American
Two Fat Cats Bakery Lancaster Street
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
‌
‌
‌
Featured Items
PIES (ONLINE)
Year Round Pies
Our signature pies-
Call the store at 207-347-5144 to order our seasonal offerings, mini pies, or pocket pies!
CAKES (ONLINE)
Cakes
6" serves 6-8; 8" serves 10-12; 10" serves 16-20. For custom decorations or additional cake sizes, please email info@twofatcatsbakery.com or call 207-347-5144
6" Blackout Cake
Our Maine spin on this Brooklyn favorite with layered chocolate cake and homemade chocolate pudding covered in chocolate cake crumbs ***We cannot write on or decorate these cakes because of the crumb coating.***$44.00
6" Black & White Cake
(our version of marble cake) Layers of Vanilla & Chocolate Cake Vanilla or Chocolate Frosting$20.00
6" Carrot Cake
A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins with a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)$44.00
6" Chocolate Cake
Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.$20.00
6" Flourless Chocolate Cake (2 Layers)
Flourless cake with chocolate pastry cream and chocolate frosting (not celiac safe, made in an open kitchen)$50.006" Fruit & Honey Cream Cake
A beautiful vanilla cake layered with vanilla pastry cream & strawberry filling with a lightly sweetened honey buttercream frosting.$38.00
6" Lemon Cake
This citrusy favorite gets a layer of lemon curd on top of vanilla cake and plenty of lemon buttercream frosting.$46.00
6" Lemon Raspberry Cake
Vanilla cake with lemon curd and raspberry filling, covered in lemon buttercream$46.00
6" Oreo Cake
Chocolate cake with oreo frosting$42.00
6" Raspberry Almond Cake
Vanilla cake with raspberry filling and almond buttercream, garnished with toasted almonds$36.00
6" Salted Caramel Cake
Chocolate cake layered with dulce de leche and finished with vanilla buttercream and a caramel chocolate drip$36.00
6" Vanilla Cake
Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting to create a specialty cake of your very own!$20.00
6" Vanilla Latte Cake
Vanilla cake layered with pastry cream and finished with a coffee buttercream$42.00
8" Blackout Cake
Our Maine spin on this Brooklyn favorite with layered chocolate cake and homemade chocolate pudding covered in chocolate cake crumbs. ***We cannot write on or decorate these cakes because of the crumb coating***$56.00
8" Black & White Cake
(our version of marble cake) Layers of Vanilla & Chocolate Cake Vanilla or Chocolate Frosting$44.00
8" Carrot Cake
A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins with a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)$52.00
8" Chocolate Cake
Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.$25.00
8" Flourless Chocolate Cake (2 Layers)
Flourless cake with chocolate pastry cream and chocolate frosting (not celiac safe, made in an open kitchen)$65.008" Fruit & Honey Cream Cake
A beautiful vanilla cake layered with vanilla pastry cream & strawberry filling with a lightly sweetened honey buttercream frosting$50.00
8" Lemon Cake
This citrusy favorite gets a layer of lemon curd on top of vanilla cake and plenty of lemon buttercream frosting.$56.00
8" Lemon Raspberry Cake
Vanilla cake with lemon curd and raspberry filling, covered in lemon buttercream$56.00
8" Oreo Cake
Rich chocolate cake covered with oreo frosting$52.00
8" Raspberry Almond Cake
Vanilla cake with raspberry filling and almond buttercream, garnished with toasted almonds$50.00
8" Salted Caramel Cake
Chocolate cake layered with dulce de leche and finished with vanilla buttercream and a caramel chocolate drip$50.00
8" Vanilla Cake
Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting to create a specialty cake of your very own!$25.00
8" Vanilla Latte Cake
Vanilla cake layered with pastry cream and finished with a coffee buttercream$52.00
10" Black & White Cake
(our version of marble cake) Layers of Vanilla & Chocolate Cake with Vanilla or Chocolate Frosting$54.00
10" Carrot Cake
A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins with a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)$64.00
10" Chocolate Cake
Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.$30.0010" Fruit & Honey Cream Cake
A beautiful vanilla cake layered with vanilla pastry cream & strawberry filling with a lightly sweetened honey buttercream frosting.$60.00
10" Lemon Cake
This citrusy favorite gets a layer of lemon curd on top of vanilla cake and plenty of lemon buttercream frosting.$64.00
10" Lemon Raspberry Cake
Vanilla cake with lemon curd and raspberry filling between in each other, covered in lemon buttercream$64.00
10" Oreo Cake
Rich chocolate cake covered with oreo frosting$62.00
10" Raspberry Almond Cake
Vanilla cake with raspberry filling and almond buttercream, garnished with toasted almonds$62.00
10" Salted Caramel Cake
Chocolate cake layered with dulce de leche and finished with vanilla buttercream and a caramel chocolate drip$62.00
10" Vanilla Cake
Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting to create a specialty cake of your very own!$30.00
10" Vanilla Latte Cake
Vanilla cake layered with pastry cream and finished with a coffee buttercream$62.00
PLATTERS
Breakfast
Cookies
Large Bar & Cookie Platter (30)
A variety of our fresh baked chocolate chip, lemon shortbread, peanut butter, and seasonal cookie, with brownies & whoopie pies (5 of each item).$135.00
Small Bar & Cookie Platter (15)
A variety of our fresh baked chocolate chip, peanut butter, lemon shortbread, and a seasonal cookie with brownies & whoopie pies (15 pieces total).$67.50
Holiday Pre-Order
FATHER'S DAY 2026
Available for pick-up only from Friday 6/19- Sunday 6/21. Special items only for a limited time.
Peanut Butter Pie 7"
Sweet & salty come together in a crunchy, chewy crust of chopped peanuts & mini chocolate chips with a light and fluffy peanut butter cream filling. *Contains peanuts. Lots of peanuts.$24.99
DAD Blueberry Pocket Pie
Just for Dad - these buttery, flaky heart-shaped pocket pies are filled with our wild Maine blueberries and signature spices$6.50
Box of 6 Snack Pack
3 Fudge Brownies and 3 Oreo Blondies$25.99DAD Deco Cookies 3 pack
"Dad" themed decorated cookies$11.25
Hamburger Buns
A 4-pack of house-made, buttery burger buns. Topped with sesame seeds & ready for the grill.$4.994 Pack Pepperoni Stromboli
House-made pizza dough stuffed with pepperoni and mozzarella.$31.99
All hours
| Sunday | 9:00 am - 2:45 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 7:30 am - 3:45 pm |
| Thursday | 7:30 am - 3:45 pm |
| Friday | 7:30 am - 3:45 pm |
| Saturday | 7:30 am - 3:45 pm |
Restaurant info
We are an American style bakery located in Maine, specializing in sweets. Our products are baked fresh every day with real butter and local eggs, made from scratch - just for you.
Location