Skip to Main content
  • PaPa J's Twin Plaza 2016 Smallman Street

    • Home
    • /
    • Pittsburgh
    • /
    • PaPa J's Twin Plaza
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image

    PaPa J's Twin Plaza

    Italian
    Closed11:30AM - 9:45PM
    CallDirectionsGift CardsReserve
    ‌
    ‌
    Traditional Menu
    "Family Size" (1/2 Pans)
    "Party Size" (Full Pans)
    Retail and Mercato

    Featured Items

    • Garden Salad

      Fresh Mild Greens Simply Dressed in a Vinaigrette made with Olive Oil, Lemon and Garlic (otherwise known as MaMa's Dressing), Garnished with Tomato and Black Oil Cured Olive.
      $10.99
    • Basil Pesto Cream

      Basil Pesto Cream Sauce Topped with Pignoli Nuts and Diced Tomato
      $24.99
    • Pomodoro

      Sautéed Garlic, Olive Oil, Cherry Tomatos, Fresh Basil
      $17.99

    Traditional Menu

    Appetizers

    • Sautéed Banana Peppers

      Banana Peppers Caramelized in Olive Oil with Salt
      $11.99
    • Veal Meatballs

      2 3oz Veal Meatballs in Marinara (contains dairy, eggs, gluten and meat)
      $11.99
    • Fried Zucchini

      Sliced fresh, then fried & served with marinara & lemon Garnished with Romano Cheese and Parsley
      $15.99
    • Greens & Beans

      Featuring Mild Greens & Mild Beans (Vegetarian and Dairy Free)
      $15.99
    • Burrata Appetizer

      4oz of Burrata with grilled focaccia laced by olive oil, salt & pepper
      $15.99
    • Eggplant Parmigiano Appetizer

      fried, battered eggplant with marinara and provolone
      $17.99
    • Side of Sautéed Vegetables

      Mixed Colorful Seasonal Vegetables
      $9.00

    Pasta Entrees

    Fresh Pasta Noodles Made in House
    • Aglio E Olio

      Sautéed Garlic with Olive oil and Butter
      $17.99
    • Pomodoro

      Sautéed Garlic, Olive Oil, Cherry Tomatos, Fresh Basil
      $17.99
    • Marinara

      Sautéed Garlic & Onions, Ground Tomato & Fresh Basil
      $19.99
    • Napolitano

      Marinara Mixed with Mozzarella and Provolone Cheese
      $20.99
    • Spinach & Feta

      Sautéed Spinach in Garlic, Pignoli Nuts, Diced Tomato, Crumbled Feta Cheese
      $22.99
    • Alfredo

      A Rich, Thick Cream Sauce
      $22.99
    • Divine

      A family favorite fusion of Marinara & Alfredo.
      $22.99
    • Sausages

      Our Marinara with Sweet Peppers, Carmelized Onions and a Mild Ground Sausage from Pittsburgh's Famous Ernie Ricci.
      $23.99
    • Carnegie Carbonara

      Our Alfredo Combined with Guanciale (An Italian Salt Cured Pork Similar to Bacon), Onions, and Ricotta Cheese
      $23.99
    • Basil Pesto Cream

      Basil Pesto Cream Sauce Topped with Pignoli Nuts and Diced Tomato
      $24.99
    • Bolognese

      Our Divine Tomato Cream Sauce Combined with Ground Veal.
      $24.99
    • Shrimp & Pasta

      6 Grilled Shrimp with our Marinara or Aglio E Olio
      $29.99

    Chicken Entrees

    • Chicken Parmigiano

      Breaded and Fried, Topped with Marinara and Provolone. Served with Marinara Pasta.
      $23.99
    • Divine Chicken Parmigiano

      Chicken Breaded and Fried, Topped with Our Divine Tomato Cream Sauce and Provolone Cheese. Served with a Side of Divine Pasta.
      $26.99
    • Alfredo Chicken Parmigiano

      6oz of Chicken Breaded and Fried, Topped with Our Alfredo Cream Sauce and Provolone Cheese. Served with Pasta Alfredo.
      $27.99
    • Chicken Milanese

