This restaurant does not have any images
Pizza
Papa's Pizza Hamburg
507 Sunset Drive
Hamburg, NY 14075
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
‌
‌
‌
Main Menu
Specials

Sheet Cheese + 50 Boneless Wings (Toppings $7.00)
$74.99
Large Cheese + 20 Boneless Wings (Toppings $4.00)
$40.99
Half Cheese + 10 Boneless Wings (Toppings $2.25)
$24.25
Quarter Cheese + 10 Boneless Wings (Toppings $1.50)
$19.50Sheet Cheese + 50 Wings (Toppings $7.00)
$84.99
Large Cheese + 20 Wings (Toppings $4.00)
$45.99
Half Cheese + 10 Wings (Toppings $2.25)
$26.74
Quarter Cheese + 10 Wings (Toppings $1.50)
$20.50Large & 15 Wings Special
$35.99
Large Pizzas

Large Cheese Pizza (Top Your Own)
Classic cheese pizza, with the option to add any and as many toppings as you'd like for an aditional fee! Homemade dough, sauce, and hand-cut cheese and pepperoni!$23.99
Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza (Large)
With well over a POUND of hand-cut mozzarella cheese and half a pound of hand-cut pepperoni, this pizza will satisfy all of your cravings and then some- with your choice of any of our 3 sauces$31.75
Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza (Large)
The base made with our original bleu cheese and medium sauce, chicken fingers sauced any way you like, and a pound of fresh mozzarella cooked to perfection$33.50
5 Cheese Garlic Pizza (Large)
Delight your taste buds with our luxurious Five Cheese Pizza! Starting with a delectable butter garlic base that adds a subtle richness, we layer on a symphony of cheeses for the ultimate cheesy indulgence. The star-studded lineup includes sharp and nutty Romano, creamy American, classic Swiss, gooey mozzarella, and bold cheddar cheeses. Each cheese brings its unique flavor profile, creating a beautiful blend of scrumptious goodness in every bite. Whether you're a cheese connoisseur or simply crave a cheesy delight, this pizza is sure to satisfy your cravings and leave you wanting more!$31.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch (Large)
Immerse yourself in the exquisite flavors of our gourmet Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, a culinary masterpiece that tantalizes the taste buds! Crafted with a lusciously creamy Ranch base, boasting a harmonious blend of tanginess and silkiness, this pizza is a symphony of flavors. Loaded with succulent chicken weighing over a pound, paired with crispy, savory bacon, each bite is a perfect combination of succulence and smokiness. Topped with a decadent layer of melted mozzarella, this pizza embodies indulgence in every cheesy, savory, and creamy mouthful—a must try!$33.50
Papa's White Pizza (Large)
Indulge in our delectable White Pizza, crafted with a homemade olive oil-based white sauce that's rich and savory. Adorned with a harmonious medley of sweet onions, juicy tomatoes, and vibrant spinach leaves, each bite is a symphony of freshness and flavor. Customize your pizza with your choice of crispy bacon for a smoky punch or hearty Italian sausage for a savory delight. We then sprinkle a generous helping of Romano cheese, adding a nutty depth to the ensemble, and finish with a blanket of melty mozzarella that ties everything together in cheesy perfection. It's a culinary masterpiece that promises a symphony of flavors in every mouthful!$31.50
Steak + 5 Cheese Pizza (Large)
Indulge in a flavor extravaganza with our Steak and Five Cheese Pizza, a culinary marvel that promises to tantalize your taste buds! Our pizza begins with a luxurious garlic butter base, infusing each slice with richness and aroma. Featuring a hearty pound of succulent steak, prepared in our unique house hoagie style, it brings a tender and savory delight to every bite. Enhancing this masterpiece are delicate touches of caramelized onions, earthy mushrooms, and a delightful medley of sweet and tangy banana peppers. The star-studded cheese ensemble—sharp Romano, velvety American, traditional Swiss, stretchy mozzarella, and robust cheddar—creates a masterpiece of textures and flavors that dance on your palate. Prepare for an unforgettable pizza experience that is bold, savory, and utterly satisfying!$34.75
Steak in the Grass Pizza (Large)
Starts with a garlic butter base, topped with spinach, and 1-pound of steak cooked in our house hoagie sauce. Finished with mozzarella.$34.75
Stinger Pizza (Large)
$39.50
Veggie Pizza (Large)
Choice of pizza sauce, top with ANY 3 VEGGIE toppings of your choosing. Additional toppings will charge extra.$30.50
White Pizza (Large)
Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, tomatoes, and Romano, with a mozzarella finish.$28.50
Half Pizzas

