Skip to Main content

  • Pizza Secret 72 5th Ave

    • Home
    • /
    • Brooklyn
    • /
    • Pizza Secret 72 5th Ave
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    Pizza Secret 72 5th Ave

    72 5th Ave

    Brooklyn, NY 11217

    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant

    Call

    Hours

    Website

    Directions

    ANTIPASTI
    PRIMI
    SIDES
    SALADS
    SMALL PIZZAS 12"
    LARGE PIZZAS 18"
    SECONDI
    DOLCI
    BEVERAGES

    ANTIPASTI

    • POLPETTE DELLA NONNA

      Beef meatballs, San Marzano tomato, Parmigiano, basil.
      $20.00

    • CROCCHETTONE 2.0

      Potato croquette, fior di latte, pecorino fondue, black pepper.
      $8.00

    • BURRATA & PROSCIUTTO DI PARMA

      Creamy burrata, Prosciutto di Parma D.O.P., basil, EVOO.
      $23.00

    • POLPO ALLA LUCIANA

      Baby octopus, San Marzano tomato, Gaeta olives, garlic.
      $22.00

    • VITELLO TONNATO

      Thinly sliced veal, arugula, lemon, capers, Parmigiano.
      $23.00

    • BEEF TARTARE

      Prime beef, capers, Dijon, egg yolk, grilled sourdough.
      $26.00

    • FRITTATINA NAPOLETANA

      Fried pasta, béchamel, Genovese ragù.
      $10.00

    • MONTANARA

      Fried dough, San Marzano tomato, Parmigiano, basil.
      $15.00

    • ARANCINI

      Crispy rice, Bolognese ragù, mozzarella.
      $10.00

    • CALAMARI FRITTI

      Lightly fried calamari, aioli.
      $20.00

    • ZUCCHINI FLOWERS

      Ricotta, zucchini cream.
      $19.00

    • TAGLIERE ITALIANO

      Italian cured meats, cheeses, olives, taralli, honey
      $28.00

    • PARMIGIANA DI MELANZANE

      Eggplant, San Marzano tomato, mozzarella, Parmigiano.
      $20.00

    PRIMI

    • BOLOGNESE

      Slow-cooked beef ragù, San Marzano tomato, Parmigiano.
      $24.00

    • GENOVESE

      Slow onions, braised beef.
      $25.00

    • SCARPARIELLO 2.0

      Cherry tomatoes, garlic, basil, pecorino, Parmigiano.
      $23.00

    • CACIO E PEPE

      Pecorino Romano, black pepper.
      $21.00

    • SAUSAGE & BROCCOLI CRUNCH

      Italian sausage, broccoli, garlic, chili, crispy panko.
      $23.00

    • TRUFFLE PASTA (TABLESIDE FINISH)

      Creamy Parmigiano, black truffle.
      $35.00

    • VONGOLE & PISTACHIO

      Clams, garlic, white wine, parsley, pistachio.
      $28.00

    SIDES

    • FRENCH FRIES

      Sea salt.
      $10.00

    • FRIARIELLI

      Garlic, chili, EVOO.
      $12.00

    • ARTICHOKES

      Crispy, lemon.
      $12.00

    • ZUCCHINI SCAPECE

      Mint, garlic, vinegar.
      $11.00

    SALADS

    • CAPRESE DI BUFALA

      Buffalo mozzarella, basil, EVOO.
      $20.00

    • BEET & GOAT CHEESE

      Arugula, walnuts, and balsamic.
      $18.00

    • SECRET CAESAR

      Romaine, Parmigiano, anchovy dressing, croutons.
      $18.00

    SMALL PIZZAS 12"

    • MARINARA 12"

      Tomato, Sicilian oregano, garlic, basil, EVOO.
      $18.00

    • MARGHERITA 12'

      Tomato, fior di latte, Parmigiano, basil, EVOO.
      $21.00

    • AMERICANA 12"

      Tomato, fior di latte, pepperoni, hot honey, basil.
      $23.00

    • BUFALA 12"

      Buffalo mozzarella, Parmigiano, cherry tomatoes, basil, EVOO.
      $23.00

    • PARMA 12"

      Fior di latte, Parmigiano, arugula, Prosciutto di Parma, Grana Padano, basil, EVOO.
      $25.00

    • PROVOLA & PEPE 12'

      Cherry tomato sauce, smoked mozzarella, black pepper, basil, EVOO.
      $24.00

    • SALSICCIA & FRIARIELLI 12"

      Fior di latte, Parmigiano, Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, chili, basil, EVOO.
      $24.00

    • RIPIENO AL FORNO 12"

      Ricotta, Napoli salame, smoked provola, tomato, Parmigiano, basil, EVOO.
      $24.00

    • PIZZA FRITTA

      Ricotta, cooked ham, fior di latte, tomato, basil.
      $23.00

    • MORTAZZA 12"

      Fior di latte, pistachio mortadella, lemon zest, pistachio, basil, EVOO.
      $25.00

    • NERANO 12"

      Fior di latte, zucchini pesto, stracciatella, lemon zest, zucchini chips, basil, EVOO.
      $26.00

    • FIGA 12"

      Buffalo mozzarella, cooked ham, fig jam, basil, EVOO.
      $25.00

    • FIORE 12'