      Breaded and Pan-Fried in Olive Oil, Garnished with a Lemon, Served with Roasted Colorful Vegetables.
      $23.99
    • Chicken Romano

      Fresh Egg, Pecorino Romano Cheese, Parsley Pan-Fried and Garnished with Lemon. Served with Roasted Colorful Vegetables.
      $24.99
    • Chicken Piccata

      Sautéed with Mushrooms, White Wine and garnished with Lemon. Served with Roasted Colorful Vegetables.
      $23.99
    • Grilled Chicken

      Simply Prepared Grilled Chicken, served with Colorful Roasted Vegetables.
      $19.99

    Veal Entrees

    • Veal & Shrimp

      Veal & shrimp tossed with red peppers, artichokes and mushrooms.
      $32.99
    • Veal Piccata

      Sautéed with Sliced Mushrooms, White Wine, Garnished with Lemon and Served with Roasted Colorful Vegetables.
      $26.99
    • Veal Milanese

      Breaded, Pan-fried in Olive Oil, Garnished with Lemon and Served with Roasted Colorful Vegetables.
      $26.99
    • Veal Parmigiano

      Breaded, deep fried, topped with marinara and provolone. Served with pasta marinara.
      $26.99

    Salmon Entrees

    • Salmon Griglia

      Salmon Grilled with Fresh Basil Pesto and Served with Roasted Colorful Vegetables.
      $24.99
    • Salmon Mama Style

      Salmon Broiled with Hot Pickled Peppers and Capers. Served with Roasted Colorful Vegetables.
      $24.99
    • Salmon PaPa Style

      Salmon Broiled with Lemon and Butter. Served with Roasted Colorful Vegetables.
      $24.99
    • Blackened Salmon

      Salmon Blackened Served with Roasted Colorful Vegetables.
      $24.99

    Polentas and Eggplant

    • Polenta Parmigiano

      Grilled Polenta Topped with Marinara and Provolone Cheese.
      $18.99
    • Polenta Spinach & Feta

      Grilled Polenta Topped with Sautéed Spinach, Garlic, Toasted Pignoli Nuts, Diced Tomato and Feta.
      $18.99
    • Polenta Sausages

      Grilled Polenta topped with Marinara, Sweet Peppers, Caramelized Onions, and Mild Ground Sausage from Pittsburgh's Famous Ernie Ricci's.
      $18.99
    • Polenta Primavera Garlic Sauce

      Grilled Polenta Topped with Roasted Colorful Vegetables.
      $18.99
    • Polenta Primavera Marinara

      Grilled Polenta Topped with Roasted Colorful Vegetables and Marinara.
      $19.99

    Pizza by the Tray 8"x24"

    • Rosso Tray

      Our pizza with tomato sauce, fresh basil and olive oil
      $36.00
    • Margherita Tray

      Fresh Tomato, Mozzarella, Basil and Olive Oil
      $36.00
    • Classic Italian Tray

      Our Classic American Italian Cheese Pizza
      $36.00
    • Classic Italian with Pepperoni Tray

      Our Classic American Italian Pizza with Pepperoni.
      $36.00
    • Mortadella Tray

      Mortadella with pistachio, sautéed banana pepper, red onion, mascarpone on a garlic butter base.
      $36.00
    • Soppressatta Tray

      Garlic Butter Base, Pizza Cheeses, Sweet Soppressatta, Hot Honey Drizzle
      OUT OF STOCK
      $36.00
    • Sausage Tray

      Peppers & Onions with Olive Oil & Salt, mozzarella and provolone
      $36.00
    • Spinach & Feta Tray

      Garlic Butter, Spinach & Feta, provolone and mozzarella
      $36.00
    • TRAY Porchetta

      Oil Cured Black Olives, Kalamata olives and Castelvetrano Green olives over a garlic butter base with mozzarella and provolone. (Available exclusively by the Tray)
      $36.00
    • Baguette

