Skip to Main content
  • Pizza Boys

    • Home
    • /
    • New York Mills
    • /
    • Pizza Boys
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image
    American

    Pizza Boys

    9 Clinton St

    New York Mills, NY 13417


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Food
    Catering
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • Chef Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, banana peppers, mozzarella cheese, turkey, ham and croutons
      $12.99
    • Fish & Shrimp Dinner

      Served with coconut shrimp, grandma's coleslaw, fries, garlic toast, tartar and mango salsa
      $22.99
    • 2 Large 16" Pizzas & 50 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizzas - toppings extra
      $89.99

    Food

    Pizza

    • Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza

      Personal 10" pizza - cheese or garlic - 6 cut
      $12.99
    • Personal Pizza 10"

      Cheese or garlic - 6 cut
      $11.99
    • Medium Pizza 14"

      Cheese or garlic - 8 cut
      $16.99
    • Large Pizza 16"

      Cheese or garlic - 8 cut
      $19.99
    • X-Large 18"

      Cheese or garlic - 10 cut
      $21.99

    Specialty Pizzas

    • Gold Dust Chicken

      Gold dust chicken and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • The Grandma

      Served only one size. Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, fresh garlic, and plum tomato
      $31.99
    • Buffalo Chicken

      Buffalo sauce, grilled chicken, and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch

      Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch, and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Sicilian Upside Down

      Served only one size
      $25.99
    • Carnivore

      Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, ham, bacon, and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Stoner Fry Pizza

      Secret stoner sauce, french fries, bacon & mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Hawaiian

      Ham, pineapple, bacon and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Mac Daddy

      The secret sauce, ground beef, tomato, onion, mozzarella, and American cheese. Topped with lettuce
      $15.99+
    • Tree Hugger

      Tomato, onion, broccoli, garlic, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Mac & Cheese

      (May add bacon). Cheddar cheese sauce, pasta, and mozzarella cheese. Topped with breadcrumbs
      $15.99+
    • Philly Steak

      Mushrooms, peppers, onions, white American and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • PB+J Pizza

      PB+J sauce, crispy chicken & mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • E.B.A (Everything but Anchovies)

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, peppers, onions and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Popeye's Pie

      Fresh spinach, tomatoes, garlic, ricotta and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Balsmic Tuscan Pizza

      $15.99+
    • Gluten Free Grandma

      $17.99
    • BBQ Chicken Pizza

      $15.99+
    • NYS Upside Down Pizza

      $15.99+

    Slice

    • Cheese Slice

      $3.25
    • Pepperoni Slice

      $3.75
    • Gold Dust Slice

      $4.00
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice

      $4.00

    Calzones

    • Original Calzone

      Stuffed with mozzarella and ricotta cheese. Served with a side of marinara
      $12.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Calzone

      Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, mozzarella cheese & ricotta cheese. Served with a side of blue cheese. Served with blue cheese dressing
      $14.99
    • Gold Dust Calzone

      Grilled or crispy chicken, gold dust sauce, mozzarella & ricotta chesse
      $14.99
    • Godfather Calzone

      Capicola ham, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella & ricotta cheese
      $15.99
    • Stoner Fry Calzone

      Secret stoner fry sauce, french fries bacon, mozzarella cheese & ricotta cheese
      $15.99
    • Philly Cheesesteak Calzone

      Supreme Angus philly steak, mushrooms, peppers, onions, mozzarella & ricotta cheese. Served with a side of marinara sauce
      $16.99
    • Boom Boom Chicken Calzone

      Grilled or crispy chicken, boom boom sauce, mozzarella & ricotta cheese
      $15.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone

      Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch, mozzarella cheese & ricotta cheese. Served with a side of ranch
      $15.99
    • Popeye Calzone

      Spinach, tomato, garlic sauce, mozzarella & ricotta cheese
      $15.99

    Pizza & Wing Deals

    • Personal 10" Pizza & 1/2 Dozen Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $18.99
    • Medium 14" Pizza & 10 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $28.99
    • Medium 14" Pizza & 20 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $40.99
    • 2 Medium 14" Pizzas & 30 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizzas - toppings extra
      $65.99
    • Large 16" Pizza & 20 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $44.99
    • Large 16" Pizza & 30 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $55.99
    • 2 Large 16" Pizzas & 50 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizzas - toppings extra
      $89.99
    • X-Large 18" Pizza & 50 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $79.99