Half Cheese Pizza (Top Your Own)
With your choice of sauce, and any toppings you crave, it doesn't get better than this!$13.99
Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza (Half)
Starts with house pizza sauce (sweet or regular), topped with nearly a pound cheese, and fresh cut aged margherita pepperoni.$19.25
Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza (Half)
Homemade blue cheese base, with nearly a pound of chicken fingers (sauced any way you like), with a mozzarella finish. Treat yourself today!$18.75
5 Cheese Garlic Pizza (Half)
Butter garlic base, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.$16.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch (Half)
Ranch base, over a pound of chicken fingers, bacon, with mozzarella finish.$18.75
Papa's White Pizza (Half)
Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, tomatoes, spinach, and your choice of bacon or Italian sausage. Romano, with a mozzarella finish.$17.75
Steak + 5 Cheese Pizza (Half)
Starts with a garlic butter base, with a pound steak (cooked in our house hoagie), light amount of onions, sweet and banana peppers, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.$20.75
Steak in the Grass Pizza (Half)
Starts with a garlic butter base, topped with spinach, and 1-pound of steak cooked in our house hoagie sauce. Finished with mozzarella.$20.75
Stinger Pizza (Half)
Starts with homemade blue-cheese base, 1.5 pounds of steak and chicken finger (sauced anyway you like), topped with mozzarella.$21.75
Veggie Pizza (Half)
Red sauce base (regular or sweet), choose your three veggie toppings.$16.75
White Pizza (Half)
Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, tomatoes, and Romano, with a mozzarella finish.$16.75
Quarter Pizzas

Quarter Cheese Pizza (Top Your Own)
Choice of sauce, mozzarella cheese, and choice of any toppings you like!$8.99
Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza (1/4)
$12.25
Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza (1/4)
Homemade blue cheese base, with over a pound of chicken fingers (sauced any way you like), with a mozzarella finish.$12.50
5 Cheese Garlic Pizza (1/4)
Butter garlic base, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.$11.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch (1/4)
Ranch base, over a pound of chicken fingers, crispy bacon, with a mozzarella finish.$12.50
Papa's White Pizza (1/4)
Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, tomatoes, spinach, and your choice of bacon or Italian sausage. Romano, with a mozzarella finish.$12.25
Steak + 5 Cheese Pizza (1/4)
Starts with a garlic butter base, with a pound steak (cooked in our house hoagie), onions, mushrooms, sweet and banana peppers, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses.$12.50
Steak in the Grass Pizza (1/4)
Starts with a garlic butter base, topped with spinach, and 1-pound of steak cooked in our house hoagie sauce. Finished with mozzarella.$12.50
Stinger Pizza (1/4)
Starts with homemade blue-cheese base, 1.5 pounds of steak and chicken finger (sauced anyway you like), topped with mozzarella.$13.50Veggie Pizza (1/4)
$12.25
White Pizza (1/4)
Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, tomatoes, and Romano, with a mozzarella finish.$11.75
Sheet Pizzas
Sheet Cheese Pizza (Top Your Own)
$38.99Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza (Sheet)
$52.50Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza (Sheet)
$59.505 Cheese Garlic Pizza (Sheet)
$44.50Chicken Bacon Ranch (Sheet)
$59.50Papa's White Pizza (Sheet)
$55.50Steak + 5 Cheese Pizza (Sheet)
$62.50Steak in the Grass Pizza (Sheet)
$62.50Stinger Pizza (Sheet)
$67.50Veggie Pizza (Sheet)
$55.50White Pizza (Sheet)
$46.50
Sides

