Skip to Main content
  • Potato Papa 1531 s 1st milwaukee WI

    • Home
    • /
    • Milwaukee
    • /
    • Potato Papa 1531 s 1st milwaukee WI
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image

    Potato Papa 1531 s 1st milwaukee WI

    Open now4PM - 2AM
    CallDirections
    ‌
    ‌
    Signature Menu Items
    Build Your Own
    Refreshers
    Sweet Treats
    Signature Menu Items (online)
    Build Your Own (online)
    Refreshers (online)
    Sweet Treats (online)
    Signature Menu Items (GH)
    Build Your Own (GH)
    Refreshers (GH)
    Sweet Treats (GH)

    Signature Menu Items

    Global Flavors

    • Carne Asada

      1/3 pound of grilled steak with cheese sauce, cilantro-lime crema, chipotle aioli, pico de gallo and guacamole
      $21.49
    • Butter Chicken

      1/3 pound of grilled chicken in a creamy buttery tomato sauce, garnished with tomatoes, cilantro and garlic aioli drizzle.
      $17.49
    • Habibi

      1/3 pound grilled chicken, traditional shawarma sauce, cheese sauce and garlic aioli topped with onions, tomatoes, pickles and sumac.
      $21.49
    • Gyro

      1/3 pound grilled steak with creamy feta cheese, tzatziki sauce, onions and tomatoes.
      $20.49
    • Bori BBQ

      1/3 pound grilled chicken with guava BBQ sauce, cilantro-lime crema, liquid gold cheese sauce, topped with guacamole and ketchup-mayo drizzle.
      $16.49
    • Patatas Bravas

      In-house made smoky spicy chipotle sauce drizzled with garlic aioli, topped with cilantro.
      $12.99
    • Poutine

      In-house made rich silky savory gravy topped with Wisconsin cheese curds and chives.
      $12.99

    American Favorites

    • OG

      Crispy beef bacon with cheese sauce, sour cream and chives. A Wisconsin favorite!
      $19.99
    • West Coast Connect

      1/3 pound seared ground beef covered in our signature zaza sauce topped with tomatoes, onions, lettuce and drizzled with in-house made cheese sauce.
      $18.49
    • East Coast Ocky

      1/3 pound seared ground beef with cheese sauce, lettuce, tomatoes and onions, drizzled with ketchup-mayo.
      $18.49

    Health is Wealth

    • Honey Harvest Crunch

      Roasted sweet potato with creamy feta cheese, golden honey drizzle, pico de gallo and crunchy glazed pecans.
      $16.99
    • Protein Papa

      Filled with 1/3 pound of your choice of protein topped with tzatziki sauce, pico de gallo and guacamole
      $18.49+

    Build Your Own

    Base

    • Hand-Cut Fries

      $5.99
    • Baked Potato

      $5.99
    • Roasted Sweet Potato

      $5.99
    • Mixed Greens

      $3.99

    Refreshers

    Agua Frescas

    • Ube Horchata

      Creamy rice blended with warm cinnamon and ube, sweetened for the perfect balance. Milky, smooth and refreshing
      $4.99+
    • Cucumber Limeade

      Fresh cucumber blended with zesty lime, sweetened for the perfect balance. Citrusy, cool and refreshing.
      $4.49+

    Drinks

    • Water bottle

      $1.49
    • Coca Cola

      $2.49
    • Sprite

      $2.49
    • Jarritos

      $3.85

    Sweet Treats

    Dessert

    • Candied Yam

      Roasted sweet potato with a luxurious honey butter sauce, vanilla sweet cream, topped with crunchy glazed pecans and toasted marshmallows.
      $11.99
    • Ube Coco Tres Leches

      Slice of tres leches cake with ube coconut cream, luscious caramel sauce, sweet vanilla drizzle and toasted coconut flakes.
      $6.99
    • Camote

      Roasted sweet potato with decadent honey, sweet vanilla cream, luscious caramel sauce and aromatic cinnamon powder.
      $9.99

    Signature Menu Items (online)

    Global Flavors

    • Carne Asada

      1/3 pound of grilled steak with cheese sauce, cilantro-lime crema, chipotle aioli, pico de gallo and guacamole
      $21.49
    • Butter Chicken

      1/3 pound of grilled chicken in a creamy buttery tomato sauce, garnished with tomatoes, cilantro and garlic aioli drizzle.
      $17.49
    • Habibi

      1/3 pound grilled chicken, traditional shawarma sauce, cheese sauce and garlic aioli topped with onions, tomatoes, pickles and sumac.
      $21.49
    • Gyro

      1/3 pound grilled steak with creamy feta cheese, tzatziki sauce, onions and tomatoes.
      $20.49
    • Bori BBQ

      1/3 pound grilled chicken with guava BBQ sauce, cilantro-lime crema, liquid gold cheese sauce, topped with guacamole and ketchup-mayo drizzle.
      $16.49
    • Patatas Bravas

      In-house made smoky spicy chipotle sauce drizzled with garlic aioli, topped with cilantro.
      $12.99
    • Poutine

      In-house made rich silky savory gravy topped with Wisconsin cheese curds and chives.
      $12.99

    American Favorites

    • OG

      Crispy beef bacon with cheese sauce, sour cream and chives. A Wisconsin favorite!
      $19.99
    • West Coast Connect

      1/3 pound seared ground beef covered in our signature zaza sauce topped with tomatoes, onions, lettuce and drizzled with in-house made cheese sauce.
      $18.49
    • East Coast Ocky

      1/3 pound seared ground beef with cheese sauce, lettuce, tomatoes and onions, drizzled with ketchup-mayo.
      $18.49

