
American
Matty's Bar & Grille
14460 College Ave
New Berlin, WI 53151
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
May Features
CHICKEN ENCHILADA SOUP
Creamy soup, loaded with chicken, corn and beans. Topped with fried tortilla strips.$4.99+FLAUTAS A LA MATTYS
Chicken, refried beans, and melted cheese rolled in a corn tortilla. Fried to perfection! Topped with shredded lettuce and queso fresco. (4) per order. Served with a side of jalapeno ranch.$9.95DARCIE'S TACO DIP
Matty's secret recipe! Topped with shredded lettuce, pico de gallo, black olives, and monterey jack cheese. Served with tortilla chips. Happy birthday month Darcie. This one's for you!$13.95MATTY'S GUACAMOLE & CHIPS
House-made guacamole served with a side of salsa and tortilla chips.$11.95SOUTHWEST EGG ROLLS
Chicken, black beans, corn, monterey jack cheese and peppers wrapped in a wonton. (4) per order. Served with a side of jalapeno ranch.$13.95THE DORITOS BURGER
Doritos encrusted burger, deep fried and topped with pepper jack cheese, pico de gallo, and a drizzle of jalapeno ranch. Served on a brioche bun with a side of Matty's guacamole. Served with your choice of side.$16.95CHEF TONY'S QUESABIRRIA DINNER
Corn tortillas loaded with birria meat and monterey jack cheese. Grilled to perfection with birria consume for dipping. (4) per order. Served with a side of cilantro lime rice, and black beans.$19.99TACO SALAD
Your choice of shredded chicken or ground beef served over a bed of shredded lettuce, black beans, corn, pico de gallo, black olives, fresh jalapenos and shredded cheddar cheese in a deep fried tortilla bowl. Topped with fried tortilla strips. Served with a side of salsa and sour cream.$16.95MATTY'S BURRITO BOWL
Grilled chicken served a bowl of cilantro lime rice with black beans, corn, shredded lettuce, pico de gallo, Matty's guacamole, queso fresco and tortilla strips. Served with a side of jalapeno ranch.$17.95
Appetizers and Sides
Cheese Curds
Lightly Breaded and deep-fried. Made with Fresh Wisconsin white cheddar cheese. Served with a side of buttermilk ranch or chipotle ranch.$10.49Mozzarella Logs
4 flash fried mozzarella logs, served with house made marinara$11.49Homemade Chips & Dip
Fresh potato chips. served with fabulous French Onion Dip$8.99Spinach and Artichoke Dip
A blend of cheeses with fresh spinach and artichoke hearts, served in a bread bowl with a side of tortilla chips and celery.$14.99Smoked Wings
Slow smoked to be tender, plump, and juicy. Served with a choice of ranch or bleu cheese and celery. Available in an order of 8 or 12 wings.$13.49+Fries
Available as a Side Order or a Basket Order.$2.15+Sweet Potato Fries
Available as a Side Order or a Basket Order.$3.20+Side of Fresh Vegetables
$3.20Side of Fresh Fruit
$3.20Side of Mac n' Cheese
$2.15Side of Coleslaw
$1.60Side of Tortilla Chips
$2.15French Onion Dip
$1.60Mallow Dip
$1.60Ranch
$0.55THE BAVARIAN BEAST
$18.95
Entrée Salads
Turkey Cobb Salad
Roasted turkey with roma tomato, smoked bacon, chopped red onions, cucumbers, hard boiled egg, bleu cheese crumbles as well as shredded cheddar cheese. Recommended with our housemade buttermilk ranch dressing$16.49Waldorf Salad
Fresh spring salad mix and grilled chicken topped with diced apples, walnuts, cucumbers, Gorgonzola cheese and grapes. Recommended with our Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing.$17.49Side Salad
Romaine lettuce and spring mix topped with tomato, cucumber, parmesan cheese and croutons.$5.50Taco Salad
A fresh bed of iceberg lettuce topped with your choice of beef or chicken, shredded cheddar, clack bean & corn medley, pico, black olives, fresh jalapeños, green onions and tortilla strips Served with a side of sour cream and salsa.$16.49
Sandwiches/Wraps/Burgers
Build Your Own Burger
$14.49Famous Reuben
Slow roasted corned beef with tangy sauerkraut, melted Gruyere Swiss cheese grilled into marble rye with 1000 island dressing.$16.95Matty's BLT
Loads of crispy smoked bacon, vine-ripe tomato, fresh lettuce and garlic aioli on toasted sourdough Add fried egg or sliced avocado for an additional charge.$15.49Grown Up Bacon Grilled Cheese
Everything good starts with bacon. Then we add sun-dried tomato, cheddar, American, smoked gouda and mozzarella cheeses grilled into sourdough bread.$15.49Blackend Pesto Chicken Sandwich