Fries
$5.99Pizza Logs with Fries (4)
$8.75OUT OF STOCKPizza Logs with Fries (8)
$14.75OUT OF STOCK
Mozzarella Sticks (5)
$6.95
Bread Sticks (3,5,12)
$3.99Bread Stick (1)
$1.49
Pizza Logs (4)
$6.95OUT OF STOCKPizza Logs (8)
$12.95OUT OF STOCK
Onion Rings (10)
$7.99
Jalapeno Poppers (5)
$8.99BBQ Sauce (side)
$0.75
Blue Cheese (side)
$1.50
Blue Cheese 12oz (side)
$4.99Ranch (3.25 oz)
$1.50Pizza Sauce (side)
$1.50Fried Dough
$5.99Wing Sauce Side
Chicken

Chicken Wings (10)
Fresh, NEVER FROZEN jumbo chicken wings, fried perfectly and sauced any way you'd like!$16.50
Chicken Wings (20)
Fresh, NEVER FROZEN jumbo chicken wings, fried perfectly and sauced any way you'd like!$29.50
Chicken Wings (30)
Fresh, NEVER FROZEN jumbo chicken wings, fried perfectly and sauced any way you'd like!$38.50
Chicken Wings (50)
$63.99
Boneless Chicken Wings (10)
$13.20
Boneless Chicken Wings (20)
$23.60
Boneless Chicken Wings (30)
$30.80
Boneless Chicken Wings (50)
$51.20
Chicken Fingers (5)
$16.50
Chicken Fingers (10)
$28.50
Chicken Fingers (20)
$47.99
Subs and wraps
12" Assorted Sub
$12.99OUT OF STOCK12" B-L-T Sub
$12.99OUT OF STOCK12" Capicola Sub
$12.99OUT OF STOCK12" Chicken Finger Sub
$12.99OUT OF STOCK12" Ham Sub
$12.99OUT OF STOCK12" Pizza Sub
$11.99OUT OF STOCK12" Salami Sub
$12.99OUT OF STOCK12" Steak & Cheese Sub
$13.99OUT OF STOCK12" Steak Hogie
$14.99OUT OF STOCK12" Stinger Hogie
$15.99OUT OF STOCK12" Turkey Club Sub
$12.99OUT OF STOCK12" Turkey Sub
$12.99OUT OF STOCKAssorted Sub Half
$8.99OUT OF STOCKB-L-T Sub Half
$8.99OUT OF STOCKCapicola Sub Half
$8.99OUT OF STOCKChicken Finger Sub Half
$9.99OUT OF STOCKHam Sub Half
$8.99OUT OF STOCKPizza Sub Half
$7.99OUT OF STOCKSalami Sub Half
$8.99OUT OF STOCKSteak & Cheese Sub Half
$9.99OUT OF STOCKSteak Hogie Half
$10.99OUT OF STOCKStinger Hogie Half
$11.99OUT OF STOCKTurkey Club Half
$8.99OUT OF STOCKTurkey Sub Half
$8.99OUT OF STOCK
HAMBURG LUNCH SPECIALS 11am - 4pm
1 Slice & Fries & Fountain
$8.992 Slice & Frie & Fountain
$10.996" Sub & Frie & Fountain (Excludes Steak and Stinger Subs)
$11.99OUT OF STOCK6" Sub & Small Caeser Salad & Fountain (Excludes Steak and Stinger Subs)
$11.99OUT OF STOCK6" Sub & Small Chef Salad & Fountain (Excludes Stinger and Steak Subs)
$11.99OUT OF STOCK6" Sub & 5 Wings & Fountain (Excludes Steak and Stinger Subs, Specialty Sauces Extra)
$14.99OUT OF STOCK3 Fingers & Frie & Fountain (Specialty Sauces Extra)
$11.99OUT OF STOCK2 Fingers & Slice & Fountain (Specialty Sauces Extra)
$11.99OUT OF STOCK2 Slices & 2 Breadstx & Fountain
$9.00OUT OF STOCK1 Slice & 2 Breadstx & Fountain
$5.49OUT OF STOCK
Kids Meals
Main Menu (Copy)
Large Pizzas

