The Big Cheese and Sammy's Deli 47 Randall Street

Dill havarti, carrots, spinach, alfalfa sprouts, tomato, and our famous honey mustard on multi-grain. (Vegetarian)

Roast beef, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on a challah.

Hickory smoked turkey, spinach, tomato, alfalfa sprouts, and our famous honey mustard on multi-grain.

Turkey, bacon, spinach, and cranberry sauce on a challah.

Turkey, smoked ham, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on sourdough.

Smoked ham, swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and deli mustard on rye.

Tuna salad, tomato, and alfalfa sprouts on rye.

Chicken salad, lettuce, and tomato on sourdough.

Roast beef, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion, horseradish and deli mustard on a challah.

Turkey, alfalfa sprouts, spinach, cucumber, and our famous honey mustard on multi-grain.

Corned beef, swiss, coleslaw, and 1000 island dressing on rye.

Smoked turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and our famous honey mustard on sourdough.

Turkey, smoked ham, swiss, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on 3 pieces of sourdough.

Smoked turkey, bacon, provolone, tomato, and mayonnaise on multi-grain.

Smoked turkey, bacon, american, lettuce, tomato, onion, and ranch dressing on multi-grain.

Chicken breast, provolone, parmesan, tomato, tomato sauce, garlic powder, and basil on a toasted baguette.

Choice of bread and grape (or) strawberry jelly. (Vegetarian)

Turkey, chicken salad, bacon, pepper jack, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on whole wheat toast.

Chicken breast, parmesan, tomato, smokey caesar spread, caesar salad dressing on a toasted challah.

Turkey, roast beef, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and tiger sauce on a challah.

This Shrimp Salad Sandwich is packed with flavor, and perfect for lunch or light dinner. Served with your choice of Bread or in Lettuce"boats" for a lighter option.

Roasted turkey, pepper jack cheese, bbq sauce, and salsa on a challah roll.

Corned beef, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and 1000 island dressing on toasted rye bread.

Pastrami, swiss cheese, and deli mustard on toasted rye bread.

Smoked ham, dill havarti, and our famous honey mustard on a challah roll.

Roast beef, feta cheese, cucumber, onion, and tzatziki sauce on a toasted challah roll.

Tuna salad, with your choice of cheese and bread.

Roasted turkey, french brie, granny smith apple, and our famous honey mustard on multi-grain bread.

Roast beef, bacon, cheddar cheese, onion, and bbq sauce on a challah roll.

Honey turkey, bacon, swiss cheese, granny smith apple, and pineapple coconut mango tequila sauce on a toasted challah roll. (Spicy)

Beef Meatballs, Provolone Cheese, Marinara Sause, and Italian Spices on a Baguette

A spicy delight with warmed French Brie and Jalapeno Pepper Spread on a baguette. Spicy.

Warmed French brie with Granny Smith Apple slices and Cinnamon sugar on a baguette. Vegetarian.

Warmed French brie with drizzled with Honey and Almonds on a baguette. Vegetarian.

French brie with Honey Mustard, Leaf Lettuce and Tomatoes on a baguette. Vegetarian.

Warmed Mild Provolone, Tomato, Red Onion, Cucumber, Alfalfa Sprouts with Ranch Dressing or Tzatziki sauce on a baguette. Vegetarian.

Fresh Mozzarella, Juicy Tomatoes, Basil, Oregano, Salt, Pepper, and Oil on a baguette. Vegetarian.

Roast Beef with warmed French Brie over on a baguette.

Italian Garlic Salami, French Brie, Leaf Lettuce, Tomato and Honey Mustard or Dijon Mustard on a baguette.

Italian Dry Cured Ham, French Brie, Leaf Lettuce, Tomato with Honey Mustard, or Dijon Mustard on a baguette.

Italian Dry Cured Ham, Mozzarella with Leaf Lettuce, Tomato, Basil with Oil on a baguette.

Italian Garlic Salami, Mild Provolone with Leaf Lettuce, Tomato, Basil with Oil on a baguette. (The Wick!)

Gouda Cheese, Leaf Lettuce, Alfalfa Sprout with Honey, or Dijon Mustard on a baguette. Vegetarian.

Slices of Country Pâté topped with Leaf Lettuce, Tomato with Dijon Mustard on a baguette.

Cambozola, a true Bavarian Blue-veined triple cream blue cheese, Leaf Lettuce, Tomato with Dijon Mustard on a baguette. Vegetarian.

Sharp Aged English Cheddar, Butter and Cucumber on a Baguette. Vegetarian.

