Skip to Main content
  • Scrappy's Italian Deli

    • Home
    • /
    • Lake Geneva
    • /
    • Scrappy's Italian Deli
    • /
    • Online Ordering

    This restaurant does not have any images

    Scrappy's Italian Deli

    Sandwiches
    Closed10:30AM - 8PM
    CallDirectionsWebsiteGift Cards
    ‌
    ‌
    Scrappy's Food Menu
    Grocery / Retail

    Scrappy's Food Menu

    Undercut Pies

    • Cheese

      Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $3.00; 12in $10.00; 16in $14.00.
      $3.00+
    • Cheese & Sausage

      Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.00; 12in $12.00; 16in $16.00.
      $4.00+
    • Cheese & Pepperoni

      Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.00; 12in $12.00; 16in $16.00.
      $4.00+
    • Cheese, Sausage & Pepperoni

      Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.50; 12in $14.00; 16in $18.00.
      $4.50+
    • Supreme

      Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.50; 12in $15.00; 16in $20.00.
      $4.50+
    • Italian Beef & Giardenera

      Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.50; 12in $15.00; 16in $20.00.
      $4.50+
    • Chicken alfredo

      Undercut pie. Pricing levels: Slice $4.50; 12in $15.00; 16in $20.00.
      $4.50+

    Sorriso Panino’s

    • Tony B Trippin - Grinder

      Italian slaw, Salami, Ham, Pepperoni, capicola, tomato, provolone
      $13.00
    • Italian Job

      Italian Beef, roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese
      $12.00

    Scrappy’s Signature Stacks

    • Bruschetta Boss - Bruschetta Panini Melt

      Bruschetta, Mozzarella Cheese, Balsamic Glaze, Provolone on Panini Bread
      $10.00
    • The Wise Guy - Hot Pastrami on Rye

      Pastrami, Swiss, dill pickle chips, deli mustard on Rye Bread
      $12.00
    • Double Cross - Corned Beef & Pastrami

      Corned Beef, Pastrami, Swiss, red onions, oil and vinegar, deli mustard, lettuce, heirloom tomatoes, on Rye Bread
      $14.00
    • Meatball Mobster

      Chopped Meatballs, Roasted Red Peppers, Grilled Onions, Red Sauce, Mozzarella on Garlic Bread Hoagie
      $14.00
    • Tuscan Kiss - Caprese

      Heirloom Tomatoes, basil, Fresh Mozzarella, prosciutto, balsamic glaze, on Toasted Ciabatta
      $12.00
    • The Scrapper

      Turkey, salami, pepperoni, provolone, fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper sauce, red wine vinaigrette, lettuce, red onion, tomatoes, salt pepper, italian oil & seasoning on hoagie roll
      $13.00
    • Shake Down - Sausage & Pepper Sandwich

      Italian Sausage, Peppers & Onions, Red Sauce, Mozzarella on Garlic Bread Hoagie
      $14.00
    • Chicago Classic - Pepper and Egg sandwich

      Egg, Peppers, Parmesan Cheese, Provolone cheese on Hoagie. Add giardinera (optional).
      $9.00
    • Italian Rooster - Chicken Bruschetta

      Fried chicken, Bruschetta, Mozzarella or Provolone, Pesto, Balsamic Glaze on hoagie
      $12.00
    • Italian Stallion

      Mortadella, Porchetta Cotta, Hot Soppressata, Hot Capicola, Provolone, Lettuce, Red Onions, Tomatoes, Oil and Vinegar, Mayo, on Sesame Italian Roll
      $14.00
    • Underboss - Burrata BLT

      Pesto Mayo, Bacon, Tomatoes, Lettuce, Burrata, Balsamic glaze
      $11.00
    • Tough Guy

      Roast beef, Lettuce, Tomato, Red onions, Mayo, Deli mustard, on a ciabatta roll
      $12.00
    • Kingpin- 3 Cheese portabella panini