Large Cheese Pizza (Top Your Own)
Classic cheese pizza, with the option to add any and as many toppings as you'd like for an aditional fee! Homemade dough, sauce, and hand-cut cheese and pepperoni!$23.99
Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza (Large)
With well over a POUND of hand-cut mozzarella cheese and half a pound of hand-cut pepperoni, this pizza will satisfy all of your cravings and then some- with your choice of any of our 3 sauces$31.75
Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza (Large)
The base made with our original bleu cheese and medium sauce, chicken fingers sauced any way you like, and a pound of fresh mozzarella cooked to perfection$33.50
5 Cheese Garlic Pizza (Large)
Delight your taste buds with our luxurious Five Cheese Pizza! Starting with a delectable butter garlic base that adds a subtle richness, we layer on a symphony of cheeses for the ultimate cheesy indulgence. The star-studded lineup includes sharp and nutty Romano, creamy American, classic Swiss, gooey mozzarella, and bold cheddar cheeses. Each cheese brings its unique flavor profile, creating a beautiful blend of scrumptious goodness in every bite. Whether you're a cheese connoisseur or simply crave a cheesy delight, this pizza is sure to satisfy your cravings and leave you wanting more!$31.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch (Large)
Immerse yourself in the exquisite flavors of our gourmet Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, a culinary masterpiece that tantalizes the taste buds! Crafted with a lusciously creamy Ranch base, boasting a harmonious blend of tanginess and silkiness, this pizza is a symphony of flavors. Loaded with succulent chicken weighing over a pound, paired with crispy, savory bacon, each bite is a perfect combination of succulence and smokiness. Topped with a decadent layer of melted mozzarella, this pizza embodies indulgence in every cheesy, savory, and creamy mouthful—a must try!$33.50
Papa's White Pizza (Large)
Indulge in our delectable White Pizza, crafted with a homemade olive oil-based white sauce that's rich and savory. Adorned with a harmonious medley of sweet onions, juicy tomatoes, and vibrant spinach leaves, each bite is a symphony of freshness and flavor. Customize your pizza with your choice of crispy bacon for a smoky punch or hearty Italian sausage for a savory delight. We then sprinkle a generous helping of Romano cheese, adding a nutty depth to the ensemble, and finish with a blanket of melty mozzarella that ties everything together in cheesy perfection. It's a culinary masterpiece that promises a symphony of flavors in every mouthful!$31.50
Steak + 5 Cheese Pizza (Large)
Indulge in a flavor extravaganza with our Steak and Five Cheese Pizza, a culinary marvel that promises to tantalize your taste buds! Our pizza begins with a luxurious garlic butter base, infusing each slice with richness and aroma. Featuring a hearty pound of succulent steak, prepared in our unique house hoagie style, it brings a tender and savory delight to every bite. Enhancing this masterpiece are delicate touches of caramelized onions, earthy mushrooms, and a delightful medley of sweet and tangy banana peppers. The star-studded cheese ensemble—sharp Romano, velvety American, traditional Swiss, stretchy mozzarella, and robust cheddar—creates a masterpiece of textures and flavors that dance on your palate. Prepare for an unforgettable pizza experience that is bold, savory, and utterly satisfying!$34.75
Steak in the Grass Pizza (Large)
Starts with a garlic butter base, topped with spinach, and 1-pound of steak cooked in our house hoagie sauce. Finished with mozzarella.$34.75
Stinger Pizza (Large)
$39.50
Veggie Pizza (Large)
Choice of pizza sauce, top with ANY 3 VEGGIE toppings of your choosing. Additional toppings will charge extra.$30.50
White Pizza (Large)
Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, tomatoes, and Romano, with a mozzarella finish.$28.50
Half Pizzas