Melted Emmental and Swiss Gruyere Cheese on a Buttered Baguette - An Alpine Dream. Vegetarian.

Sliced Roast Turkey, Bacon, Avocado, Onion, Banana Peppers, Provolone Cheese on a French baguette. Spicy.

Roasted turkey, bacon, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and honey mayonnaise on toasted sourdough.

Made with lots of tlc and lots of ingredients.

Sliced cajun turkey, muenster cheese, leaf lettuce, tomato, red onions, bacon, and chipotle sauce on a toasted challah. (Spicy)

Honey turkey, swiss cheese, avocado, lettuce, tomato, and lemon mayonnaise on multi-grain bread.

Roasted chicken breast, bacon, smoked gouda, granny smith apples, jalapenos, spinach, and smokey chipotle sauce on a toasted challah roll. (Spicy)

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on toasted sourdough bread.

Your choice of bread and cheese. (Vegetarian)

Sliced chicken breast buffalo style, provolone cheese, with hot pepper raspberry chipotle sauce on a toasted challah. (Spicy)

Soprasetta, melted mozzarella, tomato, roasted red peppers, olive oil and seasonings over a toasted challah roll.

Roasted turkey, french brie, alfalfa sprouts, and cranberry sauce on multi-grain bread.

Chicken salad, swiss cheese, cranberries, walnuts, spinach, and roasted red peppers on multi-grain bread.

Roasted turkey, low fat cheese, tomato, cucumber, alfalfa sprouts, and apple butter on multi-grain bread.

Smoked turkey, provolone, granny smith apple, and honey on multi-grain bread (warmed sandwich).

Roast turkey, swiss cheese, coleslaw, and 1000 island dressing on rye bread.

Sliced chicken breast, bacon, muenster cheese, leaf lettuce, tomato, covered in soy wasabi sauce on a toasted challah. (Spicy)

Roast turkey, hickory smoked ham, melted brie with honey on multi-grain bread.

Smoked turkey, bacon, smoked gouda, and onions on a heated challah roll.

Sliced buffalo chicken breast, muenster cheese, leaf lettuce, tomato, topped with buffalo blue cheese spread on toasted sour dough bread.

Feta cheese, tomatoes, red peppers, cucumber, red onion, olives, mixed greens, and greek dressing on a toasted challah. (Vegetarian)

Sliced roast turkey, leaf lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion, alfalfa sprouts, and our famous honey mustard on a toasted challah roll.

Roasted turkey, tomato, alfalfa sprouts, spinach, and ranch dressing on a spinach wrap.

Roast beef, cream cheese, roasted pineapple habanero sauce, topped off with chopped jalapeno peppers on a challah roll. (Spicy)

Roasted turkey, havarti cheese, lettuce, tomato, and our famous honey mustard on a challah roll.

On bagel or choice of bread.

On bagel or choice of bread.

On bagel or choice of bread.

On bagel or choice of bread.

On bagel or choice of bread.

On bagel or choice of bread.

Canada Dry Zero Sugar Ginger Ale is a refreshing soda with the classic taste of ginger ale but without the sugar. It comes in a convenient 20 fl oz bottle, perfect for enjoying on the go or with a meal.

Canada Dry Caffeine-Free Cranberry Ginger Ale is a fizzy drink that combines the refreshing taste of ginger with a hint of cranberry. It's a caffeine-free option that's perfect for those who enjoy a little flavor twist in their soda.

Crush Grape Soda is a refreshing soft drink that offers a bold grape flavor. Packaged in a convenient 20 fl oz bottle, it's perfect for enjoying on the go or with a meal.

Joe Tea, Lemon, is a refreshing iced tea with a bright lemon flavor that makes it perfect for quenching your thirst. It's a great choice whether you're relaxing at home or enjoying a sunny day outside.

"Joe’s" is a brand that offers a variety of quality denim products and casual wear known for their comfortable fit and stylish designs. Whether you're looking for a pair of jeans or a relaxed t-shirt, Joe's has something to suit everyday wear.

Calypso Juice's Tropic Tango Lemonade is a refreshing drink that blends the zesty taste of lemons with tropical fruit flavors. It's a perfect choice for a cool and fruity escape on a warm day.

Calypso Lemonade, Original is a refreshing drink that captures the classic, tangy taste of freshly squeezed lemons. It's perfect for enjoying on a hot day or whenever you want a simple, thirst-quenching beverage.

