Skip to Main content
  • Salvatore's Tomato Pies Sun Prairie

    • Home
    • /
    • Sun Prairie
    • /
    • Salvatore's Tomato Pies Sun Prairie
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    Salvatore's Tomato Pies Sun Prairie

    121 East Main Street

    Sun Prairie, WI 53590


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Specials
    Tuesday Deal
    Food Menu
    Drinks
    Merchandise
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • 16" Build Your Own Pie

      All pies start with olive oil, Romano, Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie.
      $19.45
    • 16" Walter White

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, spinach, garlic, ricotta and chili flakes
      $26.75
    • 10" Build Your Own Pie

      All pies start with olive oil, Romano, Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie.
      $13.35

    Specials

    Market pie

    • 10" Don & Mary's Best

      Don Produce heirloom tomatoes, Grande fresh mozzarella, olive oil, basil, sea salt
      OUT OF STOCK
      $18.35
    • 16" Don & Mary's Best

      Don Produce heirloom tomatoes, Grande fresh mozzarella, olive oil, basil, sea salt
      OUT OF STOCK
      $28.50
    • 10" Foraggiere

      Sautéed King Trumpet and morel mushrooms, green garlic, fontina cheese, asparagus, and Vitruvian Farms arugula
      OUT OF STOCK
      $26.00

    Specials

    • The Captain Carb Sub

      Spaghetti, Wells Farm beef and pork bolognese, Grande mozzarella, Sartori Sarvecchio, parsley, toasted roll
      $16.00

    Tuesday Deal

    Deal of the Day

    • 16" One-Topping Pie

      $16.00

    Food Menu

    Appetizers

    Dinner Menu Available to Order: Sunday, Tuesday - Thursday 4pm - 9pm Friday - Saturday 4pm to 9pm
    • Chicken Wings

      8 chicken wings - now featuring our NEW dry rub with miso aioli! East meets West in the best way. 12 secret spices make this special. Or try them tossed in the scratch made sauces below.
      $15.95
    • Garlic Bread

      Toasted Stalzy's baguette, garlic butter, Romano, with a side of house red sauce
      $9.50
    • Sal's Meatballs

      House red sauce, SarVecchio & parsley. Served with grilled bread.
      $12.00
    • Caesar Fries

      Battered fries, romano, parsley, Caesar dressing
      $12.00+
    • Chili Lime Shrimp

      Gulf shrimp, calabrese chili battuto, pickled green garlic, white wine, butter, lime, parsley, grilled focaccia
      $17.00
    • Fried Asparagus

      Lightly fried asparagus, yuzu aioli, soy marinated egg, scallions
      $15.00
    • Seasonal Risotto

      Seasonal vegetables, arborio rice finished with Sarvecchio and herbs
      $16.00

    10" Pies

    • 10" Fat Uncle Tony

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Pepperoni, Red Sauce
      $16.60
    • 10" Figgy Piggy

      Wine poached figs, prosciutto, gorgonzola, arugula, toasted pepitas, drizzle of hot honey.
      $17.35
    • 10" Joey Bananas

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Sartori MontAmore, House Red Sauce, Tempesta Uncured Pepperoni, Fresh Jalapenos, Banana Peppers, Hot Honey, Fresh Basil
      $16.60
    • 10" Sal's Supreme

      Red sauce, Italian sausage, green bell pepper, Crimini mushrooms, onion, black olives. *Make it a Vegan!
      $16.60
    • 10" Tomato Pie

      The Classic but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, and House Red Sauce, finished with Fresh Basil. Think Margherita. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, back in 1910. TO add additional toppings please navigate to the Build Your Own Pie
      $12.95
    • 10" Walter White

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, spinach, garlic, ricotta and chili flakes
      $16.60
    • 10" Woodsman

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Brown Butter Sauteed Leek, Cremini, Oyster and Shiitake Mushrooms, Pleasant Ridge Reserve, Truffle Oil, Black Pepper, Fresh Chives
      $17.45
    • 10" The Gochuzilla

      Korean BBQ marinated chicken, kimchi, scallions, arugula, soy chili vinaigrette, sesame seeds
      $16.60