    Wings

    • Wings (10 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $14.99
    • Wings (20 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $29.98
    • Wings (30 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $44.97
    • Wings (40 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $59.96
    • Wings (50 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $74.95
    • Wings (60 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $89.94
    • Wings (6 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $8.99
    • Wings (10 Pieces) (Copy)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $14.99
    • Wings (10 Pieces) (Copy)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $14.99

    Appetizers

    • Mozzarella Sticks (7 Pieces)

      With marinara sauce
      $11.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Dip

      With tortilla chips
      $10.99
    • Cheesy Breadsticks

      Add marinara sauce for an additional charge
      $12.99
    • Serious Sampler

      Three mozzarella sticks, three chicken tenders, three boneless buffalo wings, onion petals, and french fries
      $18.99
    • Loaded Tots

      Tater Tots loaded with nacho cheese, bacon and chives served with sour cream
      $9.99
    • Greens

      Our delicious Utica greens
      $10.99
    • Onion Petals

      Served with boom boom sauce
      $9.99
    • Mac N' Cheese Balls

      Served with marinara sauce
      $12.99
    • Sweet Potato Wedges

      With ranch dressing
      $9.99
    • Loaded Fries

      Fries loaded with nacho cheese, bacon and chives served with sour cream
      $9.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Quesadilla

      Tortilla stuffed with grilled chicken, bacon, diced tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese
      $12.99
    • Cheese Curds

      Served with marinara sauce and spicy Melba habanero sauce,
      $11.99
    • Super Nachos

      Nachos, nacho cheese, ground beef or grilled chicken, black olives, onions, tomatoes, cherry peppers, sour cream, and mango salsa
      $15.99
    • Buffalo Mozzarella Sticks

      Served with blue cheese dressing
      $12.99
    • Deep Fried Pickles (7 Pieces)

      With boom boom sauce and ranch
      $11.99
    • Garlic Parm Fries

      French fries tossed in our famous garlic sauce topped with Parmesan cheese
      $8.99
    • Pretzel Bites (12 Pieces)

      Dozens pretzel bites served with cheese sauce
      $9.99
    • Buffalo Mac N' Cheese Balls

      Mac n cheese balls topped with buffalo sauce and crumby blue. Served with a side of blue cheese
      $13.99

    Salads

    • Buffalo Chicken Salad

      Lettuce, chopped buffalo chicken tender, tomato, mozzarella cheese, and croutons
      $12.99
    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

      Romaine lettuce, mozzarella cheese, house Caesar dressing and croutons
      $11.99
    • Boom Boom Grilled Chicken Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, mozzarella cheese and croutons
      $12.99
    • Chef Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, banana peppers, mozzarella cheese, turkey, ham and croutons
      $12.99
    • Taco Salad

      Tortilla chips, ground beef or grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, cherry peppers, black olives, onions, mozzarella and nacho cheese, sour cream, and salsa
      $12.99
    • BLT Salad

      Lettuce, bacon, tomato, mozzarella cheese and croutons
      $11.99
    • Antipasto Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, banana peppers, provolone cheese, cappi ham, hard salami, pepperoni and croutons
      $12.99
    • Garden Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, and croutons
      $4.99

    Melts

    • French Dip Melt

      Hormel Angus roast beef, mozzarella cheese, and savory au jus sauce
      $11.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Melt

      Crispy chicken, house ranch dressing, tomato & mozzarella chesse
      $11.99
    • Reuben Melt

      Corned beef chunks, Russian dressing, sauerkraut, & Grade A Swiss cheese
      $11.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Melt

      Crispy chicken, medium buffalo sauce, tomato & mozzarella cheese
      $11.99
    • Chicken Parmesan Melt

      Crispy chicken, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese
      $11.99
    • Steak & Cheese Melt

      Certified Angus sirloin steak, peppers, mushrooms, onion & mozzarella cheese
      $11.99
    • Turkey Bacon Melt

      Antibiotic free roasted turkey, hormel bacon, tomato, & American cheese
      $11.99
    • The Italian Melt

      Authentic cappicola ham, pepperoni, Genoa salami, tomato & provolone cheese
      $11.99
    • Tuna Melt

      Our signature tuna salad, tomato & American cheese
      $11.99
    • Ham & Cheese Melt

      Hormel ham, American cheese and tomato
      $11.99

    Paninis

    • Gold Dust Chicken Panini

      Crispy chicken, gold dust sauce and provolone cheese
      $11.99
    • Godfather Panini

