American
Fenimore's Table 4871 New York 28
4871 New York 28
Cooperstown, NY 13326
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
Double Smash
Two 4 oz smash patties, american cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, pickles, and special sauce.$17.00Korean Fried BBQ Wings (10)
Double fried, gochujang glaze, Sesame Seeds, Scallions.$18.00Farmhouse Chop
Chopped romaine and greens, carrot, cucumber, tomato, radish, pickled onion, chopped egg, bacon, spurbecks cheddar, crispy onions with buttermilk dressing.$17.00
Food
Appetizers
Wings (10)
Fried or Grilled, with a choice of Buffalo, garlic-miso, Lemon pepper rub, Alabama white. Served with Blue Cheese or Rance and Celery$17.00Korean Fried BBQ Wings (10)
Double fried, gochujang glaze, Sesame Seeds, Scallions.$18.00Charcuterie Board
Rotating selection of cured meats and cheese, pickled vegetables, jam, grilled bread.$26.00French Onion Dip
Slow-cooked onions, sour cream, and crème fraîche, gruyere, topped with crispy onion and chive. Served with house-potato chips.$15.00Pimento-Cheese Dip
Spurbecks aged-cheddar blended with roasted red pepper, garlic, and smoked paprika served with crispy pork rinds.$14.00Mini Crab Cake Sliders
Three petite crab cakes with shredded lettuce, tomato, pickled onion, old bay remoulade sauce.$19.00Fried Calamari
Dredged and fried with banana peppers served with lemon, and spicy marinara sauce.$17.00Pretzel Crusted Cauliflower Bites
Served with honey mustard dipping sauce.$14.00Hummus & Pita
Beet hummus, pickled marinated beets, za’atar spice, crispy garlic, roasted grapes, with grilled pita.$16.00
Soups
Salads
Field Greens
Mixed greens, romaine, carrot, cucumber, cherry tomato, radish, and croutons with red wine herb vinaigrette.$15.00Classic Caesar
Chopped romaine, garlic croutons, shaved parmesan, with house-made caesar dressing.$15.00Farmhouse Chop
Chopped romaine and greens, carrot, cucumber, tomato, radish, pickled onion, chopped egg, bacon, spurbecks cheddar, crispy onions with buttermilk dressing.$17.00Cabbage & Bean Sprout
Cabbage, bean sprout, peanuts, avocados, herbs, with Vietnamese dressing.$17.00
Sandwiches
Served with French Fries or side House Salad. Tater Tots or Waffle Fries $3
Grilled Cheese
Gruyere and Spurbecks aged-cheddar, bacon, tomato on brioche with French fries.$17.00Cheese Quesadilla
Classic cheese with roasted peppers and onions, Monterey jack, cheddar cheese. Served with salsa and sour cream.$15.00Chicken Quesadilla
Braised chicken with roasted peppers and onions, Monterey jack, cheddar cheese, and chicken. Served with salsa and sour cream.$17.00French Conncection
Roasted and thinly sliced ribeye, caramelized onion, gruyere cheese, horseradish mayo, au jus, French roll.$18.00Pork Belly Bahn Mi
Vietnamese sandwich, pickled carrots and onions, Bahn Mi sauce, cilantro, and cucumber served on a toasted sub roll.$16.00Local Bird
Buttermilk dredged and fried chicken, cabbage slaw, chili lime mayo, pickles, on brioche.$17.00Chicken Salad
$17.00
Burgers
AB served on brioche bun / Gluten free +$3 with your choice of French fries or house salad. Tater tots or waffle fries +$3.
Beyond meat or turkey burger +$3 substitution.
Double Smash
Two 4 oz smash patties, american cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, pickles, and special sauce.$17.00House 8 oz Burger
Caramelized onion, bacon, gruyere cheese, lettuce, and thousand island.$18.00Black & Blue Burger
Bacon jam, melty crumbled blue cheese, pickled jalapeno, and garlic aioli.$18.00Mushroom
Beef patty with roasted mushrooms, Swiss cheese, arugula, and garlic aioli.$17.00
Entrees
Rigatoni a ’la Vodka
Rigatoni tossed in a creamy vodka sauce with pancetta and spinach, finished with marinated burrata, fresh basil, and parmesan.$28.00Grilled 12 oz Ribeye
A hand-cut ribeye, grilled to order and served with scalloped potatoes, seasonal broccoli, garlic–herb butter, and a classic demi-glace.$44.00Grilled 10 oz. NY Strip Steak “Frittes”
A tender NY strip paired with crisp potato wedges, bright chimichurri, and housemade garlic aioli.$37.00Sesame Crusted Salmon
Sesame-crusted salmon with a touch of wasabi, served alongside forbidden rice, sautéed spinach, and miso–honey butter.$33.00Peruvian Chicken “La Brasa”
Fire-roasted chicken with baby potatoes and grilled broccolini, finished with a romesco & aji verde sauce.$31.00
Kids
KIDS Chicken Tenders
Crispy fried tenders served with BBQ, honey mustard, or ranch and fries.$13.00KIDS Angus Burger
4 oz CAB patty with American Cheese on a brioche bun served with french fries.$13.00KIDS Hot Dog
Grilled all-beef Nathan’s hot dog on a bun served with french fries.$10.00KIDS Grilled Cheese
American and cheddar cheese on toasted brioche served with french fries.$11.00Kids Cheese Quesadilla
Melty cheddar jack cheese stuffed in a toasted quesadilla with sour cream and salsa.$11.00
Pizza
16” Pizza Pie
*Gluten free options available. Just ask your server.
Margherita
Fresh tomato, creamy mozzarella, basil, and a drizzle of garlic-infused oil.$16.00Hot Pepperoni
Spicy pepperoni, jalapeño, ricotta, and mozzarella finished with a sweet kick of hot honey.$18.00Salciccia
Italian sausage, tender broccoli, smoked mozzarella, and pecorino baked to a savory finish.$17.00Pesto & Burrata
A basil pesto base layered with grilled chicken, creamy burrata, pecorino, and a drizzle of hot honey.$22.00
Build Your Own Pizza
Create your own signature pie by selecting your base and layering on the toppings you love for a pizza tailored to your taste.
Sides
Desserts
Soft Drinks
Sodas
Juice/Milk
Peruvian Chicken “La Brasa”
$31.00
Fire-roasted chicken with baby potatoes and grilled broccolini, finished with a romesco & aji verde sauce.
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:30 am - 8:00 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 9:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 9:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:30 am - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:30 am - 8:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:30 am - 8:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Elevated American Cuisine
Location