Pizza
Sherrill New York Pizzeria
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
Large 16 Inch
16” Build your own classic New-York-style pizza. Made with hand-stretched dough, signature tomato sauce, and gooey, bubbling mozzarella. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.$17.85
Calzone
Pizza ingredients folded neatly inside soft dough with molten cheese, savory tomato sauce and your choice of fillings, baked until golden.$12.25
Large Pizza & 20 Wings Special
$43.50
Pizza
Specials
Pizza
Large 16 Inch
16” Build your own classic New-York-style pizza. Made with hand-stretched dough, signature tomato sauce, and gooey, bubbling mozzarella. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.$17.85Medium 14 Inch
14” Build your own classic New-York-style pizza. Made with hand-stretched dough, signature tomato sauce, and gooey, bubbling mozzarella. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.$16.10Small 12 Inch
12” Build your own classic New-York-style pizza. Made with hand-stretched dough, signature tomato sauce, and gooey, bubbling mozzarella. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.$13.40Personal 10 Inch
10” Build your own classic New-York-style pizza. Made with hand-stretched dough, signature tomato sauce, and gooey, bubbling mozzarella. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.$10.00
Cauliflower 12 Inch
A lighter take on pizza: a crisp cauliflower-based crust topped with sauce and melted cheese. Great for folks looking for something a little easier on wheat but still rich in flavor. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.$14.75Slice Pie 18 Inch
A giant 18-inch pizza ideal for feeding a group or saving a slice for later. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors to make it your own.$20.75
Sicilian 11x13
A thicker, square-shaped pizza with a soft, doughy base.Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors to make it your own.$22.25Calzone
Pizza ingredients folded neatly inside soft dough with molten cheese, savory tomato sauce and your choice of fillings, baked until golden.$12.25
Stromboli
All the goodness of pizza wrapped inside a golden, baked crust. Easy to slice, share, and enjoy. Choose your choice of cheese and toppings.$26.50Ham Pizza Roll
A bite-sized roll packed with melted cheese and ham. Comforting and perfect for dipping.$3.05OUT OF STOCKPepperoni Pizza Roll
A bite-sized roll packed with melted cheese and classic pepperoni. Comforting and perfect for dipping.$3.05OUT OF STOCKSausage Pizza Roll
A bite-sized roll packed with melted cheese and sausage. Comforting and perfect for dipping.$3.05OUT OF STOCKMeatball Pizza Roll
A bite-sized roll packed with melted cheese and classic meatballs. Comforting and perfect for dipping.$3.05OUT OF STOCKChicken Wing Pizza Roll
A bite-sized roll packed with melted cheese, wing sauce, and chicken wing filling. Comforting and perfect for dipping.$3.25OUT OF STOCKPizza Dough
$3.50
Food
Appetizers
Mac & Cheese Bites
Golden, crispy shells filled with creamy, cheesy macaroni. Served with your choice of sauce.$10.00
Arancini
Italian-style fried rice balls with a gooey mozzarella center and a crisp exterior. Warm, savory, and perfect for dipping. Comes with your choice of sauce.$10.00
Boneless Wings
Tender, juicy chicken bites with a lightly crispy coating. Tossed with your choice of sauce.$10.85
Chicken Tenders
Crispy, golden chicken strips served hot and ready to dip. Includes your choice of sauce$10.00
Chicken Tenders W/ Fries
Crispy, golden chicken strips served hot and ready to dip. Includes your choice of sauce.$11.25Fried Dough
Warm, fluffy fried dough lightly crisped on the outside.$9.00
Fried Mushrooms
Battered mushrooms fried to a golden crunch. Served with your choice of sauce$10.00
Small French Fries
Crispy coated, lightly salted fries with a soft, fluffy center. Comes with your choice of sauce.$4.75
Large French Fries
Crispy coated, lightly salted fries with a soft, fluffy center. Comes with your choice of sauce.$5.50
Bacon Cheese Fries
A loaded plate of crispy fries topped with melted cheese and savory bacon crumbles. Served with your choice of sauce.$10.15Garlic Bread
Toasted bread brushed with garlic butter, finished plain. Served with your choice of sauce.$4.25Garlic Bread W/ Cheese
Toasted bread brushed with garlic butter, topped with melted cheese. Served with your choice of sauce.$4.75
Garlic Knots
Soft, buttery knots baked until golden and brushed with garlic and herbs. Served with your choice of sauce.$6.25
Mozzarella Stix
6 Crispy breaded sticks filled with hot, stretchy mozzarella. Served with your choice of sauce.$10.00
Mozzarella Stix W/ Fries
6 Crispy breaded sticks filled with hot, stretchy mozzarella. Served with your choice of sauce.$11.25
Onion Rings
Thick-cut, sweet onions in a crunchy breading. Fried to a golden finish and served with your choice of sauce.$10.00Onion Rings W/ Fries