    16" Pies

    • 16" Fat Uncle Tony

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Pepperoni, Red Sauce
      $26.75
    • 16" Figgy Piggy

      Wine poached figs, prosciutto, gorgonzola, arugula, toasted pepitas, drizzle of hot honey.
      $27.50
    • 16" Joey Bananas

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Sartori MontAmore, House Red Sauce, Tempesta Uncured Pepperoni, Fresh Jalapenos, Banana Peppers, Hot Honey, Fresh Basil
      $26.75
    • 16" Tomato Pie

      The Classic but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, and House Red Sauce, finished with Fresh Basil. Think Margherita. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, back in 1910. TO add additional toppings please navigate to the Build Your Own Pie
      $18.95
    • 16" Walter White

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, spinach, garlic, ricotta and chili flakes
      $26.75
    • 16" Woodsman

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Brown Butter Sauteed Leek, Cremini, Oyster and Shiitake Mushrooms, Pleasant Ridge Reserve, Truffle Oil, Black Pepper, Fresh Chives
      $28.45
    • 16" Sal's Supreme

      Red sauce, Italian sausage, green bell pepper, mushroom, onion, black olive *Make it a Vegan Supreme!
      $27.50
    • 16" The Gochuzilla

      Korean BBQ marinated chicken, kimchi, scallions, arugula, soy chili vinaigrette, sesame seeds
      $26.75

    Build Your Own Pies

    All pies start with olive oil, Romano, Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie.
    • 10" Build Your Own Pie

      All pies start with olive oil, Romano, Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie.
      $13.35
    • 16" Build Your Own Pie

      All pies start with olive oil, Romano, Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie.
      $19.45

    Pasta

    Dinner Menu Available Sunday, Tuesday - Thursday 4pm - 9pm Friday - Saturday 4pm to 9pm
    • Shrimp Peperonata Bucatini

      Gulf shrimp, bucatini pasta, grilled pepper and onion, red sauce, Sarvecchio, parsley
      $23.00
    • Green Garlic Pesto Gemelli

      Garlic pesto, gemelli pasta, calabrese chili battuto, asparagus, mushroom, tomato, goat cheese, parsley
      $22.00

    Salads

    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine lettuce, SarVecchio crisps, house Caesar dressing, fresh dill
      $13.50
    • Market Salad

      Seasonal vegetables, mixed greens, SarVecchio cheese, vinaigrette (varies)
      $12.00
    • Side Caesar Salad

      Romaine lettuce, SarVecchio crisps, house Caesar dressing & dill
      $7.00
    • Side Market Salad

      Mixed greens, seasonal vegetables, red onion, SarVecchio, house vinaigrette
      $7.00
    • Burrata

      Heirloom tomato, burrata cheese, arugula, lemon, olive oil, garlic, arugula
      $15.00

    Burgers and Sandwiches

    • Classic Setup Burger

      1/2 lb, Wells Farm Beef, Stalzy's Butter Bun, American Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle & Onion.
      $14.50
    • BOF

      1/2 pound Well's Farm beef, Ann in a Jam Brandy Old Fashioned jam, bacon, goat cheese, onion, arugula, Stalzy’s sesame seed bun
      $17.50
    • Worlds Best Meatball Sub

      Grandma Aversano’s famous meatballs, house red sauce, pesto, provolone, romano and parsley on a Philly hoagie roll. It’s a meal!
      OUT OF STOCK
      $12.50

    Dessert

    • Butterscotch Budino

      Butterscotch budino, caramel with a Snickerdoodle cookie
      $9.00
    • Cannoli

      Old family recipe, seasonal fruit compote
      $9.00
    • Chocolate Cake

      Chocolate cake with dark chocolate ganache and seasonal fruit compote
      $8.00
    • Tiramisu

      $8.00

    Side & Extras

    • 10" Dough Ball

      $3.00
    • 16" Dough Ball

      $5.00
    • Side Blue Cheese

      $1.00
    • Side Dyno Sauce

      $1.00
    • Side Market Dressing

    • Side Market Salad

      Mixed greens, seasonal vegetables, red onion, SarVecchio, house vinaigrette
      $7.00
    • Side of Buffalo Sauce