Calypso Lemonade, Strawberry is a refreshing drink that combines the classic tang of lemonade with a sweet strawberry twist. It's perfect for quenching your thirst on a hot day or adding a fruity kick to your favorite beverage recipes.

Calypso Tea and Lemonade is a refreshing blend that combines the bold flavors of brewed tea with the tangy zest of lemonade. It's a great drink for quenching your thirst on a warm day or whenever you're in the mood for something light and citrusy.

Calypso Tropical Mango Lemonade is a refreshing drink that combines the sweet flavor of mango with a tangy lemonade twist. It's a perfect thirst-quencher in a convenient 16-ounce bottle, great for enjoying on a hot day.

Calypso Zero Sugar Strawberry Lemonade offers a refreshing blend of strawberry and lemon flavors without the sugar. It's a 16-ounce drink that's perfect for enjoying whenever you're in the mood for something both sweet and tart.

Calypso GrapeBerry Lemonade is a refreshing blend of grape and berry flavors with a citrusy lemon twist. It's a sweet and tangy drink that's great for quenching your thirst on a hot day.

Cucumber Limeade is a refreshing beverage that combines the crisp taste of cucumber with a hint of lime. It's a perfect drink to cool you down on a hot day or to accompany your favorite meal.

La Croix Coconut Sparkling Water is a refreshing beverage with a light, tropical coconut flavor. It's a great way to stay hydrated with a bit of fizz and no calories.

La Croix Lime Sparkling Water is a refreshing drink with a hint of lime flavor, offering a crisp and bubbly alternative to sugary sodas. It's perfect for staying hydrated while enjoying a light, citrusy taste.

La Croix Mojito Sparkling Water is a refreshing drink that captures the essence of a classic mojito without the alcohol. It's perfect for enjoying on its own or as a mixer in your favorite beverage.

LaCroix Sparkling Water Grapefruit is a refreshing, naturally flavored sparkling water with a hint of grapefruit. It comes in convenient 12-ounce cans, perfect for staying hydrated on the go.

LaCroix Sparkling Water, Apricot offers a refreshing way to hydrate with a light hint of apricot flavor. It's a calorie-free beverage that adds a little fizz to your day without any sweeteners.

LaCroix Cherry Blossom is a refreshing sparkling water with a subtle hint of cherry flavor. It's a great way to enjoy a bubbly beverage without any added sugars or calories.

LaCroix Sparkling Water in Beach Plum flavor offers a refreshing and subtly fruity taste inspired by the essence of plums. It's a great choice for a bubbly and calorie-free beverage option.

LaCroix Sparkling Water in the Razz-Cranberry flavor is a refreshing beverage that combines the light, bubbly texture of sparkling water with a hint of tart raspberry and cranberry taste. It's a great choice for those looking to enjoy a flavorful drink without any added sugars or calories.

Boylan Ginger Ale is a classic carbonated beverage with a zesty kick of ginger. Each 12 oz bottle offers a refreshing taste that's perfect for sipping on its own or mixing into cocktails.

Soda Grape is a refreshing carbonated beverage with a sweet grape flavor. It's a great choice for a tasty and fizzy drink break.

Boylan Lemon Seltzer is a refreshing, bubbly beverage with a hint of lemon flavor. It's a great choice for anyone looking to enjoy a crisp and light drink without any added sugars.

Orange Seltzer is a refreshing, fizzy drink infused with a bright orange flavor. It's a great choice for a bubbly beverage without the sweetness of traditional sodas.

Boylan Raspberry Seltzer is a refreshing sparkling water with a hint of raspberry flavor. It's a great choice for when you want a bubbly drink without any sweetness.

Boylan Bottling Root Beer is a classic soda that offers a rich, creamy flavor with hints of vanilla and spices. It's perfect for enjoying on its own or as a tasty addition to a float.

Mela Watermelon Water + Pineapple is a refreshing beverage made from a blend of watermelon and pineapple. It's a hydrating drink that's perfect for a hot day or as a tasty alternative to plain water.

Celsius Tropical Vibe Sparkling Energy Drink combines the refreshing flavors of starfruit and pineapple to give you a lively boost. Enjoy it as a pick-me-up during the day or before a workout for an extra dose of energy.

Spring Water 16.9 FL OZ

Water is a simple and essential drink that keeps you hydrated and refreshed. It's versatile and can be enjoyed on its own or used as a base for various beverages and recipes.

Essentia Ionized Alkaline Water is a 1-liter bottle of premium water that's been ionized for better hydration. It's a refreshing choice for those who want water with a higher pH level.

Crystal Geyser Alpine Spring Bottled Water is refreshing water sourced from natural springs. It's a great choice for staying hydrated throughout the day.

