This restaurant does not have any images
American
Carl's Tavern
3386 William Penn Highway
Pittsburgh, PA 15235
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
Lrg Fries
1 lb of Straight Fries$4.50
Carl's Famous Fish
A Pittsburgh Classic. Carl started serving these in Braddock in the 1950's. 12-16oz Atlantic Cod that is lightly hand breaded. Served on a fresh roll, cocktail and tarter on the side.$15.99
Famous Fish Platter
The Best in the Burgh. 12 -16 oz Cod lightly breaded. Served with Fries and coleslaw$17.99
LENT 2026

21 Shrimp
8oz of breaded shrimp served with french fries. Cocktail on the side.$12.99
Baked Fish Platter
A 12-16 piece of Cod. Seasoned and baked served with your choice of two sides.$19.99
Carl's Famous Fish
A Pittsburgh Classic. Carl started serving these in Braddock in the 1950's. 12-16oz Atlantic Cod that is lightly hand breaded. Served on a fresh roll, cocktail and tarter on the side.$15.99
Clams Strips
lightly breaded clam strips served with french fries.$12.99
Famous Fish Platter
The Best in the Burgh. 12 -16 oz Cod lightly breaded. Served with Fries and coleslaw$17.99FireCracker Shrimp App
$8.99Fried Oysters
Breaded Oysters served with cocktail sauce.$8.99Fried Shrimp
4 lightly breaded fantailed shrimp. Try them with the Kuro Sauce!$8.99
Lobster Bisq
8oz of Creamy Lobster Bisq!$7.49Lobster Seafood Roll
$13.99OUT OF STOCKhaluski app
$3.99OUT OF STOCK
Pierogies
Delicious potato and cheese stuffed pierogies. Cooked with buttered onions. Served with a family recipe bacon sauce.$9.99
Po' Boy
Southern classic. Hand breaded shrimp served on a 9" hoagie bun. Topped with pickles, lettuce, tomato, and a spicy mayo.$13.99Po' Boy Wrap
Don't want the Po' boy and all its bread? Thats fine. You can have it in a wrap!$13.99Shrimp Scampi
Shrimp cooked in wine, garlic, and butter. Add in the cherry tomatoes and top it with some fresh parm cheese. Poured over a large bed of noodles. That special someone might not want to kiss you after this explosion of flavor.$18.99Veg Head
Vegan option hoagie. Grilled tomato, banana peppers, broccoli, green peppers, and fried onion straws. Pepper jack cheese on top.$12.99Zucchini Po'Boy
Skip the Shrimp. Sub zucchini and make it another vegan option.$10.99
Fries
Small Fries
1/2 of Straight Cut Fries$2.50Sm Curly Fries
1/2lb of Seasoned Curly Fries$3.75Lrg Curly Fries
1lb of Seasoned Curly Fries$6.99Lrg Fries
1 lb of Straight Fries$4.50Sm Batter Fry
1/2 lb of Crispy Battered Fries$3.99Lrg Batter fry
1 lb of Crispy Battered Fries$7.50Sm Shoestring
1/2 lb of Salted Shoestring Fries$3.75Lrg Shoestring
1 lb of Salted Shoestring Fries$6.99
22 Fries
1 lb of straight cut fries topped with chili, cheese, bacon, and peppers.$10.99
Appetizers
Side of Ranch
$0.99Side of Cheez
$1.00Applesauce
$1.99
Banana Peppers
Hand Stuffed Banana Peppers. Stuffed with Frankie's hot sausage.$12.99Broc Ched Pops
5 Cheddar and Broccoli stuffed bites$6.99Broccoli
Served as a side. Steamed and lightly buttered$3.99Buffalo Chic Dip PITAS
Homemade Shredded Buffalo Chicken Dip$11.99Buffalo Chic Dip w Chips
Homemade Shredded Buffalo Chicken Dip$9.99
Cheese Plate
Cubed Provolone, Swiss, Cheddar, and Hot Pepper Cheeses. Served with crackers, peppers, peperoni, and olives.$10.99Cheese-balls
Fried Cheese Balls of your choice. Hot Pepper or Cheddar.$6.99Cheesy Bread
Hand tossed dough with garlic butter and cheese.$11.99Cole Slaw
Creamy homemade Slaw.$2.99Fire Cracker Shrimp
$8.99Fried Cauliflower
Lightly breaded cauliflower$6.99Fried Mushrooms
Lightly butter breaded mushrooms$6.99Fried Oysters
Breaded Oysters served with cocktail sauce.$8.99Fried Shrimp
4 lightly breaded fantailed shrimp. Try them with the Kuro Sauce!$8.99Garlic Toast
2 Slices of you guessed it. Garlic Toast.$1.99Jalapeno Ched Poppers
Priced Individually. Jalapeno Stuffed with Cheddar Cheese.$0.99Jalapeno Creme Poppers
Priced Individually. Jalapeno Stuffed with Cream Cheese.$0.99Kosher Pickle
