Schmackary's
Bakery
Open now9:30AM - 10PM
Schmack Packs - Early October
Solo Cookies - Early October
The Classic
Far from average, forever a classic, Packed with a blend of milk & semisweet chocolate and a hint of flake sea salt.$4.25
Funfetti
Butter, Sugar, Flour... Plus mountains of sprinkles. Topped with our famous frosting.$4.25
Cookies & Scream
A hauntingly irresistable mix of black cocoa, Oreo chunks, white chocolate, and wickedly green frosting. Deliciously creepy and instantly fang-tastic!$4.25
Spooky & Sweet
A burst of eerie enchantment! This mysteriously vibrant, swirled sugar cookie, is laced with haunting hints of almond, ghostly glitter, and spine-tingling sugary delight.$4.25
Cereal Killer
Fruity Pebbles, Fruit Loops, Cornflakes and loads of marshmallowy goodness. Part of this complete dessert.$4.25
Poisoned Apple Crisp*
Take a bite… if you dare! Granny Smith apples, caramel, toffee bits, white chocolate, and a sprinkle of spellbinding streusel. *may contain nuts$4.25
Worms & Dirt
Dig into fun with this sinfully rich chocolate cookie, topped with a luscious chocolate pudding frosting, oreo dust and chewy gummy worms.OUT OF STOCK$4.25
I Put A Spell On You
Just a bunch of Hocus Pocus loaded with cocoa, semisweet chocolate and topped with our fudgey chocolate frosting and a special Sanderson Sister sprinkle blend!$4.25
Pick of the Patch*
Autumnal splendor at its finest! Pumpkin blended with English toffee and butterscotch chips with a final touch of caramel & homemade streusel. *may contain nuts$4.25
Salty & Sweet*
The perfect flavor balancing act. This loaded cookie is packed with pretzels, kettle chips, semisweet chocolate and peanut butter chips for a little surprise in every bite.OUT OF STOCK$4.25
PB Phone Home*
Soft, peanut buttery, and stuffed with Reese’s Pieces—this cookie is ready for a close encounter of the delicious kind.$4.25
The Monster Mash*∆
This Frankencookie is an obscene blend of oats, peanut butter, M&Ms, and semisweet chocolate chunks. *contains nuts ∆gluten-freeOUT OF STOCK$4.25
Cookie Butter Bliss☮
Cookie butter straight from the jar and into a chewy delight with notes of warm cinnamon. You’ll never believe its vegan! ☮vegan$4.25
Cookie Flights
Treats
Knockout Brownies
Current Flavor: Salted Caramel BrownieOUT OF STOCK$4.75
Colossal Krispy Treats
Current Flavor: Puppy Chow Krispy TreatOUT OF STOCK$4.75
Legendary Bars
Current Flavor: Golden Ticket BarOUT OF STOCK$4.75
Coconut Schmackaroons
Current Flavor: Caramel ToffeeOUT OF STOCK$4.00
Schmanana Pudding
Current Flavor: Cookies & Cream$6.00
Ice Cream Pints
Take a Cookie Crush pint home with you! Our legendary cookies, now blended into small-batch ice cream, for a brand new flavor sensation. Flavors changing regularly.
Classic Chocolate Chip + Vanilla Ice Cream Pint
A Classic Chocolate Chip cookie blended into Vanilla Bean ice cream with ribbons of chocolate sauce.$13.00
Schmackerdoodle + Salted Caramel Truffle Pint Ice Cream
A Schmackerdoodle cookie blended into our Salted Caramel Truffle ice cream with ribbons of caramel.$13.00
Big Apple Crisp + Apple Pie Ice Cream Pint
A Big Apple Crisp cookie blended into Apple Pie Ice cream with ribbons of caramel and cinnamon streusel.$13.00
Milkshakes
Simply Vanilla Milkshake
Pure and simple—but never basic. Creamy vanilla ice cream blended with our luscious homemade anglaise for the ultimate classic shake.$8.25
Chocolate Daydream Milkshake
A rich, malted chocolate shake that’s smooth, dreamy, and just the right amount of nostalgic. One sip and you’re floating.$8.25
Pumpkin Spice Milkshake
Autumn called. We blended it. Creamy, cozy, and packed with warm pumpkin spice flavor. Basically sweater weather with a straw.$8.75
Ube-licious Milkshake
Creamy, dreamy, and naturally purple, with ube’s delicate notes of vanilla, nuttiness, and a hint of coconut. Almost too pretty to drink. Almost.$8.75
Birthday Cake Milkshake
Sweet, creamy, and ready to party, with all the nostalgic flavor of birthday cake in every sip. Candles and awkward singing not required.$8.25
Strawberry Spectacular Milkshake
Bright, creamy strawberry goodness that tastes like summer decided to become a milkshake. Sweet, juicy, and berry, berry irresistible.$8.25
Cookies & Cream Milkshake
Creamy vanilla goodness loaded with crushed Oreo cookies for plenty of chocolatey cookie flavor in every sip. Cookies and cream—the love story that never misses.$8.25
Mocha Java Milkshake
Rich chocolate and bold coffee come together in one silky, caffeinated indulgence. Part coffee break, part dessert, entirely worth the buzz.$8.75
Featured Drinks
Cold Drinks
All hours
| Sunday | 9:30 am - 10:00 pm |
| Monday | 9:30 am - 10:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 9:30 am - 10:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 9:30 am - 10:00 pm |
| Thursday | 9:30 am - 10:00 pm |
| Friday | 9:30 am - 10:00 pm |
| Saturday | 9:30 am - 10:00 pm |
Restaurant info
NYC’s go-to spot for wildly creative, freshly baked cookies. Located in the heart of the theater district, Schmackary’s offers over 100 rotating flavors—from classics like Chocolate Chip to bold picks like Maple Bacon and Cereal Killer. Don’t miss our cookie-infused ice cream, coffee, and seasonal specials. Always baked with love and a dash of Midwestern charm.
Location
362 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036