Crystal Geyser Alpine Spring Bottled Water is refreshing water sourced from natural springs. It's a great choice for staying hydrated throughout the day.

Coca-Cola Zero Sugar is a refreshing soft drink that offers the classic Coke taste without any sugar. This 20 fl oz bottle is perfect for enjoying on the go or with a meal.

Lemon Lime Soda is a refreshing and crisp beverage with a zesty citrus flavor. It's a great drink to enjoy on its own or as a mixer for cocktails.

Pepsi Cola Diet is a sugar-free version of the classic Pepsi, offering the same bold cola taste without the calories. It's a refreshing drink option for those looking to enjoy a soda while maintaining a calorie-conscious lifestyle.

Gatorade G Series Thirst Quencher in Orange is a popular sports drink designed to help replenish electrolytes lost during exercise. Its refreshing orange flavor makes it a tasty way to stay hydrated while staying active.

Gatorade Frost Blue Glacier Freeze is a refreshing sports drink that helps keep you hydrated during exercise. Its cool blue flavor is popular among athletes and great for restoring energy.

Culture Pop Ginger Lemon & Turmeric Probiotic Soda is a fizzy drink that combines the spicy kick of ginger with the zesty taste of lemon and a hint of turmeric. It's a refreshing way to enjoy some probiotics with a bit of a tangy twist.

Dr. Brown's Root Beer is a classic soft drink known for its rich and creamy flavor. Enjoy it chilled straight from the can or add a scoop of vanilla ice cream for a delicious root beer float.

Dr. Brown's Diet Cream Soda is a classic beverage that offers the smooth, nostalgic taste of cream soda without the sugar. This pack includes six 12 fl oz bottles, perfect for sharing or enjoying on your own.

Dr. Brown's The Original Cream Soda is a classic soft drink that offers a smooth and creamy vanilla flavor. This six-pack contains 12 fl oz cans, perfect for sharing with friends or enjoying on your own.

Dr Pepper Soda is a carbonated soft drink known for its unique blend of 23 flavors. It's a refreshing beverage that's perfect for enjoying on its own or pairing with your favorite meals.

Cheerwine Cherry Soda is a fizzy drink with a distinct cherry flavor that has been loved by many since 1917. It's perfect for those who enjoy a refreshing and unique alternative to traditional colas.

ZOA White Peach Zero Sugar Energy Drink has 160 MG of Caffeine

ZOA Orange Zero Sugar Energy Drink has 160 MG of Caffeine

ZOA Frosted Grape Zero Sugar Energy Drink has 160 MG of Caffeine

ZOA Green Apple Zero Sugar Energy Drink

The Chocopologie Bar is a dark chocolate delight that blends the tartness of acai with the crispness of puffed quinoa. It's a unique and satisfying treat for chocolate lovers looking for something a little different.

Maeve’s Rainier Cherry bar features fresh dried cherries and pecans praline lovingly layered in between dark chocolate. Tart, sweet, and oh, so chocolatey.

Our Birthday Gummi Bears are a joyful mix of fruity, chewy gummies. Perfect for birthday gifts, party favors, or just to brighten someone's day. Thoughtfully created by our female-owned, small family business known for elegant, gift-ready treats.

These sun-dried Mediterranean apricots are soft, naturally sweet, and full of bright stone fruit flavor. Perfect for charcuterie boards, pantry snacks, or slipping into a thoughtful gift box. Carefully crafted by our female-owned, small family business with a passion for beautiful, gift-worthy foods.

Our Lemon Sours are bursting with bright citrus flavor‚ sweet, tangy, and perfectly chewy. A refreshing treat for spring and summer gifting, Easter baskets, or a citrus-lovers snack drawer. A customer favorite, from our female-owned, small family business with a passion for joyful, giftable foods.

Don't let the name fool you‚ our Cherry Sours are more sweet than sour, with a bright cherry flavor and a satisfyingly chewy center. Vibrant and nostalgic, these ruby-red candies are packaged in our signature 5x3 box with soft watercolor artwork and a clear product window. Perfect as a gift set addition, party favor, or cheerful indulgence. Made by our female-owned, small family business with a passion for gourmet gifting.

Our Watermelon Sours deliver a rush of bold, sun-ripened watermelon flavor with a tangy kick and a satisfyingly chewy center. Part of our bright sours collection, these vibrant candies strike that perfect sweet-meets-sour balance — the kind of treat that disappears from the bowl before anyone notices.