      $9.00
    • Rosemary Potato Tray

      Cracked Black Pepper & Rosemary baked potato slices over provolone and mozzarella cheese
      $36.00
    • Tray of Foccacia Bread

      $18.00

    Salads

    • Garden Salad

      Fresh Mild Greens Simply Dressed in a Vinaigrette made with Olive Oil, Lemon and Garlic (otherwise known as MaMa's Dressing), Garnished with Tomato and Black Oil Cured Olive.
      $10.99
    • Spinach Salad

      Mild Leaf, Red Onion, Red Wine Vinaigrette, Romano Cheese
      $11.99
    • Caprese Salad

      Fresh tomato, mozzarella, basil, olive oil and fig balsamic glaze
      $14.99
    • Pizzeria Salad

      $12.49

    Beverages

    • Coke

      $4.00
    • Diet Coke

      $4.00
    • Coke Zero

      $4.00
    • Pepsi

      $4.00
    • Mountain Dew

      $4.00
    • Orange Soda

      $4.00
    • Lemon/Lime

      $4.00
    • Root Beer

      $4.00
    • Soda Water

      $4.00
    • Ginger Ale

      $4.00
    • Lemonade

      $4.00
    • Tonic Water

      $4.00
    • Chocolate Milk

      $4.00
    • Cranberry

      $4.00
    • Kid's Shirley Temple

      Kid's Cup with Lid Sprite with splash of grenadine, 1 maraschino cherry
      $4.00
    • Milk

      $4.00
    • Fruit Punch

      $4.00
    • Unsweetened Ice Tea

      $3.50
    • Acqua Panna 500mL Bottle

      $5.00
    • Acqua Panna 1L

      $8.00
    • San Pelligrino 500ml Bottle

      $5.00
    • San Pelligrino 1L Bottle

      $8.00

    Gelato Pints

    • Choose Pint Flavor at Counter

      $15.00

    Single Pizza Cut 4"x8"

    Single Cut of Pizza 4"x8"
    • Rosso Cut

      Single Cut with Tomato Sauce, Olive Oil & Fresh Basil
      $6.00
    • Bianco Cut

      $6.00
    • Classic Italian Cheese Cut

      Single Cut topped with Tomato Sauce, Shredded Mozzarella and Provolone Cheeses.
      $6.00
    • Classic Italian with Pepperoni Cut

      Single Cut with Tomato Sauce, Shredded Mozzarella and Provolone Cheeses, topped with Pepperoni.
      $6.00
    • Spinach and Feta Cut

      Single Cut with a Garlic Butter & Oil Base, Shredded Mozzarella & Provolone, Spinach and Topped with Fresh Feta Crumbles.
      $6.00
    • Rosemary Roasted Potato Cut

      Single Cut with a Garlic Butter & Olive Oil, Shredded Mozzarella and Provolone Cheese, Roasted Potato with Cracked Black Pepper & Rosemary
      $6.00
    • Sausage Cut

      Single Cut with a Garlic Butter and Olive Oil Base, Shredded Mozzarella & Provolone, Sweet Peppers & Onions, Ground Mild Sausage from Ernie Ricci's.
      $6.00
    • Mortadella Cut

      Single Cut with a Garlic Butter & Olive Oil Base, Topped with Shredded Mozzarella & Provolone, Thin Sliced Mortadella with Pistachios, Diced Red Onion, Sautéed Banana Pepper and Mascarpone Cheese
      $6.00

    Soups

    • Wedding Soup Pint

      $10.00
    • Wedding Soup Quart

      $18.00

    "Family Size" (1/2 Pans)

    Veal Meatballs (Family Size)

    • Veal Meatballs in Marinara

      $36.00
    • Veal Meatballs in Marinara with Provolone, Peppers & Onion

      $46.00

    Salads (Family Size)

    • Garden Salad (Family Size)

      $30.00
    • Caprese Salad (Family Size)

      $30.00
    • Pizzeria (Family)

      $40.00

    Pasta (Family Size)