      Grilled portabella mushrooms, Fontina cheese, Provolone cheese, Mozzarella cheese, Roasted red peppers, Spinach on italian bread
      $10.00
    • The Snitch

      Thinly sliced Ham, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Italian Dressing on Sesame Italian Roll
      $11.00
    • Beachside Boss

      Ham, Turkey, Cucumber, Provolone cheese, Brown mustard, on rye bread
      $11.00
    • Tommy Gun

      Turkey, Pesto mayo, Provolone cheese, Bacon, spinach, Tomato, on Ciabatta roll
      $13.00
    • Crunchy Guido - 3 Chicken Parm eggrolls w-red sauce

      Fried chicken, Mozzarella cheese, Wonton w-Vodka Sauce, served w-red sauce
      $9.00
    • Italian Beef Knockouts

      3 Italian beef eggrolls - Italian Beef, Mozzarella Cheese & Giardiniera
      $9.00
    • Rocky's Cheesesteak

      $16.00
    • Philly Italiano

      $16.00

    Cold Items

    • Tortellini Pasta Salad

      $6.00+
    • Antipasto Pasta Salad

      $6.00+
    • Olive Salad

      $8.00

    Deserts

    • Cannoli

      $8.00

    Chips

    • Deep River Sea Salt

      $3.00
    • Deep River Salt & Vinegar

      $3.00
    • Deep River Sour Cream & Onion

      $3.00
    • Deep River Zesty Jalapeno

      $3.00
    • Deep River BBQ

      $3.00
    • Deep River Salt & Cracked Pepper

      $3.00

    Grocery / Retail

    Grocery

    • ALESSI BALSAMIC REDUCTION TRADITIONAL

      ALESSI BALSAMIC REDUCTION TRADITIONAL
      $10.00
    • ALESSI BALSAMIC REDUCTION WHITE

      ALESSI BALSAMIC REDUCTION WHITE
      $10.00
    • ALESSI BREADSTICK GARLIC THIN

      ALESSI BREADSTICK GARLIC THIN
      $5.00
    • ALESSI BREADSTICK ORIGINAL THIN

      ALESSI BREADSTICK ORIGINAL THIN
      $5.00
    • ALESSI PESTO DI LIGURIA

      ALESSI PESTO DI LIGURIA
      $5.00
    • ALESSI SPICE PINE NUTS

      ALESSI SPICE PINE NUTS
      $8.00
    • ALESSI TOMATOES SUN DRIED IN OIL

      ALESSI TOMATOES SUN DRIED IN OIL
      $9.00
    • ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC RASPBERRY

      ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC RASPBERRY
      $8.00
    • ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC RED

      ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC RED
      $8.00
    • ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC WHITE

      ALESSI VINEGAR BALSAMIC WHITE
      $8.00
    • AMBROSI PARMESAN REGGIANO WHITE GOLD GRATED

      AMBROSI PARMESAN REGGIANO WHITE GOLD GRATED
      $9.00
    • AMBROSI PARMESAN REGGIANO WHITE GOLD SHAVED

      AMBROSI PARMESAN REGGIANO WHITE GOLD SHAVED
      $9.00
    • ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI W/ GARLIC & PARSLEY

      ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI W/ GARLIC & PARSLEY
      $5.00
    • ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI WITH ROSEMARY

      ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI WITH ROSEMARY
      $5.00
    • ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI CLASSICO