Naturally sweet and gently chewy, our dried pears are a delicate and flavorful treat. Perfect for snacking, pairing with cheese, or adding to a gift box. These pears also pair beautifully with white and sparkling wines like Riesling, Chenin Blanc, or Prosecco. Made by our female-owned, small family business dedicated to elegant, gift-worthy foods.

Colorful, fruity, and full of fun color, our Let's Celebrate Jelly Beans are packaged in a festive slim box with a clear window and celebration-themed design that says it all. Bursting with cheerful color and flavor, they're a joyful way to mark birthdays, milestones, thank-you gifts, and party moments. Created by our female-owned, small family business dedicated to joyful, gift-ready foods.

"Marcona" – the world's finest Valencian almonds – enhanced by the "beauty marks" of our fine "Flores blend." With this, we would like to once again captivate your senses and invite you to share with us the joys of a colorful summer meadow.

Deliciously addictive, our allergy-friendly Chocolate Chip cookie is a must-try for cookie enthusiasts!

Savor the delicious combination of a rich chocolate cookie and luscious white chocolate cream in our Chocolate Sandwich! Two chocolate cookies filled with vanilla cream. A perfect cookie to dunk in a glass of milk.

Made for the kid in all of us. Sprinkle some magic into your day with our delicious Sprinkle Cookie! Great tasting crispy cookies with an assortment of colorful sprinkles. Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Nut-Free, and delicious!

A cult favorite of the Hamptons, Eccentric Bagel Chips are handcrafted on Shelter Island from real artisan bagels and double-baked for an unforgettable crunch. Made with clean ingredients, bold flavors, and no seed oils, these elevated bagel chips bring a distinctly New York twist to entertaining, snacking, and everyday indulgence.

Our Garlic Herb Obsession Mini Bagel Chips are double-baked for an extra crunchy, satisfying snap in every bite. Made in small batches from real artisan bagels in our bagel shop on Shelter Island, New York, these are not repurposed scraps. Every batch is crafted intentionally, sliced, seasoned, and baked to perfection.

Our Cinnamon Raisin Brown Sugar Crunch Mini Bagel Chips are double-baked for an extra crunchy, satisfying snap in every bite. Made in small batches from real artisan bagels in our bagel shop on Shelter Island, New York, these are not repurposed scraps. Every batch is crafted intentionally, sliced, seasoned, and baked to perfection.

Toketti di Pane Carasau are satisfying, bite-size snacks made from traditional Sardinian flatbread called Pane Carasau. Dating back to ancient times, it is a thin and crispy bread made with semolina.

Taralli are a traditional Italian snack that originated in the southern regions of Italy, particularly in Puglia. They are small, ring-shaped biscuits or crackers made from a simple dough of flour, extra virgin olive oil, salt and white wine. Taralli are boiled and then baked until crisp and golden. Taralli are commonly enjoyed as a delicious and addictive savory treat, often served alongside wine, coffee, or as an appetizer. The classic taste and crumbly texture are a perfect addition to any cheese plate or charcuterie board. Taralli are a beloved snack in Italy and are enjoyed in various ways, from casual snacking at home to being offered to guests as a hospitality gesture. They are also popular to take on picnics, road trips, and as a quick bite during breaks.

Brimming with earthy truffle flavor in every bite, Sabatino Tartufi Truffle Crisps are sure to be your new go-to cracker for munching. These artisan-crafted crisps are made in small batches to preserve the true Black Summer Truffle flavor. Serve these truffle crackers as an easy appetizer, crumbled on a salad, mixed into soup, or simply eat them straight out of the bag.

ubtly sweet, slightly earthy, touched with pure maple syrup, a hint of cinnamon and balanced with sea salt. Irresistible with mild goat cheese. Great snack for the kids. They're better than a cookie.

Nutty buckwheat and hemp hearts caramelized together in the oven create a tasty and toasty bite. Dappled with rich walnuts, delicately sweet figs, and finished with a breath of thyme and pepper, they’ll be gone so quick you’ll join the clean shelf club!

Savor naturally gluten-free buckwheat flecked with wild blueberries, California walnuts, and rosemary. Terrific paired with goat cheese and creamy blues. Deliciously satisfying on their own!

Deep River Sweet Maui Onion chips are a crunchy snack with a savory onion flavor. They come in a 6-ounce bag, making them perfect for sharing or enjoying on your own.

Torres Selecta Del La Vera Smoked Paprika Hot is a flavorful spice known for its rich, smoky taste. It's perfect for adding a kick to your favorite dishes, enhancing both depth and warmth.