Blackened grilled chicken with fresh pesto sauce, topped with fresh mozzarella cheese thinly sliced on top of shredded lettuce and tomato. On a Brioche bun.$16.49Turkey Avocado BLT Wrap
Roasted turkey, shredded lettuce, tomato, bacon, avocado and garlic mayo in a veggie tortilla wrap$15.99South of the Border Wrap
Grilled chicken and black bean corn relish with chipotle ranch, pico de gallo, shredded lettuce, chihuahua cheese and tortilla strips in a veggie tortilla$14.99Bourbon Chicken Wrap
Tender grilled chicken with bourbon glaze, sautéed bell peppers and onions with Chihuahua cheese in a veggie tortilla. Served with a side of your choice.$15.99Chipotle Chicken Tender Wrap
Hand breaded chicken tenders with shredded lettuce, chipotle ranch dressing, pico de gallo and Chihuahua cheese in a veggie tortilla$14.99Brisket Wrap
Smoked brisket with caramelized onions, shredded cheddar, sautéed mushrooms, brushed with horseradish sauce and stuffed in a flour tortilla.$16.99Pulled Pork Wrap
Our slow roasted pulled pork, confetti coleslaw with fresh jalapeño, chopped tangy pineapple, green onions and spicy Gochujang Korean BBQ sauce.$15.99Gyro Wrap
Tender gyro meat with raw onion, diced cucumber, diced tomato, shredded lettuce, chihuahua cheese, feta cheese and tzatziki sauce in a tortilla.$15.99Pizza Burger
A seasoned Italian sausage patty, handcrafted and grilled, topped with melted mozzarella cheese, fresh mushrooms, diced onions, and a family secret pizza sauce, all on a toasted french roll.$16.99French Onion Burger
Our Grandmas French Onion Dip on our Smokehouse Burger pressed with caramelized onions with melted Swiss Gruyere cheese on a Brioche bun.$15.49New Berlin Burger
Our signature burger with sautéed mushrooms and caramelized onion topped with smoked brisket and smoked Gouda cheese on a pretzel bun.$16.49Double Beef Double Cheese Beast
Just what it sounds like, plus lettuce and tomato.$24.00Mushroom Swiss Burger
This is our signature burger topped with sautéed mushrooms, a layer of glorious melted Gruyere Swiss Cheese, and beef gravy on a brioche bun.$15.49BBQ Pork Burger
The perfect burger blend topped with smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, pulled pork, onion rings, garlic mayo, and smothered in BBQ sauce. Served on a brioche bun.$16.49Hangover Burger
Our signature burger topped with smoked bacon, pepper jack cheese, a sunny-side-up egg, a potato pancake, and garlic aioli on a brioche bun. You may need a bib for this one.$17.49Cuban
The Ultimate sandwich piled high with ham, swiss cheese, pulled pork, pickles, and honey mustard served on marbled rye.$15.49Patty Melt
Two pieces of buttered and grilled marbled rye hug our signature burger patty with melted American cheese and caramelized onion.$16.49Philly Cheesesteak
Sautéed to perfection with peppers and sweet onion. Topped with a white cheese sauce. Served on a hoagie roll smeared with garlic aioli$16.49Chicken Sandwich
$15.49
Pastas
Skillet Mac N Cheese
House-made three cheese blend Mac tossed with cavatappi pasta, bacon bits and smoked brisket. Topped with seasoned bread crumbs and served with garlic toast.$16.99Pasta Carbonara
Cavatappi Pasta tossed with smoked bacon, green peas, and our garlic cream sauce, topped with grilled chicken.$17.99
Midwestern Southwestern
Street Tacos
Your choice of chicken or ground beef topped with pico, Chihuahua cheese, cilantro, chipotle ranch dressing, cucumbers and avocado. Garnished with chips, salsa and sour cream. Brisket can also be added for extra.$14.49Quesadilla
Made with Chihuahua cheese, house-made pico, and bacon. Served with a side of sour cream and salsa as well as your choice of nacho chicken or nacho cheese. Add a side of guac for an extra charge.$13.49SOUTHWEST CHICKEN SANDWICH
Grilled chicken breast topped with mango fire cheddar, pico de gallo, shredded lettuce and tomato, topped with chipotle ranch on a brioche bun.$16.49
Dinner Plates
BOURBON BRUSHED ATLANTIC SALMON
Grilled and nestled over a brown rice blend and finished with house veggies and garnished with lemons.$19.99Braised Short Rib Surf & Turf
A perfect pair: tender, grilled shrimp accompanied by our braised short rib layered with mushrooms and caramelized onions. Comes with mashed potatoes and the chef's choice of vegetables.$26.50Short Rib Pot Roast