Thick-cut, sweet onions in a crunchy breading. Fried to a golden finish and served with your choice of sauce.$11.25
Poppers
Crispy, golden poppers filled with smooth, creamy cheese and a gentle kick of jalapeño heat. Served with your choice of sauce.$10.00
Poppers W/ Fries
Crispy, golden poppers filled with smooth, creamy cheese and a gentle kick of jalapeño heat. Served with your choice of sauce.$11.25
Fried Meatballs
Hearty, seasoned meatballs fried for a crisp exterior with a juicy center. Served with your choice of sauce.$11.25Fried Cauliflower
Lightly battered cauliflower florets fried until crispy yet tender. Served with your choice of sauce.$10.00
Butterfly Shrimp W/ Fries
Plump shrimp coated in a crispy breading and fried to perfection, paired with french fries. Comes with your choice of sauce.$11.00Fried Ravioli
Cheese-filled ravioli pockets fried until golden and crisp on the outside with a melty interior. Served with your choice of sauce.$10.00
Chicken Wings
10 Wings
Classic bone-in chicken wings cooked to a tender, crispy, flavorful finish and tossed in your choice of sauce.$14.9520 Wings
Classic bone-in chicken wings cooked to a tender, crispy, flavorful finish and tossed in your choice of sauce.$27.4030 Wings
Classic bone-in chicken wings cooked to a tender, crispy, flavorful finish and tossed in your choice of sauce.$38.4040 Wings
Classic bone-in chicken wings cooked to a tender, crispy, flavorful finish and tossed in your choice of sauce.$49.4050 Wings
Classic bone-in chicken wings cooked to a tender, crispy, flavorful finish and tossed in your choice of sauce.$60.40Boneless Wings
Tender, juicy chicken bites with a lightly crispy coating. Tossed with your choice of sauce.$10.85celery and blue cheese
$1.30
Cold Subs
Turkey Sub
Sliced turkey layered on fresh sub bread. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.$9.00+
Roast Beef Sub
Tender roast beef served on soft sub bread. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.$9.00+Italian Mixed Sub
A traditional duo of Italian cold cuts stacked for full, savory flavor. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.$9.00+Tuna Fish Sub
Creamy, homemade-style tuna salad served cold on fresh sub bread. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.$9.00+
Ham Sub
Thinly sliced ham served on soft sub bread. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.$9.00+Salami Sub
Rich, tangy salami served on soft sub bread. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.$9.00+Veggie Sub
A fresh, colorful mix of vegetables for a lighter option. Finish it off with cheese and sauces to tailor to your taste.$9.00+
Hot Tunnels
Chicken Parm Tunnel
A hot sandwich filled with breaded chicken, marinara, and melted cheese, served in a tunneled out sub bun.$9.50+
Chicken Tender Tunnel
A hot sandwich featuring crispy chicken tenders and melted cheese inside a tunneled out sub bun. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.$9.50+Eggplant Parm Tunnel
A hot sandwich with breaded eggplant, marinara, and melted cheese tucked into a tunneled out sub bun.$9.50+
Meatball Tunnel
A hot sandwich loaded with savory meatballs, marinara, and melted cheese inside a tunneled out sub bun.$9.50+Pepperoni Tunnel
A hot sandwich packed with pepperoni and melted cheese, served in a tunneled out sub bun.$9.50+Sausage Tunnel
A hot sandwich filled with savory sausage and melted cheese inside a tunneled out sub bun.$9.50+
Steak Tunnel
A hot sandwich layered with tender steak and melted cheese, served in a tunneled out sub bun.$9.50+
Salads
Small Anitpasto
Small classic Italian-style salad with a mix of pepperoni, ham, black olives, tomatoes, and pepperoncini. Includes choice of salad dressing. Perfect as a side- salad.$8.35
Large Antipasto
Large classic Italian-style salad with a mix of pepperoni, ham, black olives, tomatoes, and pepperoncini. Includes choice of salad dressing. Perfect for a meal.$11.25
All hours
| Sunday | 12:00 pm - 8:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 10:45 am - 8:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 10:45 am - 8:00 pm |
| Thursday | 10:45 am - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 10:45 am - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 10:45 am - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Here at Sherrill New York Pizzeria, there are three concepts that built our foundation: Family, consistency, and PIZZA. Since its beginning in 1982, we have been family owned and operated. Originated by the Lazio Family, Frank, Eleonora and Salvatore. The Lazios successfully built and ran the business for 20 years. Since 2002, The Krawiec family has been committed to serving Sherrill with quality ingredients and service. For 33 years, our pizza has been made with the recipe Frank originally brought over from Sicily. To this day we use only the freshest ingredients to make our signature sauce. Pizza is our passion, we hope you enjoy our pizza as much as we enjoy making it for you!
Location