One whole pickle sliced into 4 spears.$2.99
Lrg Chips
1 lb of Freshly Sliced chips. Choices of plain, seasoned, cajun, or salt n peppered.$7.99Mashed Potatos
Fluffy Buttered Homemade Mashed Potatos.$3.99
Mini Tacos
Small tortillas stuffed with chicken. Deep Fried.$6.99
Nachos
Crispy Chips topped with Cheese and Jalapenos$6.50Nachos Loaded
Crispy Chips topped with Chili, Cheese, and Jalapenos.$8.75Onion Rings
$6.99
Pepperoni Roll
Hand rolled dough stuffed with cheese and pepperoni slices.$10.99Pickle Slice
$0.99
Pierogies
Delicious potato and cheese stuffed pierogies. Cooked with buttered onions. Served with a family recipe bacon sauce.$9.99Pierogies n Kielbasa
Delicious potato and cheese stuffed pierogies. Cooked with buttered onions. Served with a family recipe bacon sauce. Now add some Kielbasa!$12.99Potato Pancakes
A classic fried potato pancake. Served with sour cream or applesauce.$6.99Provolone Stick
4 Mozzarella/Provolone stuff sticks.$6.99Rice Side
$2.99
Sampler
Cant decide. Try this. Zucchini, mushrooms, onion rings, and provolone sticks. served with marinara.$10.99Sm Chips
1/2 lb of Freshly Sliced chips. Choices of plain, seasoned, cajun, or salt n peppered.$4.25
Zucchini
Large Planks of breaded Zucchini. Served with ranch or marinara.$9.99
Soups
Salads
Caesar Dinner Salad LARGE
Large portion of freshly chopped romaine. Topped with Caesar dressing, parm cheese, and croutons.$6.99Caesar/Chicken Salad
Large portion of freshly chopped romaine. Topped with a 6oz Chicken breast, Caesar dressing, parm cheese, and croutons.$14.99Caesar/Steak Salad
Large portion of freshly chopped romaine. Topped with a 6oz Flat Iron Steak, Caesar dressing, parm cheese, and croutons.$16.99Chef Salad
A refreshing blend of Iceberg lettuce and spring mix. Topped with ham, turkey, american, swiss, and a hard boiled egg.$13.99Chicken Salad
A true PGH salad. Iceberg and spring mix. Topped with green peppers, cucumbers, banana peppers, french fries, and cheese.$14.99
Steak Salad
A true PGH salad. Iceberg and spring mix. Topped with green peppers, cucumbers, banana peppers, french fries, onion straws, and cheese.$16.99Tossed Salad
Small Tossed Salad. Mixture of iceberg and spring mix. Topped with croutons, cheese, green peppers, cucumbers, and banana peppers.$4.99Steak N Chic Salad
$21.99Caesar House Salad SMALL
A smaller portion of freshly chopped romaine. Topped with Caesar dressing, parm cheese, and croutons.$6.99
Bowls

Chx Pontoon Bowl
Becoming one of our most popular items. This bowl is full of rice, broccoli, bacon, and your choices of protein. Chicken and shrimp are seasoned with Cajun. All tossed in our secret Kuro Sauce! Try a single protein, double protein, or go completely crazy with all Three.$14.99Shrimp Pontoon Bowl
Becoming one of our most popular items. This bowl is full of rice, broccoli, bacon, and your choices of protein. Chicken and shrimp are seasoned with Cajun. All tossed in our secret Kuro Sauce! Try a single protein, double protein, or go completely crazy with all Three.$14.99Chx/Shrmp Pton Bowl
Becoming one of our most popular items. This bowl is full of rice, broccoli, bacon, and your choices of protein. Chicken and shrimp are seasoned with Cajun. All tossed in our secret Kuro Sauce! Try a single protein, double protein, or go completely crazy with all Three.$20.99Triple Bowl
All da meats. Tossed in our kuro sauce and served over rice, bacon, and broccoli.$24.99Steak Pontoon
Becoming one of our most popular items. This bowl is full of rice, broccoli, bacon, and your choices of protein. Chicken and shrimp are seasoned with Cajun. All tossed in our secret Kuro Sauce! Try a single protein, double protein, or go completely crazy with all Three.$17.99Chicken N Steak Bowl
Our Pontoon bowl with these choices of meats$20.99Steak And Shrimp Bowl
Becoming one of our most popular items. This bowl is full of rice, broccoli, bacon, and your choices of protein. Chicken and shrimp are seasoned with Cajun. All tossed in our secret Kuro Sauce! Try a single protein, double protein, or go completely crazy with all Three.$20.99Mash Kielbasa Bowl