      Authentic cappicola ham, salami, pepperoni, tomato, onion, provolone cheese and pesto mayo
      $11.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Panini

      Crispy chicken, tomatoes, provolone, and house ranch dressing
      $11.99
    • Meatball Panini

      Fontinini meatballs, mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce
      $11.99
    • Roast Beef Panini

      Roast beef, tomato, onion, provolone, and pesto mayo
      $11.99
    • Roasted Turkey Panini

      Roasted antibiotic free turkey, tomatoes, onions, provolone, and pesto mayo
      $11.99
    • Chicken Cordon Bleu Panini

      Crispy chicken, hormel ham, Swiss cheese, and honey mustard
      $11.99
    • French Dip Panini

      $11.99
    • Caprese Panini

      $11.99

    Subs & Wraps

    • Boom Boom Chicken Wrap

      Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, pickle, mozzarella cheese & boom boom sauce
      $13.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

      Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, bacon & ranch dressing
      $13.99
    • Chicken Caesar Wrap

      Grilled chicken, lettuce, mozzarella cheese, and Caesar dressing. Wrap only
      $13.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato, mozzarella cheese and bleu cheese dressing (wrap only)
      $13.99
    • Turkey Sub.

      Antibiotic free turkey
      $11.99
    • Italian Mix.

      Citterio capicola ham, Genoa salami, deli pepperoni and galbani provolone cheese
      $12.99
    • Tuna.

      Our delicious tuna salad recipe
      $11.99
    • Turkey Club.

      Our turkey sub with a toasted roll served with bacon. Antibiotic free, vegetarian grain fed turkey!
      $12.99
    • Chicken Club.

      Toasted served with bacon
      $12.99
    • Mixed.

      Hormel ham, deli pepperoni, Genoa salami & white American cheese
      $11.99
    • BLT.

      Hormel smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo on a toasted sub roll
      $12.99
    • Roast Beef.

      Hormel top round beef
      $11.99
    • Ham.

      Hormel cooked ham
      $11.99
    • Cheeseburger Sub.

      American cheese, lettuce, pickle, onion, mayo, ketchup, and mustard on a toasted roll
      $12.99

    Hot Subs

    • Philly Cheesesteak

      Sirloin Angus steak with mushrooms, peppers, onions & mozzarella cheese
      $12.99
    • Chicken Parmesan Sub

      Crispy chicken, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese
      $12.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Sub.

      Crispy chicken, buffalo sauce & mozzarella cheese
      $12.99
    • Gold Dust Chicken Sub.

      Crispy chicken, gold dust sauce & mozzarella cheese
      $14.99
    • Reuben

      Corned beef, Russian dressing, sauerkraut & Swiss cheese
      $12.99+
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch

      Crispy chicken, ranch dressing & mozzarella cheese
      $12.99+
    • Steak & Cheddar

      Sirloin Angus steak with mushrooms, peppers, onions & nacho Cheddar cheese
      $13.99+
    • Meatball

      Marinara sauce, meatballs & mozzarella cheese
      $12.99+
    • Fish Sub

      Icelandic beer battered haddock, white American cheese, lettuce & tartar sauce. On a toasted sub roll
      $15.99

    Smash Burgers

    • Deluxe Cheeseburger

      American cheese, pickles, onions, mayo, ketchup & brown mustard
      $13.99
    • Deluxe Bacon Cheeseburger

      Bacon, American cheese, pickles, onions, mayo, ketchup & brown mustard
      $14.99
    • Bleu Burger

      Lettuce and tomato. Topped with blue cheese dressing and crumply blue
      $14.99
    • Boom Boom Burger

      Provolone cheese, pickles, lettuce & boom boom sauce
      $13.99
    • Road House BBQ Bacon Burger

      Topped with onion petals and provolone cheese
      $14.99
    • Bacon, Mushroom & Swiss Burger

      Lettuce and tomato
      $14.99

    Fish, Baskets & Chicken Sandwhiches

    • Chicken Tender Basket (5 Pieces)

      With dipping sauce
      $13.99
    • Fish Fry Dinner

      Served with grandma's coleslaw, fries, tartar sauce, and garlic toast
      $18.99
    • Chicken Sandwich

      Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato, pickles, American cheese, and mayo
      $13.99
    • Nashville Honey Hot Chicken Sandwich