      ASTURI BRUSCHETTINI WITH SEA SALT
      $5.00
    • BELLADORO COOKIE SHORT BREAD CHERRY JAM

      BELLADORO COOKIE SHORT BREAD CHERRY JAM
      $6.00
    • BORRELLI BISCOTTI ALMOND

      BORRELLI BISCOTTI ALMOND
      $6.00
    • BORRELLI BISCOTTI CHOCOLATE CHIP

      BORRELLI BISCOTTI CHOCOLATE CHIP
      $6.00
    • BORRELLI BISCOTTI PISTACHIO

      BORRELLI BISCOTTI PISTACHIO
      $6.00
    • BORRELLI TOMATO DICED

      BORRELLI TOMATO DICED
      $3.50
    • CARFAGNAS ORIGINAL PASTA SAUCE

      CARFAGNAS ORIGINAL PASTA SAUCE
      $10.00
    • CARFAGNAS POMODORO PASTA SAUCE

      CARFAGNAS POMODORO PASTA SAUCE
      $10.00
    • CARFAGNAS SICILLIANO PASTA SAUCE

      CARFAGNAS SICILLIANO PASTA SAUCE
      $10.00
    • CARFAGNAS VODKA PASTA SAUCE

      CARFAGNAS VODKA PASTA SAUCE
      $10.00
    • COLAVITA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN

      COLAVITA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN
      $11.00
    • DECECCO PASTA BUCATINI #15

      DECECCO PASTA BUCATINI #15
      $4.00
    • DECECCO PASTA CAVATAPPI

      DECECCO PASTA CAVATAPPI
      $4.00
    • DECECCO PASTA FETTUCCINE

      DECECCO PASTA FETTUCCINE
      $4.00
    • DECECCO PASTA FUSILLI SPINACH

      DECECCO PASTA FUSILLI SPINACH
      $4.00
    • DECECCO PASTA LINGUINE

      DECECCO PASTA LINGUINE
      $4.00
    • DECECCO PASTA PENNE RIGATE

      DECECCO PASTA PENNE RIGATE
      $4.00
    • DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI

      DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI
      $4.00
    • DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI SPINACH

      DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI SPINACH
      $4.00
    • DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI WHOLE WHEAT

      DECECCO PASTA SPAGHETTI WHOLE WHEAT
      $4.00
    • GRAND AROMA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN GARLIC

      GRAND AROMA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN GARLIC
      $12.00
    • GRAND AROMA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN TUSCAN HERB