    • Family Aglio e Olio

      $36.00
    • Family Pomodoro

      $36.00
    • Family Fresh Sage and Golden Browned Butter

      $36.00
    • Family Marinara

      $36.00
    • Family Napolitiano

      $38.00
    • Family Spinach & Feta

      $40.00
    • Family Alfredo

      $40.00
    • Family Divine

      $40.00
    • Family Sausages

      $40.00
    • Family Carnegie Carbonara

      $45.00
    • Family Basil Pesto Cream

      $45.00
    • Family Bolognese

      $45.00

    Vegetables (Family Size)

    • Sautéed Banana Peppers (Family Size)

      $25.00
    • Greens & Beans (Family Size)

      $30.00
    • Eggplant Parmigiano (Family Size)

      $36.00

    Polenta (Family Size) (GF)

    • Family Polenta Primavera

      $36.00
    • Family Polenta Primavera with Marinara

      $36.00
    • Family Polenta Sausages

      $36.00
    • Family Polenta Spinach & Feta

      $36.00
    • Family Polenta Parmigiana

      $36.00

    Chicken Scallopini (Family Size)

    • Chicken Picatta (Family Size)

      $60.00
    • Chicken Milanese (Family Size)

      $60.00
    • Chicken Romano (Family Size)

      $60.00
    • Chicken Parmigiano (Family Size)

      $60.00

    Veal Scallopini (Family Size)

    • Veal Picatta (Family Size)

      $75.00
    • Veal Milanese (Group Size)

      $75.00
    • Veal & Shrimp (Family Size)

      $90.00

    Seafood (Family Size) (GF)

    • Salmon Griglia (Family Size)

      $75.00
    • Salmon MaMa Style (Family Size)

      $75.00
    • Salmon PaPa Style (Family Size)

      $75.00

    "Party Size" (Full Pans)

    Polenta (Party Size)

    • Polenta Primavera (Party Size)

      24pc @4 oz in Large Catering Tray
      $100.00
    • Polenta Primavera with Marinara (Party Size)

      24pc @4 oz in Large Catering Tray
      $100.00
    • Sausages Polenta (Party Size)

      $100.00
    • Spinach & Feta Polenta (Party Size)

      $100.00
    • Polenta Parmigiano (Party Size)

      $100.00

    Chicken Scallopini (Party Size)

    • Chicken Picatta (Party Size)

      $125.00
    • Chicken Milanese (Party Size)

      $125.00
    • Chicken Romano (Party Size)

      $125.00
    • Chicken Parmigiano (Party Size)

      $125.00

    Veal Scallopini (Party Size)

    • Veal Picatta (Party Tray)

      $175.00
    • Veal Milanese (Party Tray)

      $175.00
    • Veal & Shrimp (Party Tray)

      $175.00
    • Veal Parmigiano (Party Tray)

      $175.00

    Veal Meatballs (Party Size)

    • Veal Meatballs in Marinara (Party Size)

      $100.00
    • Veal Meatballs in Marinara with provolone, peppers & onions

      $120.00

    Seafood (Party Size)

    • Salmon Griglia (Party Tray)

      $200.00
    • Salmon MaMa Style (Party Tray)

      $200.00
    • Salmon PaPa Style (Party Tray)

      $200.00

    Salad (Party Size)

    • Garden Salad (Party Tray)

      $65.00
    • Spinach Salad (Party Tray)

      $70.00
    • Pizzeria Salad (Party Tray)

      $75.00
    • Caprese Salad (Party Tray)

      $80.00

    Appetizers (Party Size)

    • Sautéed Banana Peppers (Party Size)

      $50.00
    • Greens and Beans (Party Size)

      $75.00
    • Eggplant Parmigiano (Party Size)

      $100.00
    • Veal Meatballs (Party Size)

      $100.00
    • Roasted Colorful Vegetables (Party Size)

      $100.00

    Pasta (Party Size)

    • Butter Noodles (Party Size)

      $50.00
    • Aglio E Olio (Party Size)

      $60.00
    • Pomodoro (Party Size)

      $60.00
    • Marinara (Party Size)

      $60.00
    • Fresh Sage & Golden Browned Butter (Party Size)