      Crispy chicken, Nashville honey hot sauce, coleslaw & chopped dill pickles
      $13.99
    • Fish Tacos

      3 beer battered Icelandic haddock fish tacos, coleslaw & remoulade sauce
      $14.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

      Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato, American cheese, and bleu cheese dressing
      $13.99
    • Fish & Chips Basket

      Icelandic beer battered haddock served with tartar sauce or cocktail sauce
      $14.99
    • Boneless Buffalo Wings 7 Pieces

      Dipped in your choice of wing sauce, served with blue cheese dressing
      $7.49
    • Coconut Shrimp Basket

      Seven pieces. Served with mango salsa
      $14.99
    • Fish & Shrimp Dinner

      Served with coconut shrimp, grandma's coleslaw, fries, garlic toast, tartar and mango salsa
      $22.99
    • Fried Clam Basket

      Clam strips served with tartar or cocktail sauce
      $12.99
    • Boom Boom Chicken Sandwich

      Crispy chicken, lettuce, pickles & boom boom sauce
      $13.99
    • Boom Boom Shrimp Basket

      Southern Style Fried Shrimp Tossed in Boom Boom Sauce
      $14.99
    • Shrimp Tacos

      Coleslaw, Lettuce, & spicy remoulade sauce
      $14.99

    Pasta Dinners

    • Chicken Riggies

      Penne pasta, riggie sauce, grilled chicken, sautéed onion, green & cherry peppers
      $15.00
    • Chicken Parmesan Over Ziti

      Penne pasta, marinara sauce, crispy chicken & melted mozzarella cheese
      $18.99
    • Ziti with Meatballs

      Penne pasta, marinara sauce & meatballs
      $17.99
    • Chicken Broccoli Alfredo

      Penne pasta, Alfredo sauce, grilled chicken & broccoli
      $19.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Pasta

      Penne pasta, buffalo pasta sauce, grilled chicken, blue cheese crumbles & mozzarella cheese
      $17.99
    • Baked Ziti

      Penne pasta, marinara sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese
      $16.99
    • Family Baked Pasta

      $24.99

    Sides

    • Garlic Knots

    • French Fries

      $4.99
    • 4 Meatballs

      Served with sauce
      $7.99
    • Seasoned Waffle Fries

      $4.99
    • Tater Tots

      $4.99
    • Nachos

      Served with cheese
      $6.99
    • Garlic Toast

      $4.99
    • Chips & Mango Salsa

      $5.99
    • Curly Fries

      $4.99

    Dipping Sauces

    • BBQ Sauce

      Our BBQ dipping sauce offers a blend of smoky, savory, and slightly sweet flavors, making it an ideal complement for a variety of dishes
      $1.49
    • Blue Cheese Sauce

      A creamy blend of blue cheese typically includes tangy notes and may be enhanced with buttermilk or garlic for a rich dipping experience
      $1.49
    • Blue Hot

      Blue Cheese and Hot Sauce
      $1.49
    • Boom Boom Sauce

      Boom boom sauce typically includes a creamy base with sweet and spicy flavors, often incorporating chili and garlic to create a bold dipping experience
      $1.49
    • Gold Dust Sauce

      Grilled or crispy chicken, gold dust sauce, mozzarella & ricotta cheese, served with gold dust sauce
      $1.49
    • Honey Mustard Sauce

      A blend of sweet honey and tangy mustard, this dipping sauce combines flavors to complement a variety of dishes
      $1.49
    • Hot Sauce

      A spicy blend, typically incorporating chili peppers and other seasonings, ideal for adding a kick to various dishes
      $1.49
    • Inferno Sauce

      $1.49
    • Marinara Sauce

      $1.49
    • Melba Habanero Sauce

      $1.49
    • Mild Sauce

      A cup of our Italian-inspired mild sauce, typically includes a blend of tomatoes and subtle herbs for a smooth taste
      $1.49
    • Nacho Cheese

      Creamy nacho cheese sauce, often enriched with spices for added depth
      $1.49
    • Pesto Mayo Sauce

      Our BBQ dipping sauce offers a blend of smoky, savory, and slightly sweet flavors, making it an ideal complement for a variety of dishes
      $1.49
    • Ranch Sauce

      A creamy blend of buttermilk, herbs, and spices, typically including garlic and onion for a versatile dipping experience
      $2.98
    • Russian Dressing

