Skip to Main content
  • Two Fat Cats Bakery Lancaster Street

    • Home
    • /
    • Portland
    • /
    • Two Fat Cats Bakery Lancaster Street
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image

    Two Fat Cats Bakery Lancaster Street

    Bakery
    Closed7:30AM - 3:45PM
    CallDirectionsGift Cards
    ‌
    ‌
    Holiday Pre-Order
    PIES (ONLINE)
    CAKES (ONLINE)
    PLATTERS

    Holiday Pre-Order

    THANKSGIVING 2026

    HOLIDAY PREORDER PICK-UP SCHEDULE - **LANCASTER:** TUES 11/24: 7:30AM - 4PM ; WED 11/25: 7:30AM - 4PM ; THURS 11/26: 7:30AM - 11AM **WEST END:** TUES 11/24: 7:30AM - 4PM ; WED 11/25: 7:30AM - 4PM ; THURS CLOSED BOTH LOCATIONS CLOSED FRIDAY 11/27 ONLY HOLIDAY ITEMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THESE DATES.
    • *Sage & Cheddar Biscuits (6)

      6 flaky, buttery, savory sage & cheddar biscuits.
      $23.99
    • *Pumpkin Bread

      Delicious, moist, perfectly spiced pumpkin quick bread.
      $18.00
    • *Apple Spice Crumb Cake

      NY Style Coffee Cake with apples and fall spices folded in, and topped with a crumb topping.
      $25.99
    • *Bag of 3 Deco Cookies

      3 uniquely decorated, holiday-themed shortbread cookies.
      $11.99
    • *Bag of 6 Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies

      6 pack of a fall favorite! Moist and decadent pumpkin chocolate chip cookies.
      $21.00
    • *Bag of 6 Raspberry Almond Thumbprints (GF)

      6 pack of raspberry almond thumbprint cookies (Gluten-free).
      $21.00
    • *Bag of 6 Lemon Shortbread Cookies

      6 Shortbread cookies with lemon glaze.
      $16.99
    • *9" Apple Pie

      Made with fresh, local Cortland and McIntosh apples, this is the all-American autumn treat
      $35.00
    • *9" Blueberry Pie

      The ideal Maine pie: famous wild Maine blueberries tossed with a sprinkle of sugar and warm spices.
      $36.50
    • *9" Triple Berry Pie

      $36.50
    • *9" Bourbon Pecan Pie

      Classic with a twist - roasted buttery pecans combined with a splash of Bourbon
      $38.00
    • *9" Sour Cherry Pie

      Delicious sour cherries with a touch of almond, topped with a beautiful lattice pie crust.
      $38.00
    • *9" Chocolate Cream Pie

      Rich chocolate pastry cream in a flaky pie crust, topped with fresh whipped cream.
      $35.00
    • *9" Pumpkin Pie

      Perfectly spiced, pumpkin pie in our classic buttery crust.
      $36.00
    • *9" Pear Blackberry Galette

      An open face pastry filled with pears, blackberries and ginger.
      $25.99
    • *7" Pumpkin Cheesecake

      Creamy, pumpkin spiced cheesecake with a graham cracker crust, topped with whipped cream.
      $32.00
    • *6" Vanilla Cake

      Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting for a real crowd pleaser. Frostings: Vanilla, Chocolate Fillings: Lemon (+6.00), Raspberry (+$8.50)
      $33.00
    • *8" Vanilla Cake

      Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting for a real crowd pleaser.
      $44.00
    • *6" Chocolate Cake

      Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.
      $33.00
    • *8" Chocolate Cake

      Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.
      $44.00
    • *6" Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

      A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins layered & topped with cream cheese frosting.
      $44.00
    • *8" Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

      A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins layered & topped with cream cheese frosting.
      $52.00
    • *6" Pumpkin Latte Cake

      Pumpkin spice cake layered with coffee buttercream & caramel drizzle
      $42.00
    • *8" Pumpkin Latte Cake

      Pumpkin spice cake layered with coffee buttercream & caramel drizzle
      $52.00
    • *6" Oreo Cake

      Chocolate cake with an Oreo frosting.
      $42.00
    • *8" Oreo Cake

      Chocolate cake with an Oreo frosting.
      $52.00
    • Sage & Cheddar Biscuit

      $2.40

    Halloween 2026

    • Halloween Decorated Cookies

      3-pack variety of Halloween themed sugar cookies decorated with royal icing. Individual cookies will also be available for walk-in retail customers.
      $11.99
    • Spider Web Rice Crispy Treats

      Homemade rice crispy treats with marshmallow webs.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $3.00
    • 3" Monster Cakes