      Zucchini flowers, ricotta, Napoli salame, fior di latte, basil, EVOO.
      $28.00

    • SCARPARIELLO 12"

      Double-cooked (fried then baked), cherry tomato sauce, pecorino D.O.P., basil, EVOO.
      $26.00

    • CACIO & PEPE 12"

      Pecorino fondue, fior di latte, black pepper, basil, EVOO.
      $23.00

    • LA BELLA VITA 12"

      Yellow tomato, fior di latte, basil pesto, stracciatella, Grana Padano, basil, EVOO.
      $26.00

    • CARCIOFINA 12"

      Artichoke purée, capocollo, smoked mozzarella, Parmigiano fondue, black pepper, basil, EVOO.
      $25.00

    LARGE PIZZAS 18"

    • MARINARA 18"

      Tomato, Sicilian oregano, garlic, basil, EVOO.
      $30.00

    • MARGHERITA 18"

      Tomato, fior di latte, Parmigiano, basil, EVOO.
      $32.00

    • AMERICANA 18"

      Tomato, fior di latte, pepperoni, hot honey, basil.
      $34.00

    • BUFALA 18"

      Buffalo mozzarella, Parmigiano, cherry tomatoes, basil, EVOO.
      $34.00

    • PARMA 18"

      Fior di latte, Parmigiano, arugula, Prosciutto di Parma, Grana Padano, basil, EVOO.
      $36.00

    • PROVOLA & PEPE 18"

      Cherry tomato sauce, smoked mozzarella, black pepper, basil, EVOO.
      $35.00

    • SALSICCIA & FRIARIELLI 18"

      Fior di latte, Parmigiano, Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, chili, basil, EVOO.
      $35.00

    • RIPIENO AL FORNO 18"

      Ricotta, Napoli salame, smoked provola, tomato, Parmigiano, basil, EVOO.
      $35.00

    • MORTAZZA 18"

      Fior di latte, pistachio mortadella, lemon zest, pistachio, basil, EVOO.
      $35.00

    • NERANO 18"

      Fior di latte, zucchini pesto, stracciatella, lemon zest, zucchini chips, basil, EVOO.
      $36.00

    • FIGA 18"

      Buffalo mozzarella, cooked ham, fig jam, basil, EVOO.
      $35.00

    • FIORE 18"

      Zucchini flowers, ricotta, Napoli salame, fior di latte, basil, EVOO.
      $38.00

    • SCARPARIELLO 18"

      Double-cooked (fried then baked), cherry tomato sauce, pecorino D.O.P., basil, EVOO.
      $36.00

    • CACIO & PEPE 18"

      Pecorino fondue, fior di latte, black pepper, basil, EVOO.
      $33.00

    • LA BELLA VITA 18"

      Yellow tomato, fior di latte, basil pesto, stracciatella, Grana Padano, basil, EVOO.
      $36.00

    • CARCIOFINA 18"

      Artichoke purée, capocollo, smoked mozzarella, Parmigiano fondue, black pepper, basil, EVOO.
      $35.00

    SECONDI

    • CHICKEN MILANESE

      Crispy cutlet, arugula, lemon.
      $26.00

    • BRANZINO

      Spinach, aioli, citronette.
      $30.00

    • STEAK & MASH

      Charred vegetables, pan jus.
      $34.00

    DOLCI

    • TIRAMISÙ SIGNATURE

      (Coffee Bean Shape) - Mascarpone cream, espresso, and chocolate glaze.
      $15.00

    • PANNA COTTA

      Vanilla cream, berry sauce, crumble cookies.
      $14.00

    • SECRET CANNOLI

      Ricotta, pistachio, chocolate.
      $15.00

    • DOLCE SEGRETO

      Warm pizza dough, hazelnut chocolate cream, powdered sugar.
      $16.00

    BEVERAGES

    • FERRARELLE STILL WATER

      $8.00

    • FERRARELLE SPARKLING

      $8.00

    • COCA-COLA

      $4.00

    • DIET COKE

      $4.00

    • SPRITE

      $4.00

    • ORANGE JUICE

      $4.00

    • SAN PELLEGRINO ARANCIATA

      $5.00

    • SAN PELLEGRINO LIMONATA

      $5.00
    If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

    CROCCHETTONE 2.0

    $8.00

    Potato croquette, fior di latte, pecorino fondue, black pepper.

    Request advisory
    We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
    1
    All hours
    Sunday12:00 pm - 9:45 pm
    Monday4:00 pm - 10:15 pm
    Tuesday12:00 pm - 10:15 pm
    Wednesday12:00 pm - 10:15 pm
    Thursday12:00 pm - 10:15 pm
    Friday12:00 pm - 10:45 pm
    Saturday12:00 pm - 10:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    Pizza Secret is a modern Italian destination inspired by the flavors of Naples and the energy of Brooklyn. Ranked among America’s top pizzerias, we offer award-winning pizza, fresh pasta, craft cocktails, and seasonal Italian specialties. Our mission is simple: exceptional food, warm hospitality, and memorable experiences shared around the table. Welcome to Pizza Secret — where every meal feels like a celebration.

    Location

    72 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217

    Directions