Skip to Main content
  • Timmy's Pizza and BBQ - 105 North Randolph Street

    • Home
    • /
    • Garrett
    • /
    • Timmy's Pizza and BBQ - 105 North Randolph Street
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image

    Timmy's Pizza and BBQ - 105 North Randolph Street

    Pizza
    Closed12PM - 8PM
    CallDirectionsGift Cards
    ‌
    ‌

    Pizza

    • Pizza Your Way - 1 Regular Topping (12" Med)

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $14.75
    • Pizza Your Way - 2 Regular Toppings (12" Med)

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $15.75
    • Pizza Your Way - 3 Regular Toppings (12" Med)

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $16.75
    • Pizza Your Way - 1 Regular Topping (14" Lg)

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $17.75
    • Pizza Your Way - 2 Regular Toppings (14" Lg)

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $18.75
    • Pizza Your Way - 3 Regular Toppings (14" Lg)

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $19.75
    • Pizza Your Way - Chicago 1 Topping (12" Med)

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $23.75
    • Pizza Your Way - Chicago 2 Topping (12" Med)

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $24.75
    • Pizza Your Way - Chicago 3 Topping (12" Med)

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $25.75
    • Pizza Your Way - Chicago 1 Topping (14" Lg))

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $27.75
    • Pizza Your Way - Chicago 2 Topping (14" Lg))

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $28.75
    • Pizza Your Way - Chicago 3 Topping (14" Lg))

      Build your own pizza with homemade dough & sauce made from scratch.
      $29.75
    • Deluxe Pizza (12" Med)

      A blend of the finest ingredients found anywhere in the world. Loaded with Italian sausage complimented perfectly with just the right amount of pepperoni. Add in the freshest onions, green peppers, green olives and mushrooms. Smother it all in mozzarella cheese.
      $19.75
    • Railroader (12" Med)

      A vegetarian's worst nightmare! A meat lover's fantasy. "The ALL MEAT Pizza" loaded with sausage, fresh ground beef, scrumptious bacon finished off with a layer of pepperoni and tender ham. A monster pizza held together by a ton of fresh mozzarella cheese.
      $19.75
    • The Vegetarian (12" Med)

      The healthy escape to pizza. Juicy vegetable toppings such as fresh onions, green and black olives, thin sliced mushrooms, green peppers, plump ripe tomatoes all covered with a generous portion of pure mozzarella cheese. (Banana and Jalapeño peppers added upon request)
      $19.75
    • Timmy's Train Wreck (12" Med)

      The ultimate BBQ pizza! Hickory-smoked pulled pork, sweet banana peppers, onions, bacon and fresh tomatoes. Timmy's secret BBQ sauce topped off with mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
      $19.75
    • The Cowboy (12" Med)

      The Western Specialty Pizza! Sausage, pepperoni, onions, banana peppers, cheddar & mozzarella cheese. Made with our special BBQ sauce.
      $19.75
    • BBQ Chicken Pizza (12" Med)

      Smoked chicken loaded on our own not too tangy, not too sweet barbeque sauce, green peppers, onions, ripe tomatoes and mozzarella cheese.
      $19.75
    • Chicken Club Pizza (12" Med)

      Seasoned chicken, bacon, onions, green peppers, fresh tomatoes and mozzarella cheese on a creamy white sauce.
      $19.75
    • Timmy's Buffalo Style Pizza (12" Med)

      Smoked chicken marinated and laid in a southern style hot sauce, topped off with a healthy portion of fresh onions and a mound of cheddar and mozzarella cheeses.
      $19.75
    • Half and Half Specialty/Build Your Own (12" Med)

      Half your choice of Specialty Pizza and Half Build your own!
      $19.75
    • Cheese Pizza (12" Med)

      $14.75
    • Deluxe Pizza (14" Lg)

      A blend of the finest ingredients found anywhere in the world. Loaded with Italian sausage complimented perfectly with just the right amount of pepperoni. Add in the freshest onions, green peppers, green olives and mushrooms. Smother it all in mozzarella cheese.
      $22.75
    • Railroader (14" Lg)

      A vegetarian's worst nightmare! A meat lover's fantasy. "The ALL MEAT Pizza" loaded with sausage, fresh ground beef, scrumptious bacon finished off with a layer of pepperoni and tender ham. A monster pizza held together by a ton of fresh mozzarella cheese.
      $22.75
    • The Vegetarian (14" Lg)

      The healthy escape to pizza. Juicy vegetable toppings such as fresh onions, green and black olives, thin sliced mushrooms, green peppers, plump ripe tomatoes all covered with a generous portion of pure mozzarella cheese. (Banana and Jalapeño peppers added upon request)
      $22.75
    • Timmy's Train Wreck (14" Lg)

      The ultimate BBQ pizza! Hickory-smoked pulled pork, sweet banana peppers, onions, bacon and fresh tomatoes. Timmy's secret BBQ sauce topped off with mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
      $22.75
    • The Cowboy (14" Lg)

