Signature Menu Items
Global Flavors
Carne Asada
1/3 pound of grilled steak with cheese sauce, cilantro-lime crema, chipotle aioli, pico de gallo and guacamole$21.49Butter Chicken
1/3 pound of grilled chicken in a creamy buttery tomato sauce, garnished with tomatoes, cilantro and garlic aioli drizzle.$17.49Habibi
1/3 pound grilled chicken, traditional shawarma sauce, cheese sauce and garlic aioli topped with onions, tomatoes, pickles and sumac.$21.49Gyro
1/3 pound grilled steak with creamy feta cheese, tzatziki sauce, onions and tomatoes.$20.49Bori BBQ
1/3 pound grilled chicken with guava BBQ sauce, cilantro-lime crema, liquid gold cheese sauce, topped with guacamole and ketchup-mayo drizzle.$16.49Patatas Bravas
In-house made smoky spicy chipotle sauce drizzled with garlic aioli, topped with cilantro.$12.99Poutine
In-house made rich silky savory gravy topped with Wisconsin cheese curds and chives.$12.99
American Favorites
OG
Crispy beef bacon with cheese sauce, sour cream and chives. A Wisconsin favorite!$19.99West Coast Connect
1/3 pound seared ground beef covered in our signature zaza sauce topped with tomatoes, onions, lettuce and drizzled with in-house made cheese sauce.$18.49East Coast Ocky
1/3 pound seared ground beef with cheese sauce, lettuce, tomatoes and onions, drizzled with ketchup-mayo.$18.49
Refreshers
Agua Frescas
Sweet Treats
Dessert
Candied Yam
Roasted sweet potato with a luxurious honey butter sauce, vanilla sweet cream, topped with crunchy glazed pecans and toasted marshmallows.$11.99Ube Coco Tres Leches
Slice of tres leches cake with ube coconut cream, luscious caramel sauce, sweet vanilla drizzle and toasted coconut flakes.$6.99Camote
Roasted sweet potato with decadent honey, sweet vanilla cream, luscious caramel sauce and aromatic cinnamon powder.$9.99
Signature Menu Items (online)
Global Flavors
Carne Asada
1/3 pound of grilled steak with cheese sauce, cilantro-lime crema, chipotle aioli, pico de gallo and guacamole$21.49Butter Chicken
1/3 pound of grilled chicken in a creamy buttery tomato sauce, garnished with tomatoes, cilantro and garlic aioli drizzle.$17.49Habibi
1/3 pound grilled chicken, traditional shawarma sauce, cheese sauce and garlic aioli topped with onions, tomatoes, pickles and sumac.$21.49Gyro
1/3 pound grilled steak with creamy feta cheese, tzatziki sauce, onions and tomatoes.$20.49Bori BBQ
1/3 pound grilled chicken with guava BBQ sauce, cilantro-lime crema, liquid gold cheese sauce, topped with guacamole and ketchup-mayo drizzle.$16.49Patatas Bravas
In-house made smoky spicy chipotle sauce drizzled with garlic aioli, topped with cilantro.$12.99Poutine
In-house made rich silky savory gravy topped with Wisconsin cheese curds and chives.$12.99
American Favorites
OG
Crispy beef bacon with cheese sauce, sour cream and chives. A Wisconsin favorite!$19.99West Coast Connect
1/3 pound seared ground beef covered in our signature zaza sauce topped with tomatoes, onions, lettuce and drizzled with in-house made cheese sauce.$18.49East Coast Ocky
1/3 pound seared ground beef with cheese sauce, lettuce, tomatoes and onions, drizzled with ketchup-mayo.$18.49
Build Your Own (online)
Refreshers (online)
Agua Frescas
Sweet Treats (online)
Dessert
Candied Yam
Roasted sweet potato with a luxurious honey butter sauce, vanilla sweet cream, topped with crunchy glazed pecans and toasted marshmallows.$11.99Ube Coco Tres Leches
Slice of tres leches cake with ube coconut cream, luscious caramel sauce, sweet vanilla drizzle and toasted coconut flakes.$6.99Camote
Roasted sweet potato with decadent honey, sweet vanilla cream, luscious caramel sauce and aromatic cinnamon powder.$9.99
Signature Menu Items (GH)
Global Flavors
Carne Asada
1/3 pound of grilled steak with cheese sauce, cilantro-lime crema, chipotle aioli, pico de gallo and guacamole$23.64Butter Chicken
1/3 pound of grilled chicken in a creamy buttery tomato sauce, garnished with tomatoes, cilantro and garlic aioli drizzle.$19.24Habibi
1/3 pound grilled chicken, traditional shawarma sauce, cheese sauce and garlic aioli topped with onions, tomatoes, pickles and sumac.$23.64Gyro
1/3 pound grilled steak with creamy feta cheese, tzatziki sauce, onions and tomatoes.$22.54Bori BBQ
1/3 pound grilled chicken with guava BBQ sauce, cilantro-lime crema, liquid gold cheese sauce, topped with guacamole and ketchup-mayo drizzle.$18.14Patatas Bravas
In-house made smoky spicy chipotle sauce drizzled with garlic aioli, topped with cilantro.$14.29Poutine
In-house made rich silky savory gravy topped with Wisconsin cheese curds and chives.$14.29
American Favorites
OG
Crispy beef bacon with cheese sauce, sour cream and chives. A Wisconsin favorite!$21.99West Coast Connect
1/3 pound seared ground beef covered in our signature zaza sauce topped with tomatoes, onions, lettuce and drizzled with in-house made cheese sauce.$20.34East Coast Ocky
1/3 pound seared ground beef with cheese sauce, lettuce, tomatoes and onions, drizzled with ketchup-mayo.$20.34
Build Your Own (GH)
Refreshers (GH)
Agua Frescas
Sweet Treats (GH)
Dessert
Candied Yam
Roasted sweet potato with a luxurious honey butter sauce, vanilla sweet cream, topped with crunchy glazed pecans and toasted marshmallows.$13.19Ube Coco Tres Leches
Slice of tres leches cake with ube coconut cream, luscious caramel sauce, sweet vanilla drizzle and toasted coconut flakes.$7.69Camote
Roasted sweet potato with decadent honey, sweet vanilla cream, luscious caramel sauce and aromatic cinnamon powder.$10.99
All hours
| Sunday | 2:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 2:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 2:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Thursday | 2:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Friday | 4:00 pm - 2:00 am |
| Saturday | 4:00 pm - 2:00 am |
Restaurant info
Potato Papa is a gourmet loaded potato concept serving hand-cut fries fried in 100% beef tallow, baked potatoes, and sweet potato desserts. Inspired by flavors from around the world, we transform iconic regional dishes into loaded potato creations.
Location
1531 s 1st st , Milwaukee, WI 53204
