Skip to Main content
  • Hefner's Custard Cedarburg

    • Home
    • /
    • Cedarburg
    • /
    • Hefner's Custard
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image
    American

    Hefner's Custard

    N71W5184 Columbia Rd

    Cedarburg, WI 53012


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    GRILL
    DRINKS
    CUSTARD
    SPECIALS
    Pickup Only
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • Jumbo Cheeseburger

      Single hamburger with American cheese and your choice of toppings.
      $7.19
    • Fries

      $3.69
    • Onion Rings

      $4.19

    GRILL

    Sandwiches

    • Jumbo Hamburger

      Single hamburger with your choice of toppings.
      $6.49
    • Jumbo Cheeseburger

      Single hamburger with American cheese and your choice of toppings.
      $7.19
    • Double Hamburger

      Double hamburger with your choice of toppings.
      $9.19
    • Double Cheeseburger

      Double hamburger with American cheese and your choice of toppings.
      $10.19
    • Mushroom Swiss Burger

      Cheeseburger with Swiss cheese and fried mushrooms.
      $8.29
    • Double Mushroom Swiss Burger

      Double cheeseburger with Swiss cheese and fried mushrooms.
      $11.39
    • CEDAR-BURGER

      Cheeseburger topped with Cedar Creek Winery’s pinot grigio Swiss spread, American cheese, bacon and fried onions.
      $9.39
    • Huge Hefner

      Double cheeseburger with extra bun slice, American cheese, lettuce, pickles, raw onions and 1000 island dressing.
      $11.69
    • Fish Sandwich

      Breaded cod fillet sandwich with your choice of toppings.
      $6.69
    • JAWS

      Two breaded cod fillets sandwiched between a hamburger bun and topped with American cheese, lettuce, raw onion and tartar sauce
      $10.49
    • Grilled Cheese

      $3.99
    • Chicken Fingers

      Panko crusted chicken tenderloins with your choice of dipping sauce.
      $7.29
    • Grilled Chicken

      ***NEW Hormel® Fire Braised Chicken Breast Fillet*** Chicken breast fillet fire-seared before being slow-cooked in their own juices. Served with your choice of toppings.
      $7.29
    • Breaded Chicken

      Juicy chicken breast fillet breaded in flour seasoned with salt, pepper, buttermilk and a hint of savory spices.
      $7.29

    Sides

    • Fries

      $3.69
    • Onion Rings

      $4.19
    • Cheese Curds

      $5.49
    • Fry/Ring Mix

      $4.19
    • Tater Tots

      $3.69
    • Cheese Fries

      cheese served on the side
      $4.59
    • Mozzarella Sticks

      served with marinara
      $6.19
    • Breaded Mushrooms

      $5.69
    • Fry/Tot Mix

      $3.89
    • Mini Fried Tacos

      served with sour cream & salsa
      $4.69
    • Tater Tots

      $3.69

    Kids Meals

    • KIDS CORN DOGS

      1 Entrée, 1 Side & 1 Drink
      $6.59
    • KIDS FINGERS

      1 Entrée, 1 Side & 1 Drink
      $6.59
    • KIDS GRILLED CHEESE

      1 Entrée, 1 Side & 1 Drink
      $6.59

    DRINKS

    Sodas

    • Medium Soda

      $2.89
    • Large Soda

      $3.39

    Bottled Drinks

    • Bottled Water

      $0.99
    • AriZona Arnold Palmer

      Half Iced Tea & Half Lemonade
      $2.49
    • Cool Blue Gatorade

      $1.99
    • Fruit Punch Gatorade

      $1.99
    • Lemon-Lime Gatorade

      $1.99

    Kids Drinks

    • Kids Milk

      $1.89
    • Kids Chocolate Milk

      $2.19
    • 100% Juice Box

      $1.49
    • Kids Soda

      $2.09

    Floats/Custard Soda

    • Float

      $4.99
    • Chocolate Custard Soda

      Old fashioned custard soda made with vanilla custard, carbonation and chocolate syrup
      $4.79

    Slush/Custard Smoothie

    • Small Slush

      $2.29
    • Medium Slush

      $2.59
    • Large Slush

      $2.89
    • Small Custard Smoothie

      Blend of vanilla custard, sweet slushie and your flavor choice.
      $3.09
    • Medium Custard Smoothie

      Blend of vanilla custard, sweet slushie and your flavor choice.
      $3.49
    • Large Custard Smoothie

      Blend of vanilla custard, sweet slushie and your flavor choice.
      $3.89

    Milk

    • Small Milk

      $1.89
    • Large Milk

      $2.19
    • Small Chocolate Milk

      $2.19
    • Large Chocolate Milk

      $2.49

    CUSTARD

    Cones/Dishes

    • Baby Cone

      $3.09
    • Baby Dish

      $3.09
    • 1 Scoop Cone

      $3.59
    • 1 Scoop Dish

      $3.59
    • 2 Scoop Cone

      $4.59
    • 2 Scoop Dish

      $4.59
    • 3 Scoop Cone

      $5.49
    • 3 Scoop Dish

      $5.49
    • Waffle Cone

      served with 2 scoops of custard
      $5.29

    Dole® Soft Serve

    • Raspberry Dole® Soft Serve

      Dole® soft serve, served in a dish it is dairy-free, gluten-free, lactose-free and vegetarian.

