American
The Old Mill
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Lunch Combos
$16 Combos
Classic Hamburger (Combo)
Our classic hand pressed, locally sourced burger, seasoned to perfection and topped with your choice of lettuce, tomato, onion, and cheese at no additional cost. Served with a side of our hand cut to order French fries.$16.00Pepperoni Pizza (Combo)
A Cheese Pizza but with pepperoni on it!$16.00Buffalo Chicken Salad (Combo)
A bed of fresh greens with Buffalo chicken bits, mozzarella cheese, tomato, onion, and blue cheese dressing$16.00
Fried Chicken Sandwich (Combo)
$16.00
FOOD
Hamburgers
Classic Hamburger
Our classic hand pressed, locally sourced burger, seasoned to perfection and topped with your choice of lettuce, tomato, onion, and cheese at no additional cost. Served with a side of our hand cut to order French fries.$14.50
All-American Burger
A bacon cheeseburger$15.75Bacon and Blue Burger
A burger with onions, blue cheese crumbles, and bacon$16.50Mushroom Swiss Burger
A burger with Swiss cheese and sauteed mushrooms$15.50Roadhouse Burger
A burger topped with onion rings and barbecue sauce$15.50Mill Stack Burger
A burger bun piled high with lettuce, pickles, chicken tenders, cheese, a quarter-pound burger, cheese again, bacon, onion rings, and another bun--served with a side of Garlic Parmesan French Fries$28.50The Double Mill Stack Burger
A Mill Stack Burger stacked on top of a Mill Stack Burger—served with a side of Garlic Parmesan French Fries and a whole order of onion rings$56.50Fried Chicken Sandwich
$14.25Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$14.75
Pasta
Baked Ziti
Ziti with pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese baked till melted, served with garlic bread$14.50Chicken Tender Parmesan
A bed of penne topped with chicken tenders, pasta sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese—served with garlic bread$18.75Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese
Mix in any one of our chicken rubs or sauces for a bit more bang!$12.50
Buffalo Chicken Mac ‘n Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with Frank’s Red Hot, chicken, and a scoop of blue cheese dressing on top$16.75Taco Mac ‘n Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with our own taco-seasoned beef, topped with lettuce, tomato, and a dollop of sour cream$17.75
Cheeseburger Mac
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with burger mixed in and topped with lettuce, tomato, and onion$17.75BBQ Ribs Mac ‘n Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with a healthy scoop of pulled barbecue pork rib meat mixed in$16.50Philly Cheese Steak Mac
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with shaved beef, roasted red peppers, and onions mixed in$16.75Roadhouse Mac ‘n Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese topped with a generous portion of onion rings and drizzled with barbecue sauce$14.75Sauteed Pierogie Entree
$16.75
Sides
Side Of Mac
A side order of our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese$6.25Tomato Soup (cup)
Its a cup of tomato soup.$4.50Tomato Soup (bowl)
Its a bowl of tomato soup.$6.50Soup of the day (cup)
Ask us about our soup of the day!$4.50Soup of the day (bowl)
Ask us about our soup of the day!$6.50Coleslaw
Cabbage and carrots shredded in-house and tossed in our homemade slaw dressing$4.00Mac Salad
A side dish of our house made pasta salad$4.00Side Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, croutons and your choice of salad dressing$4.50
Potato Chips
A bag of potato chips$2.50Cottage cheese
Two scoops, not one$4.00Garlic bread
Two pieces of out garlic bread$3.50Side of fries (half Order)
A smaller portion of our fresh cut fries$3.50CHILI and Cornbread
$8.75+
French onion soup
$7.50
Wings & Tenders
6 Boneless Wings
6oz of our world (ish) famous boneless wings$7.7512 Boneless Wings
12oz of our world (ish) famous boneless wings$14.0018 Boneless Wings
18oz of our world (ish) famous boneless wings$20.50Boneless Wings Party Box (5 LB)
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$78.503 Chicken Tenders
Great for dipping$8.255 Chicken Tenders
Great for dipping$13.508 Chicken Tenders
Great for dipping$22.00Chicken Tenders 5lb. Party Box
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$87.756 Wings
Literally 6 of the best wings in Alfred Station$7.7512 Wings
Literally 12 of the best wings in Alfred Station$14.0018 Wings
Literally 18 of the best wings in Alfred Station$20.50
50 Wings
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$55.50Polish Wings
12 deep fried Pierogies tossed in any wing sauce or rub$14.0012 Chicken Nuggets
Oh, We have the Nugs!$11.5036 Chicken Nuggets
That is a lot of Nugs!$27.7573 Chicken Nuggets
Practically a lifetime supply of Nugs!!$49.75Chicken Tender Dinner
3 chicken tenders fried golden brown and served with a side of our fresh cut fries$13.75
Party platters
Party Platers
1/2 Pan Baked Ziti
Noodles, tomato sauce, cheese, what more could you need? Oh, BEEF!. Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$59.75Mac n' Cheese (1/2pan)
Our classic Three Cheese Mac n Cheese! Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$62.501/2 pan Cavatappi Aurora
Pasta tossed in out house made creamy tomato sauce. Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$72.501/2 pan Cavatappi Pesto
Pasta tossed in basil pesto. Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$67.501/2 pan Cavatappi Alfredo
Pasta tossed in our house made Alfred Sauce. Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$69.501/2 pan Buffalo Chicken Mac
Our classic Mac but with a bit more chicken... and SPICY, Topped with Blue Cheese.$78.501/2 pan Bbq Ribs Mac
Our classic mac loaded with pulled BBQ ribs meat and BBQ sauce. Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$79.501/2 pan toss salad
$46.001/2 pan chef salad
$74.751/2 pan Greek Salad
$71.751/2 pan Crispy Chicken Salad
$56.00Boneless Wings Party Box (5 LB)
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$78.50Chicken Tenders 5lb. Party Box
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$87.75Chicken Nugget Party Box (6lb)
Each order feeds 12-15 people as a meal, or more as a side dish! about 240 nuggets per box$87.5050 Wings
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$55.501/2 pan Pasta Salad
Serves about 12-15 as a side dish$46.00Mashed Potatoes (1/2 pan)
Serves about 12-15 as a side dish$46.00Bread stick
Per Roll, Includes butter (2)$1.75Garlic Bread Sticks (Dozen)
Buttery and delicious$26.00Coleslaw (qt)
Feeds about 6$15.00Pasta Salad (qt)
Feeds about 6$15.00Shrimp Cocktail (2lb)
$69.001/2 pan Green Bean Casserole
Thanksgiving would be ruined without it$42.00Dinner Napkins (150)
$7.50Silverware kits
$0.65Paper Plates (100)
$6.5010" black serving spoon
$1.506" black tong
$1.50black salad tongs
$3.50
All hours
| Sunday | 6:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 6:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 6:00 am - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
The Old Mill Inn is a quintessential small town American pub and eatery in Alfred Station, NY, "The Mill" is nestled in the structure of the former grain mill which used to serve the local railway. Over the years, "The Mill" has evolved into a comfortable gathering spot for locals and visitors alike. Today we are re-imagining ourselves under new management, offering an expanded menu featuring classic American cuisine as well as a variety of other traditional favorites. We welcome you to come see what The "New" Old Mill Inn has to offer.
Location