      GRAND AROMA OLIVE OIL XTRA VIRGIN TUSCAN HERB
      $12.00
    • KRINOS ANTIPASTI LEMON FETA

      KRINOS ANTIPASTI LEMON FETA
      $7.00
    • KRINOS ANTIPASTI SALAD

      KRINOS ANTIPASTI SALAD
      $7.00
    • KRINOS OLIVES JUBILEE ASSORTMENT

      KRINOS OLIVES JUBILEE ASSORTMENT
      $7.00
    • KRINOS OLIVES KALAMATA PITTED

      KRINOS OLIVES KALAMATA PITTED
      $7.00
    • KRINOS OLIVES SALAD GREEK FETA

      KRINOS OLIVES SALAD GREEK FETA
      $7.00
    • MARCONI GIARDINIERA HOT

      MARCONI GIARDINIERA HOT
      $7.00
    • MARCONI GIARDINIERA MILD

      MARCONI GIARDINIERA MILD
      $7.00
    • MARCONI OLIVES MUFFALETTA

      MARCONI OLIVES MUFFALETTA
      $9.00
    • MUTTI TOMATO PUREE

      MUTTI TOMATO PUREE
      $5.50
    • MUTTI TOMATOES CRUSHED

      MUTTI TOMATOES CRUSHED
      $4.00
    • MUTTI TOMATOES WHOLE PEELED

      MUTTI TOMATOES WHOLE PEELED
      $5.50
    • NEGRONI ANTIPASTO CLASSICO SLICED

      NEGRONI ANTIPASTO CLASSICO SLICED
      $10.50
    • NEGRONI GENOA/ASIAGO/TARALLI

      NEGRONI GENOA/ASIAGO/TARALLI
      $6.00
    • NEGRONI MORTADELLA PISTACHIOS SLICED

      NEGRONI MORTADELLA PISTACHIOS SLICED
      $8.00
    • NEGRONI PROSCIUTTO SLICED

      NEGRONI PROSCIUTTO SLICED
      $9.00
    • NEGRONI SALAMI TRIO SLICED

      NEGRONI SALAMI TRIO SLICED
      $10.50
    • NEGRONI SOPRESSATA SALAMI SLICED

      NEGRONI SOPRESSATA SALAMI SLICED
      $9.00
    • SARTORI ASIAGO ROSEMARY CHEESE WEDGE

      SARTORI ASIAGO ROSEMARY CHEESE WEDGE
      $8.00
    • SARTORI BALSAMIC BELLAVITANO CHEESE

      SARTORI BALSAMIC BELLAVITANO CHEESE
      $8.00
    • SARTORI BELLAVITANO TOMATO BASIL CHEESE

      SARTORI BELLAVITANO TOMATO BASIL CHEESE
      $8.00
    • SARTORI CHEDDAR FARMHOUSE CHEESE

      SARTORI CHEDDAR FARMHOUSE CHEESE
      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.00
    • SARTORI CHEDDAR ITALIAN HERB CHEESE BITES

      SARTORI CHEDDAR ITALIAN HERB CHEESE BITES
      $7.00
    • SARTORI CHEDDAR MONTAMORE CHEESE BITES

      SARTORI CHEDDAR MONTAMORE CHEESE BITES
      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.00
    • SARTORI MERLOT BELLAVITANO CHEESE

      SARTORI MERLOT BELLAVITANO CHEESE
      $8.00
    • SARTORI MERLOT CHEESE SPREAD

      SARTORI MERLOT CHEESE SPREAD
      $8.50
    • SARTORI GARLIC & HERB CHEESE SPREAD

      SARTORI GARLIC & HERB CHEESE SPREAD
      $8.50
    • BARILLA ORECCHIETTE PASTA

      BARILLA ORECCHIETTE PASTA
      $6.00
    • PIANCONE CACCAVELLE PASTA

      PIANCONE CACCAVELLE PASTA
      $12.00
    • PIANCONE GNOCCHI

      PIANCONE GNOCCHI
      $6.00
    • PIANCONE TAGLIATELLE PASTA

      PIANCONE TAGLIATELLE PASTA
      $9.00
    • PIANCONE FUSILLI PASTA

      PIANCONE FUSILLI PASTA
      $9.00
    • COFFEE BEANS DECAF

      DECAF BEANS by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
      $14.00
    • COFFEE GROUND DECAF

      DECAF GROUND by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
      $14.00
    • COFFEE BEANS ARTISAN

      ARTISAN ROAST BEANS (Medium Roast) by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
      $14.00
    • COFFEE GROUND ARTISAN

      ARTISAN GROUND COFFEE (Medium Roast) by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
      $14.00
    • COFFEE BEANS WAKE THE LAKE

      WAKE THE LAKE BEANS (Dark Roast) by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
      $14.00
    • COFFEE GROUND WAKE THE LAKE

      WAKE THE LAKE GROUND (Dark Roast) by LAKE GENEVA COFFEE ROASTERY
      $14.00
    • MIKES NUTS ORIGINAL

      $6.00
    • MIKES NUTS HABENRO

      $6.00
    • MIKES NUTS GHOST PEPPER

      $6.00
    • BARILLA PASTINA STARS

      BARILLA PASTINA STARS
      $4.00
    • PRIMAL PEPPERONI BEEF STICK

      $6.00
    • PRIMAL ORIGINAL BEEF STICK

      $6.00
    • PRIMAL JALAPENO BEEF STICK

      $6.00

    All hours
    Sunday10:30 am - 5:00 pm
    MondayClosed
    TuesdayClosed
    Wednesday10:30 am - 8:00 pm
    Thursday10:30 am - 8:00 pm
    Friday10:30 am - 8:00 pm
    Saturday10:30 am - 8:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    272 Broad Street, Lake Geneva, WI 53147

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play