Skip to Main content
  • Benny's Pizza 18 West Road

    • Home
    • /
    • Pleasant Valley
    • /
    • Benny's Pizza
    • /
    • Online Ordering

    This restaurant does not have any images

    Pizza

    Benny's Pizza

    18 West Road

    Pleasant Valley, NY 12569


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Website

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Benny's Pizza
    Everyday Special!
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • Wings

      $8.99+
    • Large Pizza (16")

      $15.99

    Benny's Pizza

    Appetizers

    • Beef Patty

      $3.99
    • Beef Patty w cheese

      $4.99
    • Boneless Wings

      $8.99+
    • Bread Sticks w Garlic (3)

      $4.99
    • Bread Sticks W Garlic & Cheese (3)

      $5.99
    • Broccoli Bites (8)

      $8.99
    • Calamari

      $13.99
    • Chicken Fingers

      $10.99
    • Chicken Fingers & Fries

      $13.99
    • French Fries

      $5.99
    • Garlic Bread

      $6.99
    • Garlic Bread w/ Cheese

      $7.99
    • Garlic Knot Slider - Chicken

      Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce in our house-made Garlic Knot Bun
      $5.99
    • Garlic Knot Slider - Meatball

      Meatball, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce in our house-made Garlic Knot Bun
      $5.99
    • Garlic Knot Slider - Sausage & Pepper

      Sausage, Peppers, Onions, and Marinara Sauce in our house-made Garlic Knot Bun
      $5.99
    • Garlic Knots (6)

      $4.99
    • Garlic Knots w/ Cheese

      $5.99
    • Jalapeno Poppers (6)

      $9.99
    • Mac & Cheese Bites (8)

      $9.99
    • Mozzarella Sticks

      $9.99
    • Quesadilla - Chicken

      Chicken, Cheese, Peppers, Onions
      $13.99
    • Quesadilla - Steak

      Steak, Cheese, Peppers, Onions
      $14.99
    • Toasted Ravioli

      $9.99
    • Wings

      $8.99+

    Salads

    • Antipasto Salad

      Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Cucumbers, Salami, Olives, Ham, Mozzarella
      $14.99
    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine Lettuce with Croutons
      $9.99
    • Chef Salad

      Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Cucumbers, Ham, Turkey & Mozzarella
      $13.99
    • Garden Salad

      Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Cucumbers, Carrots
      $8.99
    • Greek Salad

      Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Black Olives, and Feta Cheese
      $13.99
    • Side Salad

      A smaller portion of our Garden Salad. Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Cucumbers, Carrots
      $5.99

    Soups

    • Chicken Noodle

      $7.99
    • Chili

      $7.99
    • Pasta Fagioli

      $7.99
    • Veggie Chili

      $7.99

    Pizza

    • Personal Pizza (12")

      $11.99
    • Small Pizza (14")

      $14.99
    • Large Pizza (16")

      $15.99
    • Sicilian

      $21.99
    • Gluten Free Pizza

      $14.99
    • Cauliflower

      $14.99

    Pasta

    • Alfredo

      $17.99
    • Baked Ziti

      Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella & Ricotta
      $15.99
    • Cheese Ravioli

      $15.99
    • Eggplant Rollatini

      $19.99
    • Kids Pasta

      Small portion of pasta with butter or marinara sauce
      $7.99
    • Lasagna

      $18.99
    • Meat Sauce

      $15.99
    • Pasta Marinara

      $12.99
    • Pasta with Broccoli, Garlic & Oil

      $15.99
    • Pasta with Garlic & Oil

      $12.99
    • Penne Vodka

      $17.99
    • Spaghetti & Meatballs

      $15.99
    • Stuffed Shells

      $15.99

    Entrees (served over pasta with a side salad & bread.)