      The Western Specialty Pizza! Sausage, pepperoni, onions, banana peppers, cheddar & mozzarella cheese. Made with our special BBQ sauce.
      $22.75
    • BBQ Chicken Pizza (14" Lg)

      Smoked chicken loaded on our own not too tangy, not too sweet barbeque sauce, green peppers, onions, ripe tomatoes and mozzarella cheese.
      $22.75
    • Chicken Club Pizza (14" Lg)

      Seasoned chicken, bacon, onions, green peppers, fresh tomatoes and mozzarella cheese on a creamy white sauce.
      $22.75
    • Timmy's Buffalo Style Pizza (14" Lg)

      Smoked chicken marinated and laid in a southern style hot sauce, topped off with a healthy portion of fresh onions and a mound of cheddar and mozzarella cheeses.
      $22.75
    • 1/2 BYO and 1/2 Specialty Pizza (14" Lg)

      $22.75
    • Half and Half Build Your Own (14" Lg)

      $17.75
    • Cheese Pizza (14" Lg)

      $17.75
    • 12" Deluxe Chicago

      A blend of the finest ingredients found anywhere in the world. Loaded with Italian sausage complimented perfectly with just the right amount of pepperoni. Add in the freshest onions, green peppers, green olives and mushrooms. Smother it all in mozzarella cheese.
      $28.75
    • 12" Railroader Chicago

      A vegetarian's worst nightmare! A meat lover's fantasy. "The ALL MEAT Pizza" loaded with sausage, fresh ground beef, scrumptious bacon finished off with a layer of pepperoni and tender ham. A monster pizza held together by a ton of fresh mozzarella cheese.
      $28.75
    • 12" Vegetarian Chicago

      The healthy escape to pizza. Juicy vegetable toppings such as fresh onions, green and black olives, thin sliced mushrooms, green peppers, plump ripe tomatoes all covered with a generous portion of pure mozzarella cheese. (Banana and Jalapeño peppers added upon request)
      $28.75
    • 12" Timmy's Train Wreck Chicago

      The ultimate BBQ pizza! Hickory-smoked pulled pork, sweet banana peppers, onions, bacon and fresh tomatoes. Timmy's secret BBQ sauce topped off with mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
      $28.75
    • 12" Cowboy Chicago

      The Western Specialty Pizza! Sausage, pepperoni, onions, banana peppers, cheddar & mozzarella cheese. Made with our special BBQ sauce.
      $28.75
    • 12" BBQ Chicken Chicago

      Smoked chicken loaded on our own not too tangy, not too sweet barbeque sauce, green peppers, onions, ripe tomatoes and mozzarella cheese.
      $28.75
    • 12" Chicken Club Chicago

      Seasoned chicken, bacon, onions, green peppers, fresh tomatoes and mozzarella cheese on a creamy white sauce.
      $28.75
    • 12" Timmy's Buffalo Chicago

      Smoked chicken marinated and laid in a southern style hot sauce, topped off with a healthy portion of fresh onions and a mound of cheddar and mozzarella cheeses.
      $28.75
    • 14" Deluxe Chicago

      A blend of the finest ingredients found anywhere in the world. Loaded with Italian sausage complimented perfectly with just the right amount of pepperoni. Add in the freshest onions, green peppers, green olives and mushrooms. Smother it all in mozzarella cheese.
      $32.75
    • 14" Railroader Chicago

      A vegetarian's worst nightmare! A meat lover's fantasy. "The ALL MEAT Pizza" loaded with sausage, fresh ground beef, scrumptious bacon finished off with a layer of pepperoni and tender ham. A monster pizza held together by a ton of fresh mozzarella cheese.
      $32.75
    • 14" Vegetarian Chicago

      The healthy escape to pizza. Juicy vegetable toppings such as fresh onions, green and black olives, thin sliced mushrooms, green peppers, plump ripe tomatoes all covered with a generous portion of pure mozzarella cheese. (Banana and Jalapeño peppers added upon request)
      $32.75
    • 14" Timmy's Train Wreck Chicago

      The ultimate BBQ pizza! Hickory-smoked pulled pork, sweet banana peppers, onions, bacon and fresh tomatoes. Timmy's secret BBQ sauce topped off with mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
      $32.75
    • 14" Cowboy Chicago

      The Western Specialty Pizza! Sausage, pepperoni, onions, banana peppers, cheddar & mozzarella cheese. Made with our special BBQ sauce.
      $32.75
    • 14" BBQ Chicken Chicago

      Smoked chicken loaded on our own not too tangy, not too sweet barbeque sauce, green peppers, onions, ripe tomatoes and mozzarella cheese.
      $32.75
    • 14" Chicken Club Chicago

      Seasoned chicken, bacon, onions, green peppers, fresh tomatoes and mozzarella cheese on a creamy white sauce.
      $32.75
    • 14" Timmy's Buffalo Chicago

      Smoked chicken marinated and laid in a southern style hot sauce, topped off with a healthy portion of fresh onions and a mound of cheddar and mozzarella cheeses.
      $32.75