Tender Braised Short Rib with carrots, onions, potatoes, and mushrooms in our signature gravy. Served with your choice of side.$18.00Chicken Tenders
The adults asked, and we delivered! Our juicy, breaded chicken tenders are served with your choice of two sides. Staff recommends BBQ, Buffalo, Buttermilk Ranch, or Honey Mustard for dipping.$14.49
Kids
Little Leaguers Grilled Cheese
Cheddar and mozzarella cheese between sourdough bread. Served with your choice of side.$9.50Little Leaguers Chicken Tenders
Two breaded chicken tenders with your choice of dipping sauce as well as a side.$9.50Little Leaguers Mac N' Cheese
Macaroni and cheese made like Mom's$9.50Little Leaguers Cheeseburger Sliders
Mini slider burger topped with American cheese, served with a side of your choice. Additional sliders may be added for an extra charge.$9.50Little Leaguers Beef Nachos
Fresh tortilla chips topped with nacho beef and shredded cheese.$9.50Little Leaguers Cheese Quesadilla
Flour tortilla filled with cheddar and jack cheese served with a side of salsa.$9.50
Pizzas
9" Cheese Pizza
$12.4914" Cheese Pizza
$17.9912" Gluten Free Pizza
$13.99BBQ Chicken Pizza
Tangy BBQ sauce with red onion, shredded chicken, cilantro and cheddar and mozzarella cheeses.$16.99+MEAT LOVERS PIZZA
Our crust topped with pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, ham, pepperoni, Italian sausage, and bacon$17.99+MARGHERITA PIZZA
Pesto sauce, sliced and shredded fresh mozzarella, sliced tomato, and basil on our crispy crust. Drizzled with balsamic glaze$17.99+
Desserts
White Choc. Raspberry Cheesecake
A dark chocolate crust holds a sweet, white chocolate cheesecake filling, swirled with tart red raspberries, and scallops of cream to create a flavorful dessert.$9.50Carrot Cake
Triple layer carrot cake topped with rich cream cheese frosting, freshly grated carrots, white chocolate curls, coconut bits, and chopped walnuts.$9.50Cinnamon Churro Cheesecake
$9.50
Housemade Bloody Mary Mix
Matty's Old Fashioned on Tap
12 oz Tub Old Fashioned
Great for tailgating or parties. Elijah Craig small batch bourbon, amaretto, housemade cherry-orange old fashioned mix. Makes 5-6 drinks, all you need to do is add ice and your mixer. We recommend club soda, sprite/7-up or press. Our recipe is 2.5 oz of the mix...Enjoy!!$30.0032 oz Crowler Old Fashioned
Great for tailgating or parties. Elijah Craig small batch bourbon, amaretto, housemade cherry-orange old fashioned mix. Makes 12 -14 drinks, all you need to do is add ice and your mixer. We recommend club soda, sprite/7-up or press. Our recipe is 2.5 oz of the mix...Enjoy!!$75.0032 oz Crowler Refill Old Fashioned
Great for tailgating or parties. Elijah Craig small batch bourbon, amaretto, housemade cherry-orange old fashioned mix. Makes 12 -14 drinks, all you need to do is add ice and your mixer. We recommend club soda, sprite/7-up or press. Our recipe is 2.5 oz of the mix...Enjoy!!$70.0064 oz Growler Old Fashioned
Great for tailgating or parties. Elijah Craig small batch bourbon, amaretto, housemade cherry-orange old fashioned mix. Makes 24 -28 drinks, all you need to do is add ice and your mixer. We recommend club soda, sprite/7-up or press. Our recipe is 2.5 oz of the mix...Enjoy!!$140.0064 oz Growler Refill Old Fashioned
Great for tailgating or parties. Elijah Craig small batch bourbon, amaretto, housemade cherry-orange old fashioned mix. Makes 24-28 drinks, all you need to do is add ice and your mixer. We recommend club soda, sprite/7-up or press. Our recipe is 2.5 oz of the mix...Enjoy!!$130.00
Appetizer
Food
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
$14.99
A blend of cheeses with fresh spinach and artichoke hearts, served in a bread bowl with a side of tortilla chips and celery.
1 quantity selected.1
All hours
| Sunday | 9:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 10:00 pm |
| Saturday | 9:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy! Please note: our online system is only available during kitchen hours so all Event Tickets and Barrel Picks will only be available during the times of Monday - Thursday 11am until 9pm, Friday 11am until 10pm and Sat/Sun 9am until 9pm. We apologize for the inconvenience.
Location