    • Chicken Scarpariello

      Pan Seared Chicken, Sausage, Onion, Cherry Peppers & White Wine Sauce
      $23.99
    • Chicken Francese

      Lightly Battered Pan Fried Chicken Breast, Simmered over Buttery White Wine Lemon Sauce
      $22.99
    • Chicken Marsala

      Pan Seared Chicken, Sautéed Mushrooms & Marsala Wine
      $22.99
    • Parmigiana

      Chicken, Meatball, or Eggplant with Marinara Sauce & Mozzarella
      $21.99

    Seafood Entrees

    • Linguini w Clam sauce

      Sautéed Clams with Garlic, Parsley, Olive Oil and Red or White Wine
      $22.99
    • Shrimp Francese

      Lightly Battered Pan Fried Shrimp, Simmered Over Buttery White Wine Lemon Sauce
      $23.99
    • Shrimp Parmigiana

      Shrimp, Marinara Sauce & Mozzarella
      $23.99
    • Shrimp Scampi

      Shrimp Sautéed in Garlic Butter & White Wine Sauce served over Pasta
      $23.99

    Wraps

    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Crispy Chicken Cutlet tossed in our House-made Buffalo Sauce, with Lettuce
      $12.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

      Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Ranch with Lettuce
      $12.99
    • Chicken Wrap

      Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Lettuce, Tomatoes
      $12.99
    • Gjonis Wrap

      Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Penne Vodka, Mozzarella
      $13.99
    • Grilled Chicken Wrap

      Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Tomatoes
      $12.99
    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

      $12.99
    • Crispy Chicken Caesar Wrap

      $12.99
    • Turkey Wrap

      Turkey, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayo & American Cheese
      $12.99

    Calzones

    • Cheese Calzone

      $8.99
    • Chicken Calzone

      $10.99
    • Ham Calzone

      $10.99
    • Pepperoni Calzone

      $10.99
    • Sausage Calzone

      $10.99
    • Spinach Calzone

      $10.99

    Rolls/Pinwheels

    • Chicken Roll

      $9.99
    • Eggplant Roll

      $9.99
    • Ham Roll

      $9.99
    • Pepperoni Roll

      $9.99
    • Sausage & Peppers Roll

      $9.99
    • Spinach Roll

      $9.99
    • Stromboli

      Ham, Pepperoni, Salami
      $12.99
    • Pinwheels (3) - Chicken Parm

      $14.99
    • Pinwheels (3) - Vodka Chicken Parm

      $14.99
    • Pinwheels(3) - Buffalo Chicken

      $14.99
    • Pinwheels (3) - Chicken Bacon Ranch

      $14.99
    • Pinwheels (3) - Pepperoni & Hot Honey

      $14.99

    Cold Sandwiches

    • Ham & Cheese Sandwich

      Ham, cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes & mayo
      $11.99
    • Italian Combo Sandwich

      Ham, salami, cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, oil, vinegar
      $13.99
    • Salami & Cheese Sandwich

      Salami, cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes
      $11.99
    • Turkey & Cheese Sandwich

      Turkey cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes & mayo
      $11.99
    • American Combo

      Ham, Turkey, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo
      $13.99

    Hot Sandwiches

    • The 914

      Chicken Cutlet. Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers
      $13.99
    • Buffalo Jack Sandwich

      Crispy Chicken Cutlet, House-made Buffalo Sauce, Mozzarella
      $12.99
    • Chicken Club Sandwich

      Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayo
      $12.99
    • Chicken Parm Sandwich

      Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce
      $12.99
    • Vodka Chicken Parm Sandwich

      Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Mozzarella, House-made Vodka Sauce
      $13.99
    • Eggplant Parm Sandwich

      Eggplant, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce
      $12.99
    • Meatball Parm Sandwich

      Meatballs, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce
      $12.99
    • Pepper & Eggs Wedge

      $9.99
    • Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich

      Chopped Steak w/ Peppers, Onions, American Cheese
      $13.99
    • Sausage & Peppers Sandwich

      w/ Onions & Marinara Sauce
      $12.99
    • Sausage Parm Sandwich

      Sausage, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce
      $12.99
    • Shrimp Parmigiana Sandwich

      Shrimp, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce
      $13.99
    • Chicken Francese Sandwich