This one can fill you up. Homemade mashed potatoes topped with kraut and kielbasa.$10.99
Wings

10 Wings
10 jumbo cut wings. Your choice to have them breaded or not. Adding sauce to breaded wing will soften the crispy breading. Limited two one flavor per order. Extra sauce my be included on the side.$15.956 Jumbo Wings
6 Jumbo whole wings. Cooked to a juicy perfection. Wanted them fried hard. Just ask. limit one flavor per order.$15.955 Wings
5 jumbo cut wings. Your choice to have them breaded or not. Adding sauce to breaded wing will soften the crispy breading.$8.503 Jumbo Wings
3 Jumbo whole wings. Cooked to a juicy perfection. Wanted them fried hard. Just ask. Limit one flavor per order.$8.50Ranch and Celery
$1.50Bleu Cheese and Celery
$1.50Ranch
$0.99Bleu Cheese
$0.99Celery Only
$0.7512 Whole Wings
12 Jumbo whole wings. Cooked to a juicy perfection. Wanted them fried hard. Just ask. Limit 2 flavors.$26.00Extra Buffalo
Homemade Buffalo. 7 out of 10 on the spice scale.$1.00Extra Dry Guy
Wings tossed in buffalo then sent thru the oven to cook in the sauce!$1.00Extra Erie
A mixture of Pittsburgh (butter garlic) and Buffalo. Think about it!$1.00BBQ
Homemade BBQ. A little tangy and a little smokey.$1.00Seasoned
$1.00Pittsburgh
Butter Garlic$1.00Kuro
Homemade Asian Sauce.. Kind of like a Carl's Chili Sauce. But better.$1.00Carolina Tangy
Southern BBQ. Mustard based.$1.00Bruce Lee
Our Kuro and Buffalo mixed. Asian sauce with a KICK.$1.00
Burgers
Carl Burger
The Original! The Best in the Burgh! 8oz of a Triple blend ground meat. Served on a Fresh Triangle Bread Bun. Topped with your choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle!$11.99
Double B Que Burger
8oz of Triple Blend ground meat. Topped with bacon, onion straws, lettuce, and tomato. Adding to the flavor is a houses made tangy bbq sauce.$13.99My Boy Bleu
8oz of Triple Blend ground meat. Topped with bacon, dry bleu cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion.$13.99
The Past Time
This is a mouthful of flavor. 8oz of Triple Blend ground meat, pastrami, fried onions, and a fried egg. Your choice of cheese.$13.99Shroom and Swiss
8oz of Triple Blend ground meat topped with mushrooms, lettuce, tomato, onion and Swiss cheese.$13.99The Pig and Cow
8oz of Triple Blend ground meat, fresh pulled pork, coleslaw, and a house made tangy bbq. Try some cheese on top if you would like!$13.99
The Overbite
Our Biggest Burger on the list! 10oz of Triple Blend ground meat!! That's 2 5oz patties topped with cheese, lettuce, tomato, and 1000 island dressing.$13.99RustyBurger
A true classic. Brock's favorite burger. 5oz of Triple Blend ground meat, bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Add a fried egg to heighten the experience!$10.99Hamburger
5oz of Triple Blend ground meat, lettuce, and tomato.$8.99Cheeseburger
5oz of Triple Blend ground meat,your choice of cheese, lettuce, and tomato.$9.99
Baskets

21 Shrimp
8oz of breaded shrimp served with french fries. Cocktail on the side.$12.99Cajun Shrimp
a variation of our 21 shrimp. These have a crispy cajun breading instead.$13.99Chicken Fingers
Breaded chicken fingers served with fries.$12.99
Clams Strips
lightly breaded clam strips served with french fries.$12.99
Dinners

Baked Fish Platter
A 12-16 piece of Cod. Seasoned and baked served with your choice of two sides.$19.99Chicken Plate
Two 6oz chicken breast. Seasoned to your liking. Served with two sides.$17.99
Famous Fish Platter
The Best in the Burgh. 12 -16 oz Cod lightly breaded. Served with Fries and coleslaw$17.99
Ma's Meatloaf
Homemade Meatloaf served with mashed potatoes or fries. All covered by another homemade gravy.$14.99Hot Roast Beef
Thin Sliced Roast Beef covered in brown gravy and your choice of fries or mashed.$13.99
Hot Turkey
