
American
Mill City Public House
1103 West College Avenue
Appleton, WI 54914
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
‌
‌
‌
Featured Items
The OK Burger
double smash patty, shaved onions charred and smashed into a double smash patty, American cheese, pickles, pub sauce on a toasted brioche bun$20.95
Classic Smash Burger
Double smash patty, american cheese, house pub sauce, shaved red onion and pickles on a toasted brioche bun. Served with your choice of side.$18.95Chicken Caesar Wrap
choose crispy or smoked chicken, kale, pickled red onion, herbed crouton crumble, parmesan, cherry tomato, tomato basil wrap$18.95
Starters & Snacks
Cheesy Brisket Jalapeno Dip
cowboy candy, montemore cheese, served with crispy pita chips$14.95Brussels Sprouts
Fried crispy with bacon and tossed with a sesame ginger ponzu glaze.$12.95Cheese Curds
smoked ranch for dipping$12.95Street Corn Tots
charred corn, jalapeno, cotija, chipotle honey lime aioli$13.95Truffle Tots
roasted mushrooms, garlic aioli, parmesan, truffle oil, fresh herbs$14.95Buffalo Bacon Bleu Tots
$14.95Wings
one pound+ of fresh jumbo wings tossed in our house signature dry rub, served with pickled carrots + your choice of dipping sauce$21.95Side French Fries
$5.95Side Tater Tots
$5.95Side Slaw
$3.00Side Pita
$4.00Side Haystacks
$4.00
Salad & Soup
House Salad
sartori montamore cheese, pickled red onion, dried cherry, candied pecan, sherry vinaigrette$12.95Beet Salad
arugula, smoked orange goat cheese, pistachio cornbread crumble, bourbon honey vinaigrette$14.95Kale Caesar
pickled red onion, parmesan, crouton crumble, cherry tomato$14.95Wedge Salad
$15.951/2 House Salad
satori montamore, pickled red onion, dried cherry, candied pecans, sherry vinaigrette$7.491/2 Kale Caesar
pickled red onion, parmesan, crouton crumble, cherry tomato$8.49Cup Day Soup
$5.95Bowl Day Soup
$10.95
Burgers & Sandos
Mortadella Melt
$19.95
Classic Smash Burger
Double smash patty, american cheese, house pub sauce, shaved red onion and pickles on a toasted brioche bun. Served with your choice of side.$18.95The OK Burger
double smash patty, shaved onions charred and smashed into a double smash patty, American cheese, pickles, pub sauce on a toasted brioche bun$20.95Mushroom Gruyere Burger
double smash patty, herb roasted mushrooms, swiss cheese, haystack onions, garlic aioli on a toasted brioche bun$20.95Bacon Jam Burger
double smash patty, bourbon bacon jam, runny egg, haystack onions, cheddar, on a toasted brioche bun$20.95Black & Bleu Burger
double smash patty, crispy black pepper bacon, chunky garlic bleu cheese sauce, pickled red onions and arugula on a toasted brioche bun.$19.95Jalapeno Burger
double smash patty, spicy cream cheese, pepper jack, crispy bacon, pickled jalapenos, haystack onions on a toasted brioche bun$19.95Pesto Truffle Burger
$20.95Smoky Salsa Burger
$19.95BYO Double
$15.00BYO Single
$12.00Brisket French Dip
house-smoked brisket, swiss, pepper jack, horseradish peppercorn aioli, caramelized onions, hoagie roll, au jus for dipping$23.95Salmon BLT
blackened salmon filet, crispy bacon, sun-dried tomato + caper aioli, arugula, brioche$19.95Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich
spicy breaded chicken breast, chili garlic mayo, hot honey, crunchy pickles, slaw, brioche$18.95Pulled Pork Sandwich
house smoked pork, bourbon bbq, slaw, p[pickles, brioche$16.95Chicken Caesar Wrap
choose crispy or smoked chicken, kale, pickled red onion, herbed crouton crumble, parmesan, cherry tomato, tomato basil wrap$18.95Falafel Wrap
house-made falafel, feta, cherry tomato, pickled red onion, radish, arugula, tzatziki, garlic tahini, tomato basil wrap$16.95
Features
Mussels
$19.95Brisket Mac & Cheese
1st place winner at The Great Wisconsin Cheese Festival! 4 cheese blend, house smoked brisket, herbed bread crumbs$25.95Fish Fry
Great Lakes Walleye, two panko-breaded filets, house slaw, tartar and fries$29.95OUT OF STOCKSmoked Rib Plate
1/2 rack fresh of the smoker, bourbon bbq and house slaw with your choice of side$29.95OUT OF STOCKHot Dish
15 hour smoked brisket, peas, corn, carrots, tomatoes, house gravy, topped with tater tots, haystack onions$23.95OUT OF STOCK
Sauce
Side Ranch
$0.99Side Smoked Ranch
$0.99Side Garlic Aioli
$0.99Side Bourbon BBQ
$0.99Side Chunky Garlic Bleu
$0.99Side Pub Sauce
$0.99Side Chipotle Aioli
$0.99Side Chili Garlic Aioli
$0.99Side Horseradish Peppercorn
$0.99Side Mayo
$0.60Side Ketchup
Side Yellow Mustard
Side Tzatziki
$0.99Side Caesar Dressing
$0.99Side Maple Bacon Jam
$1.99Side Caper Aioli
$0.99Side Tartar Sauce
$0.99Side Sherry Vin
$0.99Side Buffalo Sauce
$0.99Side Wes' Hot Sauce
$0.99Side Garlic Bleu
$0.99Side Hot Honey
$1.99Side Featured Sauce
$0.99Side Smoky Salsa
$0.99Side Pesto Truffle Aioli
$1.99Side of Au Jus
$3.00No Sauce
Pint of Sauce
$10.00Pint of Premium Sauce
$20.00Side Sour Cream
$0.60OUT OF STOCK

Classic Smash Burger
$18.95
Double smash patty, american cheese, house pub sauce, shaved red onion and pickles on a toasted brioche bun. Served with your choice of side.
Customize your item
Sandwich Side
Required
Select 1
Sandwich Substitutions
Optional
Sandwich ADD
Optional
Allergy
Optional
Classic Smash Burger Mods
Optional
1
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 4:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 4:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 4:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 4:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 4:30 pm |
| Saturday | Closed |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location