      3" cakes (comes in chocolate and vanilla) frosted as mini monster heads.
      $14.00
    • Halloween Cupcakes (4 Pack)

      A mixture of chocolate and vanilla cupcakes with a variety of Halloween themes. Comes in a 4-pack.
      $14.00
    • Witches' Fingers (3 Pack)

      Pretzel rods dipped to look like witches' fingers. Comes in a pack of three.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $4.00
    • Caramel Dipped Apples

      Whole apples dipped in caramel.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.99

    PIES (ONLINE)

    Year Round Pies

    Our signature pies- Call the store at 207-347-5144 to order our seasonal offerings, mini pies, or pocket pies! NOT AVAILABLE TO ORDER 11/24-11/26 PLEASE ORDER FROM THANKSGIVING MENU. AVAILABLE 10/12
    • Blueberry Pie

      NOT AVAILABLE TO ORDER 11/24-11/26 PLEASE ORDER FROM THANKSGIVING MENU.
      $26.50+
    • Black & Blue Pie

      OUT OF STOCK
      $25.00+
    • Bourbon Pecan Pie

      NOT AVAILABLE TO ORDER 11/24-11/26 PLEASE ORDER FROM THANKSGIVING MENU.
      $28.00+
    • Sour Cherry Pie

      NOT AVAILABLE TO ORDER 11/24-11/26 PLEASE ORDER FROM THANKSGIVING MENU.
      $28.00+
    • Triple Berry Pie

      Wild Maine blueberries, blackberries & raspberries NOT AVAILABLE TO ORDER 11/24-11/26 PLEASE ORDER FROM THANKSGIVING MENU.
      $26.50+
    • Vegan Blueberry

      NOT AVAILABLE TO ORDER 11/24-11/26 PLEASE ORDER FROM THANKSGIVING MENU.
      $26.50+
    • Vegan Cherry

      NOT AVAILABLE TO ORDER 11/24-11/26 PLEASE ORDER FROM THANKSGIVING MENU.
      $28.00+

    CAKES (ONLINE)

    Cakes

    6" serves 6-8; 8" serves 10-12; 10" serves 16-20. For custom decorations or additional cake sizes, please email info@twofatcatsbakery.com or call 207-347-5144. See twofatcatsbakery.com/menu/cakes/ for inspiration.
    • 6" Blackout Cake

      Our Maine spin on this Brooklyn favorite with layered chocolate cake and homemade chocolate pudding covered in chocolate cake crumbs ***We cannot write on or decorate these cakes because of the crumb coating.***
      $44.00
    • 6" Black & White Cake

      (our version of marble cake) Layers of Vanilla & Chocolate Cake Vanilla or Chocolate Frosting
      $20.00
    • 6" Carrot Cake

      A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins with a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)
      $44.00
    • 6" Chocolate Cake

      Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.
      $20.00
    • 6" GF Flourless Chocolate Cake (2 Layers)

      Flourless cake with chocolate pastry cream and chocolate frosting (not celiac safe, made in an open kitchen)
      $50.00
    • 6" Fruit & Honey Cream Cake

      A beautiful vanilla cake layered with vanilla pastry cream & strawberry filling with a lightly sweetened honey buttercream frosting.
      $38.00
    • 6" Lemon Cake

      This citrusy favorite gets a layer of lemon curd on top of vanilla cake and plenty of lemon buttercream frosting.
      $46.00
    • 6" Lemon Raspberry Cake

      Vanilla cake with lemon curd and raspberry filling, covered in lemon buttercream
      $46.00
    • 6" Oreo Cake

      Chocolate cake with oreo frosting
      $42.00
    • 6" GF Raspberry Almond Cake (ALMOND)

      Gluten Free Almond Flour cake, raspberry filling, almond buttercream, toasted almonds as a garnish
      $36.00
    • 6" Salted Caramel Cake

      Chocolate cake layered with dulce de leche and finished with vanilla buttercream and a caramel chocolate drip
      $36.00
    • 6" Vanilla Cake

      Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting to create a specialty cake of your very own!
      $20.00
    • 6" Vanilla Latte Cake

      Vanilla cake layered with pastry cream and finished with a coffee buttercream
      $42.00
    • 8" Blackout Cake

      Our Maine spin on this Brooklyn favorite with layered chocolate cake and homemade chocolate pudding covered in chocolate cake crumbs. ***We cannot write on or decorate these cakes because of the crumb coating***
      $56.00
    • 8" Black & White Cake