Delicious Turkey breast covered in homemade gravy with your choice of Fries or mashed potatoes.$13.99Missing Home
A new spin off of our classic meatloaf. This comes with a extra half of meatloaf. Covered with onion straws and our homemade BBQ. Mashed potatoes on the side.$14.99
The Worx
6oz natural chicken breast. 8 cajun grilled shrimp and your choice of a side.$18.99
Sandwiches
Gluten Free Bun
add this if you would like one of your sandwich choices on a gluten free hoagie bun.$3.00
Barking Dog
All beef hot dog topped with a hand stuff banana pepper, Pepper Jack cheese, lettuce, and tomato.$9.99BLT
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato. just sayin... Served on Italian Bread.$10.99Buffalo Ceasar Wrap
Fried or Grill Chicken tossed in buffalo. Wrapped up with parm cheese, romaine, and caesar dressing.$13.99Cap N' Beef
9' hoagie with Roast beef, capicola, provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato. We add Balsamic and a homemade tangy sauce!$14.99
Cap N' Beef Supreme
9' hoagie with Roast beef, capicola, provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato. We add Balsamic and a homemade tangy sauce! Making it supreme adds a fried egg, bacon, and peperoni.$16.99
Carl's Famous Fish
A Pittsburgh Classic. Carl started serving these in Braddock in the 1950's. 12-16oz Atlantic Cod that is lightly hand breaded. Served on a fresh roll, cocktail and tarter on the side.$15.99Carlos Diablos
6oz Natural Chicken breast topped with a hand stuff banana pepper, lettuce, tomato, and a spicy ranch.$13.99Chicken AHOLIE Wrap
Imagine a cajun chicken salad but in a wrap. Chicken, fries, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and shredded cheeses. Topped off with some ranch!$14.99Chicken Parm Sandwich
Fried or Grill chicken. Topped with a marinara and provolone cheese.$13.99Chicken Pita
Some people call it a chicken gyro. But this pita is filled with chicken, lettuce, tomato, and onion. Tzatki sauce on the side$12.99
Chicken Rancher
6oz Chicken breast topped with provolone cheese, bacon, lettuce, and tomato.$13.99Chicken Sandwich
6oz natural chicken breast. Your choice to have it fried or grilled. Comes with Lettuce and tomato.$11.99Chipotle Club Wrap
This wrapped is filled with ham, turkey, bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, and a chipotle sauce.$13.99Combo Club
A classic that isnt on our actual menu. Ham, turkey, swiss, american, lettuce, and tomato. Served on our italian bread.$13.99
Confucius
One of our top selling sammiches. This fried and dry guy'd chicken breast is topped with capicola, bacon, pepperoni, and provolone cheese. The lightly toasted bun has pizza sauce to add some more flavor.$14.99Corned Beef
Our freshly sliced corn beef with onion and tomato. Can be served hot or cold. Our marble rye is lightly toasted.$13.99French Dip
Served on a 9" hoagie bun. Thinly sliced roast beef and swiss cheese. Aujus on the side.$12.99Grill Cheese
Cheese, Butter Bread, and grilled. There's fun stuff to add if you would like.$8.99Gyro
Big and beautiful gyro. This is an underrated item on our menu. Sliced of a spit meat with lettuce, tomato, onion, and tzatki on the side.$11.99Ham and Cheese
Low Key Simple and delicious. Server Hot with lettuce, tomato, and onion.$12.99Hot Dog
All beef weiner in a cozy roll.$6.25Hot Pastrami
Thinly sliced pastrami served on marble rye. Onion and tomato. Pick a cheese if you would like. Served Hot.$12.99Hot Sausage
Locally produced Frankie's mild sausage on a toasted bun. Served with green peppers and onions in a red sauce.$12.99Italian Hoagie
What's better than a Pgh EYE-TALIAN hoagie. Ham, cap, pepperoni, salami, provolone, banana peppers, lettuce, onion, and tomato. Italian dressing on it all! Served hot and toasted$12.99Jamaican Me Hungry
Jamaican breaded chicken breast with lettuce , tomato. and a white bbq sauce. def worth a try.$13.99Meatball Hoagie
Homemade meatballs on a 9" hoagie bun. Marinara and Provolone cheese on top.$12.99Philly Select