      $62.00
    • Napolitiano (Party Size)

      $75.00
    • Primavera Pasta Garlic Butter (Party Size)

      $75.00
    • Primavera Pasta Marinara (Party Size)

      $75.00
    • Spinach & Feta (Party Size)

      $80.00
    • Alfredo (Party Size)

      $80.00
    • Divine (Party Size)

      $80.00
    • Sausages (Party Size)

      $90.00
    • Carnegie Carbonara (Party Size)

      $90.00
    • Basil Pesto Cream (Party Size)

      $95.00
    • Bolognese (Party Size)

      $95.00
    • Clams & Pasta Aglio e Olio (Party Size)

      $95.00
    • Clams & Pasta Marinara (Party Size)

      $95.00
    • Shrimp & Pasta Aglio e Olio (Party Size)

      $110.00
    • Shrimp &. Pasta Marinara (Party Size)

      $110.00

    Retail and Mercato

    Dried Pastas

    • 2 for 15 Radiatori Pasta

      $15.00
    • Bronze Cut Radiatori Bag

      $8.00
    • Box Capellini Nests

      $9.00
    • Box Fettuccini Nests

      $9.00
    • Box Mafaldini

      $8.00
    • Box Orrecchiette

      $8.00
    • Box PaPaTini

      $8.00
    • Box Radiatori

      $8.00
    • Box Shells

      $8.00
    • Box Fusili

      $8.00
    • Box Rigatoni

      $8.00
    • Box Spaghetti

      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.00
    • Seasonal Box

      $10.00

    Fresh Pastas

    • 1 lb Fresh Capellini

      OUT OF STOCK
      $9.00
    • 1 lb Fresh Mafaldini

      $8.00
    • 1 lb Fresh Orecchiette

      $8.00
    • 1 lb Fresh Radiatori

      $8.00
    • 1 lb Fresh Spaghetti

      $9.00
    • 1 lb Fresh Fettuccine

      OUT OF STOCK
      $9.00

    Baking Supplies

    • Caputo Semola Flour 1kg

      Caputo Il mulino di Napoli Semola Double Milled Semola Rimacinata Di Grano Duro *Non-GMO*All Natural*Noadditives
      $8.00
    • Caputo "00" Soft Wheat Flour 1kg

      Caputo Professionals' Flour: Il mulino di Napoli Pasta fresca e gnocchi Soft Wheat Flour Type "00" Easy-Roll
      $8.00
    • Caputo Pizzeria "00" No Additives 1kg

      Caputo Il mulino di Napoli PIZZARIA TRADIZIONALE Farina di grano tenero tipo "00" *Non-GMO*All Natural*No Additives
      $8.00
    • Caputo Dry Yeast 3.5oz Can

      Made in Italy Perfect with "00" Flour Dry Yeast Naturally Gluten Free
      $6.00
    • Maldon Sea Salt Flakes 4.40z box

      $5.00
    • Fabbri Amarena Cherries in Syrup 3200kg Can

      $118.00

    Grocery

    • Imported Sliced Provolone 5oz

      $7.00
    • Imported Sliced Mortadella 4oz

      $8.00
    • Imported Sliced Proscuitto 4oz

      $9.00
    • Retail Boccini

      $10.00
    • Marinara Sauce

      $2.00+
    • Divine Sauce

      Fusion of Marinara & Alfredo
      $3.00+
    • Alfredo Sauce

      $7.00+
    • Basil Pesto Cream Sauce

      $8.00+
    • Bolognese Sauce

      Divine Tomato Cream with Veal
      $10.00+
    If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

    All hours
    Sunday11:30 am - 8:45 pm
    MondayClosed
    TuesdayClosed
    Wednesday11:30 am - 8:45 pm
    Thursday11:30 am - 8:45 pm
    Friday11:30 am - 9:45 pm
    Saturday11:30 am - 9:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    We are proud to serve World Class, In-house Produced Small Batch Gelato, Roman-Style Street Pizzas, Fresh Pasta Dishes and More! E-Gift cards available!

    Location

    2016 Smallman Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15222

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play