      (our version of marble cake) Layers of Vanilla & Chocolate Cake Vanilla or Chocolate Frosting
      $44.00
    • 8" Carrot Cake

      A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins with a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)
      $52.00
    • 8" Chocolate Cake

      Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.
      $25.00
    • 8" GF Flourless Chocolate Cake (2 Layers)

      Flourless cake with chocolate pastry cream and chocolate frosting (not celiac safe, made in an open kitchen)
      $65.00
    • 8" Fruit & Honey Cream Cake

      A beautiful vanilla cake layered with vanilla pastry cream & strawberry filling with a lightly sweetened honey buttercream frosting
      $50.00
    • 8" Lemon Cake

      This citrusy favorite gets a layer of lemon curd on top of vanilla cake and plenty of lemon buttercream frosting.
      $56.00
    • 8" Lemon Raspberry Cake

      Vanilla cake with lemon curd and raspberry filling, covered in lemon buttercream
      $56.00
    • 8" Oreo Cake

      Rich chocolate cake covered with oreo frosting
      $52.00
    • 8" GF Raspberry Almond Cake (ALMOND)

      Gluten Free Almond Flour cake, raspberry filling, almond buttercream, toasted almonds as a garnish
      $50.00
    • 8" Salted Caramel Cake

      Chocolate cake layered with dulce de leche and finished with vanilla buttercream and a caramel chocolate drip
      $50.00
    • 8" Vanilla Cake

      Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting to create a specialty cake of your very own!
      $25.00
    • 8" Vanilla Latte Cake

      Vanilla cake layered with pastry cream and finished with a coffee buttercream
      $52.00
    • 10" Black & White Cake

      (our version of marble cake) Layers of Vanilla & Chocolate Cake with Vanilla or Chocolate Frosting
      $54.00
    • 10" Carrot Cake

      A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins with a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)
      $64.00
    • 10" Chocolate Cake

      Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.
      $30.00
    • 10" Fruit & Honey Cream Cake

      A beautiful vanilla cake layered with vanilla pastry cream & strawberry filling with a lightly sweetened honey buttercream frosting.
      $60.00
    • 10" Lemon Cake

      This citrusy favorite gets a layer of lemon curd on top of vanilla cake and plenty of lemon buttercream frosting.
      $64.00
    • 10" Lemon Raspberry Cake

      Vanilla cake with lemon curd and raspberry filling between in each other, covered in lemon buttercream
      $64.00
    • 10" Oreo Cake

      Rich chocolate cake covered with oreo frosting
      $62.00
    • 10" GF Raspberry Almond Cake (ALMOND)

      Gluten Free Almond Flour cake, raspberry filling, almond buttercream, toasted almonds as a garnish
      $62.00
    • 10" Salted Caramel Cake

      Chocolate cake layered with dulce de leche and finished with vanilla buttercream and a caramel chocolate drip
      $62.00
    • 10" Vanilla Cake

      Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting to create a specialty cake of your very own!
      $30.00
    • 10" Vanilla Latte Cake

      Vanilla cake layered with pastry cream and finished with a coffee buttercream
      $62.00

    PLATTERS

    Breakfast

    • Large Breakfast Platter (30)

      Enjoy a mix of fresh baked muffins, cinnamon buns, scones, morning toasties, and blueberry buckle.
      $142.50
    • Small Breakfast Platter (15)

      Enjoy a mix of fresh baked muffins, cinnamon buns, scones, morning toasties, and blueberry buckle.
      $71.25

    Cookies

    • Large Bar & Cookie Platter (30)

      A variety of our fresh baked chocolate chip, lemon shortbread, peanut butter, and seasonal cookie, with brownies & whoopie pies (5 of each item).
      $135.00
    • Small Bar & Cookie Platter (15)

      A variety of our fresh baked chocolate chip, peanut butter, lemon shortbread, and a seasonal cookie with brownies & whoopie pies (15 pieces total).
      $67.50

    Whoopies

    • Large Whoopie Platter (24)

      24 Maine classic chocolate & vanilla whoopie pies.
      $90.00
    • Small Whoopie Platter (12)

      12 Maine classic chocolate & vanilla whoopie pies
      $45.00

    All hours
    Sunday9:00 am - 2:45 pm
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday7:30 am - 3:45 pm
    Wednesday7:30 am - 3:45 pm
    Thursday7:30 am - 2:45 pm
    Friday7:30 am - 2:45 pm
    Saturday7:30 am - 2:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    We are an American style bakery located in Maine, specializing in sweets. Our products are baked fresh every day with real butter and local eggs, made from scratch - just for you.

    Location

    195 Lancaster, Portland, ME 04101

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play