Half Cheese Pizza (Top Your Own)
With your choice of sauce, and any toppings you crave, it doesn't get better than this!$13.99
Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza (Half)
Starts with house pizza sauce (sweet or regular), topped with nearly a pound cheese, and fresh cut aged margherita pepperoni.$19.25
Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza (Half)
Homemade blue cheese base, with nearly a pound of chicken fingers (sauced any way you like), with a mozzarella finish. Treat yourself today!$18.75
5 Cheese Garlic Pizza (Half)
Butter garlic base, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.$16.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch (Half)
Ranch base, over a pound of chicken fingers, bacon, with mozzarella finish.$18.75
Papa's White Pizza (Half)
Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, tomatoes, spinach, and your choice of bacon or Italian sausage. Romano, with a mozzarella finish.$17.75
Steak + 5 Cheese Pizza (Half)
Starts with a garlic butter base, with a pound steak (cooked in our house hoagie), light amount of onions, sweet and banana peppers, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.$20.75
Steak in the Grass Pizza (Half)
Starts with a garlic butter base, topped with spinach, and 1-pound of steak cooked in our house hoagie sauce. Finished with mozzarella.$20.75
Stinger Pizza (Half)
Starts with homemade blue-cheese base, 1.5 pounds of steak and chicken finger (sauced anyway you like), topped with mozzarella.$21.75
Veggie Pizza (Half)
Red sauce base (regular or sweet), choose your three veggie toppings.$16.75
White Pizza (Half)
Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, tomatoes, and Romano, with a mozzarella finish.$16.75
Quarter Pizzas

Quarter Cheese Pizza (Top Your Own)
Choice of sauce, mozzarella cheese, and choice of any toppings you like!$8.99
Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza (1/4)
$12.25
Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza (1/4)
Homemade blue cheese base, with over a pound of chicken fingers (sauced any way you like), with a mozzarella finish.$12.50
5 Cheese Garlic Pizza (1/4)
Butter garlic base, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.$11.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch (1/4)
Ranch base, over a pound of chicken fingers, crispy bacon, with a mozzarella finish.$12.50
Papa's White Pizza (1/4)
Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, tomatoes, spinach, and your choice of bacon or Italian sausage. Romano, with a mozzarella finish.$12.25
Steak + 5 Cheese Pizza (1/4)
Starts with a garlic butter base, with a pound steak (cooked in our house hoagie), onions, mushrooms, sweet and banana peppers, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses.$12.50
Steak in the Grass Pizza (1/4)
Starts with a garlic butter base, topped with spinach, and 1-pound of steak cooked in our house hoagie sauce. Finished with mozzarella.$12.50
Stinger Pizza (1/4)
Starts with homemade blue-cheese base, 1.5 pounds of steak and chicken finger (sauced anyway you like), topped with mozzarella.$13.50Veggie Pizza (1/4)
$12.25
White Pizza (1/4)
Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, tomatoes, and Romano, with a mozzarella finish.$11.75
Specials