    Health is Wealth

    • Honey Harvest Crunch

      Roasted sweet potato with creamy feta cheese, golden honey drizzle, pico de gallo and crunchy glazed pecans.
      $16.99
    • Protein Papa

      Filled with 1/3 pound of your choice of protein topped with tzatziki sauce, pico de gallo and guacamole
      $18.49+

    Build Your Own (online)

    Build Your Own

    • Hand-Cut Fries

      $5.99
    • Baked Potato

      $5.99
    • Roasted Sweet Potato

      $5.99
    • Mixed Greens

      $3.99

    Refreshers (online)

    Agua Frescas

    • Ube Horchata

      Creamy rice blended with warm cinnamon and ube, sweetened for the perfect balance. Milky, smooth and refreshing
      $4.99+
    • Cucumber Limeade

      Fresh cucumber blended with zesty lime, sweetened for the perfect balance. Citrusy, cool and refreshing.
      $4.49+

    Drinks

    • Water bottle

      $1.49
    • Coca Cola

      $2.49
    • Sprite

      $2.49
    • Jarritos

      $3.85

    Sweet Treats (online)

    Dessert

    • Candied Yam

      Roasted sweet potato with a luxurious honey butter sauce, vanilla sweet cream, topped with crunchy glazed pecans and toasted marshmallows.
      $11.99
    • Ube Coco Tres Leches

      Slice of tres leches cake with ube coconut cream, luscious caramel sauce, sweet vanilla drizzle and toasted coconut flakes.
      $6.99
    • Camote

      Roasted sweet potato with decadent honey, sweet vanilla cream, luscious caramel sauce and aromatic cinnamon powder.
      $9.99

    Signature Menu Items (GH)

    Global Flavors

    • Carne Asada

      1/3 pound of grilled steak with cheese sauce, cilantro-lime crema, chipotle aioli, pico de gallo and guacamole
      $23.64
    • Butter Chicken

      1/3 pound of grilled chicken in a creamy buttery tomato sauce, garnished with tomatoes, cilantro and garlic aioli drizzle.
      $19.24
    • Habibi

      1/3 pound grilled chicken, traditional shawarma sauce, cheese sauce and garlic aioli topped with onions, tomatoes, pickles and sumac.
      $23.64
    • Gyro

      1/3 pound grilled steak with creamy feta cheese, tzatziki sauce, onions and tomatoes.
      $22.54
    • Bori BBQ

      1/3 pound grilled chicken with guava BBQ sauce, cilantro-lime crema, liquid gold cheese sauce, topped with guacamole and ketchup-mayo drizzle.
      $18.14
    • Patatas Bravas

      In-house made smoky spicy chipotle sauce drizzled with garlic aioli, topped with cilantro.
      $14.29
    • Poutine

      In-house made rich silky savory gravy topped with Wisconsin cheese curds and chives.
      $14.29

    American Favorites

    • OG

      Crispy beef bacon with cheese sauce, sour cream and chives. A Wisconsin favorite!
      $21.99
    • West Coast Connect

      1/3 pound seared ground beef covered in our signature zaza sauce topped with tomatoes, onions, lettuce and drizzled with in-house made cheese sauce.
      $20.34
    • East Coast Ocky

      1/3 pound seared ground beef with cheese sauce, lettuce, tomatoes and onions, drizzled with ketchup-mayo.
      $20.34

    Health is Wealth

    • Honey Harvest Crunch

      Roasted sweet potato with creamy feta cheese, golden honey drizzle, pico de gallo and crunchy glazed pecans.
      $18.69
    • Protein Papa

      Filled with 1/3 pound of your choice of protein topped with tzatziki sauce, pico de gallo and guacamole
      $20.34+

    Build Your Own (GH)

    Build Your Own

    • Hand-Cut Fries

      $6.59
    • Baked Potato

      $6.59
    • Roasted Sweet Potato

      $6.59
    • Mixed Greens

      $4.39

    Refreshers (GH)

    Agua Frescas

    • Ube Horchata

      Creamy rice blended with warm cinnamon and ube, sweetened for the perfect balance. Milky, smooth and refreshing
      $5.49+
    • Cucumber Limeade

      Fresh cucumber blended with zesty lime, sweetened for the perfect balance. Citrusy, cool and refreshing.
      $4.94+

    Drinks

    • Water bottle

      $1.64
    • Coca Cola

      $2.74
    • Sprite

      $2.74
    • Jarritos

      $4.24

    Sweet Treats (GH)

    Dessert

    • Candied Yam

      Roasted sweet potato with a luxurious honey butter sauce, vanilla sweet cream, topped with crunchy glazed pecans and toasted marshmallows.
      $13.19
    • Ube Coco Tres Leches

      Slice of tres leches cake with ube coconut cream, luscious caramel sauce, sweet vanilla drizzle and toasted coconut flakes.
      $7.69
    • Camote

      Roasted sweet potato with decadent honey, sweet vanilla cream, luscious caramel sauce and aromatic cinnamon powder.
      $10.99

    All hours
    Sunday2:00 pm - 10:00 pm
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday2:00 pm - 10:00 pm
    Wednesday2:00 pm - 10:00 pm
    Thursday2:00 pm - 10:00 pm
    Friday4:00 pm - 2:00 am
    Saturday4:00 pm - 2:00 am
    Restaurant info

    Potato Papa is a gourmet loaded potato concept serving hand-cut fries fried in 100% beef tallow, baked potatoes, and sweet potato desserts. Inspired by flavors from around the world, we transform iconic regional dishes into loaded potato creations.

    Location

    1531 s 1st st , Milwaukee, WI 53204

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play