      $13.99

    Side Order

    • Broccoli Garlic & Oil

      $6.99
    • Side Meatballs

      $6.99
    • Side Sausage

      $6.99
    • Spinach Garlic & Oil

      $6.99
    • Side of Grilled Chicken

      $6.99
    • Side of Chicken Cutlet (Breaded)

      $6.99

    Desserts

    • Cannoli

      $4.99
    • Cheesecake

      $5.99
    • Tiramisu

      $5.99
    • Zeppoli

      $5.99

    Slices

    • Plain Slice

      $4.00
    • Specialty Slice

      $4.50

    Drinks

    • 2 Liter

      $4.25
    • 20 oz

      $2.75
    • Cans

      $1.85
    • Sports Drinks

      $3.50
    • Gold Peak

      $3.50
    • Water

      $2.00
    • Az

      $1.00
    • Starbucks Frapp

      $3.75

    Catering

    • 40 Pieces

      BBQ, Mild, Hot, or Extra Hot
      $65.00
    • 80 Pieces

      BBQ, Mild, Hot, or Extra Hot
      $110.00
    • Alfredo

      Must order in person
      $55.00+
    • American Combo - $23/ft

      Must order in person
      $69.00+
    • Antipasto Salad

      Must order in person
      $55.00+
    • Baked Ziti

      $50.00+
    • Caesar Salad

      Must order in person
      $40.00+
    • Cheese Raviolli

      Must order in person
      $50.00+
    • Chicken Cutlet - $25/ft

      Must order in person
      $75.00+
    • Chicken Francese

      Must order in person
      $65.00+
    • Chicken Marsala

      Must order in person
      $65.00+
    • Chicken Parmigiana

      Must order in person
      $65.00+
    • Chicken Scarpariello

      Must order in person
      $70.00+
    • Chicken Tenders

      Must order in person
      $55.00+
    • Eggplant Parmigiana

      Must order in person
      $65.00+
    • Eggplant Rollatini

      Must order in person
      $65.00+
    • Garden Salad

      Must order in person
      $40.00+
    • Garlic Knots

      Must order in person
      $35.00+
    • Greek Salad

      Must order in person
      $55.00+
    • Italian Combo - $23/ft

      Must order in person
      $69.00+
    • Lasagna

      Must order in person
      $60.00+
    • Meatball Parmigiana

      Must order in person
      $65.00+
    • Meatballs

      $60.00+
    • Mozzarella Sticks

      Must order in person
      $55.00+
    • Pasta Marinara

      Must order in person
      $45.00+
    • Pasta with Broccoli Garlic & Oil

      Must order in person
      $50.00+
    • Pasta with Garlic & Oil

      Must order in person
      $45.00+
    • Penne Vodka

      Must order in person
      $55.00+
    • Sausage & Peppers

      Must order in person
      $60.00+
    • Stuffed Shells

      Must order in person
      $50.00+

    * Paninis * NEW

    • The Capri Press

      Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, Garlic, Pesto Sauce, served w/ fries
      $15.99
    • The Adriatic

      Eggplant, Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Balsamic Glaze, served w/ fries
      $15.99
    • The Southwest Smoke

      Roasted Turkey, Cheddar Cheese, Cajun Spice, Chipotle Mayo, served w/ fries
      $15.99
    • The Backyard Melt

      Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Ranch, served w/ fries
      $15.99
    • The Sweet Heat

      Chicken Cutlet, Jalapenos, American Cheese, Hot Honey, Chipotle Mayo, served w/ fries
      $15.99

    Everyday Special!

    • Large Cheese Pie, Penne Vodka, Garlic Knots

      $30.99

    Alfredo

    $0.00

    Must order in person

    Customize your item

    Size

    Required
    Select 1
    1

    All hours
    Sunday11:45 am - 7:45 pm
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday10:45 am - 8:30 pm
    Wednesday10:45 am - 8:30 pm
    Thursday10:45 am - 8:30 pm
    Friday10:45 am - 8:30 pm
    Saturday10:45 am - 8:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    18 West Road, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569

    Directions