opening. The calamari was crisp and light, steering clear of excess oil or chew. Burrata garlic bread leaned indulgent, the creamy cheese softening roasted garlic’s bite. Most memorable were the artichoke hearts—delicately battered, subtly earthy, and finished with a bright acidity that kept each bite refreshing. Mains showcased two very different strengths. The Lasagna Bolognese was deeply satisfying, with generous layers of béchamel and ragù woven together into a dish as comforting as it was flavorful. The Campanelle al Pesto offered a brighter counterpart: perfectly al dente pasta ribbons coated in basil pesto sharpened by Parmesan, delivering a lively, herbaceous punch. Both were excellent in their own right—equal in quality, with the choice depending entirely on mood. Desserts closed on a celebratory note. The tiramisu was classic and assured—airy mascarpone balanced by espresso and cocoa—while the limoncello cake stole the finale with its bright citrus flavor and elegant presentation. Drinks were as thoughtful as the food. “Smoke and Mirrors” arrived with depth and flair, while the non-alcoholic Berry Bliss Elixir and Lemon Spritz proved that Mangiamo invests equal care in every guest’s experience. Mangiamo Italiano Elevato is not a casual stop but a destination. In Grand Rapids, few restaurants capture such a seamless blend of service, setting, and cuisine, making it a worthy choice for anniversaries, milestones, and any occasion deserving something more.

    Ordered Lasagna Bolognese, Campanelle al Pesto, Calamari, Smoke & Mirrors, Burrata Garlic Bread, Artichoke Hearts, Tirimisu, Limoncello Cake, N/A Berry Bliss Elixer, 6oz Moscato D'Asti, N/A Lemon Spritz, Side Options, and Gelato & Sorbetto.