      $1.00
    • Side of Caesar Dressing

      $1.00
    • Side of Hot Honey

      $1.00
    • Side of Miso Aioli

      $1.00
    • Side of Mozzarella

      $2.00
    • Side of Pesto

      $3.00
    • Side of Ranch

      $1.50
    • Side of Red Sauce

      $2.00
    • Side of thin bread

      $2.00
    • Side Sriracha

      $1.00
    • Side of Mayo

      $1.00

    Drinks

    To Go Drinks

    • Barretts Ginger Beer 12oz

      $2.00
    • Barq's Root Beer, 12oz

      A delicious, caffeinated, full bodied flavored soda
      $2.50
    • Coca-Cola, 12oz

      Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
      $2.50
    • Diet Coke, 12oz

      Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink
      $2.50
    • Grapefruit Jarritos

      OUT OF STOCK
      $4.00
    • Mexican Coke, 12oz Bottle

      Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
      $5.00
    • Pellegrino Limonata 12oz can

      $4.00
    • Sprecher Root Beer 16oz bottle

      $6.00
    • Sprite, 12oz

      Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free
      $2.50
    • Sprite Zero Sugar, 12oz

      Clear, crisp lemon-lime flavored, zero sugar soda will keep you refreshed and inspired
      $2.50
    • Mello Yello, 12oz

      The ideal blend of lemon, lime, and orange flavors
      $2.50
    • Colectivo Oat Latte 8oz

      $11.00
    • Colectivo Cold Brew 8oz

      $11.00
    • Barq's Root Beer, 2 Liters

      A delicious, caffeinated, full bodied flavored soda
      $5.50
    • Coca-Cola, 2 Liters

      Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
      $5.50
    • Coca-Cola Zero Sugar, 2 Liters

      Enjoy the great taste of Coca-Cola with zero sugar, zero calories
      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.50
    • Diet Coke, 2 Liters

      Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink
      $5.50
    • Mello Yello, 2 Liters

      The ideal blend of lemon, lime, and orange flavors
      $5.50
    • Coca-Cola Cherry, 2 Liters

      Delicious combination of Coca-Cola and cherry flavor
      $5.50
    • Sprite, 2 Liters

      Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free
      $5.50
    • Sprite Zero Sugar, 2 Liters

      Clear, crisp lemon-lime flavored, zero sugar soda will keep you refreshed and inspired
      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.50

    Merchandise

    Dough Balls

    • 16" Dough Ball

      $5.00
    • 10" Dough Ball

      $3.00

    Frozen Pies

    • 10" Fat Uncle Tony FROZEN

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Pepperoni, Red Sauce, Fresh Basil
      $14.50
    • 10" Pepperoni FROZEN

      $12.00
    • 10" Tomato Pie FROZEN

      The Classic but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, and House Red Sauce, finished with Fresh Basil. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, back in 1910
      $11.00
    • 10" Vegan Supreme FROZEN

      Vegan "Mozzarella", House Red Sauce, Vegan "Italian Sausage", Cremini Mushroom, Yellow Onion, Green Pepper, Fresh Basil
      $15.00
    • 10" Wake and Bake FROZEN

      OUT OF STOCK
      $14.00
    • 10" Woodsman FROZEN

      Whole Milk Mozzarella, Brown Butter Sauteed Leek, Cremini, Oyster and Shiitake Mushrooms, Pleasant Ridge Reserve, Truffle Oil, Black Pepper, Fresh Chives
      $14.50

    FROZEN Lasagna

    Our tomato sauce, béchamel, housemade pasta over one pound of: mozzarella, ricotta and parmesan cheese Choose either: Italian Sausage and ground beef or Our blend of crimini, oyster and shiitake mushrooms cooked down in brown butter with leeks
    • FROZEN Small Woodsman Lasagna

      $16.00
    • FROZEN Large Woodsman Lasagna

      $46.00
    • FROZEN Small Italian Sausage and ground beef lasagna

      OUT OF STOCK
      $16.00
    • FROZEN Large Italian Sausage and ground beef lasagna

      $46.00
    If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

    All hours
    Sunday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Wednesday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Thursday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    121 East Main Street, Sun Prairie, WI 53590

    Directions