Choice of Steak or chicken. Provolone cheese, green peppers and onions.$12.99
Po' Boy
Southern classic. Hand breaded shrimp served on a 9" hoagie bun. Topped with pickles, lettuce, tomato, and a spicy mayo.$13.99Po' Boy Wrap
Don't want the Po' boy and all its bread? Thats fine. You can have it in a wrap!$13.99Pulled Pork
Pulled in house.....get your mind out of the gutter... Pulled pork on a toasted bun served with bbq on top.$12.99Rachel
Sometimes confused in today's times. Our rachel can be turkey, corn beef, cornbeef and pastrami. Topped WITH COLESLAW. and also 1000 island dressing.$14.99
Reuben
Thinly sliced corn beef with swiss cheese, kraut and 1000 island dressing. Served on a toasted marble rye. Can be served with a 50/50 blend of pastrami. Also can be served with turkey also.$14.99Rustic Chicken
6oz natural chicken breast topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Bbq on the side.$13.99Sizzlin Steak Wrap
Cajun flavored chipped steak. Pepper Jack cheese, onions, and green peppers.$13.99Son o' Diablo
Send your taste buds on a trip. Fried Chicken breast, stuffed banana pepper, bacon, tangy bbq, and marinara.$13.99Southwest Select Wrap
Cajun Chicken wrap filled with pepper jack cheese, green peppers, and onions.$13.99Tangy Pig
Spice up our Pulled pork sammich with onion straws, coleslaw, and a tangy bbq.$13.99Tribute
Hand breaded chicken breast with bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and kuro. Dont skip these sauces together.$13.99Turkey Club
Thickly sliced turkey breast on italian bread. Topped with American cheese, bacon, lettuce, and tomato.$11.99Turkey Reuben
Thickly Sliced roasted turkey breast. Served on toasted marble rye. Kraut, 1000 island, and Swiss Cheese.$14.99Veg Head
Vegan option hoagie. Grilled tomato, banana peppers, broccoli, green peppers, and fried onion straws. Pepper jack cheese on top.$12.99Zucchini Parm Sndwch
Another Vegan option. Zucchini planks topped with marinara and provolone cheese. Served on a toasted hoagie bun.$10.99Zucchini Po'Boy
Skip the Shrimp. Sub zucchini and make it another vegan option.$10.99Lobster Roll
$15.99Nashville Hot Sandwich
$13.99
Steak/Ribs

6oz Steak
6oz flat iron steak cooked to your liking. Served with two sides.$18.99Full Rack Ribs
A legit full rack of ribs. cooked in house. Bones will fall right out, Served with two sides.$28.99OUT OF STOCKHalf Rack
Generous sided half rack of ribs. cooked in house. Bones will fall right out, Served with two sides.$13.99OUT OF STOCK
Pizza
Noodles
All Pastas are served with a salad and garlic toast.
Banana Pep Pasta
Two hand stuffed banana peppers over a large plate of noodles and marinara.$16.99Chicken Parm Pasta
Breaded Chicken breast smothered in marinara and provolone cheese. Over a bed of noodles. Make it grilled chicken if you would like.$15.99Chili Pasta
Sometimes called german pasta. Our version has a large bed of noodles and topped with our homemade chili.$12.99Shrimp Scampi
Shrimp cooked in wine, garlic, and butter. Add in the cherry tomatoes and top it with some fresh parm cheese. Poured over a large bed of noodles. That special someone might not want to kiss you after this explosion of flavor.$18.99Spaghetti
Welp. You guessed it. Large plate of noodles and a tasty marinara!$10.99Spaghetti N' Meatballs
Homemade meatballs. Very light and flavorful. Over a large plate of noodles.$14.99
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.
Pulled Pork
$12.99
Pulled in house.....get your mind out of the gutter... Pulled pork on a toasted bun served with bbq on top.
Customize your item
Cheese Choice
Select up to 3
Pull Pork No's
Optional
Pull Pork Add On's
Optional
Request advisory
No substitutes. Additions may be charged extra.
1
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 10:45 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 10:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Come on in and enjoy!
Location
