The Bagel Jar

A single bagel to take home. Not sliced or toasted. All of our bagels are boiled and baked fresh every morning.

6 bagels to take home. Not sliced or toasted. All of our bagels are boiled and baked fresh every morning.

12 bagels to take home in a bag. Not Sliced or Toasted. All of our bagels are boiled and baked fresh every morning. *Does not come served on a platter with cream cheese.

Choose a 3 pack of our signature kettle boiled and baked sliced and frozen bagels!

Serves 4-5

8 oz of our Specialty Cream Cheese. All of our specialty flavors are mixed fresh in-house. Serves 4-5

8oz of the same salted butter we use on our sandwiches! Serves 20-25

3 oz of our house-mixed cream cheese. The perfect portion for a single bagel or to try a new flavor!

A fresh bagel with a spread of your choice

A folded egg on a fresh bagel of your choice. Customize your sandwich to add any meats, cheeses, and/or toppings.

A fresh bagel with Bacon, Egg, Scallion Cream Cheese, & a Hashbrown

A fresh Buffalo Bagel with Sahlen's ham, melted Cheddar Cheese, a Hashbrown, and topped with Frank's RedHot *Our Buffalo Bagel is a plain bagel dipped in hot sauce and topped with cheddar cheese!

A fresh bagel with St. James Nordic Reserve Smoked Salmon, Cream Cheese, Capers & Red Onion

A fresh bagel with Turkey, Bacon, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, & Mayo

A fresh bagel with Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo

A fresh bagel with Avocado Mash, Olive Oil, Smoked paprika, & Flake Salt

Cup & Char Pepperoni, Mozzarella Cheese & Pizza Sauce, piled on and cooked to perfection!

Build your own bagel sandwich. If your sandwich contains egg, please use the "Egg Sandwich" option.

Spiced pumpkin puree and white chocolate sauce layered with our in house brewed & infused Nitro Espresso, milk, and finished with cold foam and pumpkin spice.

Maple syrup and in house brewed & infused Nitro Espresso, milk of choice, and topped with maple sugar. Our maple syrup and maple sugar are produced locally by Maple Glen in Gowanda, NY.

Our house-made Chai mixed with white chocolate and cinnamon powder.

Our version of the NOLA! House-made Nitro Cold Brew layered with Pittsford Dairy's Chocolate Milk. Served over ice.

House-steeped for 20 hours using locally roasted beans from Undergrounds Coffee House.

Spiced Tea Concentrate, brewed in-house and topped with creamy steamed milk. Available hot over over ice.

Our house-made Nitro Cold Brew layered with Maple Syrup and topped with salted sweet cream cold foam.

Pittsford Dairy Chocolate Milk & Chocolate Sauce steamed to order and topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle

Locally Roasted Columbia Beans by Undergrounds Coffee House.

Variety Of Harney & Sons Tea.

Smooth and creamy matcha over Strawberry Puree & Vanilla Syrup with milk of your choice. Served over ice.

Smooth and creamy unsweetened matcha. Sweeten it up with your choice of syrup! Served with milk over ice.

House Made Lemonade

96 oz (10) 8oz cups of Underground Coffee's Columbia Blend, the same coffee we serve in the shop! Please allow additional time at pick-up as the coffee is brewed fresh to order.

Natalie's Orange Juice is deliciously squeezed from one ingredient only: oranges. No preservatives, artificial ingredients, added sugars, or GMOs. It's the bright, boldly fresh way to start your day.

Bubbly Sparkling Water (12 oz)

Locally produced by Pittsford Dairy (16 oz)

Pure Leaf Tea (Sweetened or Unsweetened)

Can of pop (12 oz)

Aquafina Water Bottle (20oz)

The perfect dairy free pairing for our half gallon Cold Brew or Chai Concentrate!