Sheet Cheese + 50 Boneless Wings (Toppings $7.00)
$74.99
Large Cheese + 20 Boneless Wings (Toppings $4.00)
$40.99
Half Cheese + 10 Boneless Wings (Toppings $2.25)
$24.25
Quarter Cheese + 10 Boneless Wings (Toppings $1.50)
$19.50Sheet Cheese + 50 Wings (Toppings $7.00)
$84.99
Large Cheese + 20 Wings (Toppings $4.00)
$45.99
Half Cheese + 10 Wings (Toppings $2.25)
$26.74
Quarter Cheese + 10 Wings (Toppings $1.50)
$20.50
Sheet Pizzas
Sheet Cheese Pizza (Top Your Own)
$38.99Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza (Sheet)
$52.50Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza (Sheet)
$59.505 Cheese Garlic Pizza (Sheet)
$44.50Chicken Bacon Ranch (Sheet)
$59.50Papa's White Pizza (Sheet)
$55.50Steak + 5 Cheese Pizza (Sheet)
$62.50Steak in the Grass Pizza (Sheet)
$62.50Stinger Pizza (Sheet)
$67.50Veggie Pizza (Sheet)
$55.50White Pizza (Sheet)
$46.50
Sides

Fries
$5.99Pizza Logs with Fries (4)
$8.75OUT OF STOCKPizza Logs with Fries (8)
$14.75OUT OF STOCK
Mozzarella Sticks (5)
$6.95
Bread Sticks (3,5,12)
$3.99Bread Stick (1)
$1.49
Pizza Logs (4)
$6.95OUT OF STOCKPizza Logs (8)
$12.95OUT OF STOCK
Onion Rings (10)
$7.99
Jalapeno Poppers (5)
$8.99BBQ Sauce (side)
$0.75
Blue Cheese (side)
$1.50
Blue Cheese 12oz (side)
$4.99Ranch (3.25 oz)
$1.50Pizza Sauce (side)
$1.50Fried Dough
$5.99
Chicken

Chicken Wings (10)
Fresh, NEVER FROZEN jumbo chicken wings, fried perfectly and sauced any way you'd like!$16.50
Chicken Wings (20)
Fresh, NEVER FROZEN jumbo chicken wings, fried perfectly and sauced any way you'd like!$29.50
Chicken Wings (30)
Fresh, NEVER FROZEN jumbo chicken wings, fried perfectly and sauced any way you'd like!$38.50
Chicken Wings (50)
$63.99
Boneless Chicken Wings (10)
$13.20
Boneless Chicken Wings (20)
$23.60
Boneless Chicken Wings (30)
$30.80
Boneless Chicken Wings (50)
$51.20
Chicken Fingers (5)
$16.50
Chicken Fingers (10)
$28.50
Chicken Fingers (20)
$47.99
Dessert
Subs
12" Chicken Finger Sub
$12.99OUT OF STOCK12" Pizza Sub
$11.99OUT OF STOCK12" Steak & Cheese Sub
$13.99OUT OF STOCK12" Steak Hogie
$14.99OUT OF STOCK12" Stinger Hogie
$15.99OUT OF STOCKChicken Finger Sub Half
$9.99OUT OF STOCKPizza Sub Half
$7.99OUT OF STOCKSteak & Cheese Sub Half
$9.99OUT OF STOCKSteak Hogie Half
$10.99OUT OF STOCKStinger Hogie Half
$11.99OUT OF STOCK
HAMBURG LUNCH SPECIALS 11am - 4pm
1 Slice & Fries & Fountain
$8.992 Slice & Frie & Fountain
$10.996" Sub & Frie & Fountain (Excludes Steak and Stinger Subs)
$11.99OUT OF STOCK6" Sub & Small Caeser Salad & Fountain (Excludes Steak and Stinger Subs)
$11.99OUT OF STOCK6" Sub & Small Chef Salad & Fountain (Excludes Stinger and Steak Subs)
$11.99OUT OF STOCK6" Sub & 5 Wings & Fountain (Excludes Steak and Stinger Subs, Specialty Sauces Extra)
$14.99OUT OF STOCK3 Fingers & Frie & Fountain (Specialty Sauces Extra)
$11.99OUT OF STOCK2 Fingers & Slice & Fountain (Specialty Sauces Extra)
$11.99OUT OF STOCK2 Slices & 2 Breadstx & Fountain
$9.00OUT OF STOCK1 Slice & 2 Breadstx & Fountain
$5.49OUT OF STOCK
Salads
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location