American
Fairport Harbor Creamery
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
‌
‌
‌
Ice Cream Pies & Cakes
Ice Cream Pies
Customized Ice Cream Pie **NEED 48HRS NOTICE**
Don't like our options? We get it. You're the creative genius here! Build your own ice cream pie, add toppings as you please. **NEED 48 HRS NOTICE** If your pick up date isn't 48 hrs from when we receive your order, we will be calling you. Don't make us do that please :)$33.00
Caramel Graham Ice Cream Pie
Graham crust + layers of salted caramel ice cream, House caramel streaks and our graham crumble$36.00
Reese's Ice Cream Pie
Chocolate crust + layers of vanilla ice cream, Reese's chunks, PB & fudge sauce, decorated with vanilla buttercream$36.00
Ice Cream Cakes
Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream Cake
Vanilla cake + strawberry jam & strawberry crunch layer + cheesecake ice cream, decorated in fresh whipped cream & buttercream details$55.00
Cookies&Cream Ice Cream Cake
Chocolate cake, fudge/Oreo dirt crunch layer, cookies and cream ice cream. Decorated with fresh whipped cream, fudges drizzles, Oreo dirt & vanilla buttercream$55.00
Ice Cream
Ice Cream
To-Go Treats
House Drumstick With Peanuts
classic drumstick with vanilla ice cream, chocolate dipped + peanuts, made in house$7.00
BYO Ice Cream Sammy
Build Your Own Ice Cream Sammy!- choose a cookie option- choose a ice cream flavor (single scoop amount)- add toppings for us to roll them in!$7.50
Seasonal To-Go Sundaes
$9.00
Ice Cream Sammy
$7.00Spongebob Bar
$3.60Lemon Italian Ice
$3.60Strawberry Italian Ice
$3.60
S'mores IC Cake Slice
Chocolate cake + fudge/marshmallow & graham layer, vanilla ice cream swirled with graham crumbles + fresh whip/fudge & mallow drizzles$11.50
Fluffernutter IC Cake Slice
Vanilla cake + candied peanuts/PB marshmallow sauce + marshmallow ice cream swirled with peanut butter + fresh whip and PB marshmallow drizzles$11.50Peach Streusel Ice Cream Cake Slice
$11.50
Buckeye Ice Cream Bar
Kind of like a PB Klondike bar! Our buckeye bar base + vanilla ice cream & our candied peanuts, dipped in chocolate dip, topped with PB drizzles, candied peanuts & a little Maldon salt$9.00
Pints (2026)
*BOOZY* Chocolate Pint
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey infused chocolate ice cream$11.65
*BOOZY* Mint Pint
whiskey and creme de menthe infused mint ice cream$11.50*BOOZY* Old Fashioned Pint
Bulleit Bourbon infused ice cream, flavored with Amarena cherries, orange zest and Angostura bitters$12.25
*BOOZY* Vanilla Pint
kahlua and seven brothers expresso vodka infused vanilla ice cream (approx. 4% - 4.5% ABV per pint)$11.50*BOOZY* Whiskey Oreo Pint
Black Velvet whiskey infused Oreo ice cream$11.65
Banana Cream Pie Pint
fresh banana ice cream with house brown butter, oat & vanilla wafer crumble$9.65
Better than Therapy Pint
our rich chocolate ice cream + house caramel streaks and our house chocolate cake crumbles$9.95Blue Moon Pint
blue moon flavored ice cream, soaked & strained out fruity pebble cereal$9.50Blueberry Crumble Pint
sweet cream base + house blueberry jam streaks & our brown butter 'Nilla wafer crumbles$9.75
Butter Pecan Pint
butter pecan ice cream + buttery toasted pecans mixed in$9.75Butterscotch Banana Coffee Pint
butterscotch banana and coffee ice cream$9.65
Chocolate Pint
chocolate ice cream made with Extra Brute cocoa powder, making a sinfully delicious chocolate ice cream$9.75
Cookie Dough Pint
vanilla bean ice cream + house edible cookie dough crumbles$9.65
Cookies & Cream Pint
vanilla ice cream + Oreo cookie chunks$9.50
Cotton Candy Pint
blue cotton candy flavored ice cream$9.50Dark Chocolate Chip Pint
our darkest chocolate ice cream + soft chocolate flakes$9.85Fluffernutter Pint
peanut butter & mallow ice cream + marshmallow streaks mixed in$9.85
Mint Chip Pint
green mint ice cream + soft chocolate flakes$9.50
PB Oreo Pint
real peanut butter ice cream + oreo chunks$9.65
Pineapple Dole Whip Pint
gluten free / soy free / dairy free / vegan Pineapple Dole Whip$9.00
Pomegranate Dole Whip Pint
gluten free/ soy free / dairy free / vegan Dole Whip. pomegranate flavored$9.00S'Mores Pint
toasted marshmallow ice cream with streaks of house chocolate ganache + buttery & toasted graham crumbles$9.95
Salted Caramel Pint
caramel ice cream + salted caramel streaks$9.65Strawberry Pint
strawberry ice cream + house roasted strawberries$9.65
Vanilla Bean Pint
classic vanilla ice cream made with pure Mexican vanilla and vanilla bean$9.65VEGAN Chocolate Pint
a completely vegan/gluten free/soy free chocolate ice cream, made with a coconut base$9.95VEGAN Orange Creamsicle Pint
$9.65Wedding Cake Pint
almondy cake batter ice cream + a house almond cookie crumbles$9.85OUT OF STOCK
Toppings To Go (8oz)
Caramel Topping To Go Container
8oz of caramel sauce$5.00
Cherries To Go Container
8oz of maraschino cherries$4.00
House Crunch Coat
house candied peanuts & rainbow sprinkles$5.50
Homemade Jam
8oz of our homemade jam$7.00
Hot fudge To Go Container
8oz of hot fudge$5.00
PB Sauce To Go Container
8oz of peanut butter sauce$5.50
Sprinkles To Go Container
8oz of sprinkles$3.00
Strawberry Sauce (not jam!) To Go Container
8oz of strawberry sauce$4.00
Waffle Cones (2)
2 waffle cones, for ice cream cone making at home!$2.00
Whipped Cream Can
Did you forget the whip? We've got you!$4.25House Caramel
$7.00
Bakery
Take & Bake Menu
Take&Bake Brown Butter Cookies (6)
6 of our brown butter cookies, frozen and ready to bake! comes with parchment and directions$15.00
Take&Bake Chocolate Chip Cookies (6)
6 of our chocolate chip cookies, frozen and ready to bake. Includes 1 sheet parchment paper, instructions, and enough Maldon salt for all 6$15.00Take&Bake Peanut Butter Cookies (6)
6 of our peanut butter cookies, frozen and ready to bake. Includes 1 sheet parchment paper & instructions$15.004 Take&Bake Scones, savory only
Call for current flavor option! It will always be cheesey, but if you need to know specifics -- 440-898-0030$14.50OUT OF STOCK
Spongebob Bar
$3.60
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
Restaurant info
If this menu is unavailable, it is because the ordering period has closed. Check our social media for when the next menu will be released. Thanks!
Location