      $1.49
    • Salsa

      $1.49
    • Sour Cream

      $1.49
    • Sweet n Sour Sauce

      $1.49
    • Sweet n Tangy

      $1.49
    • Tarter Sauce

      $1.49
    • Celery and Blue Cheese

      $3.49

    Desserts

    • Deep-Fried OREOs

      OREOs are enveloped in a light, crisp batter and deep-fried, then typically dusted with powdered sugar
      $5.99
    • Cinni Sweet Sticks

      Our fresh pizza dough stretched 10" topped with cinnamon sugar & hot icing
      $9.99
    • OREO Cream Pie

      An OREO cream pie consists of a cookie crumb crust filled with a smooth, creamy mixture, often featuring chunks of OREO cookies throughout
      $5.99
    • Cannoli

      Flaky pastry filled with a delightful creamy filling, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth
      $2.99
    • S'mores Cheesecake

      A creamy cheesecake infused with the essence of s'mores, typically includes a graham cracker crust, chocolate chips, and a marshmallow topping
      $6.99
    • Strawberry Cheesecake

      Creamy cheesecake with a strawberry topping, perfect for strawberry lovers
      $6.99
    • Marshmallow Rice Crispy Treat

      A marshmallow rice crispy treat typically consists of melted marshmallows mixed with crispy rice cereal, often resulting in a chewy and slightly crunchy texture
      $3.50
    • Plain Cheesecake

      $5.99
    • Peanut Butter Pie

      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.99

    Drinks

    • 20 Oz Beverages

      Coca-Cola products
      $2.75
    • 2 Ltr Beverages

      Coca-Cola products
      $4.50

    Kids Menu

    • 2 Chicken tenders w/Fries

      served with BBQ sauce
      $7.99
    • Cheese Quesadilla

      served with sour cream
      $7.99
    • 2 Mozzarella Sticks w/ Fries

      served with marinara sauce
      $7.99
    • Noodles w/ Sauce &Parm CHeese

      $7.99
    • Noodles w/ Butter & Parm Cheese

      $7.99

    Catering

    • 100 Chicken Wings

      $125.00
    • 2 Large Cheese & 50 Wings

      $90.00
    • 2 Large Pizzas & 50 Chicken Wings

      $90.00
    • 5 Large Cheese Pizzas

      $75.00
    • 5 Large Cheese Pizzas (toppings extra)

      $75.00
    • Antipasto Roll

      $30.00
    • Antipasto Salad Full Tray

      $75.00
    • Antipasto Salad Half Tray

      $40.00
    • Assorted Sub Platter (30 pc)

      $75.00
    • Baked Ziti w/ Mozzerella Full Tray

      $75.00
    • Baked Ziti w/ Mozzerella Half Tray

      $40.00
    • Buffalo Chicken Roll

      $30.00
    • Celery & Blue Cheese Platter

      $20.00
    • Chicken Ceasar Salad Full Tray

      $75.00
    • Chicken Ceasar Salad Half Tray

      $40.00
    • Chicken Rigges Full Tray

      $110.00
    • Chicken Rigges Half Tray

      $60.00
    • Crispy Chicken Tenders w/ Dip (25 pc)

      $45.00
    • Dinner Rolls with Butter (30 pc)

      $19.00
    • Dozen Cannolis

      $30.00
    • Garden Tossed Salad Full Tray

      $55.00
    • Garden Tossed Salad Half Tray

      $30.00
    • Garlic Bread (30 pc)

      $25.00
    • Garlic Knots (30 pc)

      $25.00
    • Italian Fare

      $11.99
    • Meatballs In Sauce Full Tray

      $90.00
    • Meatballs In Sauce Half Tray

      $55.00
    • Premium Italian Fare

      $14.99
    • Sausage & Peppers Full Tray

      $90.00
    • Sausage & Peppers Half Tray

      $55.00
    • Spinach Roll

      $30.00
    • Stromboli Roll

      $30.00
    • Utica Greens Full Tray

      $110.00
    • Utica Greens Half Tray

      $60.00
    • Utica Tomato Pie

      $17.00

    All hours
    Sunday10:45 am - 9:00 pm
    Monday10:45 am - 9:00 pm
    Tuesday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Wednesday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Thursday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Friday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Saturday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy! "You Just Can't Get Enough"

    Location

    9 Clinton St, New York Mills, NY 13417

    Directions