    Shakes/Malts

    • Regular Shake

      16oz
      $5.39
    • Regular Malt

      16oz
      $5.39
    • Large Shake

      24oz
      $6.39
    • Large Malt

      24oz
      $6.39

    Whiteouts

    • WHITEOUT

      Heaping scoops of vanilla, chocolate or flavor the day custard mixed with your choice of two toppings from our curated list.
      $6.99

    Sundaes

    • Regular Sundae

      1 large scoop of custard with your choice of topping.
      $5.29
    • Large Sundae

      3 scoops of custard with your choice of topping.
      $6.29

    Specialty Sundaes

    • Doggie Delight

      1 scoop of vanilla custard topped with dog biscuits for your pooch!
      $2.99
    • Regular Turtle Sundae

      2 scoops of vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, caramel and pecans.
      $5.99
    • Large Turtle Sundae

      3 scoops of vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, caramel and pecans
      $7.49
    • Banana Split

      3 scoops of vanilla custard cradled by bananas and topped with chocolate syrup, raspberries, strawberries and crushed nuts.
      $7.49
    • Cashew Creation

      3 scoops of vanilla custard topped with marshmallow, butterscotch and cashews.
      $7.49
    • Hefner's Delight

      3 scoops of vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, marshmallow, butterscotch and pecans.
      $7.49
    • Caramel Brownie

      3 scoops of vanilla custard topped with brownie pieces and caramel.
      $6.99

    Packed Custard

    • Pint

      $5.99
    • Quarts

      $10.99
    • 1/2 Gallon

      $17.49

    SPECIALS

    Summer Specials

    • June Special: Shrimp Po Boy

      Southern-style breaded shrimp with lettuce, tomato and remoulade sauce on a French roll.
      $9.49
    • Bavarian Burger

      Cheeseburger topped with American cheese, Swiss cheese, cheddar cheese sauce, bacon, fried onions and served on a pretzel bun.
      $9.79
    • Lobster Roll

      Tom's homemade lobster salad recipe with real lobster, celery, onion and dill. Served in a wrap or on a French roll.
      $9.49
    • Funnel Cake Fries

      Fried funnel cake fries with vanilla custard and cinnamon sugar dusting.
      $5.49
    • Flavor of the Month: M&M's® Cookie Sandwich

      3" Oreo® cookie sandwich filled with vanilla custard and chopped M&M's®.
      $3.99
    • Oreo® Cookie Sandwich

      3" Oreo® cookie sandwich filled with Oreo® pieces and vanilla custard.
      $3.99
    • Cookie Dough Cookie Sandwich

      3" Oreo® cookie sandwich filled with cookie dough chunks and vanilla custard.
      $3.99
    • Trio of Custard Cookie Sandwiches

      This Summer there are 3 options to choose from! We have an Oreo® sandwich with cookie dough, an Oreo® sandwich with Oreo® or June's Cookie of the Month: Oreo® sandwich with vanilla custard and M&M's!
      $11.49
    • June Special: Pink Cotton Candy Shake (Regular)

      Creamy vanilla custard mixed with pink cotton candy flavor then topped with whipped cream and cotton candy crunch.
      $6.29
    • June Special: Pink Cotton Candy Shake (Large)

      Creamy vanilla custard mixed with pink cotton candy flavor then topped with whipped cream and cotton candy crunch.
      $7.29
    • Raspberry Dole® Soft Serve

      Dole® soft serve, served in a dish it is dairy-free, gluten-free, lactose-free and vegetarian.
    • Small Lemonade Slush

      $2.29
    • Medium Lemonade Slush

      $2.59
    • Large Lemonade Slush

      $2.89

    30th Anniversary Specials!

    • Large T-Shirt

      $25.00

    Lobster Roll

    $9.49

    Tom's homemade lobster salad recipe with real lobster, celery, onion and dill. Served in a wrap or on a French roll.

    Customize your item

    Bread Option

    Required
    Select 1
    Request advisory
    Some additions may be charged extra.
    1

    All hours
    Sunday11:00 am - 8:45 pm
    Monday11:00 am - 8:45 pm
    Tuesday11:00 am - 8:45 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 8:45 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 8:45 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 8:45 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 8:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    N71W5184 Columbia Rd, Cedarburg, WI 53012

    Directions