    Crazy Dough & Garlic Bread

    • Crazy Dough Pizza (Two Toppings)

      Pizza for one made delicious! This single serving pizza is like a snowflake, no two are ever the same. Actual shape and size may vary, but load these little guys up with your choice of toppings.
      $7.99
    • Crazy Dough Pizza (Specialty)

      Pizza for one made delicious! This single serving pizza is like a snowflake, no two are ever the same. Actual shape and size may vary, but load these little guys up with your choice of toppings.
      $9.99
    • Garlic Bread With Cheese

      Italian white bread with garlic butter, cheese and Greek seasoning.
      $6.99
    • Crazy Dough With Cheese

      Hand-stretched pizza dough with garlic butter, cheese and Greek seasoning.
      $6.99

    Italian Submarines

    • Grinder (1/2)

      This irresistible sandwich is topped off with ham, salami, lettuce, onions, green peppers and mozzarella cheese and pizza sauce on a submarine bun. If you want a sandwich with tons of meat, this is the one for you!
      $7.99
    • Grinder (Whole)

      This irresistible sandwich is topped off with ham, salami, lettuce, onions, green peppers and mozzarella cheese and pizza sauce on a submarine bun. If you want a sandwich with tons of meat, this is the one for you!
      $13.50
    • Ham & Cheese (1/2)

      This tender, juicy sandwich will fill your appetite. It is loaded with tender ham, mozzarella cheese and pizza sauce. Super this tasty sandwich with fresh toppings for an additional charge.
      $7.99
    • Ham & Cheese (Whole)

      This tender, juicy sandwich will fill your appetite. It is loaded with tender ham, mozzarella cheese and pizza sauce. Super this tasty sandwich with fresh toppings for an additional charge.
      $13.50
    • Chicken Club (1/2)

      Smoked chicken, bacon, mozzarella cheese, onions, green peppers, tomatoes & Ranch dressing.
      $7.99
    • Chicken Club (Whole)

      Smoked chicken, bacon, mozzarella cheese, onions, green peppers, tomatoes & Ranch dressing.
      $13.50
    • Timmy's Cordon Blu (1/2)

      Smoked chicken, ham, bacon, mozzarella cheese & Ranch dressing.
      $7.99
    • Timmy's Cordon Blu (Whole)

      Smoked chicken, ham, bacon, mozzarella cheese & Ranch dressing.
      $13.50
    • Buffalo Chicken Sub (1/2)

      Smoked chicken smothered in Buffalo sauce, mozzarella cheese, onions & Ranch dressing.
      $7.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Sub (Whole)

      Smoked chicken smothered in Buffalo sauce, mozzarella cheese, onions & Ranch dressing.
      $13.50
    • Stromboli (1/2)

      Sauce, banana peppers, onions, cheese and pizza sauce.
      $7.99
    • Stromboli (Whole)

      Sauce, banana peppers, onions, cheese and pizza sauce.
      $13.50

    Rolls

    • Sausage Roll

      More than one gigantic foot of Italian sausage, juicy onions and a mound of mozzarella cheese, wrapped up in our freshest pizza dough. Served with our own BBQ sauce upon request.
      $13.50
    • Pizza Roll

      Build your own treat with your choice of two of any of our delicious pizza toppings on the same fresh pizza dough, sauce & mozzarella cheese.
      $13.50

    Bar-B-Que

    • Pulled Chicken BBQ Sandwich

      $8.99
    • Pulled Pork Sandwich

      $8.99
    • Pulled Pork Nachos

      Pulled Pork, BBQ sauce, onions, banana peppers, cheddar cheese & Tomatoes
      $11.99
    • Pulled Chicken Nachos

      Pulled Chicken, BBQ sauce, onions, banana peppers, cheddar cheese & Tomatoes
      $11.99
    • Rib Tips

      $10.99

    Hickory Smoked Wings

    • Hickory Smoked Wings

      Hickory smoked wings. Choose your quantity and sauce.
      $9.99
    • Ranch

    • Bleu Cheese

    Soda/Water

    • Bottled Water

      $1.25
    • Diet Pepsi Can

      $1.25
    • Dr. Pepper Can

      $1.25
    • Mountain Dew Can

      12 oz can
      $1.25
    • Pepsi Can

      12 oz can
      $1.25
    • Two Liter Diet Pepsi

      $3.99
    • Two Liter Dr. Pepper

      $3.99
    • Two Liter Mountain Dew

      $3.99
    • Two Liter Pepsi

      $3.99

    Dipping Sauces

    • BBQ

      $0.75
    • Bleu Cheese

      $0.75
    • Buffalo

      $0.75
    • Garlic Butter

      $0.75
    • Nacho Cheese

      $0.75
    • Pizza cup

      $0.75
    • Ranch

      $0.75

    All hours
    Sunday12:00 pm - 8:00 pm
    MondayClosed
    TuesdayClosed
    WednesdayClosed
    ThursdayClosed
    Friday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Award Winning Local Pizza and BBQ

    Location

    105 North Randolph Street, Garrett, IN 46738

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play