Skip to main content
Toast Local logo

All restaurants in Shelter Island

Local restaurants near Shelter Island, NY. Order delivery or pickup, book a table, and browse menus and hours for every spot in one place.

The Chequit Catering The Chequit Catering
The Chequit Catering The Chequit Catering
Shelter Island1.4 miles

Also nearby

Harbor Market & Kitchen
Harbor Market & Kitchen
Rated 4.8 out of 5 by 27 guestsGift Shop / MarketSag Harbor5.5 milesPrice range $1-15
Sag Pizza
Sag Pizza
Rated 5.0 out of 5 by 34 guestsItalianSag Harbor5.2 milesPrice range $15-30
Provisions Natural Foods
Provisions Natural Foods
Rated 5.0 out of 5 by 10 guestsAmericanSag Harbor5.1 milesPrice range $1-15
Sen Restaurant
Sen Restaurant
Rated 4.8 out of 5 by 11 guestsJapaneseSag Harbor5.1 milesPrice range $30-60
Springs Tavern and Grill
Springs Tavern and Grill
Bar / PubEast Hampton9.1 milesPrice range $30-60
Yama Q
Yama Q
JapaneseBridgehampton9.3 milesPrice range $30-60
Cruust 2 Main St
Cruust 2 Main St
AmericanSag Harbor5.0 milesPrice range $1-15
Señor Taco Mexican Grill - Southold
Señor Taco Mexican Grill - Southold
MexicanSouthold4.9 milesPrice range $15-30
LT Burger
LT Burger
AmericanSag Harbor5.2 milesPrice range $15-30
Elaia Esiatorio
Elaia Esiatorio
MediterraneanBridgehampton9.3 milesPrice range $30-60
Carissa's Bakery -Sag Harbor 3 Bay Street
Carissa's Bakery -Sag Harbor 3 Bay Street
Rated 5.0 out of 5 by 12 guestsBakerySag Harbor5.1 milesPrice range $1-15
Dopo il Ponte 2402 Montauk hwy
Dopo il Ponte 2402 Montauk hwy
ItalianBridgehampton9.3 milesPrice range $60+
K PASA
K PASA
LatinSag Harbor5.0 milesPrice range $15-30
Pip's Cafe & Provisions
Pip's Cafe & Provisions
Cafe / Coffee ShopGreenport2.6 milesPrice range $1-15
Brick Oven La Capricciosa Pizza
Brick Oven La Capricciosa Pizza
Rated 5.0 out of 5 by 12 guestsItalianGreenport2.6 milesPrice range $1-15
Legends Restaurant
Legends Restaurant
Rated 4.9 out of 5 by 20 guestsBar / PubNew Suffolk8.7 milesPrice range $30-60
Almond - Brigehampton 2495 Montauk Highway
Almond - Brigehampton 2495 Montauk Highway
EuropeanBridgehampton9.3 milesPrice range $60+
Dopo La Spiaggia 6 Bay Street
Dopo La Spiaggia 6 Bay Street
EuropeanSag Harbor5.2 milesPrice range $60+
Harbor Market Kitchen - Catering
Harbor Market Kitchen - Catering
Gift Shop / MarketSag Harbor5.5 milesPrice range $60+
Léon 1909 29 Westneck rd
Léon 1909 29 Westneck rd
EuropeanShelter Island Heights1.0 milesPrice range $60+
The North Fork Table & Inn 57225 Main Road
The North Fork Table & Inn 57225 Main Road
AmericanSouthold4.1 miles
Dopo il Ponte CHURNED - DO NOT USE
Dopo il Ponte CHURNED - DO NOT USE
ItalianBridgehampton9.3 miles
Waypoint Restaurant 400 OLD MAIN RD
Waypoint Restaurant 400 OLD MAIN RD
AmericanSouthold3.3 milesPrice range $30-60
Nourish By The Roundtree
Nourish By The Roundtree
AmericanBridgehampton8.9 milesPrice range $60+